Kids At Every Income Level Were Asked To Show Their Favorite Toys, And The Result Will Make You Think
Anna Rosling Rönnlund has spent the last 15 years making global public data easier to understand and use. Trying to come up with an idea that would connect with people better than colorful charts, she started Dollar Street. The initiative had a team of photographers documenting over 264 homes in 50 countries. In each home, the photographer spent a day taking pictures of up to 135 objects, like the family’s shoes, toothbrushes, or… children’s toys.
Turns out, you can paint a pretty accurate picture of how people at every income live if you pay attention to the things that their kids play with. From $45 a month households to more than $3,000, these intimate glimpses into the everyday lives of hundreds of families are eye-opening and more vivid than any graph will ever be.
“People in other cultures are often portrayed as scary or exotic,” Anna said. “This has to change. We want to show how people really live. It seemed natural to use photos as data so people can see for themselves what life looks like on different income levels. Dollar Street lets you visit many, many homes all over the world. Without traveling.” Scroll down to visit those who participated!
More info: gapminder.org (h/t businessinsider)
In a Burkinabe home living on $29/month per adult, the favorite toy is an old tire
In a Burundian home living on $29/month per adult, the favorite toy is dried maize
In an Indian home living on $31/month per adult holding his favorite toy
In a Zimbabwean home living on $34/month per adult, the favorite toy is a home-made ball
In a Haitian home living on $39/month per adult, the favorite toy car made out of recycled plastic items
In a Zimbabwean home living on $41/month per adult, the favorite toy is a car
In a Haitian home living on $43/month per adult, the favorite toy is a hoop
In a Burkinabe home living on $45/month per adult, the favorite toy is a broken plastic doll
In a Burkinabe home living on $54/month per adult, the favorite toy is a tire
In an Ivorian home (Cote d’Ivoire) living on $61/month per adult, the favorite toy is a shoe
In an Indian home living on $65/month per adult, the favorite toy is a home-made cricket bat
In a Rwandan home living on $72/month per adult, the favorite toys are leaves
In a Haitian home living on $102/month per adult, the favorite toy is a handheld video game
In a Palestinian home living on $112/month per adult, the favorite toy is a plastic bottle
In a Colombian home living on $123/month per adult, the favorite toy is a volleyball ball
In a Nigerian home living on $124/month per adult, the favorite toys are wooden poles
In a Colombian home living on $163/month per adult, the favorite toy is a cat
In an Indian home living on $245/month per adult, the favorite toy is a toy truck
In a Jordanian home living on $249/month per adult, the favorite toys are stuffed animals
In a Rwandan home living on $251/month per adult, the favorite toy is a stick
In a Bolivian home living on $254/month per adult, the favorite toy is a stuffed toy
In a Indian home living on $369/month per adult, the favorite toy is a cell phone
In a Latvian home living on $480/month per adult, the favorite toy is a stuffed animal
In a Jordanian home living on $583/month per adult, the favorite toy is a table computer
In a American home living on $855/month per adult, the favorite toy is Lego
In a Chinese home living on $2,235/month per adult, the favorite toy is a military tank model
In a South African home living on $2,862/month per adult, the favorite toy is a stuffed animal
In a Kenyan home living on $3,268/month per adult, the favorite toy is a tablet computer
In an American home living on $4,650/month per adult, the favorite toy is baseball gear
In a Jordanian home living on $7,433/month per adult, the favorite toy is a large stuffed animal
In a Ukrainian home living on $10,090/month per adult, the favorite toy is a large stuffed animal
In a Chinese home living on $10,098/month per adult, the favorite toy is stuffed animal
Are you sure about the incomes? Ukraine with 10000 bucks per person? The girl would be living a dream.
Why not? Or did you think everyone outside of America and Western Europe lives with dirt floors and outdoor toilets?
Load More Replies...In some of the cases, the furniture and inside of houses don't seem to be like 10k$ income per person, like author suggests
It's hard to tell from the pictures, they don't show very much of the houses.
Load More Replies...cuddly toys, no matter the income, seemed to be popular among some of the children, at least they all have their imaginations.
picture 2 (Burundi) is banana flower not a dried maize... (and no, I have no friend)
When I buy an expensive toy for our cat, she prefers the wrapper. I can't see anything wrong with liking non toys like tyres or plastic bottles as fav toys. It shows imagination. Its not sad, if it gives the same pleasure as an expensive toy. Even as someone who grew up in Germany, I sometimes made stuff out of plastic or cardboard or fabric. I also find it wrong to say that it is 'telling' that the [mostly white] kids prefer their expensive toys. All it is telling me is that the parents gave them to their kids and they don't know any different. Plus if any of the poor kids suddenly had money, they too would opt for more expensive things. Kids are adaptable. This is mildly interesting but tells me no more than that human kids are humans.
Yup. The pictures themselves show that, when they show some kids with more income than others with simpler toys (there's a boy with a stick, while poorer kids have actual toys) and that most of the richer kids still prefer things like stuffed animals. The kids that have digital devices are clearly older, so it's only natural they're more drawn to that than toys - it's not about income alone. But I think that "human kids are humans" is actually the whole point of the series, so it fulfills that.
Load More Replies...Are the incomes in USD? In India, a family living on $369 per month per adult is a lot of money.
Yes, I think that was the point of the series (although an additional conversion to PPP would have been quite instructive)
Load More Replies...Growing up poor, My Dad prob. only made around $1,000 a month with 4 kids, my favorite toy was a doll that I got from our Churches Christmas grab bag donated by other members. I was 5 and had that doll for yrs and I loved her to death. It didn't matter to me if I had any other toys because she was the best friend a little girl could ever have. Fond memories of her from an other wise sad childhood.
when I was lil my fav toy was a piece of fabric I made into a cape and a sword made out of cardboard, we had all the latest games and stuff but I still loved those more than any of the $50 buck games or $150-200 game systems we had, all up till age 16, I am a white American {as if that actually helps but people seem to think it does} we were on welfare and such but we were sick {3 out of a family of 5} and had disability checks to use for other stuff, so we wernt "well" off but doing rather good {this was in the early 90s-00s} and now we are way worse off But basically, anything will be a fav toy for a child if they love and play with it all the time {hell I at one time only loved one lego figure, I used to play in the mud with him and that was my fav toy, I found it in the street!}
I know it's just a detail, but I can't help be concerned about the chinese boy's less than half full aquarium with nothing but fish in it. Hope they were just cleaning it up at the time.
What an incredible lesson it would be, to show these in the classroom of same age children , in the USA, and Canada !!!
Stuffed animals and tires ahah i loved getting inside a tire and have my siblings push me around in it. It was so fun
So "the results will make me think" . That they did! I believe life is about the love, joy and peace that one carries in their heart. And no amount of physical things, wether it be toys or cars or houses or good looks can create these intimate feelings that we crave. I feel that the seemingly poorest child could be experiencing more joy with an old tire than the richest one is experiencing with the so called "best toy". It all depends on the child's perspective of the world in which they have been taught and the love and nurture in which they are receiving.
The Burundian kid... its not a maize... it's the flower of a banana plant
I'm a Kenyan and I can authoritatively speculate that that is not likely a $3k per adult per month household
Children think quite differently. My grandkids might enjoy a 10 cent balloon and skip with total indifference a $150 super toy. Price is seldom the ultimate decision factor.
Ha ha! The tire and a wooden pole were my favorite toys as a kid. The challenge was to make that bicycle tire roll as long and as far as you can without letting it drop by running behind it and tapping it with your hand. It was an incredible amount of fun when I was 5-ish years old. The stick was to play high jumps and pretend to be Donatello from the TMNT. Cars were great but only if I was crashing them into something.
As a Chinese,according to the chinese characters printed on the stuffed toy, I think this toy is a souvenir bought when you travelled or the child gets it from the toy machine. We have the toy-catching machines in the malls.You can buy a game coin and throw it into the machine.Then,you got a chance to catch once.When i was little,my father caught two toys for me.
We have machines like that in the US too, but they all are rigged so its EXTREMELY hard to catch a toy. The only way I've ever seen anyone catch one is if there is one by the edge of the shoot, and its up high enough to knock it over
Load More Replies...https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKEe6YWYIsw Please take this video down for copyright This channel has other videos doing the same thing
Yes, they used their imagination. That is another loss in today's children, they have no need to use their imagination !!!
We're currently running a similar project. With the "@eyeLeveL Project" we let young students all around the world take pictures of things they consider most important in their life. Ans just like this project here, the outcome is as unexpected as it is interesting! If you have a minute, check out the project at https://www.at-eyelevel.com/
In a Burundian home living on $29/month per adult, the favorite toy is dried maize - the child is holding banana flower not maize
All I'm thinking is that the $855/adult -family must have some rich relatives and friends if they can afford real LEGO for their kids...And I'm happy if when children have things to play and occupy their minds with (regardless of if it is a piece of cardboard box or a piece of fruit).
I dont know what to think about this. If you asked me and my sister what our favorite toys were when at that age, we would have a different answer daily. Sometimes it was a stick that looked like a gun. Sometimes a stick that was a sword. Sometimes a rock that was shiny. Sometimes mud, we could make all sorts of "sculptures with it"; sometimes bugs, jars, balls. Most of the times our pets. So yeah. All i can say for sure is that a child doesnt need complex items to be happy. Imagination is enough.
In the cat picture, I feel like the cat looks so content and happy, it doesn't matter who is its owner, how much money they have, etc. the cat is happy and in love with the little girl just for who she is. Animals have that kind of power
Very insightful! How children use their imagination is really the key. Of course, I know that family, community and upbringing all play part. Great piece!
I'm starting to think that the income is per year, not per month. Like 10.000 per person, if a family of 4 it would be 40.000. thats one hell lot of money to spend in a month. It would be live in the mansion
It is stated that the money is per month and per adult, but the article also vaguely says per household. So it could be that you have to multiply the income by 2 (2 parents/adults) to get the total per month but thats just speculation. And 10k for a household is what would classify as upper middle class in europe, not yet rich but definitely a very comfortable life. And of course it exists
Load More Replies...Terrifies me how one of them answered her favourite toy is the cat. ANIMALS ARE NOT TOYS!
WTH what Venezuela do you live in? Because apparently I’ve visited (Many many many times) the wrong one.
Load More Replies...As much as I love the project the part I really can't get over is the "volleyball ball" like what??? Most likely I'm just irrationally obsessive over it but it really bugs me
That's not what this is. This is showing the lives of people both rich and poor.
Load More Replies...We had 5 kids in my family, so we shared toys. When I had a toy of my own, I treasured it. Too many children today, get expensive toys that they soon lose interest in.
But not every kid is like that, a lot of the friends I grew up with cried in happiness when they got a toy they’d really wanted, or a N64 or Sega, heck when I was a teenager I cried for like an hour when I got my first laptop (which I half paid for)
Load More Replies...Your figures for African countries are way out. The average household in Rwanda lives on no more than USD 50. Your figures for Kenya...no way!!! The average income for household where both adults work would not exceed USD 600.
It's an average. The average is not the number. If you think there are no wealthy or professional people in Africa, then I have a bridge to sell you.
Load More Replies...Maybe that was her way of saying she prefers her cat over toys. The cat is obviously cool with the situation.
Load More Replies...Are you sure about the incomes? Ukraine with 10000 bucks per person? The girl would be living a dream.
Why not? Or did you think everyone outside of America and Western Europe lives with dirt floors and outdoor toilets?
Load More Replies...In some of the cases, the furniture and inside of houses don't seem to be like 10k$ income per person, like author suggests
It's hard to tell from the pictures, they don't show very much of the houses.
Load More Replies...cuddly toys, no matter the income, seemed to be popular among some of the children, at least they all have their imaginations.
picture 2 (Burundi) is banana flower not a dried maize... (and no, I have no friend)
When I buy an expensive toy for our cat, she prefers the wrapper. I can't see anything wrong with liking non toys like tyres or plastic bottles as fav toys. It shows imagination. Its not sad, if it gives the same pleasure as an expensive toy. Even as someone who grew up in Germany, I sometimes made stuff out of plastic or cardboard or fabric. I also find it wrong to say that it is 'telling' that the [mostly white] kids prefer their expensive toys. All it is telling me is that the parents gave them to their kids and they don't know any different. Plus if any of the poor kids suddenly had money, they too would opt for more expensive things. Kids are adaptable. This is mildly interesting but tells me no more than that human kids are humans.
Yup. The pictures themselves show that, when they show some kids with more income than others with simpler toys (there's a boy with a stick, while poorer kids have actual toys) and that most of the richer kids still prefer things like stuffed animals. The kids that have digital devices are clearly older, so it's only natural they're more drawn to that than toys - it's not about income alone. But I think that "human kids are humans" is actually the whole point of the series, so it fulfills that.
Load More Replies...Are the incomes in USD? In India, a family living on $369 per month per adult is a lot of money.
Yes, I think that was the point of the series (although an additional conversion to PPP would have been quite instructive)
Load More Replies...Growing up poor, My Dad prob. only made around $1,000 a month with 4 kids, my favorite toy was a doll that I got from our Churches Christmas grab bag donated by other members. I was 5 and had that doll for yrs and I loved her to death. It didn't matter to me if I had any other toys because she was the best friend a little girl could ever have. Fond memories of her from an other wise sad childhood.
when I was lil my fav toy was a piece of fabric I made into a cape and a sword made out of cardboard, we had all the latest games and stuff but I still loved those more than any of the $50 buck games or $150-200 game systems we had, all up till age 16, I am a white American {as if that actually helps but people seem to think it does} we were on welfare and such but we were sick {3 out of a family of 5} and had disability checks to use for other stuff, so we wernt "well" off but doing rather good {this was in the early 90s-00s} and now we are way worse off But basically, anything will be a fav toy for a child if they love and play with it all the time {hell I at one time only loved one lego figure, I used to play in the mud with him and that was my fav toy, I found it in the street!}
I know it's just a detail, but I can't help be concerned about the chinese boy's less than half full aquarium with nothing but fish in it. Hope they were just cleaning it up at the time.
What an incredible lesson it would be, to show these in the classroom of same age children , in the USA, and Canada !!!
Stuffed animals and tires ahah i loved getting inside a tire and have my siblings push me around in it. It was so fun
So "the results will make me think" . That they did! I believe life is about the love, joy and peace that one carries in their heart. And no amount of physical things, wether it be toys or cars or houses or good looks can create these intimate feelings that we crave. I feel that the seemingly poorest child could be experiencing more joy with an old tire than the richest one is experiencing with the so called "best toy". It all depends on the child's perspective of the world in which they have been taught and the love and nurture in which they are receiving.
The Burundian kid... its not a maize... it's the flower of a banana plant
I'm a Kenyan and I can authoritatively speculate that that is not likely a $3k per adult per month household
Children think quite differently. My grandkids might enjoy a 10 cent balloon and skip with total indifference a $150 super toy. Price is seldom the ultimate decision factor.
Ha ha! The tire and a wooden pole were my favorite toys as a kid. The challenge was to make that bicycle tire roll as long and as far as you can without letting it drop by running behind it and tapping it with your hand. It was an incredible amount of fun when I was 5-ish years old. The stick was to play high jumps and pretend to be Donatello from the TMNT. Cars were great but only if I was crashing them into something.
As a Chinese,according to the chinese characters printed on the stuffed toy, I think this toy is a souvenir bought when you travelled or the child gets it from the toy machine. We have the toy-catching machines in the malls.You can buy a game coin and throw it into the machine.Then,you got a chance to catch once.When i was little,my father caught two toys for me.
We have machines like that in the US too, but they all are rigged so its EXTREMELY hard to catch a toy. The only way I've ever seen anyone catch one is if there is one by the edge of the shoot, and its up high enough to knock it over
Load More Replies...https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKEe6YWYIsw Please take this video down for copyright This channel has other videos doing the same thing
Yes, they used their imagination. That is another loss in today's children, they have no need to use their imagination !!!
We're currently running a similar project. With the "@eyeLeveL Project" we let young students all around the world take pictures of things they consider most important in their life. Ans just like this project here, the outcome is as unexpected as it is interesting! If you have a minute, check out the project at https://www.at-eyelevel.com/
In a Burundian home living on $29/month per adult, the favorite toy is dried maize - the child is holding banana flower not maize
All I'm thinking is that the $855/adult -family must have some rich relatives and friends if they can afford real LEGO for their kids...And I'm happy if when children have things to play and occupy their minds with (regardless of if it is a piece of cardboard box or a piece of fruit).
I dont know what to think about this. If you asked me and my sister what our favorite toys were when at that age, we would have a different answer daily. Sometimes it was a stick that looked like a gun. Sometimes a stick that was a sword. Sometimes a rock that was shiny. Sometimes mud, we could make all sorts of "sculptures with it"; sometimes bugs, jars, balls. Most of the times our pets. So yeah. All i can say for sure is that a child doesnt need complex items to be happy. Imagination is enough.
In the cat picture, I feel like the cat looks so content and happy, it doesn't matter who is its owner, how much money they have, etc. the cat is happy and in love with the little girl just for who she is. Animals have that kind of power
Very insightful! How children use their imagination is really the key. Of course, I know that family, community and upbringing all play part. Great piece!
I'm starting to think that the income is per year, not per month. Like 10.000 per person, if a family of 4 it would be 40.000. thats one hell lot of money to spend in a month. It would be live in the mansion
It is stated that the money is per month and per adult, but the article also vaguely says per household. So it could be that you have to multiply the income by 2 (2 parents/adults) to get the total per month but thats just speculation. And 10k for a household is what would classify as upper middle class in europe, not yet rich but definitely a very comfortable life. And of course it exists
Load More Replies...Terrifies me how one of them answered her favourite toy is the cat. ANIMALS ARE NOT TOYS!
WTH what Venezuela do you live in? Because apparently I’ve visited (Many many many times) the wrong one.
Load More Replies...As much as I love the project the part I really can't get over is the "volleyball ball" like what??? Most likely I'm just irrationally obsessive over it but it really bugs me
That's not what this is. This is showing the lives of people both rich and poor.
Load More Replies...We had 5 kids in my family, so we shared toys. When I had a toy of my own, I treasured it. Too many children today, get expensive toys that they soon lose interest in.
But not every kid is like that, a lot of the friends I grew up with cried in happiness when they got a toy they’d really wanted, or a N64 or Sega, heck when I was a teenager I cried for like an hour when I got my first laptop (which I half paid for)
Load More Replies...Your figures for African countries are way out. The average household in Rwanda lives on no more than USD 50. Your figures for Kenya...no way!!! The average income for household where both adults work would not exceed USD 600.
It's an average. The average is not the number. If you think there are no wealthy or professional people in Africa, then I have a bridge to sell you.
Load More Replies...Maybe that was her way of saying she prefers her cat over toys. The cat is obviously cool with the situation.
Load More Replies...
458
156