“[Am I The Jerk] For Ignoring What My Fiancée’s Parents Wanted And Wore My Wedding Dress To Her Funeral?”
Grief is a terrible thing to deal with. It comes in many different forms and may take a drastically different amount of time to heal for people.
Navigating the last requests of people that have passed away also may be difficult, but it is a beautiful tribute to a loved one.
A Redditor wanted the internet’s opinion on whether she was a jerk for wanting to grant a request just like this, honoring her fiancée, against her parents’ wishes.
More info: Reddit
Fulfilling the last wishes of your loved ones may be a beautiful and respectful gesture
Image credits: Pavel Danilyuk (not the actual image)
A woman’s fiancée wanted them both to wear wedding dresses during her funeral, after a tragic accident cut short their future plans of getting married
Image credits: u/Fun_Towel_2726
Wanting to grant this wish, she wore her dress against the fiancée’s parents’ request, catching their ire and even getting bigoted remarks
The poster, a 24 y.o. woman, had recently lost her 27 y.o. fiancée due to a tragic car accident. Before her passing, she let her know that her last request was for them both to wear their wedding dresses during the funeral, as they wouldn’t be able to get married.
The parents would have been okay with a traditional wedding dress, but not with the one that OP had picked out.
We dusted off the old Google-fu and even looked in the Wayback Machine, but even digital time travel didn’t reveal what the dress was, as the link was broken by then.
You may think the dress was provocative or flashy, but from the old comments, it seems that it was reserved, elegant, and beautiful – seemingly tasteful enough for the ceremony.
She talked to her deceased fiancée’s brothers and sisters who said they’d support her wearing the dress, but the parents did not relent and cussed her out for arriving to the ceremony in the dress.
What’s even worse, they let it slip that they never approved of their daughter being LGBT or of her fiancée, calling her a selfish butthole on top of all that.
This left the poster majorly conflicted and hurt, unsure if she did the right thing.
Image credits: Pixabay (not the actual image)
To get a more experienced perspective, Bored Panda reached out to Shannan Guillory, a licensed funeral director who strives to educate people about death on her I Do Death website. She’s got a great blog on her website, where she talks about various sensitive topics where you are likely to find a lot of affirmation for your feelings – I know I did.
Asked about executing last requests and how they should be communicated with the family, Shannan said that open and honest communication is key, a dramatic last request shouldn’t be sprung on them.
“This woman probably saw this as a meaningful tribute, but her parents probably viewed this as [the fiancée] making [this] memory about her.”
According to Shannan, everyone grieves differently, and in her opinion both parties have valid reasons to be upset. This conversation should have happened long before someone passed away.
Requests that fall outside of societal norms are perfectly normal, as long as they are legal, but if their wishes contradict the legal next-of-kin’s choices, the waters may get muddled.
Therefore, telling someone what you want to be done after your passing isn’t enough, you should make it legal. An Advance Health Care Directive is a good way to start, according to Shannan, choosing a person you can trust…
“You can choose who gets to be in charge of your health care AND funeral arrangements if something happens to you. That person can be whoever you want!”
Another more expensive route is to preplan your own funeral in advance. Most funeral homes offer the option to plan your own funeral, freeing your family of the financial obligation and protecting your own wishes.
Image credits: Victoria Priessnitz (not the actual image)
Shannan doesn’t believe that any requests are unusual, she rather encourages families to think outside the box.
Some unique requests that she’s seen over the years include everyone attending choosing a song that made them think of the person that passed and using that as a playlist for the memorial service, the family bringing a person’s dog to the service to allow them to say goodbye, and the family serving an entire buffet of different birthday cakes because the person who had passed adored cake.
Shannan finishes the interview with a thoughtful statement: There are so many ways to make your memory last, but what really matters is the conversations you have while you’re still here.”
Things you want done after your passing may go beyond your physical possessions and thus are outside of your last will and testament. Therefore, you may want to let your loved ones know what you’d like to happen after your passing.
It may be convenient to talk about these things with them beforehand so they have no questions when the time comes. You could possibly create a document with all of your requests too, so nothing is forgotten or misinterpreted.
The Balance suggests several things that should be in such a document. These may include: whether you want a funeral or memorial service, where the service should be held, who should be notified of your passing, whether you want to be cremated or buried, money that you have put away for your final expenses and where it is, etc.
Diaspora Insurance says that last wishes should be fulfilled if possible, as it is important to respect them and preserve their dignity.
The post collected more than 9k upvotes over the course of two years. With almost 700 comments, the community judged OP not to be a jerkhole, saying that perhaps the parents could have been right, but seeing as the dress was reasonable and especially when the bigotry came out, they lost all support from the internet.
The commenters supported the poster and judged her not to be a jerk
Image credits: Sofia Hernandez (not the actual image)
Last wishes should be followed if at all possible. If my mom had told me before she died that she wanted me to wear a rainbow leotard and a fuzzy top hat to her funeral, you can be damn sure I would have worn the brightest leotard and the fuzziest top hat ever made!
I want my child (or children) to shave half of their head hair and put on mustaches and sombreros, while wearing pointe shoes and tie dye sweatshirts
Load More Replies...The real problem isn't the dress or even the homophobia (though that is definitely a big part of it), the problem is telling your soon to be daughter-in-law that you never wanted her to be part of the family as she is grieving her fiancée. Of course, loosing a child hurts. Loosing any loved one hurts, but hurting the deceased's loved ones while they are mourning does nothing to honor the person who died.
Ngl. I'm calling b******t on this. It just seems a bit off and the story has conflicting moments. Even with the explanation after. Maybe I'm wrong and just speculating. But yeah that's my thoughts.
In many countries, you could have a "wedding" as in organising a fun day with all the fanfare in your backyard, but you cannot officially get married. My country for example doesn't recognise same-sex marriage.
Load More Replies...Being homophobic isn't being afraid, it's being disgusted, and being what I like to call a "rainbow hater." I am so sorry for OP's loss :(
Grief is private. As long as you are not a annoying a*s grieve how you want to.
I went thru a situation too when my husband of 35 years died. His family was known for totally ignoring what the deceased wanted and having a funeral by they’re own beliefs. There was always a big fight when someone died in their family (5 siblings). Not on my watch, I knew what my husband wanted and shut them down when they started in on the DAY HE DIED. I text to all of them something along the lines of: “Everything was going to be exactly as my husband wanted, I know what he wanted because we talked about it, and I don’t give a mad f*€k what anyone thinks about it. Don’t like it? Lose my number. Period. Show up on my door, I call the police.” It went my way. They wanted to view his body. He specified he didn’t want to be viewed, even by me. He wanted cremation.
A coworker/ friend of mine and I bonded over our love of vintage. When she passed, I wore a glamorous yellow formal dress (her favorite color) to the super religious church funeral. I was a bit afraid, but her mother told me it was such a beautiful way to honor her. I will never forget that and am so glad I went with my gut. Funerals should be about honoring the person, which I’d say you did. NTA, I’m so sorry they acted like that to you. Don’t let it get to you too much, as they are also grieving n that makes people odd sometimes. 💛
This story sounds a little iffy, and I dont believe it to be true.. but ignoring inconsistencies... please explain to me how you honestly think you could be the AH by respecting/honoring your fiancee's "dying wish"..
Clearly you arent LGBT because this kind of 180 treatment of partners after the mutual loved ones death is so endemic that it is practically cliche. A little better now that marriage is legal so there is real protections out there for long term partners but the pretending to be ok with things and then spewing homophobic hate after the person passes on the surviving partner is still common. Parents trying not to lose thier kids by acting ok with the relationship only for thier true colors to come out after. OP also said it was a deadly car crash which means there easily could have been a short window to say goodbye and give last wishes in the hospital once drs knew they could do no more besides make them comfortable but before the person actually dies.
Load More Replies...listen, people are putting too much on the grieving parents and saying they are wrong. No one is in the wrong here. She honored her wishes, and the parents just lost their child and are grieving and not in their proper mindset. No one is in the wrong here
The OP was grieving too; she just lost her fiancée, whom she was going to get married to and spend her life with, that's pretty devastating itself. Hearing that kind of homophobia from her fiancée's parents hurts too. It was an AH comment to make, though I wouldn't be TOO hard on them in that moment. Still, they should have kept those comments to themselves, the OP was just trying to follow their daughter's last wishes.
Load More Replies...I followed the link, it doesn’t show the exact dress but all the ones are these really cool but super short dresses. I think they look awesome, one has all these little mirrors on it, but they are kinda skimpy.
YTA because it sounds like you airing it on her parents. It should have been talked through before the funeral. Just truly sad. Beyond sad. I know people hate it when other people say this, but you can't understand what it is to be a parent, especially a mom, unless you've been one. Your fiancée's mother was walking through Hell at that funeral. I would have worn a cape, or something over it as middle ground.
NTA You honoured 27 in the way you’d both talked about.. I’m just so sorry that you had to experience your future in laws hatred in that way. You don’t have to interact with them anymore, and certainly don’t have to care about their feelings
Funerals are for the living, not the dead. it can help the living deal with their grief. therefore, a last wish is rather irrelevant since the deceased will not live to see it. BUT it can help those living in their grief to grant a last wish. so it's only right for the fiancée to deal with the loss in this way. it is also a beautiful sign in my eyes. I probably would have put a black train over the dress to combine the marriage and the funeral but that would only be an idea
Last wishes should be followed if at all possible. If my mom had told me before she died that she wanted me to wear a rainbow leotard and a fuzzy top hat to her funeral, you can be damn sure I would have worn the brightest leotard and the fuzziest top hat ever made!
I want my child (or children) to shave half of their head hair and put on mustaches and sombreros, while wearing pointe shoes and tie dye sweatshirts
Load More Replies...The real problem isn't the dress or even the homophobia (though that is definitely a big part of it), the problem is telling your soon to be daughter-in-law that you never wanted her to be part of the family as she is grieving her fiancée. Of course, loosing a child hurts. Loosing any loved one hurts, but hurting the deceased's loved ones while they are mourning does nothing to honor the person who died.
Ngl. I'm calling b******t on this. It just seems a bit off and the story has conflicting moments. Even with the explanation after. Maybe I'm wrong and just speculating. But yeah that's my thoughts.
In many countries, you could have a "wedding" as in organising a fun day with all the fanfare in your backyard, but you cannot officially get married. My country for example doesn't recognise same-sex marriage.
Load More Replies...Being homophobic isn't being afraid, it's being disgusted, and being what I like to call a "rainbow hater." I am so sorry for OP's loss :(
Grief is private. As long as you are not a annoying a*s grieve how you want to.
I went thru a situation too when my husband of 35 years died. His family was known for totally ignoring what the deceased wanted and having a funeral by they’re own beliefs. There was always a big fight when someone died in their family (5 siblings). Not on my watch, I knew what my husband wanted and shut them down when they started in on the DAY HE DIED. I text to all of them something along the lines of: “Everything was going to be exactly as my husband wanted, I know what he wanted because we talked about it, and I don’t give a mad f*€k what anyone thinks about it. Don’t like it? Lose my number. Period. Show up on my door, I call the police.” It went my way. They wanted to view his body. He specified he didn’t want to be viewed, even by me. He wanted cremation.
A coworker/ friend of mine and I bonded over our love of vintage. When she passed, I wore a glamorous yellow formal dress (her favorite color) to the super religious church funeral. I was a bit afraid, but her mother told me it was such a beautiful way to honor her. I will never forget that and am so glad I went with my gut. Funerals should be about honoring the person, which I’d say you did. NTA, I’m so sorry they acted like that to you. Don’t let it get to you too much, as they are also grieving n that makes people odd sometimes. 💛
This story sounds a little iffy, and I dont believe it to be true.. but ignoring inconsistencies... please explain to me how you honestly think you could be the AH by respecting/honoring your fiancee's "dying wish"..
Clearly you arent LGBT because this kind of 180 treatment of partners after the mutual loved ones death is so endemic that it is practically cliche. A little better now that marriage is legal so there is real protections out there for long term partners but the pretending to be ok with things and then spewing homophobic hate after the person passes on the surviving partner is still common. Parents trying not to lose thier kids by acting ok with the relationship only for thier true colors to come out after. OP also said it was a deadly car crash which means there easily could have been a short window to say goodbye and give last wishes in the hospital once drs knew they could do no more besides make them comfortable but before the person actually dies.
Load More Replies...listen, people are putting too much on the grieving parents and saying they are wrong. No one is in the wrong here. She honored her wishes, and the parents just lost their child and are grieving and not in their proper mindset. No one is in the wrong here
The OP was grieving too; she just lost her fiancée, whom she was going to get married to and spend her life with, that's pretty devastating itself. Hearing that kind of homophobia from her fiancée's parents hurts too. It was an AH comment to make, though I wouldn't be TOO hard on them in that moment. Still, they should have kept those comments to themselves, the OP was just trying to follow their daughter's last wishes.
Load More Replies...I followed the link, it doesn’t show the exact dress but all the ones are these really cool but super short dresses. I think they look awesome, one has all these little mirrors on it, but they are kinda skimpy.
YTA because it sounds like you airing it on her parents. It should have been talked through before the funeral. Just truly sad. Beyond sad. I know people hate it when other people say this, but you can't understand what it is to be a parent, especially a mom, unless you've been one. Your fiancée's mother was walking through Hell at that funeral. I would have worn a cape, or something over it as middle ground.
NTA You honoured 27 in the way you’d both talked about.. I’m just so sorry that you had to experience your future in laws hatred in that way. You don’t have to interact with them anymore, and certainly don’t have to care about their feelings
Funerals are for the living, not the dead. it can help the living deal with their grief. therefore, a last wish is rather irrelevant since the deceased will not live to see it. BUT it can help those living in their grief to grant a last wish. so it's only right for the fiancée to deal with the loss in this way. it is also a beautiful sign in my eyes. I probably would have put a black train over the dress to combine the marriage and the funeral but that would only be an idea
58
34