Man Sparks Family Feud After Telling Sister A Pregnancy Announcement Isn’t A Christmas Present
Good communication and timing aren’t just useful at the office, they can be very helpful in family contexts, too. When a relative of yours announces that they’re having a child, it’s usually cause for celebration. However, there’s a time and a place for this sort of happy moment. Generally, you want to make the announcement its own thing instead of having it overlap with other celebrations.
Redditor u/OkSeaworthiness6960 went viral on the AITAH online group after sharing a disagreement he had with his family over the holidays. According to the author, instead of a proper Christmas present, his sister gave him a wrapped-up pregnancy test. However, he called her out on this, claiming that this doesn’t count as a proper Xmas gift. He asked for the internet’s verdict. Scroll down to read the full story. Bored Panda has reached out to the author for further comment, and we’ll update the article as soon as we hear back from him.
When your entire family has a long-running tradition of exchanging gifts, naturally, you expect to get something
Image credits: francescosgura (not the actual photo)
One man was upset that instead of a proper present, his sister announced that she was having a child
Image credits: Farknot (not the actual photo)
Image credits: OkSeaworthiness6960
Raising children is very expensive. Some parents start prioritizing their finances when they learn they’re pregnant
As a rule of thumb, if you and your family agree to exchange Christmas presents, then you should follow through. It’d be weird to go back on your promise.
Not to mention that if you have a long-running family tradition that spans years or even decades, it means a lot to everyone that you honor it. The point isn’t the exact tradition itself, so much as there is a tradition that connects everyone and gives them a reason to get together.
Of course, you could argue that the mother-to-be’s new top priority is her child. And raising kids is expensive, so it makes some sense to save every penny… though this shouldn’t be done at the expense of your relationships.
As per Investopedia, it costs a lot of money to raise a child in the United States. Data from the Brookings Institution economic think tank shows that the average middle-income American family with two children will spend $310,605 to raise a child born in 2015 up to the age of 17 in 2032.
This is a very marked increase from previous stats published by the US Department of Agriculture which back in 2017 estimated the cost to be $233,610.
The greatest expense for parents is housing, which eats up around a third of their income and covers things from mortgage and rent to taxes, insurance, repairs, utilities, maintenance, and household goods. Of course, the exact expenses will vary depending on your lifestyle and where you live.
None of these expenses factor in the cost of higher education, which can balloon the cost of raising a child even further. A lot will depend on the particular program, its length, and whether it’s a public or private university.
The average annual in-state cost for a public college in the US for the 2023-2024 academic year was $24,030. The cost was $56,190 for private colleges. These numbers include tuition, fees, and room and board.
Image credits: Rawpixel (not the actual photo)
That being said, family traditions and good relationships with your loved ones are also important. There’s also a time and a place for pregnancy announcements
Though, to be fair, getting your loved ones a gift or two once a year isn’t going to destroy your budget. What’s more, when one person feels left out, it’s going to strain your relationship and lead to some resentment. That’s not great for you if you hope to ask them to babysit your kid in the future.
If your children are your top priority in life, that’s all fair. That being said, they can’t be your only priority. People are more than just parents. And life is more than just about raising kids. There has to be some sort of balance.
You’ve got other important people in your life to maintain relationships with, namely your family and friends. If you constantly neglect and ignore them, you might regret it later. Meanwhile, you also can’t forget your career, passion projects, creative hobbies, health, etc.
Meanwhile, there’s the question of timing. Broadly speaking, you shouldn’t make any important announcements if they overlap with massive events or other people’s celebrations. This is so that the event doesn’t suddenly start revolving around you and you alone.
For instance, you shouldn’t announce that you’re pregnant or engaged at someone else’s wedding or engagement party. Similarly, it feels a bit bizarre to announce your pregnancy via a Secret Santa gift. Such an important piece of news deserves the right setting. You could, for example, invite your loved ones over to dinner at your place to share the happy news.
Alternatively, if your family is scattered all over the world and rarely gets together in the same place except for the holidays, then your announcement could happen after all the gift exchanges, festivities, etc.
You could use it as a way to finish the family gathering on a high note. And it doesn’t have to be anything overly elaborate. Simply getting up and telling everyone that you’d like to share some good news about the family expanding is enough. It’s also helpful if your partner is there by your side to offer you their support.
What’s your take, Pandas? Do you think the guy was right to be upset? How would you have announced your pregnancy to the entire family? Let us know in the comments.
Image credits: alexlucru123 (not the actual photo)
Most readers were on the guy’s side. Here’s what they said after reading through what happened
Not everyone was convinced. Some people called the man out for how he reacted
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
The family Secret Santa and the pregnancy announcement are two totally unrelated things. A pregnancy test is no more an appropriate gift than it is an appropriate dish to bring to a pot luck.
That last YTA thinking someone else's pregnancy test is a gift to you? Yeah, NO. She put herself in her own position. She could have gotten a token present from a charity or thrift shop, instead she thought that her miracle child with what sounds like a douche ex is HIS gift? Nope, real hard nope.
Yaaay, I got a stick you peed on as a christmas present! NTA, if she wanted to announce her pregnancy she could do it in general instead of gifting her BROTHER a used pregnancy test.
YTA's... STFU! Trolls! I mean really! I'm personally not a kid person, so, I'd be super p****d off!! I mean, what kind of creepy sister gives her brother her pregnancy test pee stick? That would be a little cringe to me. Oh, and WTF is a nibling (besides an annoying word to me?)?
Niblings is the niece/nephew equivalent for siblings, it is a proper word https://www.merriam-webster.com/wordplay/words-were-watching-nibling
Load More Replies...I'd ask for a "receipt" to return the "present". Sounds more like a burden than a present to me. Also, YTA fuggnuts, I hope Santa stuffs more peed-on sticks in your stockings this or next Christmas. SMH!!!
I'd also be asking where she got the empty DVD case from. Did she get it from a dumpster? Did she keep the DVDs and gave him the box without thinking? I know the DVDs aren't the important part, but it's super weird she used the box for OP's favorite show. --- More importantly, who is "fuggnuts"? I thought you were talking about one of the YTA reddit comments or another commenter here, but I didn't see any with that name.
Load More Replies...Easy fix: Next year the baby will be born, so you'll gift her the most obnoxious sound-toy for the baby. 😁
I've actually done something like that but you need to wait until the kid's 3-5 years old for it to be really effective. At that age a toy bugle or tin drum makes a GREAT present. 😇
Load More Replies...If I were OP, next Christmas, I'd make sure I got my sister. I would get a fancy box and when she opened it, there would be a 3x5 card that said "I pooped today!" in Sharpie. Yes, I would absolutely be TA... and proudly.
In Sharpie? Why not in poop? If you're going to go, go all the way.
Load More Replies...I like the "Regift her the peed-on stick for sis's baby shower." 🤣
Giving your BROTHER a postive pregnancy test is unhinged at best! Also seriously gross! Here i peed on this you can have it now. Smh
Play the long game with some petty revenge. Save the test and give it back to her or your parents the next time you get their name. Or if you want to up the crazy on the s**t gift next year do your own home pregnancy test and give that to her or your parents.
I would be miffed at a GIFT like that. I also don't like getting photos of relatives as gifts. Over the years 1 person seem to just give pictures of her son in a cheapish frame. Lovely picture nothing special, but I had already seen them as they had been posted online.
It is not a gift it is conditiononing to be her future servant via emotional manipulation.
Load More Replies...He should act like is actually a gift for him and say “I am weirded out that you were thinking of me while trying to get pregnant.” 😂
He should tell the family that he changed his mind and ask how soon after birth he can pick up his "Christmas present".
He should ask his sister how soon after birth he can pick up his 'Christmas present'. She gave it to him, he accepted it.
Since she peed on a stick and gave it to you, I would do the same for her birthday. The sick and twisted part of me would go with a used condom (my gift is letting you know that I don't plan on having kids anytime soon), but that would be going too far.
Sound like what the sister really needs is a Finnish baby box, since it sounds like she isn't adequately prepared....
My brother in law got very insulted when my husband and wasn't clapping when he told us our wedding present was to become aunt and uncle. For two years we had tried for a baby. He had been with this girl first 6months. 12 years married and still no kids. We are at best second class in the family.
Save that test strip and wave it everytime she asks you to babysit. "Nah, I'm good."
Love uncle Rumpelstiltskin... All I picture in my head is the scene from Shrek when they're having Fiona's baby shower and one if the seven dwarves is gifted to her as a nanny and he just keeps saying in an old man voice " where's the baby"... Like it's mine now hahahaha
OP's sister didn't get him a gift. She even said so: "her gift to me *and the family* was the pregnancy." The point of a secret Santa is to strengthen relationships; spend some time thinking about the other person and giving them something they would like. I'm really confused about the DVD case. If she took the time to choose that DVD case because she knew it was his favorite, then that is definitely a slap in the face; but if she didn't consider that at all it shows complete selfishness. Either way someone I wouldn't want to have a relationship with. This "gift" would have been passable if she had the DVDs set aside to give to her brother. I think the most important unanswered question is: where did she get packaging for a DVD of a TV show and what happened to the DVDs??? I'm so confused about that! --- OP was totally justified in asking about the DVDs and expressing his disappointment about not getting a gift. Maybe that could have been done privately. I hope he gave the stick back. NTA.
I like the Secret Santa idea, but unless the recipient is the father, the pregnancy test should not be the secret gift. All that said, OP there seemed a little too pouty and sulky about the whole thing. Have a sense of humor FFS.
I’m sure he does have a sense of humor, but there’s nothing funny about a positive pregnancy test....from your sister. It's weird.
Load More Replies...It was a s****y gift, but not worth ruining Christmas.
Load More Replies...Why? The sister needs her family's help in raising this child. What does that tell you? That she's not able to do it herself, therefore she shouldn't have a child.
Load More Replies...The family Secret Santa and the pregnancy announcement are two totally unrelated things. A pregnancy test is no more an appropriate gift than it is an appropriate dish to bring to a pot luck.
That last YTA thinking someone else's pregnancy test is a gift to you? Yeah, NO. She put herself in her own position. She could have gotten a token present from a charity or thrift shop, instead she thought that her miracle child with what sounds like a douche ex is HIS gift? Nope, real hard nope.
Yaaay, I got a stick you peed on as a christmas present! NTA, if she wanted to announce her pregnancy she could do it in general instead of gifting her BROTHER a used pregnancy test.
YTA's... STFU! Trolls! I mean really! I'm personally not a kid person, so, I'd be super p****d off!! I mean, what kind of creepy sister gives her brother her pregnancy test pee stick? That would be a little cringe to me. Oh, and WTF is a nibling (besides an annoying word to me?)?
Niblings is the niece/nephew equivalent for siblings, it is a proper word https://www.merriam-webster.com/wordplay/words-were-watching-nibling
Load More Replies...I'd ask for a "receipt" to return the "present". Sounds more like a burden than a present to me. Also, YTA fuggnuts, I hope Santa stuffs more peed-on sticks in your stockings this or next Christmas. SMH!!!
I'd also be asking where she got the empty DVD case from. Did she get it from a dumpster? Did she keep the DVDs and gave him the box without thinking? I know the DVDs aren't the important part, but it's super weird she used the box for OP's favorite show. --- More importantly, who is "fuggnuts"? I thought you were talking about one of the YTA reddit comments or another commenter here, but I didn't see any with that name.
Load More Replies...Easy fix: Next year the baby will be born, so you'll gift her the most obnoxious sound-toy for the baby. 😁
I've actually done something like that but you need to wait until the kid's 3-5 years old for it to be really effective. At that age a toy bugle or tin drum makes a GREAT present. 😇
Load More Replies...If I were OP, next Christmas, I'd make sure I got my sister. I would get a fancy box and when she opened it, there would be a 3x5 card that said "I pooped today!" in Sharpie. Yes, I would absolutely be TA... and proudly.
In Sharpie? Why not in poop? If you're going to go, go all the way.
Load More Replies...I like the "Regift her the peed-on stick for sis's baby shower." 🤣
Giving your BROTHER a postive pregnancy test is unhinged at best! Also seriously gross! Here i peed on this you can have it now. Smh
Play the long game with some petty revenge. Save the test and give it back to her or your parents the next time you get their name. Or if you want to up the crazy on the s**t gift next year do your own home pregnancy test and give that to her or your parents.
I would be miffed at a GIFT like that. I also don't like getting photos of relatives as gifts. Over the years 1 person seem to just give pictures of her son in a cheapish frame. Lovely picture nothing special, but I had already seen them as they had been posted online.
It is not a gift it is conditiononing to be her future servant via emotional manipulation.
Load More Replies...He should act like is actually a gift for him and say “I am weirded out that you were thinking of me while trying to get pregnant.” 😂
He should tell the family that he changed his mind and ask how soon after birth he can pick up his "Christmas present".
He should ask his sister how soon after birth he can pick up his 'Christmas present'. She gave it to him, he accepted it.
Since she peed on a stick and gave it to you, I would do the same for her birthday. The sick and twisted part of me would go with a used condom (my gift is letting you know that I don't plan on having kids anytime soon), but that would be going too far.
Sound like what the sister really needs is a Finnish baby box, since it sounds like she isn't adequately prepared....
My brother in law got very insulted when my husband and wasn't clapping when he told us our wedding present was to become aunt and uncle. For two years we had tried for a baby. He had been with this girl first 6months. 12 years married and still no kids. We are at best second class in the family.
Save that test strip and wave it everytime she asks you to babysit. "Nah, I'm good."
Love uncle Rumpelstiltskin... All I picture in my head is the scene from Shrek when they're having Fiona's baby shower and one if the seven dwarves is gifted to her as a nanny and he just keeps saying in an old man voice " where's the baby"... Like it's mine now hahahaha
OP's sister didn't get him a gift. She even said so: "her gift to me *and the family* was the pregnancy." The point of a secret Santa is to strengthen relationships; spend some time thinking about the other person and giving them something they would like. I'm really confused about the DVD case. If she took the time to choose that DVD case because she knew it was his favorite, then that is definitely a slap in the face; but if she didn't consider that at all it shows complete selfishness. Either way someone I wouldn't want to have a relationship with. This "gift" would have been passable if she had the DVDs set aside to give to her brother. I think the most important unanswered question is: where did she get packaging for a DVD of a TV show and what happened to the DVDs??? I'm so confused about that! --- OP was totally justified in asking about the DVDs and expressing his disappointment about not getting a gift. Maybe that could have been done privately. I hope he gave the stick back. NTA.
I like the Secret Santa idea, but unless the recipient is the father, the pregnancy test should not be the secret gift. All that said, OP there seemed a little too pouty and sulky about the whole thing. Have a sense of humor FFS.
I’m sure he does have a sense of humor, but there’s nothing funny about a positive pregnancy test....from your sister. It's weird.
Load More Replies...It was a s****y gift, but not worth ruining Christmas.
Load More Replies...Why? The sister needs her family's help in raising this child. What does that tell you? That she's not able to do it herself, therefore she shouldn't have a child.
Load More Replies...
45
63