Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
249
SIL Inherits House That Man Put His Money Into, Drama Ensues After He Refuses To Pay Her Taxes
Mixing money with family is like playing Monopoly – it starts off fun, but someone always ends up flipping the board. It’s a recipe for drama and sometimes epic meltdowns. Whether it’s lending a sibling some cash or investing in a relative’s big idea, money can turn even the closest relationships into a real family feud.
Our protagonist, John (we’ll stick with that name for now), learned this the hard way, when he moved closer to his in-laws to help them out and ended up in the middle of a real estate saga worthy of its own TV show. If you thought family drama was best left to soap operas, think again. We’ve got a juicy one here.
More info: Reddit
RELATED:
Couple spends $75k renovating the parents’ home, expecting to get it back after they pass away, once the house is sold, but the youngest sister inherits the house and asks them for tax money
Image credits: Sven Mieke (not the actual photo)
The couple buy a house close to the wife’s elderly parents to help take care of them and renovate their home, investing a lot of their own money into it
The husband expects to get the money back after the house is sold, but the younger sister inherits it and doesn’t want to sell it
Image credits: todd kent (not the actual photo)
The woman can’t afford to pay the $30K tax for the home, asks her sister to give her the money or she risks losing the family house
Image credits: Kinga Howard (not the actual photo)
Image credit: LateAfternoon9
“We poured enough of our own money into that pit”: the husband refuses to give his sister-in-law money to pay her taxes, leaving wife furious
Years ago, John and his wife made the noble decision to relocate near her elderly parents, snapping up a cozy house just a few streets away. But they weren’t just neighbors, as they soon became the parents’ go-to caretakers, investing a cool $75,000 into upgrading their home. We’re talking new carpet, shiny appliances, and even a couple of AC units that cost more than a luxury vacation.
The deal was that once the parents passed away, the house would be sold, and John and his wife would get their money back, with the rest of the profit divvied up among the siblings. Sounds fair, right? Wrong. Of course there is a plot twist in our story. If there wasn’t, you would probably not be reading about it right now.
When the wife’s parents passed away, instead of the anticipated sale and profit-sharing, the house was handed over entirely to the youngest sister. The parents left a heartfelt letter explaining they wanted to ensure she had a home, as she couldn’t afford one on her own.
All the other siblings were financially stable homeowners, so they easily accepted this decision. John, however, was less than thrilled. After putting so much of his own money into the house, it felt like their investment had gone up in smoke. “I was livid because we poured money into that house and now we’re not going to get it back,” John recalls. The couple argued for weeks, and John was fuming, until he finally calmed down, accepting the fact that he had lost that money, for the sake of his marriage.
After a few years when the real estate market went bananas, John’s house skyrocketed to $1.75 million. The sister-in-law’s home also saw a hefty appreciation to over $1 million. But, of course, with great property value comes great property taxes – over $30,000 a year, to be exact. Struggling with these payments, especially after her husband lost his job, the sister-in-law missed their tax payment, racking up huge penalties and interest.
With the taxman knocking on her door, John’s sister-in-law turned to her siblings for help. Unfortunately, everyone was financially drained, except for John and his wife. So, guess who got asked for a loan? Yep, you guessed it. John’s wife approached him, hoping they could bail out her sister. “The problem is that all of the siblings had financial difficulties last year so none of them could loan her money as they did in previous years. However, we’re doing okay so my wife asked me the other day if we could loan her sister the money,” John continues. His response? A resounding “no way, José!”
“We poured enough of our own money into that pit and refused her request,” John says. This sparked another round of arguments between him and his wife, escalating to the kind of shouting matches you’d expect to see on a reality TV show. John admits he might be a tad petty, but believes he is justified. After all, they’ve already lost $75,000 to her. His wife, on the other hand, can’t stand the thought of her sister losing their childhood home.
Image credits: Celyn Kang (not the actual photo)
While it is normal, and sometimes even expected, to help out your family when they are in need, acknowledging your own limits to generosity is crucial, especially when mixing money and family.
As explained in an article on how to handle financial differences with a sibling, “When one sibling is better off than the others, it is common for others to feel entitled to the former’s wealth. When financial differences are a given, it is critical to recognize that the better-off sibling has the power to decide how, how much, and when he is willing to share his wealth. Any greed, desire or entitlement is most likely to sour the relationship, even if both parties take time to find out when things go wrong,” the article explains.
Just because one sibling has more doesn’t mean they owe the others. Open, honest conversations about expectations and limits can help maintain a good relationship with family. The goal is to support each other without allowing money to become a force that divides the family.
John’s story is the perfect example of how money can cause tensions even in the closest of families. While his decision to not lend his sister-in-law money might seem harsh, it’s coming from a sense of fairness. Just because he has more money than the rest of the siblings doesn’t mean that he is responsible for their financial well-being. After all, they are all adults.
When faced with repeated requests for money from a family member, it’s important to establish clear limits. As experts explain, setting financial boundaries with family members is necessary for maintaining healthy relationships. The first step is to identify those who frequently ask for financial help. If you notice a pattern, it’s a sign that the relationship has become unhealthy.
“It’s one thing to help a family member or friend out of a single event or crisis situation, but if you’re constantly being asked for money or loans, you’re likely caught up in an unhealthy financial relationship. You may simply feel getting taken advantage by these friends and family members who have come to rely on you as the ‘dependable’ place where they can turn,” experts explain.
After identifying the pattern, communicate your boundaries clearly and assertively. Explain that you can no longer provide financial support and suggest alternative solutions. Remember, it’s okay to say no without feeling guilty.
What do you think of family drama? Should John have agreed to help out his sister-in-law with the tax money? Drop your thoughts in the comments below.
People in the comments side with the man, saying he is not a jerk for refusing to lend his sister-in-law money, saying that he will probably not see that money again
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
What do you think ?
Alexandra 5 months ago
Why is OP's wife more loyal to her sister than her husband on this issue? It's not as if the sister would be homeless: sell this house and buy another one. Maybe downsize and it's not the family home, but how many of us have a family home to be passed down through the generations? That's an expensive hobby to have and one she can't afford. I'm sorry, but OP must stand fast on this one.
just me 5 months ago
Wife doesn't want her sister to lose the house they grew up in. But if things had gone as originally planned the house would have been sold when the parents passed. Unless that wasn't really the plan, and just what they told OP to get him to agree to bankroll the improvements?
Load More Replies...
notlikeyou1971 5 months ago
Your wife needs to understand that you have already invested and took a $75,000 loss over that house. You are not going to do anything else. You've done more than enough and are not her sister's ATM. It's not your problem anymore. If she doesn't like it she can leave. It's worth losing her over. You don't want to spend the rest of your life being her sister's bank because you most likely won't see that money back .You've done more than enough for that family. Tell her sister sell the house or take out a loan. Either way your in laws were right, they would never be able to afford to own a home. They still can't afford it. They are just like majority of people in the world these days. Back to an apartment for them again. Yes this is a hill worth dying on. Enough is enough.
Sunny Day 5 months ago
Sister can't afford that house or that neighborhood. Since neither she nor husband are working now, they need to sell the house and move somewhere affordable. There are still places like that. Just remind them to save money aside for capital gains taxes.
Load More Replies...
Alexandra 5 months ago
Why is OP's wife more loyal to her sister than her husband on this issue? It's not as if the sister would be homeless: sell this house and buy another one. Maybe downsize and it's not the family home, but how many of us have a family home to be passed down through the generations? That's an expensive hobby to have and one she can't afford. I'm sorry, but OP must stand fast on this one.
just me 5 months ago
Wife doesn't want her sister to lose the house they grew up in. But if things had gone as originally planned the house would have been sold when the parents passed. Unless that wasn't really the plan, and just what they told OP to get him to agree to bankroll the improvements?
Load More Replies... notlikeyou1971 5 months ago
Your wife needs to understand that you have already invested and took a $75,000 loss over that house. You are not going to do anything else. You've done more than enough and are not her sister's ATM. It's not your problem anymore. If she doesn't like it she can leave. It's worth losing her over. You don't want to spend the rest of your life being her sister's bank because you most likely won't see that money back .You've done more than enough for that family. Tell her sister sell the house or take out a loan. Either way your in laws were right, they would never be able to afford to own a home. They still can't afford it. They are just like majority of people in the world these days. Back to an apartment for them again. Yes this is a hill worth dying on. Enough is enough.
Sunny Day 5 months ago
Sister can't afford that house or that neighborhood. Since neither she nor husband are working now, they need to sell the house and move somewhere affordable. There are still places like that. Just remind them to save money aside for capital gains taxes.
Load More Replies... You May Like “I Laughed In His Face”: Woman Refuses To Let Roommate’s BF Move In After He “Tested Her” “Am I A Jerk For Not Letting My Mother-In-Law See My Baby Until I Put Cameras Up In My Home?” Lady Upset As Bestie Dates Her Toxic Bro, Refuses To Reconcile After He Sends Her To The Hospital
Dominyka
Rugilė Žemaitytė
Monika Pašukonytė
Related on Bored Panda
52
48