“For Exposure”: 40 Screenshots Of Choosing Beggars Caught In Action When It Came To Paying For Services They Asked For
InterviewThe concept of providing exposure instead of just recompense for work is a problem that affects many businesses, and "For Exposure" on Twitter exposes this behavior. The page collects direct statements from people and organizations who have made offers to work for exposure rather than payment to professionals in a variety of areas, including artists and photographers. These statements reveal a disregard for the time and effort required to produce high-quality work.
"For Exposure" seeks to raise awareness about the significance of appreciating professionals' efforts and compensating them fairly for their services by sharing these messages. The page has spurred significant discussions about the importance of labor and the necessity of valuing people who devote their time and effort to their art. It serves as a reminder that experts need to be paid adequately for their work and that publicity alone is insufficient.
The article also includes an exclusive interview with Ryan Estrada who is an established comic artist, author, and the creator of the "For Exposure" Twitter page, so make sure to keep on reading.
This post may include affiliate links.
The problem is, they will have had enough writers agreeing to do an article for free to make it worth their while to keep asking. If they ask 10 writers, and one or two agree to no fee, why would they change their policy? It's the same with "influencers" They've obviously had some businesses or individuals agree to provide something free of charge so they just keep on sending out begging messages because it works.
Bored Panda reached out to Ryan Estrada, the creator of the "For Exposure" Twitter page, to learn more about his inspiration behind the page and his thoughts on compensation and recognition in the creative industry.
Ryan shared that the whole thing started as a joke. "I'd been seeing a lot of 'txt' accounts, so when I got a really dumb message about working for no pay, I thought to myself 'I bet I could fill up a txt account of these for exposure messages for a whole week!' I spent an hour procrastinating by tinkering with it, and before I knew it, I'd scheduled a year's worth of posts."
The "For Exposure" Twitter account gained massive popularity over the years, reaching millions of people and changing the conversation around terrible offers. Estrada shared that "everyone from aspiring teen artists to Eisner, Emmy, and Grammy winners followed the account. I was really happy to see how much it changed the conversation. How people would reply to terrible offers with 'this sounds like something out of @forexposure_txt' and the places where offers like that were made got better." Despite its success, Ryan recently decided to end the account after ten years when Elon Musk, whom he had quoted on the account multiple times, bought Twitter, and it no longer felt as fun to work for free to keep the account running.
"I ordered the filet from your restaurant, but then I found a hot dog cart outside who only charged a dollar. I got woefully sick from it. Why didn't you stop me?!?!"
Looks like the bride will just have to make do with grainy snaps taken by the guests on their phones as the memento of her big day
We also asked Ryan about his experience with compensation and value recognition in his work and what steps he has taken to address it. The artist replied, "Everyone who makes art has to fight to make a living at it. The place I learned the most was when I ran a custom comic company. People would order comics about their boyfriends as superheroes, or 'how we met' comics for their weddings, comics about their company to hand out at trade shows, that kind of thing. I started off charging next to nothing, and that price ended up shrinking due to repeated demands for redos. Eventually, I upped the price just because I couldn't keep up and I wanted to slow the orders down."
The creator of the page went on to explain how he gradually increased his prices, and as he did, he found that his orders actually increased as well. He said, "I ended up charging 50 times what I charged in the beginning, and making rules that everything they wanted in the comic needed to be said in advance. If they wanted any changes, they would have to pay again. The professional rate made people trust that they were getting a professional product. And the confident, unapologetic demand to be treated like a professional invited customers who were glad to do it."
Estrada said that he has taken the lessons he learned from running his custom comic company into the rest of his career. While he only works on projects he's passionate about now, he's confident in his worth and has no problem asking for fair compensation.
He's right, you shouldn't call 911 for things like that, it should be used for things like complaining about not getting the right pizza delivered or asking the police to send someone over to open a jar of pickles
When asked for advice he would give to young artists and professionals who are just starting their careers and may be struggling with the issue of being offered exposure instead of fair payment. Ryan's response was: "You are going to spend your whole life making art for little to no money. But make sure it's YOUR art. When you make someone else's art for no money, you only expose yourself as someone who works for free. I can't tell you how many people told me how much exposure I'd get from designing their logo. I'd love to ask them to name ANY designer of ANY logo. Spend your time making the art that only you can make, that you are passionate about, and you will discover untold ways to monetize it."
Estrada emphasized the need to break down the stigma surrounding compensation and treatment in order to build a culture that values and respects the contributions of professionals across various industries. "We need to get rid of the stigma of talking about compensation and treatment. Not just with our peers, so we know how to compare what we are being offered to common standards... but to the people who want to hire us. Don't be afraid to question, or ask for what you deserve. Even I have to be reminded sometimes. Last year, I started posting AI-generated comics based on @forexposure_txt quotes and hundreds of people rightfully called me out for going against the very mission of the account. They were absolutely right, and I appreciate their kindness in pointing it out to me so I can do better. Extend that same kindness to the rest of the world, so everything can get better," he said to Bored Panda.
Ryan's experiences collaborating with various publishers and companies, such as Scholastic, Star Trek, and Garfield, have helped him understand the importance of fair compensation and recognition in the creative industry.
"Anyone whose 'exposure' has ever been worth it for me was already successful enough that paying me was not even a question," he shared with Bored Panda. "It took many years and a lot of hard lessons to know how to stand up for myself, so I hope others can use the ten years of quotes on @forexposure_txt to learn the red flags, know they're not alone, and have the confidence to stand up for what they deserve."
He also urged others to extend the lesson to help and support authors in their own communities. "Like for example, if you enjoyed the ten years of unpaid work I put into @forexposure_txt, buy one of my books! I have a new one called 'Occulted' coming out in May!" he added.
There are not enough spelling mistakes for it to be Eric.
Load More Replies...Talk about not understanding what that phrase is used for
Load More Replies...So the threat is that his dad will ask the leader of the yakuza to get one of his henchman to fly from Japan to the US to rub out a guy who won't teach his kid graphics. I'd take that risk
Which yakuza? There are several yakuza groups, you know. Oh wait .. you don't actually know because you're making it up.
Yeah, well I know the Flying Spaghetti Monster! Let those two battle it out!
That's nothing, I befriended the lake monster that lives in the lake by my house!
Load More Replies...Ever wondered what happened to that kid who said their dad owned Roblox? Well now you know.
Your dad knows the leader of the Yakuza, huh? Well, I know the number of the local PD and huh, guess what, I just called them to say hello. Would you like to say hello as well? Smh...
I keep scrolling these through these posts and they're getting more nuts and ridiculous
What is normally do when someone asks me to teach them is to dm them some links to tutorials to get started... Which is what might have happened hear if this person wasn't bonkers
Be like this kid - never give up! Even after insulting and threatening the person you want to teach you for free.
signing in specifically to say the majority of these posts remind me of my ex XD
I thought they had different chapters. I don't think there is one leader.
oh hey, it's a 14 year old. first red flag when they said 'can you teach me graphics?'
A Fantasy life it seems from someone who is probably ignored a lot and watches too many videos
It's Baron, (or Barron). Some forget the other two. The three stooges have been front fox c**p for a while now. Javanka (who can tell them apart anymore), d.j., or Eric.
Uh-oh, careful - he knows THE leader of THE Yakuza, not just one of the leaders of the various gangs that make up the Yakuza so you'd better go teach him. Then when you walk into daddy's office you can pretend they all stopped and started clapping for you.
He should ask the people who “stop and clap” for him to teach him since they worship him so much. 🙄
From the wording and attitude I'm guessing 12 to 15 years old give or take.
The yakuza? Like, the entire yakuza? That would be quite an accomplishment.
"It's a privilege to work for my benefit" followed by "check your ego at the door", brilliant
"HR might want a word with you soon." That word's going to be, "We fired the other person for harassment and threats. We apologize. Please don't sue us."
And I expect Hugh Jackman to call and declare his undying love for me, but looks like we're both out of luck.
How difficult is it to give credit?! Cite your sources, grade school 101.
That man is really gaining points in his running for the 'Biggest Scum on Earth' award.
Saying 'no offence' immediately means that you will say something offensive
Tbf you can also seduce them but you need to bring something to the table to be interesting in the first place
This guy's not looking for an EA, he's looking for a mommy with benefits.
Careful. He's a violent felon. Weird how they don't introduce him like that. "Live on stage, Violent Felon Chris Brown!! Don't look at him funny he'll slap the s**t outta ya!"
Guessing people have forgotten most nations have abolished slavery, for good reasons. If your business can't function without slavery, then your business model sucks and is unsustainable.... or you suck at the business. If people do the work, they get pay. Period. Rant over.
Newsflash. Slavery is still very much up and running.
Load More Replies...Could get that far. You clearly have more stamina. Is this world we now live in?? God help us.
Load More Replies...When I was in film school I made a short thriller and my very little budget went to props, insurance, and food for everyone. I had no money left to pay crew or cast but I still had professional actors, and crew who volunteered for the love of the art (and they knew I would not be making any money off it). It was a lot of fun.
yes but u said urself that the professional actors VOLUNTEERED their time and selves. totally not the same situation. 🙃
Load More Replies...I'm a mechanic. I charge a $50 an hour plus parts. I'm also an artist. Guess how much I charge for commissions. As much as I love to draw, time spent on someone else's art is time not spent fixing engines. (Or working on my own stuff) I know what my time is worth.
Cuz they're broke. They don't have any money but they still want stuff. They figure it doesn't hurt to ask. Which it technically wouldn't hurt to ask, if they weren't such pricks about it when they're told no.
Load More Replies...I don't get it: if you can't do it yourself, you have to pay for someone else to do it. What's the question?
Guessing people have forgotten most nations have abolished slavery, for good reasons. If your business can't function without slavery, then your business model sucks and is unsustainable.... or you suck at the business. If people do the work, they get pay. Period. Rant over.
Newsflash. Slavery is still very much up and running.
Load More Replies...Could get that far. You clearly have more stamina. Is this world we now live in?? God help us.
Load More Replies...When I was in film school I made a short thriller and my very little budget went to props, insurance, and food for everyone. I had no money left to pay crew or cast but I still had professional actors, and crew who volunteered for the love of the art (and they knew I would not be making any money off it). It was a lot of fun.
yes but u said urself that the professional actors VOLUNTEERED their time and selves. totally not the same situation. 🙃
Load More Replies...I'm a mechanic. I charge a $50 an hour plus parts. I'm also an artist. Guess how much I charge for commissions. As much as I love to draw, time spent on someone else's art is time not spent fixing engines. (Or working on my own stuff) I know what my time is worth.
Cuz they're broke. They don't have any money but they still want stuff. They figure it doesn't hurt to ask. Which it technically wouldn't hurt to ask, if they weren't such pricks about it when they're told no.
Load More Replies...I don't get it: if you can't do it yourself, you have to pay for someone else to do it. What's the question?