Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
25submissions
Finished
Too Good To Gift? 25 White Elephant Presents We’re Tempted To Keep
Let's talk about the ultimate white elephant gift paradox – when you find something so ridiculously perfect that parting with it feels like giving away the last slice of pizza. These 25 gifts aren't just party contributions; they're treasures so good, you'll find yourself "accidentally" ordering two (one for the exchange and one for, um, quality control purposes). From games that'll make game night feel like a fever dream to items so wonderfully weird they deserve their own TED Talk, we've curated a list that's turning gift-giving into an internal struggle between generosity and "but I want it!"
The true test of a white elephant gift isn't just its ability to make people fight over it – it's whether you can resist the urge to keep it for yourself. These finds sit firmly in that dangerous sweet spot between "hilariously awesome" and "weirdly useful," making them harder to part with than that sweatshirt you "borrowed" from your ex. Whether it's socks that'll turn your feet into poultry or games that combine burritos with combat, these gifts are the reason people start questioning their own gift-giving nobility. Warning: Shopping for these items may result in unexpected additions to your personal wishlist.
This post may include affiliate links.
#1
What's The Matter? Cat Hook's Got Your Clothes?
Review: "This cute and because I love cats it makes me laugh as I had what I called an acrobat for a cat." - Pam
RELATED:
#2
This Have A Nice Day Mug Hides A Special Little Message At The Bottom… Guess Which Finger Its Holding Up?
Review: "Purchased this as a gift for a family member, they loved it obviously. Very well made." - bob
#3
Whether You Are Working With Bad Lighting Or Heading To A Rave In 1999, These Flashlight Gloves Have You Covered
Review: "I got these for my husband, because he used to do work with a headlight or big yellow work light hang under the hood, but he loves so much better. They’re flexible and comfy to wear, so he finds himself using them for the smallest of tasks to changing the oil. Great Christmas gift!" - Mary Anne
#4
Unleash Your Inner Bob Ross And Find Serenity In This Tiny But Mighty Paint By Number Mini Bob Ross Edition That'll Make You Say, "Happy Little Trees, Everywhere!"
Review: "This is perfect for what I wanted to go with my Bob Ross Funko Pop! It's a great addition to my Funko collection at work and looking at him, and the painting, makes me smile." - Hilary
Review: "Great game for those nights with friends. Humorous." - robert drummond
#6
It Will Be A Nice Change Of Pace To Blame The Mr. Predicto Fortune Telling Ball Instead Of Mercury
Review: "The kiddos love playing with Mr. Predicto! I found the best way to settle disagreements between the kids. This size is as big as a fist so it is easy to put on the shelves." - Albert B.
Review: "They are heavier than expected. They write well and are comfortable to hold. The printing on them is clear and easy to read. I can now communicate my anger and frustration, just by lifting my pen." - Shannon Smith
Review: "It's waaaaay thicker then I thought it would be but surprisingly very light! Love they sectioned the categories in chapters like "crime" "history" etc. I also like that I can literally just open the book at random and just start reading which is perfect for those odd 5-10minutes you need to kill." - Bunny
#9
Who Needs To Break A Sweat In The Gym This Year If You Can Simply Cover Up With This Sexy Apron
Review: "This made making tamales a little easier considering how much went into making them! Definitely made people smile!" - MrBigg87
#10
Get Ready To Wrap, Unwrap, And Devour With This Ridiculously Awesome Throw Throw Burrito Card Game That's The Perfect Recipe For A Party Full Of Burrito-Loving Chaos
Review: "Combining dodgeball with a card game is a brilliant idea, and it’s a lot of fun to play with friends and family. The rules are easy to understand, and the game is highly engaging. Highly recommend for game nights." - Backfiring Datsun
#11
"Pivot" Their Holiday Into A New Direction With This Awesome Friends 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
Review: "This puzzle is so much fun, and not to mention comes exactly as advertised in the pictures. Honestly worth the price and one of the best friends puzzles I’ve seen." - Esha Patel
#12
Let's See If This In Case Of Emergency Box Even Makes It To New Years Eve
Review: "These boxes are well built and easy to open. Perfect for a small fun gift or money." - Lee
#13
Snoop Dogg's From Crook To Cook Cookbook Has Been Blazing Its Way Up The "Most Wished For" Lists This Holiday
Review: "I bought this as a gift and flipped through it upon opening. It’s fantastic, funny, and the recipes look and sound great. My husband will love it." - JDN
#14
Help Somone Make Some Extra Cash On Feet Finder With These Foot Boots
Review: "I love the funny bare feet slippers! I gave them as a gift and paired them with foot lotion and a pair of socks in a gift giving and my friend loved them. They are crazy and fun! I highly recommend this to anyone who loves to give, laugh and just have fun!" - Marilyn F.
#15
Cluck Your Way To Comfort With This Egg-Cellent Chickenleg Socks
Review: "These showed up and I instantly started cracking up. Put them on and chased my toddler around the house while she screamed(she was laughing too, it was a good time not a traumatizing time). I’m so excited for leg day. 10/10 would order again." - Jamie
#16
Let Out A Little Laughter And Let Your Creativity Run Wild With This Farting Animals Coloring Book
Review: "I've been coloring for my coworkers and letting them choose the color of their "poot" lol it's a stress reliever for me and hilarious for them!" - Chelsea Hart
Review: "I work in an elementary school kitchen and sometimes I need an emotional support something. I keep these on top of my printer and at LEAST every other day, I have a few students who as me to just look at them, hug one, and hand it back. Looking at them all day makes me smile and the fact that that can be helpful to the students is a huge bonus as well." - Yourgirlelm
#18
This Star Projecting Galaxy Night Light Might Be The Closest Most Of Us Get To The Mars 2030 Mission
Review: "I bought this for my toddlers room and they love it. I like it too. All the different color options is great. I love that the positioning is adjustable. Definitely recommend." - Amanda B
#19
Seems Like Everyone And Their Mom Has An Apple Device. Be Different. Use A Bananna Phone Instead
Review: "I just absolutely have to say I would purchase this over and over again! It is just so good when your hands are to use a phone. The quality of this banana is incomparable to any other banana! This banana even has an added bonus that it makes your bundle of bananas more impressive!" - andrew frank
Review: "Gifted this to a friend and he loved it, very cute to drink coffee in. Dishwasher safe." - Taniha A
Review: "My razor’s not sitting in standing water anymore! This is sticking to the shower wall super well, and it’s ridiculously adorable." - Maggie Moore
#22
This Belly Bag Might Not Be Too Far From The Truth After All Those Christmas Dinner Seconds And Thirds
Review: "If you want to totally embarrass, mortify and antagonize everybody around you, this is perfect! Couldn’t be happier Mission accomplished! ??" - Alena S
Review: "Ummm when the packaging says “Giant”, believe them!! We have soo much fun playing UNO now!! Wait until you have a lot of cards in your hands! Definitely recommend!!" - kwill
Review: "This was the perfect gift for my Disney obsessed little chef. She couldn't be more pleased." - Niki
#25
Funny Enough, Once You Saw This Toilet Timer You Knew Exactly Who Is Supposed To Get This
Review: "Got this for my partner for his birthday. Very funny and easy to use and reset." - Matthew R. Daniels
Add New Image
Related on Bored Panda
