“[Am I The Jerk] For Telling My Wife I’m Not Going To Sacrifice My Hobbies Just So That I Can Babysit?”
Many marriage stories, unfortunately, end far from the classic “till death do us part” – and the role of death is actually played by the court in divorce proceedings. However, experts strongly believe that it’s often better to try to start all over again than to desperately glue together a marriage that is simply falling apart.
The story we are going to tell you today, from the user u/Logical-Carpet-4381, is one of them. It features a husband and wife, her daughter and ex-husband – and lots and lots of golf balls. Already intrigued? Then let’s just read on!
More info: Reddit
The author of the post is a 38-year-old man married to a woman with a 9-year-old daughter from her previous marriage
Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)
The ex-spouses have a custody agreement, and the girl lives from Friday to Sunday at her bio dad’s home, especially since he’s a decent father
Image credits: Logical-Carpet-4381
Image credits: sunnyn / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Recently that guy remarried to another woman with kids, and the 3 stepsiblings don’t get along at all
Image credits: Logical-Carpet-4381
Image credits: Steve Momot / Pexels (not the actual photo)
So the girl’s parents decided to change the custody terms so that she could spend the weekends at the mom’s house
Image credits: Logical-Carpet-4381
However, the author refused to agree with this, since he’d be the main babysitter to the girl on Saturdays – and he has a long-term tradition of playing golf at this time
So, the Original Poster (OP) is a 38-year-old man who is happily married to his 34-year-old wife. From her first marriage, the woman has a 9-year-old daughter “Emily,” with whom our hero is on good terms. His wife, however, has repeatedly noted that he need not become another parental figure for her – after all, the girl’s bio dad is also a decent guy and they have split custody.
The problems started recently, when that guy remarried, and his new wife also had kids, who, according to the terms of her divorce from her ex, were also supposed to live with their mother for a few days. And it soon became clear that Emily didn’t get along with her new stepsiblings. Fight followed fight – and the girl’s bio dad suggested that his ex change the custody conditions.
Said change would involve Emily not having to cross paths with his new wife’s children in their house. The woman readily agreed – but did it behind the author’s back. And he, having learned that Emily would now be at their house on Saturdays, flatly opposed it.
The thing is that in the next 12 months, the author’s wife will take a certification course – just on Saturdays, from morning until evening. And this means that now, the main and only caretaker on Saturday will be the OP himself, who has a regular game of golf with his brother and sister on Saturday mornings.
Moreover, this tradition, according to our hero, is many, many years old, and they started playing long before Emily and her mom appeared in the author’s life. And no, the original poster is not at all against watching the girl – the problem is that his wife negotiated changes in the custody conditions behind his back, essentially putting him before the fact.
After facing a refusal, an offer to find the girl a babysitter for the “golf hours,” the spouses had a massive spat, and the wife called our hero all sorts of offensive words. He sincerely believes that before agreeing, she should have at least asked his opinion – considering that she knew about all these circumstances.
Image credits: Timur Weber / Pexels (not the actual photo)
“The issue is not even about golf – it is that such problems in the family should be resolved through a general discussion, and not through all kinds of manipulation,” says Irina Matveeva, a psychologist and certified NLP specialist, with whom Bored Panda got in touch for a comment on this case. “It’s quite reasonable that this man feels hurt and partly neglected.”
“Partly, this looks like double standards – in a normal situation, this woman didn’t need her husband’s help, since the girl already has a biological father. But as soon as a serious problem arose, they immediately tried to solve it with his participation – but without even consulting him.”
“Moreover, I cannot call this a solution. Trying to ‘separate’ the children in time is not a solution to the problem, but an attempt to escape from it. It would be better to have counseling and maybe therapy – so that the kids would finally get along better. And the fact that the parents didn’t do this also says a lot,” Irina concludes.
Even legal experts note that the main issue in parenting after remarriage is the emotional aspect of raising kids, because the divorce and the new people in their lives are almost always stressful. “Therefore, it ought to be handled with care and understanding to ensure that the child’s best interests are always at the forefront of any decisions or changes,” this dedicated post on Fischer & Van Thiel’s PC website says.
People in the comments to the original post also mostly took our hero’s side, noting that his wife should have consulted with him first anyway. And since she stated from the first days of their life together that his parenting help was not so critical, then she needs to be consistent to the end.
As for the attempt to simply avoid conflict between the girl and her stepsiblings, this is definitely not the best idea on the part of her parents, the responders considered. Our hero also agrees with this. In the comments, the OP noted that he has found a solution to the problem. Now, during his golf games, the girl will be at his brother’s house, playing with his kids.
In addition, the man told his wife that if she now and in the future counts on his help in raising her daughter, then she should treat him as a parental figure after all. This, in the author’s opinion, would be more appropriate and reasonable. Well, let’s wish this family good luck… And what do you, our dear readers, think about this story?
People in the comments mostly sided with the man, praising him for standing up for his personal boundaries
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
The last comment says it all: "Jane told me Emily doesn't need a 2nd father figure."
The life of a stepchild is usually very difficult. It’s not the Brady Bunch, it’s usually much crueler. I bet 100 to one that neither natural parent has a will in place to provide for and protect the natural child. Stepchildren have zero rights
People don't have children these days. They have ping pong balls!
There was another on reddit last week. Second wife had a gym class in the evening that she wouldn't cancel because step daughter needed driven to and from an activity. The dad had to work and wouldn't leave at 6 pm for the kid. Ex wife/mom's new husband the step dad was taking his kids somewhere (and he clearly said no.) So parents decided step mom (who had the same deal as this OP, said no. Parents lost their minds.
I read that one and people were pissed OP wouldn't skip 1 gym class to take the step kid to a football event. It's interesting that in this one OP is a step dad and people are siding with him but when it was the step mom she was the AH. I love all the misogyny. Basically if you date and marry someone with kids expect to be a step parent and your life isn't completely your own anymore.
Load More Replies...OP, your stepdaughter IS your daughter. You have helped raise her for more than half her life. My daughter and her husband, her second, have a wonderful blended family. Yes, parenthood often means sacrifice once in a while. Your stepdaughter needs love and attention. As the mother of two kids in their thirties, two biological grandchildren and one step- grandchild, I love them all. Parenthood, even step parenthood requires commitment. You knew and your partners daughter when you got together. Self care is fine, but a child will certainly know if you put them in second place. My son-in-law is an awesome father to all three kids.
I don't love that he refers to it as "babysitting" though .Why didn't anyone call him out on that??
Sorry ... both of you are TA ... her for telling you the child does not need a 2nd father and you for not fighting this ridiculessness tooth and nail. You both are playing russian roulette with the mental health of this poor child. She deserves so much better.
I can see why Emily's bio parents are divorced. The dad got remarried to a woman with kids and didn't to the work beforehand to integrate their families. Emily's mom doesn't communicate with her partner and volunteers his time while sending mixed messages. Those two are selfish and poor Emily and the OP are trapped in the middle. I hope the family therapy helps. I'd suggest the OP and his wife also go to couples counseling as her disrespect for him and and the boundaries they agreed on together is a bad sign for a lasting marriage.
Yes because golfing with a kid every single Saturday for a year is exactly the same as golfing with your two grown adult siblings for leisure every Saturday.. you don't golf do you?
Load More Replies...She attacked his hobby, his joy! She said he should put his step-daughter above his siblings. Here’s the thing: they will *always* be his siblings no matter what happens in life. Whether or not Jane is his wife & Emily his step-daughter can change, as both are a choice. Seems she really resents his relationship with his brother & sister & therefore is attacking their tradition & family activity as stupid. A babysitter for 6 hours one day a week shouldn’t be an issue. That Jane won’t agree to the obvious solution makes it clear her issues really aren’t about OP babysitting.
Yes you are. Have you ever heard the song “The Cat’s in the Cradle”? If not, listen to it, please!
Have YOU heard the song? It's literally nothing to do with this situation... And it sucks
Load More Replies...If you date a parent things can always change, you can't plan life like this, you need to be ready for a parental role or not date them
The last comment says it all: "Jane told me Emily doesn't need a 2nd father figure."
The life of a stepchild is usually very difficult. It’s not the Brady Bunch, it’s usually much crueler. I bet 100 to one that neither natural parent has a will in place to provide for and protect the natural child. Stepchildren have zero rights
People don't have children these days. They have ping pong balls!
There was another on reddit last week. Second wife had a gym class in the evening that she wouldn't cancel because step daughter needed driven to and from an activity. The dad had to work and wouldn't leave at 6 pm for the kid. Ex wife/mom's new husband the step dad was taking his kids somewhere (and he clearly said no.) So parents decided step mom (who had the same deal as this OP, said no. Parents lost their minds.
I read that one and people were pissed OP wouldn't skip 1 gym class to take the step kid to a football event. It's interesting that in this one OP is a step dad and people are siding with him but when it was the step mom she was the AH. I love all the misogyny. Basically if you date and marry someone with kids expect to be a step parent and your life isn't completely your own anymore.
Load More Replies...OP, your stepdaughter IS your daughter. You have helped raise her for more than half her life. My daughter and her husband, her second, have a wonderful blended family. Yes, parenthood often means sacrifice once in a while. Your stepdaughter needs love and attention. As the mother of two kids in their thirties, two biological grandchildren and one step- grandchild, I love them all. Parenthood, even step parenthood requires commitment. You knew and your partners daughter when you got together. Self care is fine, but a child will certainly know if you put them in second place. My son-in-law is an awesome father to all three kids.
I don't love that he refers to it as "babysitting" though .Why didn't anyone call him out on that??
Sorry ... both of you are TA ... her for telling you the child does not need a 2nd father and you for not fighting this ridiculessness tooth and nail. You both are playing russian roulette with the mental health of this poor child. She deserves so much better.
I can see why Emily's bio parents are divorced. The dad got remarried to a woman with kids and didn't to the work beforehand to integrate their families. Emily's mom doesn't communicate with her partner and volunteers his time while sending mixed messages. Those two are selfish and poor Emily and the OP are trapped in the middle. I hope the family therapy helps. I'd suggest the OP and his wife also go to couples counseling as her disrespect for him and and the boundaries they agreed on together is a bad sign for a lasting marriage.
Yes because golfing with a kid every single Saturday for a year is exactly the same as golfing with your two grown adult siblings for leisure every Saturday.. you don't golf do you?
Load More Replies...She attacked his hobby, his joy! She said he should put his step-daughter above his siblings. Here’s the thing: they will *always* be his siblings no matter what happens in life. Whether or not Jane is his wife & Emily his step-daughter can change, as both are a choice. Seems she really resents his relationship with his brother & sister & therefore is attacking their tradition & family activity as stupid. A babysitter for 6 hours one day a week shouldn’t be an issue. That Jane won’t agree to the obvious solution makes it clear her issues really aren’t about OP babysitting.
Yes you are. Have you ever heard the song “The Cat’s in the Cradle”? If not, listen to it, please!
Have YOU heard the song? It's literally nothing to do with this situation... And it sucks
Load More Replies...If you date a parent things can always change, you can't plan life like this, you need to be ready for a parental role or not date them
40
34