ADVERTISEMENT

Especially during these times of extreme inflation, we’re all looking to save a few bucks anywhere we can. Whether that means clipping coupons, waiting to make purchases until what we need goes on sale or simply opting to buy less brand-name products, we can all find a few places to cut back. But there is a difference between being frugal and making purchases or decisions that won't actually help you out in the long run. A great deal can be exciting to find, but only if the product will last just as long or longer than the same thing at full price!  

Reddit users have been sharing some situations where it is not worth it to be cheap, so we’ve gathered some of their most spot-on answers down below. From purchasing items that keep you and your loved ones safe to splurging on well-made products that will prevent you from having health problems in the future, be sure to upvote the replies mentioning things you agree never to skimp on. Feel free to let us know in the comments what else you refuse to be too frugal about, and then if you’re interested in reading another Bored Panda article noting even more “false frugalities” that aren’t worth it in the long run, you can find that right here

More info: Reddit | Reddit | Reddit

#1

People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Your kids. You had them now f*****g support them you cheap prick.

flamingomike23 , Phil Nguyen Report

RELATED:
    #2

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Anything where being frugal could impact negatively on your health. I'd rather throw the smelly chicken away than eat it and get sick.

    cvetankaschair , Amanda Mills Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Brenda Spagnola-Wilson
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Yup! I've thrown away food when we barely had any rather than risk someone getting ill. Brother had salmonella at 5 and almost died. Just not worth it

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #3

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Anything that separates you from the ground. IE) Tires, bed, shoes etc

    concerned_coder , luizph Report

    Typically, being frugal is a great thing. We live in a world where large corporations and the media are often pressuring us to believe that we need to buy more, more, more and that we’re out of touch if we don’t have the latest and greatest technology. I am all for shopping second hand, buying that produce that’s marked down because it has to be eaten within the next few days and taking public transit instead of driving yourself to be a bit easier on your wallet and the environment. But as with everything else in life, it is possible to go too far when being frugal.

    ADVERTISEMENT

    If you’re putting yourself or others at risk, perhaps by eating food out of the garbage or by refusing to get that mysterious sound your car is making checked out, you might have fallen a little too far down the rabbit hole of frugality. Sometimes, it is worth it to just purchase something nice up front, such as a pair of leather shoes or a high quality chef’s knife, to ensure that it will last for years to come. Being frugal is not always about spending as little as possible. You also have to make wise decisions about where it is worth it to spend money, and you shouldn’t be making yourself (and everyone else around you) miserable by choosing to shower only once a week.

    #4

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Shoes. Good shoes are important.

    Tomatosouppah , Lukas Report

    #5

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) A bed. Investing in good bedding will make you less susceptible to getting back pains

    ravenwasrobbed , Ketut Subiyanto Report

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #6

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Tattoos. I'd rather overpay for a perfect tattoo than have a bad one for the rest of my life

    FerragamoHussein , u/kittenshateme Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    a fruity dream of delusion
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    THIS. the sheer amount of dumbass tattoos i’ve seen here.. god. if it’s something that permanent, *make sure it is worth it*

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu

    When people are passionate about something, they often feel the desire to go as hard as they possibly can in regards to that passion. We see this when people watch a documentary and decide to go vegan cold turkey (cold tofurkey?) overnight or when individuals decide they must live a zero-waste lifestyle and attempt to immediately stop consuming. Typically, making drastic lifestyle changes such as these overnight will lead to burn out. Often, the person is unprepared for what they’re getting themself into and they put way too much pressure on themselves to be a perfect *insert whatever label they desire*.

    When they inevitably cannot keep up with the new rules they have placed on themself, the person will likely abandon the venture altogether. The same thing can happen with frugality. A person may choose to start showering once a week, eating food out of dumpsters, refusing to turn on the lights in their home, and spending hours clipping coupons each week. But this will drastically lower their quality of life, and eventually, they will return to their old habits. When it would have been much more frugal, in the long run, to adopt reasonable habits and choose attainable goals that will allow them to keep up their pace of saving money.   

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #7

    My wife likes to buy things on sale and tout how much money she saved.

    "I got this purse for 50% off! I saved $50!"

    "No, you spent $50."

    She also likes to shop at Marshall's, TJ Maxx, Burlington Coat Factory; basically anywhere the price tag says "compare to $xx.xx" on it.

    So this rug costs $89. It says "compare to $139!" on the price tag. OK, yes, $89 is less than $139. Problem is, I have no idea where that $139 number came from.

    OldArmyMetal Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    E Menendez
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    So true. If you were not planning to buy a product (such as a purse, rug, etc.) then you are spending money you weren't planning to. It doesn't matter how much of a sale it is, you just wasted money. Unless you leave it packed up to replace your current purse or rug when it wears out. I do this when I find something I like and it happens to be on sale - like a wallet, shoes, etc. If it is on sale I will buy it and keep it stored until I need it to replace. But no more than one extra.

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #8

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Dental care.

    Nothing worse than having a tooth f*****g *shatter* because the cheap dentist you went to years ago did the silver fillings (this was mid-2000's, what the hell?) completely improperly. One of them had a small space under it that just let infection go to town regardless of brushing. Had to get a root canal there. Then having to go and get all the fillings he did redone... Cost way more and was way more painful in the long run.

    Go to a well-rated dentist, regardless of cost.

    Ringo_Roadagain , Andrea Piacquadio Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Luna Crow
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Yes, *if* you can, do. I really wish the US wasn't so behind other countries on things like this. Many dental procedures are considered "cosmetic" and not covered, never mind that it can impact your health. I've gone to Mexico for dental work and saved enough money that I could afford to stay there and vacation for a while

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    ADVERTISEMENT
    ADVERTISEMENT
    #9

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Car maintenance. Small things like oil changes and getting your tires rotated and aligned saves wear and tear and fuel costs. Plus, it's nice to know that couple-few thousand pound hunk of metal you're piloting at 75 MPH down the road is taken care of.

    pope0476 , Andrea Piacquadio Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    LazyPanda
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Yes! Absolutely. Take care of your car and it will last. You won't have to trade in for a new one every 3 years...

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu

    I have to admit, there are some things on this list that I myself am guilty of, such as washing sandwich bags and reusing them. But that has never hurt my quality of life. What would negatively impact me would be buying the cheapest winter coat possible and suffering through the snow and freezing temperatures just to save a little money. Or worse, buying a “cheap” coat and then hating it so much that I end up spending much more in the long run when I have to invest in another coat. It is important to know where it is worth it to spend and where it’s worth it to save. Some things, such as a winter coat, are worth investing in to ensure they last. Putting off going to the doctor or dentist to avoid paying a bill is also not likely to be worth it. If you wait until you’re forced to go to the emergency room when your health problems inevitably escalate, you will likely be suffering physically and financially a lot more than you would have had you made a routine appointment months prior.

    ADVERTISEMENT
    #10

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Anything going into your body - oral medication, contact lens etc.

    Recently read an article about a guy that wore cheap contact lens he bought from a gas station for a year and is now blind in one eye.

    If it's going into your body (or in your eye!) spend the extra $$ for your health

    Keica , איתן טל Report

    #11

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Toilet paper. Cheap TP just feels like sandpaper.

    blueflameangel , Anna Shvets Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    percysowner
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Also invest under $50 and buy a bidet. If you are handy they are easy to install, if not it's not that big a lift to pay a handyman to do it. It pays itself off in TP costs pretty quickly and if there is another shortage, you don't have to worry as much. Plus you are just so much cleaner.

    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #12

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) People that drive across town to save a couple cents off a gallon of milk [don't actually save money]

    Alexlam24 , AshokaJegroo Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Luna Crow
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    This is true, but also depends on the savings. I will drive across town to buy gas for a dollar less per gallon

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu

    According to Tim Jordan, the man behind Atypical Finance, “There should be no deprivation when it comes to being frugal.” He explains that the true meaning of being frugal is about being intentional with your money. Frugal people don’t throw their money away on impulsive purchases that they will later regret or waste it on things they don’t need. But it does not mean that you should make yourself miserable pinching pennies and denying yourself and loved ones an occasional evening out, a car that has a working heater or showers that take longer than 2 minutes. “Determining what you value is the very essence of being frugal,” Tim writes on his blog. “You have to know yourself and what you do and do not like. It is the conscious decision to not spend money on certain things (what you don’t value) so you can spend money on other things (what you do value).”

    #13

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Pillows. I bought a good pillow and I've never slept better.

    anon , Andrea Piacquadio Report

    #14

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) For me, food. And I don't mean going out to eat. I do cook myself, but when I buy meat or fish I usually go to a store I trust and spend a few extra bucks on it.

    anon , José Ignacio Pompé Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Brenda Spagnola-Wilson
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    I'd rather have a smaller excellent cut of meat than a cheaper average (or poor) cut. In the end, you'll enjoy it more and it's better for you.

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #15

    Eye surgery.

    letkiewiczj Report

    If you haven’t already learned from your own experiences or from the responses you’ve read on this list, there are plenty of ways being too frugal can come back to bite you. Financial expert Jim Garnet, also known as “Ask Mr. G” spoke to NBC News about the dangers of being too stingy, and one of the first things he warns people not to do is ignore insurance. It may seem costly up front, but it will certainly be worth it when a rainy day comes around. “One accident, one major illness, one fire, or one death can literally send us to the bankruptcy court if we are not insured adequately,” Garnet notes. It’s always better to be safe than sorry when it comes to insurance. 

    #16

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Frugal doesn't mean cheap. Getting a $300 pair of shoes that lasts you >5 years is frugal. Getting $50 ones that will fall apart after a few months not so much. Ditto with getting good roof shingles, etc.

    That being said don't be frugal on vacation or when you're having a blast. That's not to say blow all your money in a night, but don't miss out on the time of your life because there might be a bargain around the corner.

    DFP_ , Riccardo Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Rachknits
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    This is why being poor is expensive, I don't have that kind of money to spend in the first place (not complaining, I'm happy with my income, I value different things but some people don't realise that when you're poor you barely have enough to buy cheap shoes, never mind good quality ones)

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #17

    Contractors to fix something in your home.

    Just because someone comes in a few thousand under everyone else quotes you with doesn't mean their work is equally as good

    FlapJackSam Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Brenda Spagnola-Wilson
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Check average prices, ask for references, check with the BBB. Quality work is worth paying for

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #18

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Car seat. You don't have to get an expensive one, but if you buy it second hand, you don't know if it was ever in an accident.

    uncertainhope , Erik Mclean Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Brenda Spagnola-Wilson
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Yesterday my son, his pregnant girlfriend and their 14 month old son were in a bad hit & run accident. Car was totaled but they are OK. Grandson was in his NEW car seat.car hit his side, but he was spared injuries because his car seat saved him! I thank God we bought it 2 months ago! Best $$$ I ever spent

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    See Also on Bored Panda

    One thing that can take up the bulk of many of our budgets is food. But it’s another thing that we should be wary of becoming too cheap about. Cathi Brese Doebler, author of Ditch The Joneses, Discover Your Family, told NBC News, “If you spend less money on food, but the food is unhealthy, you can impact your health over time. This can lead to long-term health problems and more visits to the doctor," says Brese Doebler. "Many healthy foods can also be affordable foods." A lot of being frugal comes down to thinking about the future as well, not simply opting for the cheapest choice at that moment. It’s much easier to keep your body healthy than to try to fix or eliminate issues later down the line. 

    #19

    I knew a guy who bought lottery tickets because if he ever won, "it'd be the smartest investment he could've ever made".

    How can you be right and so stupid at the same time?

    SECRETLY_STALKS_YOU Report

    #20

    Winter boots and coats. Don't go too expensive but you really don't want something falling apart in the middle of winter

    darkphoenix168 Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    C C
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    I've had the same Land's End winter wool coat for at least a decade and it's still worthy of the expensive price tag. Live near the great lakes so it can get mighty cold

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #21

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) *Roofing shingles.*

    If you're replacing your home's roof, roofing shingles come in all quality grades for duration (10-year, 20-year, 30-year, lifetime, etc.)

    Since most of the cost is in the labor, prep and clean-up, it pays to buy the better quality, long-lasting shingles so you don't have to do the job again. Plus, it's a selling point when you put the house on the market to have a superior, long-lasting roof.

    Back2Bach , Skylar Kang Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Brenda Spagnola-Wilson
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Don't underestimate the value of an excellent roofing product AND installation, especially when it comes to resale!

    View more commentsArrow down menu

    We hope this list is inspiring you to be a bit more frugal if you can, but not too frugal. Don’t let your desire to save money negatively impact your life or your health, and know when it’s worth it to splurge to save yourself time, energy and even money in the future. Keep upvoting the responses mentioning things you’re willing to spend money on as well, and feel free to share any other “false frugalities” you refuse to get on board with in the comments. Then if you’d like to check out Bored Panda’s last article on this same topic, you can find that right here.  

    #22

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) It doesn't pay to cheap out on cooking knives. It's amazing how much more you enjoy cooking when cutting ingredients isn't an infuriating process. You can get by with cheaper pots and pans but buying at least one decent chef knife makes a huge difference.

    I should say knives are less of a thing to be really cheap about than frugal. You can get some great knives for $25-50. I'm not getting snobby about needing a $500 Japanese steel knife hand forged in a volcano, you just need to find ones that work for you. And pans are more important to the quality of your food but I find many of my friends and family don't consider a knife as important as the cookware. As others have pointed out a [bad] knife can still be made sharp but I still think it's well worth spending a little money for a knife that will last and make cooking less frustrating.

    Young_Omni_Man , Airam Dato-on Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    RafCo (he/him)
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Not gonna lie. I love my $200 hand forged Japanese Santoku knife. I also have a hand forged Japanese pairing knife that is lovely

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #23

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Clothes. I'm not saying spend more than you can afford, but I think it's worth it to spend a little more up front on the things you wear a lot (for me, it's khaki pants and button down shirts), and have basics that last, rather than getting the cheaper stuff and have it c**p out quickly. You wind up spending more in the long run when you buy cheap clothes.

    akanefive , Ylanite Koppens Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Luna Crow
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Two words: thrift stores. If you know where to look, you can get quality clothing for a fraction of what you'd pay for new cheap clothes

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #24

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) I always buy really expensive underwear and make up for it by buying really cheap bags of socks. And before you get all excited, I'm a dude and we're talking boxer briefs. Good underwear is one of those things that can make a difference in how comfortable you are all day long.

    underdabridge , pxhere Report

    #25

    Tools.

    anon Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Luna Crow
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Depends on the tool. Some of them are going to get beat up no matter what. With power tools though, definitely invest in a reliable brand

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #26

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) The majority of people who coupon [end up spending more]. You're buying items that you probably didn't need, won't use, only because they're cheaper with a coupon.

    JudgySheebs , Mandy_Jansen Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    Domo KO
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Meh I'd like to see the statistic behind this. My opinion is anecdotal but everyone I know that uses coupons actually uses it for things that they need or they know they're going to use. I don't see someone, who's looking to save money, waste it by getting something they're not going to use.

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #27

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) Computer power supplies.

    Aleczarnder , Andre Tan Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    cogadh
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Eh. Not so much. Absolutely, don't cheap out and get the questionable no-name model, but those top of the line branded models are really no better than any other model that has the same performance rating. Most of the time you are only paying extra for the paint job or the cable options, not the power performance or reliability.

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #28

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) A suit.

    Granted, you don't have to go spend a couple thousand dollars (though you can, and you'll notice the difference), but don't go buy one off the rack at Macy's. Spend the $600-700 to get a perfectly tailored suit. You will feel so GD confident walking around in that thing, it is absolutely ridiculous.

    And beyond that, I tend to spend the money necessary to get a high quality item, if 2 cheaper alternatives are more expensive than one quality one. The idea here being that, if I'm going to have to replace this item because I bought cheap, I'm better off buying one I won't have to replace.

    Things like: clothes racks, umbrellas, kitchen utensils/pans/knives, tools for the house, electronics.

    ChicagoCowboy , Pavel Danilyuk Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    kath morgan
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Buying the off the rack suit and getting it altered probably still works out cheaper.

    View more commentsArrow down menu
    See Also on Bored Panda
    #29

    Musical instruments. Especially if you are a beginner! Good quality helps you play better.

    ConnieConehead Report

    Add photo comments
    POST
    RafCo (he/him)
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Bad advice. You want something that won't warp and sound like c**p, but you don't need to buy a grand piano to start learning. Buy an Epiphone before you invest in a Les Paul. A quality acoustic guitar will be around $150. You will hear the difference if you buy a $1000 guitar, but you will still suck at playing it for a few years.

    Jen Hart
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    I'm thinking of musical instruments in general; many people start learning in elementary or middle school, before they may be good at taking care of the thing... so medium-low quality would be the way to go.

    Load More Replies...
    Ba-Na-Na
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    But if you don’t keep playing or just hate the instrument… you’ve like, wasted a bunch of money. Why not see if it’s something you’re interested in long term first?

    Bobby
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    I think they mean don't buy the cheap but pretty instruments all over Amazon. Those are horrible and will make you not want to play. Instead of that really pretty lacquered sax for 100 on Amazon get the used Yamaha that's scratched up and not shiny at all from your local band store for 200. Yeah it's twice the cost but you'll actually be able to play that one

    Load More Replies...
    William Tinsley
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Yeah I've been playing stringed instruments for over 25 years and I actually recommend learning on something cheap. If you can learn to play that it'll be all that easier to play well on something higher end after a couple of years

    Argle Bargle
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    I was so excited to play my upgraded violin after playing on a piece of junk when I began. My playing improved out of sight. I just splurged on new strings yesterday, and I cannot stop playing. So mellow and fresh. Bet you can relate

    Load More Replies...
    moggie63
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    I wanted to play the trumpet at school and my mum bought me a cheap one from God knows where to start. When I passed my Grade 5 a couple of years later she bought me a new one for £400 (about £4000 in today's money) as she knew I would definitely be using it. Although I no longer play, 40 years later I still have that trumpet.

    harpling
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Better yet: find a place that will rent good quality instruments. I tell my students not to bother actually buying a harp until they've decided for absolute certain whether they're going to continue playing for a very long time. Harps are incredibly expensive, even cheap ones. Fortunately, there are several harp companies that have rent-to-own setups for students.

    The Darkest Timeline
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    As a band director, I can tell you there is a bunch of garbage out there. $100 trumpet or $230 saxophone from Amazon or Walmart? Complete waste of money. They break and bend easily, are poorly made so often work improperly leading to frustration and failure. You’re best off finding a decent QUALITY used instrument for about the same price as the new one off the internet. Then, if you continue, you can upgrade to a better model but even then, there are good used instruments available.

    David Paterson
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Agree. Don't buy the cheapest violin, piano, cello, harp, drums, etc. Unfortunately, more expensive instruments sound better. Learning to play on an instrument that produces an unpleasant sound is a huge mistake, it will become a chore rather than a pleasure. That said, I do know a violinist who bought the absolute cheapest violin and immediately replaced the strings, bridge and pegs with top quality components.

    UpQuarkDownQuark
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    This was true 30 years ago, well made cheap instruments abound these days. I bought a $169 Telecaster-style guitar from Rondo Music, spent a $100 on a new nut and setup, and it plays like a dream. I constantly get compliments on my guitar tone. I’ve been playing for more than 30 years. Taking it to a good guitar tech is the real key to a playable instrument, expensive or cheap.

    GadgetGirl
    Community Member
    2 years ago (edited) DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    No. Band teacher wanted us to buy the most expensive retail instrument for kiddo to learn on. We did not. 4 months later, kiddo broke both wrists and couldn't play anymore. During the long recovery from that, different interests took it's place. Expensive is for a definite, lifetime hobby. Not just learning it well enough to see if you like it. Edit to add: the instrument doesn't help you play better. Practice does. I promise the keys on the expensive instrument are in the exact same place as on the cheaper one.

    Bobby
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    The funny thing is, at least my experience with woodwinds, cheaper student models are more forgiving on embrachure than professional models so they are easier to learn on

    Load More Replies...
    Shine Chisholm
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    My kid started playing cello at 3. One of her classmates (they had both individual and group lessons) had a cello made out of plywood. That student hated practicing, and I don't blame her! My kid's instrument was expensive rent to own, but after 9 years she's in the youth orchestra still loving it.

    Shine Chisholm
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    To clarify-- cellos come in different sizes, and this rental place transferred equity when we sized up. She went from a 1/10 size (it was SO CUTE) and is now on a 1/2.

    Load More Replies...
    Bloobee bloobee bloo bloo bloo
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Not true. My 12 year old started playing the trumpet last school year with a loaner from the school. This year I decided to splurge and get a professionally refurbished rent to own $1000 trumpet and literally the only difference is how bright and shiny her new one is

    Bobby
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    With wind instruments embrachure is very important. Student instruments tend to be more forgiving that intermediate and professional in this regard. If he sounds the same in both horns he likely needs practice on embrachure. A 1000 horn should sound brighter than the loaner, but I'll also say that a surprising number of loaner trumpets that schools use are of a very good quality. Some of those old Conn and Selmer horns from like the 50s and earlier were very solid instruments

    Load More Replies...
    Bobby
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Honestly if you've heard of the brand before their beginner or student model is probably good too start on. My advice is unless you know what you are doing only buy from a store. You might find a clarinet for 30 bucks that is the same as the one you saw for 100 in the store, but I guarantee that market place horn needs a repad and maybe a mechanical overhaul before its playable and that kind of repair can run up to about 250

    RandomFrog(He/They️‍️)
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Somewhat good. My first guitar was 200$, pretty good for what was in the store. I sucked at playing. Showed up to class and I couldn’t even get the notes to make sounds on the frets. Now I’d say I’m quiet a bit more experienced, and would maybe splurge on the nicer $400-700 ones they had in there. Whilst on the other hand I bought a cheap keyboard (piano) and I totally suck at piano unless I hyperfocus on a song for a week or two, and I don’t need a full a*s arrangement of keys and strings. I hardly play songs and if I do I’m not going to be jumping from the lowest to the highest, also I have no room for a grand piano. But now I’m not out $10,000 for something I won’t use.

    Mark Secker
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    that said there are some great budget instruments - the $200 Squier Affinity I had had a better neck than some guitars three times the price (and a bad neck will put off new players like nothing else)... sure not the greatest pickups and hardware but more than good enough to learn, to jam with friends, and even gig with when you're at that stage.... moving on purchased a Fender Mexican Player series, 4 times the price and probably 3 times as good and is a sweet spot for intermediate and pro players - anything more expensive gets less and less better.

    William Smith
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Awful advice. A 1200 dollar guitar + several hundreds more on amps, pedals and whatever else can still sound like sh-t.

    Tammy Kirks
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    If you're going to buy a musical instrument go to a music store and talk to the pros! They are there to help you make the best decision for *your* needs! Walmart may be cheap, but you'll get way more for your time and money having a professional help you with your purchase. And every music store has affordable options. They are not there to gouge you or talk you into something expensive. Trust them!

    Fxnglhl
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    in my opinion, if ur a beginner u can get by with a cheaper instrument, but as u progress more u can upgrade to better instruments. when i started piano few years ago i got one of those electric pianos. i'm planning on upgrading to an actual upright acoustic piano in another few years.

    Fxnglhl
    Community Member
    2 years ago

    This comment has been deleted.

    Load More Replies...
    Ruth Hempsey
    Community Member
    2 years ago (edited) DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Artist's supplies once you're a bit more than a novice, not a beginner. Too much waste, and maybe you won't keep at it for long enough to make good stuff worthwhile.

    iseefractals
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    .....NO. If you don't know how to play a $75 instrument, you're not going to do any better on a $1000 instrument. You can't buy skill or proficiency. Some people just lack the capacity to play, or play well, while some will find they just don't enjoy it no matter how much they would like to. It's like the people who spend $2000 a treadmill because they want to get in shape and having the "best" will make it easier to do! 6 months later, it's got a layer of dust, 3 jackets hanging from it and you've gained 10 pounds because the problem is the cost of the machine but how much YOU are willing to work to reach a goal.

    GoldfishCrackers
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    I say rent if you’re starting out. THEN see if it’s worth it to you to buy something nice.

    Temporary Dork
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    My mom selected three different instruments for me & my sister by bringing an experienced player (she asked around) with her to the store and selecting the cheapest recorder/flute/piano that was at least capable of producing pretty sounds. That worked.

    Real Princess
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    I was given a used B-flat clarinet. I ended up being first chair first clarinet. After that my mother gifted me a terribly expensive professional clarinet.

    Captain Awesome
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Don't buy cheap, don't buy top grade. Middle range is perfect for beginners.

    Gabby Ghoul
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Although I do agree that a higher-quality instrument is easier or more enjoyable to play, I cannot recommend going top-of-the-line on a beginner.

    Bobby
    Community Member
    2 years ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

    Also for instruments I would say if you are good enough that you need to upgrade to the "intermediate" instrument and you are planning on playing professionally then just go for the professional model. You're already good enough you need a higher quality instrument and you plan on playing professionally, skip that middle tier, those are for hobbyists (like myself) in my opinion.

    View More Replies...
    View more commentsArrow down menu
    #30

    People Are Sharing Examples Of Where Frugality Is Taken Too Far, And Things That Are Actually Worth The Money (30 Answers) When you start sharing toothbrushes, it doesn't even save money, they just wear out twice as fast!

    neverdox , Henrik Lagercrantz Report