Mom Keeps Having Kids She Can’t Afford, Teen Finally Loses Patience
Interview With ExpertChildhood should be all about growing, learning, and having fun. However, not all parents can afford to provide the stability and resources needed for such a childhood. Some may even rely on their kids for help, urging them to take over their responsibilities like childcare, housework, and money earning.
This teenager found himself in a similar situation, frequently taking care of his siblings and home, as both parents worked long hours, trying to catch up on bills. But the last straw for him was his mom getting pregnant with another child, which pushed him to provide her with a reality check.
Scroll down to find the full story and a conversation with Dr. Jennifer Toof, therapist and owner of Trauma Informed Counseling and Consulting, Dr. Maya Weir, clinical psychologist and founder of Thriving California, and Gayle Weill, a licensed psychotherapist, who kindly agreed to tell us how children can be affected when they take over parental responsibilities.
Not all parents can afford to provide children with the childhood they deserve
Image credits: Sébastien Mouilleau / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Just like these parents, who, despite not being able to afford or take care of their already existing children, are still having more kids
Image credits: Getty Images / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Daniel Martinez / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: ZookeepergameLeft184
“Children taking over adult responsibilities before they are ready to do so is often referred to as adultification or parentification”
“Children taking over adult responsibilities before they are ready to do so is often referred to as adultification or parentification,” explains Dr. Jennifer Toof, therapist and owner of Trauma Informed Counseling and Consulting. “Essentially, they become the caregiver to parents or younger siblings. It can indeed be considered a form of trauma, particularly in extreme cases, with both short- and long-term effects.”
Momentary effects can include elevated stress, anxiety, depression, difficulty regulating emotions, and behavioral problems, says Dr. Toof. In the long term, children who were parentified are more likely to struggle with relationships. They might particularly find it difficult to set boundaries, trust others and avoid unhealthy relationships. They’re also at higher risk of experiencing physical and mental health issues like anxiety, depression, eating disorders, and substance use disorders.
“It can lead to arrested development, where children miss out on critical stages of growth, such as building social skills or exploring their identity,” adds Gayle Weill, a licensed psychotherapist.
However, Dr. Maya Weir, clinical psychologist and founder of Thriving California, notes that children can thrive when given responsibilities at home, but they have to be age-appropriate and not overwhelming. “It makes them feel like participants and that the family is working as a team. However, if children are given too many tasks or tasks that are not appropriate for their age, this is when mental health issues will occur.”
Parents don’t always pass over their responsibilities to children intentionally
Image credits: Sandra Seitamaa / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Experts say that parents don’t always pass over their responsibilities to children intentionally. They might do this because they are overwhelmed, lack support and can’t afford resources like childcare or house cleaners. “They may feel that they have no choice but to pass responsibilities over to their children. Oftentimes, parents are working long hours or multiple jobs so they need their children to do adult-like tasks,” says Dr. Weir.
“Sometimes parents don’t realize the emotional burden they’re placing on their child, especially if they were raised the same way,” additionally notes Weill.
When children feel parentified, they should speak up, but only if they feel safe. “Children should speak up if they feel they are being parentified/adultified, as it’s important for them to have their feelings heard and needs met,” says Dr. Toof.
However, they shouldn’t feel like they have to do it alone. “A trusted adult or therapist can help them express their feelings and advocate for change. The goal is to ensure children can contribute in ways that build skills without sacrificing their childhood,” says Weill.
“Additionally, professional help can mitigate potential trauma symptoms in the child through various therapeutic approaches,” mentions Dr. Toof.
Parents should also take a step back and evaluate if the tasks they’re giving their child are appropriate. And if their kid approaches them having issues with this, they should listen, says Dr. Weir.
“If the adults do listen, there may be a way to do some creative brainstorming around how to support the family with more resources (like maybe the kids can stay in aftercare or they can go to friends/family after school, etc.). Also, if parents are unfamiliar with the downsides of giving children too many tasks, they may need some education around the harm this can cause,” she concludes.
The majority of readers were on the teenager’s side, assuring him that he’s a good kid
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
Blocking him from getting a job, then refusing to drive him to school and turn off his phone is very manipulative. It won't be long until he figures out how to get an ID and job without her. I also hope she realizes eventually her younger kids will grow, and if she treats all of them this way, they may go no or low contact once they leave.
Glad OP only has two years left and can then get some distance. Sounds like he had to raise himself and did a pretty good job. It's brutal to wait that long, but once you're out it's worth it.
So she loves being a mother? Which part? Some really like babies, but don't like their children much after they reach a certain age.
And some people just like beings martyrs and having something to b***h and complain about nonstop.
Load More Replies...Can't believe no one said it. She loves being a mother to infants/toddlers. This is the human version of the person who adopts a puppy and then drops it off at the pound six months later and then repeats the cycle. She needs help, badly.
OP is focused on his mother but his father is equally the problem. He needs to get his father to give him his id. If the father won’t, search the house until he finds it. In the meantime, get under the table work like yard work or snow shoveling. Then be out of the house as much as possible working, at the gf’s or at school.
As usual, the YTAs are unhinged and clueless. I have walked in this poor kids shoes. I can say from personal experience that having a serious talk will not improve his situation. It will make things 10x worse. Parents like this think they are the best parents in the world and they are incapable of failing their children. So, having their children point out their failures as a parent is the ultimate betrayal. They will go nuclear and making the children pay for their insolence.
I just wouldn't do s**t at home anymore and stay out as much as possible.
Exactly my thoughts. If his mother even looked like she was going to stick him with parental duties, he should just walk out. Hopefully, he has a friend he could stay with every time this happens. Perhaps he could ask a friend's parents how to get an ID for work, and inform them about what's going on under his roof. They may be able to get him the help he needs to break free.
Load More Replies...I'm not sure which country he's in, but i suggest working with his school's guidance counselor.
Cont'd.... school counselors are pretty good at helping students get the resources needed to work; mine helped me with a work permit document when I was 15. Guidance counselors are there to guide you into adulthood.
Load More Replies...I live in the U.S. and when my son was of the age to get working papers, he took the initiative (I never pushed him to work, he wanted his own money). He went to the school guidance officer or whoever helped kids get working papers. I did need to sign them, once they were filled out, but the dad could also sign them, in this instance.
If this horrible woman is going to insist upon treating her womb like a clown car, she shouldn't be making it this poor kid's problem.
It would be very sad if he sees it right. But he's also a teenager and lots of teenagers think their parents are extremely unreasonable while they themselves are the perfect child. So I wonder if there's another side to (parts of) this story? I would like to hear what his parents and other adults who know this family, think about this situation.
If OP's in the US, there has to be resources for him to get out of this situation, other than waiting it out until he's 18. A school counselor, CPS or DCF, someone has to be able to help him. A foster home until he is an adult may be his only option.
To some extent I think we have a whinging teenager, but we also see parents who seem disconnected from the family. Again a lot of this seems to be Normal teenage angst. Most teenagers think there parents are ignoring them, that they are in the wrong, that their parents don't see how good their teenager is. But honestly it does sound like he's trying to get a job. As for tge walking to school, yes he should if at all possible - we need to use cars less and it's good exercise. Yes he should help around the house and he's probably not doing as much as he says he is - teenagers often think they do more than they have. He is incredibly callous about his mother's miscarriage, that may be because of his extreme youth and lack of worldly experience. Mum wanting another child is Normal after a miscarriage, yes it does sound selfish but tge loss of a pregnancy is really hard emotionally. I think tge truth in this post is somewhere in the middle.
100% of unwanted pregnancies are caused by MEN. Stop blaming women for everything. Recently there was an article on BP about a father being awful to his kid so of course the mom was trashed instead of him. And the missing woman was blamed for the actions of her dad. Stop it. I'm tired of men getting a pass for everything they do and women taking the fall. OK, end rant.
I think by now even she's figured out how babies are made.
Load More Replies...Blocking him from getting a job, then refusing to drive him to school and turn off his phone is very manipulative. It won't be long until he figures out how to get an ID and job without her. I also hope she realizes eventually her younger kids will grow, and if she treats all of them this way, they may go no or low contact once they leave.
Glad OP only has two years left and can then get some distance. Sounds like he had to raise himself and did a pretty good job. It's brutal to wait that long, but once you're out it's worth it.
So she loves being a mother? Which part? Some really like babies, but don't like their children much after they reach a certain age.
And some people just like beings martyrs and having something to b***h and complain about nonstop.
Load More Replies...Can't believe no one said it. She loves being a mother to infants/toddlers. This is the human version of the person who adopts a puppy and then drops it off at the pound six months later and then repeats the cycle. She needs help, badly.
OP is focused on his mother but his father is equally the problem. He needs to get his father to give him his id. If the father won’t, search the house until he finds it. In the meantime, get under the table work like yard work or snow shoveling. Then be out of the house as much as possible working, at the gf’s or at school.
As usual, the YTAs are unhinged and clueless. I have walked in this poor kids shoes. I can say from personal experience that having a serious talk will not improve his situation. It will make things 10x worse. Parents like this think they are the best parents in the world and they are incapable of failing their children. So, having their children point out their failures as a parent is the ultimate betrayal. They will go nuclear and making the children pay for their insolence.
I just wouldn't do s**t at home anymore and stay out as much as possible.
Exactly my thoughts. If his mother even looked like she was going to stick him with parental duties, he should just walk out. Hopefully, he has a friend he could stay with every time this happens. Perhaps he could ask a friend's parents how to get an ID for work, and inform them about what's going on under his roof. They may be able to get him the help he needs to break free.
Load More Replies...I'm not sure which country he's in, but i suggest working with his school's guidance counselor.
Cont'd.... school counselors are pretty good at helping students get the resources needed to work; mine helped me with a work permit document when I was 15. Guidance counselors are there to guide you into adulthood.
Load More Replies...I live in the U.S. and when my son was of the age to get working papers, he took the initiative (I never pushed him to work, he wanted his own money). He went to the school guidance officer or whoever helped kids get working papers. I did need to sign them, once they were filled out, but the dad could also sign them, in this instance.
If this horrible woman is going to insist upon treating her womb like a clown car, she shouldn't be making it this poor kid's problem.
It would be very sad if he sees it right. But he's also a teenager and lots of teenagers think their parents are extremely unreasonable while they themselves are the perfect child. So I wonder if there's another side to (parts of) this story? I would like to hear what his parents and other adults who know this family, think about this situation.
If OP's in the US, there has to be resources for him to get out of this situation, other than waiting it out until he's 18. A school counselor, CPS or DCF, someone has to be able to help him. A foster home until he is an adult may be his only option.
To some extent I think we have a whinging teenager, but we also see parents who seem disconnected from the family. Again a lot of this seems to be Normal teenage angst. Most teenagers think there parents are ignoring them, that they are in the wrong, that their parents don't see how good their teenager is. But honestly it does sound like he's trying to get a job. As for tge walking to school, yes he should if at all possible - we need to use cars less and it's good exercise. Yes he should help around the house and he's probably not doing as much as he says he is - teenagers often think they do more than they have. He is incredibly callous about his mother's miscarriage, that may be because of his extreme youth and lack of worldly experience. Mum wanting another child is Normal after a miscarriage, yes it does sound selfish but tge loss of a pregnancy is really hard emotionally. I think tge truth in this post is somewhere in the middle.
100% of unwanted pregnancies are caused by MEN. Stop blaming women for everything. Recently there was an article on BP about a father being awful to his kid so of course the mom was trashed instead of him. And the missing woman was blamed for the actions of her dad. Stop it. I'm tired of men getting a pass for everything they do and women taking the fall. OK, end rant.
I think by now even she's figured out how babies are made.
Load More Replies...
29
24