Plus-Size Comedian Accuses Cancer Research Ads Of Fat-Shaming, And Here’s How They Reply
Sofie Hagen, a Danish-born and UK-based comedian has ignited heated discussions after publicly accusing Cancer Research UK of ‘fat-shaming.’ The organization claims it doesn’t want to insult anyone, but hopes to raise awareness of the link between cancer and obesity. Hagen, however, says their campaign is “incredibly damaging.”
You see, according to Cancer Research UK, obesity “is the biggest cause of cancer in the UK, after smoking.” This statement came after a recent report by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), saying there is now strong evidence linking bodyweight issues to 13 types of cancer. What’s more alarming, in a time when Millennials are set to be the fattest generation of Britons, only 15% of British people are aware of the link between obesity and cancer.
“Right, is anyone currently working on getting this piece of sh*t CancerResearchUK advert removed from everywhere?” Hagen began her Twitter rant. “Is there something I can sign? How the fuc*ing fu*k is this okay?” Cancer Research UK even wrote a personal reply to the angry lady, but it wasn’t enough. She continued fighting for it to be taken down. “Society viewing fatness as a negative thing is a thing that kills more than the cancer,” she wrote.
Scroll down to check out the entire Twitter battle, and let us know your thoughts on the subject in the comments!
More info: Twitter
Cancer Research UK started a campaign, informing that obesity is the second-biggest cause of cancer in the UK
Image credits: Sofie Hagen
Comedian Sofie Hagen, however, found it incredibly offensive
It wasn’t the first time when she was vocal about beauty standards
Image credits: sofiehagen
Cancer Research UK was quick to respond
But it wasn’t enough to calm Sofie down
The campaign was inspired by a report by the International Agency for Research on Cancer, linking bodyweight issues to 13 types of cancer
Image credits: Cancer Research UK
Which is pretty alarming, considering that the rate of obesity is spreading across the UK. In fact, Millennials are set to be the fattest generation of Britons
Image credits: BBC
Despite the data, some commenters agreed with Sofie
While others stood behind the campaign
What are your thoughts on the matter? Let us know in the comments below.
Fat stomach doesn't look beautiful and it's not healthy. Stop being delusional because ignoring facts won't spare you from getting a heart attack .
Leading cause of death in the USA and pretty much everywhere else in the developed world. So can't wait until that "comedian" starts a campaign for smoking, drug use, arming schoolkids and driving while you are drunk.
[12 year old does drive-by shooting while smoking and high on coke] - leave him alone, he's expressing himself...
Load More Replies...Nothing wrong with the ad. It is a proven risk factor for cancer; along with smoking, alcohol consumption, physical inactivity and poor diet. You don't see smokers, alcohol drinkers or fast food eaters complaining that they are being shamed for their lifestyle choices. They just accept that their lifestyle habits are unhealthy and may be increasing the risk of cancer. She should do the same. Be obese and proud if you want, just don't be a special snowflake and turn yourself into a victim.
You want to love you body, do it up, but don't pitch a hissy fit because being over weight has, once again, been linked to an earlier death. We all know being overweight is unhealthy; why deny it?
Being obese is unhealthy. Being slightly overweight is linked to a longer life.
Load More Replies...I've been fat and I've been thin. Thinner looks better, feels better and is healthier. Sorry fat people, but I get offended if people call me thin and keep commenting on my weight. And basically, being really fat just looks bad, on everyone. What does not offend me, is an organisation stating facts about health risks. Get over yourself.
As a fat person who had been thin and got shamed both times - I wholeheartedly agree with you!!!
Load More Replies...Did she seriously say that fat shaming is more damaging than cancer? I can't wait to see the statistics on that one. You know, something along the lines of "N thousand of people died from fat shaming this year which is M thousand more than from cancer"...because otherwise it really doesn't sound very convincing to me.
"JFK: Literally NOBODY knows what causes any cancer" That's shocking, if only there was an organisation that was set up to "Research" "Cancer" it would be even more awesome if they were based in the "UK" were I'm from, then following their research they could advise us regular Joe's that know literally nothing about what causes cancer how best to avoid getting it.
Cancer is the most researched disease that humans get. We DO know what causes most cancers.
Load More Replies...So the medical world is supposed to lie to you or omit facts between cancer and obesity because it may offended someone?
As an obese adult man who recently had a heart attack I want to know the best scientific evidence. Facts are not offensive. We as a society can only (and I mean only) advance when we make rational decisions based on the best scientific evidence.
Good to see you're taking it rationally. More carrots, more water, more moving, it's all good. Best of luck to you.
Load More Replies...As a fat girl I am totally NOT offended by this ad. It is simply stating a fact-Obesity could contribute to cancer. As someone who would like to avoid cancer at all cost by now knowing this perhaps it will be more of a motivator to get healthy. (already working on it and having some success).
Well, what can you say? A fat woman who is offended when scientists point out that obesity is dangerous for health? It's no different from a rotten-teeth-owner (who always craves for candy and never brush her teeth properly after that) that complains about the fact offered by the dentist which said "over consumption of candy and no brushing after it is dangerous for your tooth".
Where are all the cigarette smokers throwing their hands up in the air whining about the insulting ads about lung cancer? Oh they don't do that? This "comedian" clearly hates herself. Those fat acceptance photos these people post are a mere "security signal" and are there to BEG people to look at you and comment on how secure and brave you are. Nothing could be more insecure. Sorry you're obese, now go get a hug from someone and get on the f*****g treadmill.
Being overweight is okay upto an extent... That's when you say you are confident with who you are... Being Morbidly obese is not something to be proud of, and should concern you if you think that it's who you are, cause it's not. You need to change if you're obese... Coming from an overweight person !
Being big is not healthy, I get that it hurts some people's feelings to hear that but we cannot withhold important life or death scientific information to protect peoples feelings over their health. If Sofie does not want to hear this fine, but don't stop others from hearing this too.
Fat shaming is real and serious thing, but that doesn’t make being overweight healthy. No one should be made fun of or punished for their weight, whether they are underweight or over. But these are actual doctors, and your weight IS relevant to them, and they understand how obesity works. It’s silly to ignore facts just because you don’t like the way it is.
Why do I get the feeling that these are same type of people that say "Global Warming is fake," "Vaccines make you sick," and the "Earth is Flat"....?
Genetics make me sit on my couch and binge watch netflix all day while eating fast food. It isn't my fault I'm fat, it is genetics!
Everyone has different beauty standards. But I think we all would agree, that when a person is eating healthy and exercising enough, you wouldn't be obese. Maybe curvy, but not obese. And so obesity is not healthy.
Very true. Since I got Netflix I have a few pairs of pants that don't fit anymore... Granted, I'm getting a bit older, but sitting on my a**e every day is not going to help me fit in those pants...
Load More Replies...So she googled herself a scientist degree? Its not about some cellulite or love handles, its about being pathological overweight.
reminds me of a former friend who doesnt talk to me anymore, because i said i´d like to loose a few pounds. according to her i was putting women down who a thicker than me by that..wtf.
Load More Replies...Dieting is the worst thing you can do to your body? Um, okay. >_>
Well, many diets actually are unhealthy because they favor some sort of food type over the other, or favor unhealthy habits, or dangerously low calorie intake. It's not the worst thing you can do to your body, but if you do it constantly, it can actually be just as damaging as smoking. A healthy balanced lifestyle (and thus loosing weight) is what every doctor would probably recommend, unless you have health related dietary restrictions.
Load More Replies...People like Sophie are why some go from being 20-something liberals to mid-30-something conservatives, and maybe go too far that way. You have to listen to science, even when that goes against your political beliefs.
I agree, but I also see plenty of conservatives ignoring science in favor of their own political or religious beliefs
Load More Replies...As an obese woman who has had uterine cancer and has Type 2 diabetes, I can tell you this: fat cells produce estrogen. Too much estrogen sends your uterus into overdrive, which causes replication errors on the cellular level, which *is* cancer. And there is a strong correlational link between being obese and having insulin resistance, the essence of what Type 2 diabetes is. And so many people have reversed their insulin resistance by losing weight, which points strongly to causation. Yes, it could be that the obesity itself is yet another symptom of an underlying metabolic syndrome, harmless in and of itself but associated with deeper problems. But if losing weight will get rid of the other deeper problems, then why not try. In the meantime, though, we have to be careful to not stereotype obese people as lazy or having poor self-control. But merely calling us obese is not an insult. It's a fact. I will never have children because of my cancer. If I can save one person from that I will.
And I'm grateful for my inherited metabolism; it saved my parents' and grandparents' lives when they were starving during war. But now, in this time of plenty, it's working, uh, too well. :p
Load More Replies...Fat-shaming against cancer? Bring it. Obesity IS an illness. It's a MEDICAL CONDITION. I am not referring to BIG-BONED here, (tall and squarely-set people, there is a huge difference.) I am referring to an adult who was 55Kg during their teens and 90kg during the mid-life, who are NOT at 7% Body-fat, preparing for a bodybuilding contest.
so, don't encourage it, don't disparage it, don't ignore it, highlight it (but don't single it out). you can see why there is confusion. 'freedom of speech for some'. surely just 'living as healthily as possible' is the best advice? but how do you give advice in a 'don't tell me what to do' world? with difficulty it would appear.
NO. Your photo of your fat belly is NOT beautiful. It is very sad and dispiriting for those in the health and medical professions. As a teacher I would never embark on shaming anyone, but education of the REAL risks and lifestyle choices that contribute to such health problems is ESSENTIAL.
Deciding you are offended by something that is trying to save your life is ridiculous. If you are overweight and completely happy with it, that is brilliant, but most people aren't happy with it (and I can say that from solid experience) and it's time to start realising that being overweight DOES lead to heart attacks, diabetes and now possibly cancer, so it's not SHAMING and HATING on you for being overweight, it's literally trying to help you. Some people think big is beautiful, some don't, whatever you're into, but only the blindly stupid people can fail to see that being fat DOES bring medical issues (again, speaking from experience) so you can't blame on Cancer Research UK (bless them for the amazing work they do) for trying to HELP!
ok first of all she's only doing this for publicity and honestly in that respect, shes won. So kudos. But you CANNOT seriously argue that being obese isn't harmful to your health. How about you stop getting so "hurt" by these statements and start eating right and exercising? Would that kill you? Let me answer that for you: no. In the contrary, would NOT doing any of these things kill you: yes. yes it would.
She's got too much body fat and it's not healthy. She looks very unhealthy for such a young woman (29 years old). I for one didn't realise being obese could lead to cancer so the advert IS successfully raising awareness and I will keep the information in mind and try to eat well and exercise more!
There are far more serious things to get offended about - medical facts are not among them. I have struggled with my weight my entire life and know damn well the adverse affects it has on my health. Being offended doesn't make you right. Pointing out that carrying excessive weigh is directly responsible - FACT - for many health issues - is not discriminating against overweight people. It is trying to educate and warn. And yes - I know how hard it is to lose weight. But I'm also not stupid and I know that it is down to me to do something about it. Doctors and scientists warning me about the various implications are not offending me. Get off your high and ill--informed horse, Sofie. Nobody is attacking you, or any other overweight person. Educating isn't attacking, you silly girl. Grow up.
Obesity is a health risk. The ads are a public service. Whining about it being "fat-shaming" is just wrong.
It's one thing to accept your weight, it's a whole other thing to get offended by the fact that having a lot of fat isn't healthy. That's like a smoker getting mad about health warnings (like the last person on Twitter mentioned). It's not a means to offend someone, it's trying to educate the public about what is true.
Some anorexics think they are Fat. Some Obese people think they are fine. Their opinions on health issues shouldn't be considered.
I agree with the latter about how people need to if the advert makes them feel bad do something and try work on it.
Her and everyone like her should be directly held accountable for everyone who dies via obesity related issues. Her misinformation is MALICIOUS.
On one hand, according to statistics, obesity is the second biggest cause for cancer. Then again, we all know that statistician are people who drown in lakes with the average depth of 4,72 inches. On the other hand, as an obese person myself, I find this lady's "happy stomach" photo incredibly disgusting. There are people who can't lose weight because of thyroid problems, whatnot. That's sad but fact and they don't deserve being fat-shamed. That being said, obesity, as a health risk - cancer or not -, should NOT be handled as if it was perfectly normal and the new sexy.
I'm pale AF and if I see a report from the cdc thats like "pale skin and blonde hair hint at a lack of melanin which can increase risk of skin cancer." I'd be like "oh wow! Thanks for looking out for my well being! I'll remember to put sunscreen on today!" Not "They're shaming me for my pale skin!"
So you can't say anything negative about obesity because as soon as you do it's considered fat shaming? Geesh. Obesity does lead to a lot of health issues, that's not shaming, it's a FACT. I mean, imagine if a smoker said the same thing ? "How DARE you say to me that smoking increases the risk of lung cancer and destroys my overall health? I am OFFENDED!" That would be kinda stupid wouldn't it? Yeah, and so is this.
Remind me at all the times people told me to quit smoking. However, saying someone they are too fat, this is unhealthy and they should quit eating so much (and/or bad) food, is unaceptable because of "public shaming". Us as smoker and drinker got use to these remarks and kind of campaigns, apparently some obese people still not ... :-)
LOL. Yeah, f**k science, I have feels! Yet another lady that should have been checked in to the psych ward.
the problem is that the general consensus is that fat people need to get off the couch and stop eating take aways. this for the majority is not the case. those people that say " i just started eating healthy and i lost 2 stone ... etc etc" are the reason the rest get fat shamed.
Load More Replies...Holy Hell, when are we going to actually get past this idea that fat is beautiful and fat is healthy?? Yes, there is a certain percentage of fat that is healthy to have on your body to support organ function, etc., but OBESITY is not health and it is not beautiful. I have never looked at an obese person and thought "hey there are beautiful", maybe as an individual but not in physical appearance. Call me shallow, but humans are meant to be fit and in great shape, that is why we were able to suceed in our evolution. Sorry, but this "comedian" is fat and gross.
I'm all about being comfortable with your body... but come on. Don't lie to yourself about the health complications that come with being obese. Next thing they will say is that it's offensive to say obesity causes heart attacks and diabetes.
"Obese" is a technical term for someone who is more than just 'a little overweight', it's a term used to signify your weight is now a detriment to your health. I'm gonna stick with the science board, not someone who is upset at seeing something around her she doesn't want to hear.
Ischemia and ischemic heart disease are overwhelmingly caused by obesity. Ischemic heart disease is the number one cause of death by over 2 million per year (in 2015) above strokes. Now there is evidence that 13 cancers are may also be caused by obesity? To me this is a wake-up call, not some ignorant comedian's already shamed self's time to try to gain popularity. I am obese and I despise it, Its not a question of shaming, its a question of the more knowledge the better. If this campaign should make people not accept being obese, then where is the shame in this? People need to stop thinking their feelings are the responsibility of anyone else.
Why are we giving this lady a platform? She is ignorant and writing this article just gets her more exposure than she deserves
You can tell someone that smoking is unhealthy and causes cancer: socially acceptable, you are seen as a hero to everyone. Telling someone obesity is unhealthy and causes cancer: Oh, my god! YOU'RE FAT SHAMING! Fat shaming has killed more people than cancer!
It's killed mostly stupid people, who, instead of the right, chose the easy path: and that is committing a suicide instead of simply looking at their problem directly into the eye and try to beat it!
Load More Replies...Okay... Time to get personal. My Aunt, a lovely woman who I am named after, is overweight (not sure if clinically obese) and had breast cancer. So yeah, I believe there is a link. Luckily she survived, but had to surgically remove her breasts. "Fat is beautiful" sure, you can think that, that’s your aesthetic opinion. But "Being obese isn’t a negative thing that effects your health” is just stupid, and it’s hurting more people than it’s helping.
Oh wow... Seriously? Well give yourself a major pat on the back if you feel it's so healthy to be obese. This "fat acceptance" thing went a little bit too far.
You'd have to give her a pat. You certainly can't wrap your arms around her in a hug. (Yeah, that's fat shaming but I don't care because she brought it up in the first place and tried to attack the people trying to save her life so f**k her).
Load More Replies...I really have no patience for these ""body positive" people who are ignoring actual medical science that says that being overweight is unhealthy. They want to be overweight? That's on them. Telling others that being overweight is super Ok is just stupid, dangerous, and anti-science. Sure, it can be hard to lose the weight. I know, cause I try, and I'm not perfect.
Uhhh.. seriously ? These doctors are trying to look out for you, not trying to shame you. I get that there has been a lot of fat-shaming in the media, and I'm not in ANY way saying that's okay. But the bottom line is that obesity IS extremely dangerous and unhealthy and it is in your best interest to work hard to lose that extra weight. It doesn't have anything to do with your level of attractiveness; it is simply about staying alive. Jesus Christ.
Anyone think the DIET our idiot governments are pushing on us MIGHT have more to do with both problems? We've had "Low Fat/High Carb" pushed on both of our countries for FIFTY YEARS, on the hypothesis that it will make us all healthier. Guess what IT DOES NOT WORK! For 50 years we've gotten fatter and sicker than ever before, to the point that we now have children with "ADULT ONSET DIABETES"! We should be eating like humans naturally ate for hundreds of years when obesity, diabetes, AND CANCER WAS UNCOMMON!
Except that overall caloric intake has MARKEDLY increased. THAT is why people are getting fatter. Eating bread won’t make you fat. Consuming more calories than you expend will whether you’re eating bread, pure sugar cane or nothing but vegetables. Also cancer rates are NOT increasing.
Load More Replies...so she's ignoring the science, and concentrating on being offended? Makes sense. And BMI hasn't been debunked. In the world of Google there is no excuse to be this dull.
I don't see fat-shaming. The ad is blunt, but it is based on current medical research, not some newly enlightened groupie's interpretation of outdated data. Now if the ad had something like "if you look like this, then you're fat", yeah that's fat-shaming. Now if I can only recall what movie that line came from...
I've been smoking for nearly twenty years and a recent lung checkup turned out so good that the doctor didn't believe me I was a smoker. Am I bitching around about the fact that wherever I go I'm told smoking is bad and causes a trillion forms of cancer? No of course not. Because I'm aware of that. It's my choice. And I'm happy that I'm healthy despite this habit. But if I were to get sick I knew whom to blame. But just because I'm lucky and in good shape it doesn't mean I have to go on a rant about scientific evidence and be offended by every poster I see... She knows exactly that she's wrong and doing something very unhealthy to her body but simply can't admit it. Grow up, girl. You're fat and it's bad for you.
Right, something tells me she already Knows all of it!
Load More Replies...Great ad! Raising awareness is important and apart from maybe avoiding cancer, trying to loose wait is beneficial for your body in so many ways.
So.....you don't like the truth. Fine, but shut your gob. This could save people's lives. You are not the only one. Selfish 'Look at me'.
So she googled herself a scientist or doctors degree?! Its not about some cellulite or love handles, its about being obese..
Obesity should not be normalized. It is a preventable illness. It should be treated as such.
The ad is stating a fact based on research. Why does she need to make it about her insecurities?
I agree that it is 100% okay to be heavy, but obesity SERIOUSLY causes cancer. It's because of our unhealthy intake that builds up fat, blocks cells from cleaning, and clogs our areas that need the most movement in order to stay healthy. This is a serious issue and all they are trying to do is to bring awareness to this fateful disease.
confident as my fat a*s and I are .....I dont see a problem with the add
She and the like should be held personally responsible for everyone who's ever died because of weight based complications. Her self righteous miseducation is beyond dangerous. Teach the loudest that their barking is irrelevant.
Why is it that human beings have such trouble with nuance? Yes Obesity is a health risk. No, no one should be shamed for their physical appearance. There IS a way to communicate this important information without shaming and alienating people. Think of the times in your life when you had the courage to change and grow. Someone supported you, showed you compassion. There is a big problem in our society. Obesity is just a symptom. We have to get better at helping one another. You don't have to sacrifice facts to do that. Just embrace the best parts of being human. We can be intelligent AND kind.
You can not like the truth all you want. Still doesn't mean the organization that's repsonsible for informing people about cancer awareness is wrong. If you're diabetic, your chances of hear tattack are significantly higher. That's not an offensive belief, it's a fact.
Obesity is unhealthy. That's a medical fact. Just because you don't choose to believe in science doesn't mean you're right. You can't complain that doctors are telling people not to be obese and claim it's fat-shaming. There's nothing to be ashamed of! It's a disease like anything else. You wouldn't be ashamed of having cancer, right?
I don't think this is shaming. I need to lose some weight and this just gives me more incentive to do so. This is a factual advert. Being overweight is linked to many health issues. It's just the way it is.
Here we have yet another example of the reality distortion ride so many folks seem to be on these days.
I've seen this sign a few times. More attention needs to be given to food we put in our bodies and what it can do to our health. Why are cigarettes covered in warnings and hard to attain when anyone can just buy junk food and soda without warnings on the packaging? Being obese is probably more dangerous than being a smoker in many cases, especially in the young. Double standards much?
Pandas I dont post many comments. you can check my history. I felt the anger and vitriol in the comments were truly disgraceful. Firstly - why this level of reaction to someone complaining that they felt offended by an advert. this is a comment we see again and again on the internet and only a few areas receive this abusive reaction, and being overweight is one. think to yourself why you feel you need to react so aggressively. Secondly. did anyone read into CancerResearch UKs information on this? I can break it down to 3 statments. 1. obese people die. 2 obese people get cancer. 3 we dont know how but obesity probably causes cancer and here is how i think it might happen. If they entered into research into this topic, they have not provided the data or a link to the data. It is the equivalent of 30% of all people hit by cars smoked - therefore smoking increases your chance to be hit by a car by 30%. read the research before you sign up to it. Thanks for reading. Be Nice to each other
The anger is because you can say "Hey man, smoking is bad for you and I wish you'd cut it out for your own sake and those who love you". You can say that all day long, but try substituting smoking for obesity and people lose it. People are just sick of being told they're awful people just because they point out biological facts that are in fat people's best interest to adhere to.
Load More Replies...I don't think that it is fatshaming. People are just being overly sensitive. It's a fact. Not an attack.
Sorry, fat stomachs are NOT beautiful. And being overweight is not healthy, it's a fact. Nothing wrong with the ads
Ahhhh!!!! comedians teaching us science. Where do they get so much confidence ?
How is it okay that there are kids starving and you keep eating enough for 4 people? Dumbass.
Hi you delusional fat idiot ... if you want to stay fat, it's your bussiness .... but if someone gets cancer because you succeeded in removing the anti-cancer add to inform people about cancer risk factors, then I consider you a murderer.
loose some weight you fat idiot ... and get over yourself .... if you don't want to loose weight, at let others be informed to make their own lifestyle choices !!!!
For people with lipedema I'm sorry, I hope you can get better soon, but for others, it's called junk food for a reason
People with lipedema could hardly do anything to prevent the disease from appearing, so they do have an excuse. However, people who are not genetically predisposed to any similar conditions really are just being stupid and eating unhealthy.
Load More Replies...While obesity may/may not be directly related to causing cancer, obesity does increase the chances for a person to contract health diseases and that has been a fact for a loooooong time.
No one wants to be obese. So many people are this way due to severe health problems though. It is something beyond just "stop eating" school of thought. I feel this story can go two ways, Stating the obvious or agreeing with her that the ad is shaming fat people. For myself, I think just about everything we touch, breath or taste is loaded with harmful chemicals that can and do cause us cancer. We are living in an age when everything is loaded with dangerous chemicals esp. our food and the way we prepare it. So I wish she would be quiet about this silly little issue and concentrate more on the WHY and WHAT is in our food that is really causing cancer. These are things we really need to be protesting about but no one seems to really care.
Cancer Research UK 's third-largest donor is the diet company Slimming World, and I think in good conscience they should put this on the ads.
She's f*****g stupid and in denial about her own health. She is obese and doesn't like the fact that it could be lethal.
I happen to own a beer gut myself. I damn sure ain't going to paint it up and parade around in a speedo and expect love and applause. (You're welcome) The lady needs to quit wallowing in her pity party and take a reality check.
I believe the comedian needs to dig deeper into herself to get at the root of why this upsets her so much. She probably knows she needs to make a life change to better her health, but has chosen the easier route by denying body fat is a health concern and promoting others to form a community around that idea
Good grief, a bunch of sensitive snow flakes aren't they? Being over weight is bad for your health. Period. It's not fat shaming, it's reality.
People always fear facts. Many thing in the extreme cause cancer. THAT we know is a fact. People on this planet need to re-learn moderation. even for criticism.
typo - yikes - "many things* in the extreme"
Load More Replies...B*tch, please!! Fatness IS a negative thing, and seeing it as otherwise is dangerous. Being healthy is a goal and obesity is not healthy and no political correctness will change that.
I know that we shouldn't body shame others but she needs to wake up and see that being obese is linked to cancer, and if people can't deal with that then there's a real problem THERE not in the ad
I imagine the entire medical and scientific community currently have their eyes stuck pointing towards the back of their heads after reading her idiotic twitter posts.
To play devil's advocate, are you referring to the same medical community who treats obesity with pills and surgery, and tells you that grains are the most important foods to eat? Just askin.
Load More Replies...Being fat isn't healthy. It has many negative side effects for your health, and chances are that if you are overweight you have an unhealthy lifestyle. The fact that people who are fat are told to love their bodies is positive and all, but let's be real. Fat isn't healthy. It can be life threatening. You shouldn't be offended every time someone say something about fat being bad for you. Suck it up buttercup.
Fat acceptance is damaging to health in multiple ways. No one should be shamed, but don't pretend keeping an unhealthy weight or damaging lifestlye {diet} is okay. It's not.
Oh for f*cks sake, stop this sh!t. Fat is neither beautiful nor healthy. I was really fat. Now I say that fat people should move more and eat less/healthier. It's way much better.
Does the "link" between obesity show correlation or causality? As was pointed out in one of the tweets: in many , many types of cancer all we know is correlation, not causality. And If you cannot prove that obesity causes cancer, then whatever your good intentions, you need to dial your campaign down a notch, because the way it is now is not only harmful emotionally to many, many people, it's misleading.
I get what you're saying, but if you want to get all pedantic, you don't even know that you are you. Maybe you are a butteryfly dreaming you are you. All we can do is go by the latest information we have, and I'll be damned it ALL of it doesn't lead to: "being obese is less healthy than being not obese".
Load More Replies...It's a sad that now people can't even accept simple statements of fact. Being fat is not healthy. If you want to not get Cancer, exercise and eat healthily until you're not fat, keep it up. Simple as that. I need to lose weight, only a little, but still. We can't be offended at the results of research and facts, or we'll stop advancement.
Just because you don't like the outcome of a scientific study doesn't mean you should take it personally. I really dislike this lady. Should we stop telling people cigarrettes cause cancer? Addiction is a really legitimately hard thing to beat and should we not inform people of the connection because we might make people who have had trouble quitting feel bad about themselves?
Facts are facts. Obesity isn't healthy and no amount positive body imagine can change the facts.
Shh... I'm waiting for Sofie's doctor to inform her she has cancer. XD Is she an anti vaxxer? Why does she hate science?
Why to people keep equating fatties to anti vaxxers? They are not related in any way whatsoever. One says "I don't believe the things I put into my own body are bad for me" and the other says "Please don't make me put s**t in my body against my will". Big difference. Obese difference ;-P
Load More Replies...While this advertisement certainly could've been worded differently, it's insanely thick to go through life thinking that being obese is completely free of health risks. Insinuating that people can be as enormous as they like without any repercussions, is far more damaging.
You can also be thin obese by having to much fat in your stomach area, it should be about 20%, so just because someone looks thin doesn´t mean they aren´t having an unhealthy amount of fat on their bodies, obese isn´t just being big.
First comment: Literally nobody knows what causes cancer (who is he, Trumps brother?) I can give you some reasons. let's start with: there is sugar in EVERYTHING....
There it is: the Trump reference. Thankfully they aren't as frequent as they once were. What obesity and cancer research have to do with the president is beyond me.
Load More Replies...I don't find the ad offensive to fat people - if you're obese, you should definitely know it's unhealthy. It might not change your eating-habits, but you should be aware. What I really really REALLY find offensive is that tabacco-industry is doing this ad. The people who for YEARS forged records and medical data to make people believe smoking isn't dangerous, or even make them think it's healthy! Why is TABACCO doing this? If it came from some hospital or science-forum or whatever - great! But why tabacco? What possible GAIN would they have, because you can be sure their gain is not for people to live healthier. That won't make them more money. No, what it's meant to do is make people look somewhere else for bad health. They are trying to shift blame, to make some other industry the Bad Guy they have been for so long. They are saying "Look - obesity is so bad, it has so many negative side-effects... come, have a smoke, at least you'll only die of ONE cancer". It's evil!
Um the ad was created for a cancer research organisation not a tobacco company. You are offended because of your own inability to read.
Load More Replies...Cancer doesn't care about your feelings, Sofie. Neither does science. Move along now...you could use the exercise.
F**k off, you stupid bitch! What you and fat nobs like you are doing is so much worse!!!!!!! Being fat and UNHEALTHY is not a goal that anyone needs to reach and promoting it like its some stupid trophy is beyond ludicrous!!!!!!!! Being fat is never something I wanted to be! My 80yrs old mum can walk rings around my lard ass!!!!!!!!!!
Honestly some people struggle so hard to loose weight no matter what they try also like if you feel healthy and ok with your self who cares if you're chubby like if you're struggling to loose weight but your weight isny cause health issues then who cares you're beautiful how you are body positivity needs to be shared like ya some people have health problems from weighing more but honestly it up to them on how they not to look or feel and no one else why are people going to sit here in the the moments like completely calling chubby people ugly it's more about personality anyways not looks plus like some other people said some people like big tummys
I really don't give a d*m about ads p*ssing people off, if the facts are supported by solid, scientific research, then you just gotta face the music
It is so childish to call this fat shaming. I'm a fatty and all I take from this is a reminder that my weight is a health risk and that by taking steps to change that, I'm doing the right thing. I make myself feel bad about the rest of it, not ads like this.
The guy who said that 'more studies show that it is a genetic cause than a circumstantial' one is the reason why lay people should not be making statements about biological issues. That is PATENTLY false. The environment is what ALTERS the genetic code directly or indirectly (epigenetics) and results in overproduction of cells (cancer). Things like hormone replacement therapy, smoking and obseitiy have been linked to cancer. Also, his statement saying that no one knows the cause of cancer is also wrong. Cancer isn't just 1 disease. It is almost a conglomerate of diseases. Unlike say...the common cold, there are different variations of cancer (I'm talking about divisions beyond just breast cancer and lung cancer). Even within the same cancer, there can be different genetic or epigenetic anamolies.causes. The truth is that cancer is a complicated disease. Her anger over an informational add is unjustified and she also provides 0 facts to support her claims.
I'm glad I live in Japan where fewer of my taxes go to supporting those who knowingly make poor choices about their health.
Omg not this again. Obesitz isn't healthy and never will be and deal with it. Exactly as being too skinny isn't healthy as well. And that whole Sofie should really do something about herself.... :x
Dear god, that is the line between rightful anger and attention seeking.
Dieting is damaging to the body? Seriously? That happens when you use sudden starvation and immediately switch from an unhealthy diet to another unhealthy diet just to slice some kilos off for beach season. Maybe take a look at what can be achieved with gradual changes in eating habits, reducing processed carbs and sugar, and combine that with strength training and conditioning. Then take a measure of your health indicators and say that losing fat the right way is damaging.
Wow she is alarmingly stupid, and all the ones in the article that agreed with her, what is with this over sensitivity? Where does it come from? There isn't even any merit to it and it drives me insane because I can't begin to understand it. The food that generally causes one to become obese is usually laced with tons of chemicals, additives, hormones, artificial ingredients etc etc, these are the elements that many times cause cancer and obviously an obese person is consuming more of these things so why is this so hard to understand?
I'm normally enthralled by all things Denmark, but she's an idiot. Maybe she didn't leave, they just kicked her out. Eat cake, get fat, do what you want. They didn't make the add to hurt you, they did it to hopefully save you, you ungrateful cow. Please reconsider your awful lifestyle for your own sake and those who love you.
This woman is a goddamn idiot. As a 31 year old obese man who has been obese all his life, I can say with 100% certainty that the only reason obese people would find literally anything offensive when it comes to weight is simply because they are too lazy to deal with the issue and have simply found another way around it. Being curvy and "plump" is beautiful and sexy, not cross-legged and smelling like a pig because you break into sweat if you run for more than five seconds. I've avoided dealing with it my entire life and even though I think it's kind of too late, I'm changing that this year!
If science is allowed and encouraged to point out that alcohol, smoking and other lifestyle factors increase your risk of cancer then it is essential people know that obesity increases this risk too. Anyone who finds this a personal attack has failed to see the bigger pricture of educating people. Once again it’s political correctness gone too far. If obesity causes cancer people SHOULD know. Don’t take it personally!
How can anyone be offended about this advert and say it's 'body shaming'. What should they write? 'Hey you're beautiful as you are, whatever your size! You're perfect. Except factually you're more at risk of this disease. Objectively you're at risk. But subjectively you're beautiful. But yeah you could die.' The advert isn't saying 'you're fat and it's bad' it's saying 'obesity is a cause of cancer'. Beauty has nothing to do with this s**t. Would smokers be offended if it said 'hey there cool kid, smoking may look cool but you might get cancer.' It's just as factual, it's still a personal choice.
I'm thinking the body never chose to be that way. It's an excess of standard in-take of food expected. This excess brought on by innovations and availability of foods not immediately provided by nature and filled with fats. While I wouldn't shame it, I would not accept it as normal as well. Hence all the health issues associated with it. I don't look at that stomach and immediately think, "Ahh the wonders of nature, ordewring it to appear so." I think, "Holy hell somethings wrong here. That the way that's supposed to be?" Sorry to all obese pple in depresson and self pity and sorrow, but sometimes having terminal cancer is as simle as having terminal cancer, and being obese is as simple as being obese. You wish it weren't so, then congrats, you're functioning normally as someone crying at cancer diagnosis. ignoring it and taking everything as shaming just doesn't hange a thing. Much love to y'all
corrections: "simple" not "simle" ; "ordering" not "ordewring"
Load More Replies...I need to see more data, though. The data as presented suggests not that obesity is a cause of cancer but that there are more cases of cancer in obese people- the age-old adage of correlation, not causation. This isn't to say that there isn't a connection between the health issues associated with obesity and ailments like cancer, but it's more complex than more weight = more sick. Sophie did exaggerate the situation and misconstrue the organization's message, but, IMO, both sides are guilty of shaping the narrative here.
When they publish research showing that processed meat increases cancer risk, it's not to demonize people who eat processed meat. The research isn't meant to convince me that putting pepperoni on a pizza makes me less valuable as a human being. It's not even telling me not to eat pepperoni, really. It's just sort of... letting you know the score. If you want to eat that go ahead, but know the risks. If you're happy being overweight and you have decided not to try and change that, then good for you, but you should make that decision knowing the consequences.
i think its good because it is "problematic", so people will start talk about the topic , sharing their opinions and perspective about an apparent connection
Actually people like her are very dangerous making obesity be the norm. No, it is not healthy to be overweight! No, it is not okay to talk out of your a*s dismissing scientific evidence! #idiot
IF obesity causes cancer is it truly obesity that causes it or is it the fact that most obese people have horrible diets? Not diet in the meaning of someone trying to lose weight but diet in what we eat on a regular basis. The vegetarian obese person is absolutely healthier than a "thin" person who eats nothing but junk food. Quality of food, not personal weight should be examined here
She is disgusting. I certainly don't want to see her flabby rolls caused by excessive eating and laying around. Where do these people get their nerve?
So, an overweight comedian got butt hurt because she felt she was called out because of her weight. If being overweight contributes to some cancers, why not make it known. If someone is obese and feels that they are happy that way and doesn't want to try to be healthier, that is their right. However, if that pregnant woman sees the bill board linking cancer and obesity, and in turn, ensues that her child learns healthy eating and exercise habits, the advertisements have done their job.
Being a survivor, I know the feeling of worry and I tell you what, scare tactics, no matter how small, are scary. I don't agree with the rant, but I agree it may have been a bit blunt. Then again, Cancer is blunt too.
I can't help but think of all the medicine commercials they have out now. Medicine for bladders or asthma or even allergies that can cause any number of side effects "even death" and it's those same scientist that claim being fat causes cancer.
I think Cancer Research would be better off sharing stories of overweight/obese people who have successfully changed made a difference in their lives and health. I also think they should have dialogue with people who are overweight as opposed to this advert. I am not offended but I think it could be a lot better.
She’s obviously done this for attention. She’s just received free advertising for her upcoming shows. Not stupid.
The doctors are providing you and us with facts. If the facts say that you, the obese comedienne, are more likely to get cancer than are slim people, that's not a personal attack, that's just presentation of the facts.
Are we really living in a world that has gone so insane with political correctness that simply pointing out medical research shows being obese is unhealthy gets people this upset?
I'm fat and I don't find this ad offensive. It's not the comments about my bodyweight or shape that hurt me, but the opinions people have about me 'Oh you must be lazy' etc. There is a reason why most obese people look the way they do and most of the times it's not about being lazy or not caring. But attitudes like Sophie aren't helping. Obesity does kill. Encourage yourself to heal what's underneath it.
Whether the ad is true and whether the ad is effective are entirely different questions. I see a lot of people arguing about the former, but isn't the latter entirely more important? Stating true facts isn't always the fastest way to get a desired result. Any legitimate beef with the ad would be over its effectiveness, IMO. Whether there are grounds for that beef is a subtler question. Who has studied the effectiveness of such campaigns? Possibly, no one has.
Fat Shaming has become popular in the UK now and in the United States, if you are not thin then you are a reject. Meaning thin by what the stars in Hollywood look like. Most are sickly looking. I am not fat and not thin, just right and I see shaming all the time for both sides. Wish everyone would just like people for who they are not what they look like.
It would be so much more rewarding if all the money was put into searching for solutions. For exampe, put it into: 1) research why so many people grow obese and do something about that (viruses, diabetes, et, 2) use all the taxes on smoking into research and medication so that people really can quit smoking. Nowadays all the tax money is put into shaming victims. It should be used for research and medical help instead of criminilizing people.
First of all it is not an advertisement, they are not going to earn money from anyone reading it. They are doing a public service for the public good. These people opposing it are just showing their own ignorance. If they wish to live in denial it’s their own problem. I preferred to watch my weight and stay healthy. They can keep complaining all the way to their Kemo therapy appointments.
Now, you looking at the wrong side of this. First - obesity often is mistaken with chubiness. Some people are born to be bigger than others. For such individuals having 'weight' won't cause any trobule. Another point is that most extreme obesity cases are caused by dis-eases and side effects of medication. Third point : Yes, there are people who don't manage their diet, who eat junk food filled with thousands of calories and therefore becoming obese. However cancer research looks at only one side of it -result of overweight. What about the reason why people stuff themselves in the midnight with chiken nuggets and fries? You should acknowledge the cause of this type of obesity rather than effect of it. That is just my opinion.
I used to be a smoker and I don't know about anywhere else but Australia has some extremely aggressive anti smoking adds. I didn't find these offensive I found them accurate, I was a smoker because I chose to be. Quiting was horrendous and difficult and required constant trying and failing but it happened and now I have a reduced likelihood of getting cancer. If you are fat you will get sick and die. You have the ability to do something about that, stop pretending you don't.
I know much people with obesity I find beautiful. But that doesn't change, it's unhealthy. You mix two different things. pictures of a stomach doesn't change the risk of getting ill. And: don't you have AdBlock? If you don't want to see the ad, block it. Ignoring facts just because some people find them offending doesn't change them.
GOOD GRIEF! HOW IS A LINK TO CANCER "A BEAUTY STANDARD"? What is her take on breast cancer? Is it a plot to target women ?? Because, obbviously, it is an attack on women to make them feel fearful and thus cower knowing they have a ticking time bomb. GROW UP. It means fat=cancer. A fact. Not "you should be ashamed of being fat". How about " If you weigh more than recommended, you should be aware of a possible increase of the likely hood you'll be diagnosed with cancer." Oh, thats what the campaign said. And what I read said to make small changes, not do whatever it takes to look like a model.
As someone who has been and is still classed in the "obesity" category (f**k off BMI), to me its her allowing people to think that being obese (which is extremely unhealthy to the body) is okay. There is scientific research claiming that this is an issue. It'll be just the same if Mind posted that those with anorexia have one of the leading death rates for those with a mental illness. Yes, I personally understand that there are medical conditions & mental health issues that may make people overweight, but for me that's what I used to use as an excuse to not try and lose weight. Unfortunately she's upset that her lifestyle doesn't fit the criteria of healthy. It's not fat shaming, it's science.
Such people should not get health insurance. Fat shaming is different. This infoAD is spreading awareness that how can you save yourself from health issues. There is difference in being a body type and being lazy.
Even if this was "incredibly damaging" - is it really worse than getting cancer? If it isn't, then maybe we can handle the ad.
it'd be exactly like me getting offended at the part saying that smoking is the number one cause, because how dare they attack me like that for choosing to smoke, but for real c***s like her just close the door for solving ACTUAL issues
I hate that we have to live in a society that doesn't know what's bad for them.
I agree with most others on here- the woman doth protest too much! Go vegan, exercise at least 30 min 5 x week & get back to us.
No I've changed my mind: Just saw a TEDTALK on YT & doctor reminded me that America & much of Europe's food industries have scientifically engineered such such a huge amount of our food is loaded with sugar, fats & artificial ingredients that deliberately addicts us to the very bad foods available. It's ridiculous that the FDA & other European institutions designed to regulate these things have totally failed. Obesity across the planet that is making us sick & left with medical bills here in the states since we cannot get single payer! Dirty rats. It took me nearly all my 50 years to make a conscious effort to get away from all the lousy food but still addicted to sugary treats. Gawd help us but don't punch down - don't blame people for sh!t we aren't even aware we are being manipulated by science!
Load More Replies...We will look back in a few years with absolute horror that the idea "Big is Beautiful" was so widespread... just like we look back now with horror at the time when smoking was deemed healthy and positively reinforced by doctors
There is a difference between fat shaming and health promotion. Obesity (which can be unrelated to BMI) is a significant risk factor for anything terrible. It's called a "comorbidity" in healthcare for a reason...it usually goes with death at an early age. So yeeeaahh if you have a large amount of fat that places additional stress on your body...not good things happen. Also obesity is usually correlated to "an unhealthy lifestyle" (high fat, low exercise, poor nutrition, poverty, homelessness, etc.) which increases the risk of cancer, strokes, and yeah everything. So I'll go with science on this one.
So she’s hysterical because proven medical advice supported by numerous scientific studies is offensive to her? There’s no way to make this truth of overeating and under exercising work for her because she’s talked herself into an alternate reality like the anti-vaxxers have. Look, she can declare that she loves her fat sagging belly all she wants, but the reality is, like all abusive one-sided relationships it doesn't love her back and in fact its very likely going to slowly kill her.
Just because someone is offended by something doesn't mean it's always wrong. The ad didn't say obese people were ugly or had less worth, all they were doing was letting people know. Just because a comedian decided it was offensive, she isn't a scientist nor did she study cancer at all so I support this ad.
She needs to grow up. I'm fat and I'm not offended by science. I know my weight comes with a LOT of health risks, not just a higher chance of developing cancer. Now, if someone decides to treat me like c**p simply because of my weight then we're gonna have a problem. But stating health facts isn't offensive.
Guys, you only live once, so why not do what you want, eat what you want, and have fun while you can
Because doing what you want in the moment isn't always the safest choice in the long wrong. Hard work tends to be more fulfilling (just make sure to balance out the work with bursts of fun sometimes ;)
Load More Replies...Its bull. i have known many obese people who never had cancer, also why do skinny people get cancer then uh, it is wrong to make a claim that is not right, scientists my a*s they dont k now fk all they make up c**p all the time
I also know people who smoke and don't have lung cancer, I guess they're wrong about that as well.
Load More Replies...Nothing feels sexier than when you sit, your stomach too sits...on your lap. Haha
I have only known non-obese people with cancer, so I'm not so sure about the statistics. I do think obese people do have shorter life spans though. But I wouldn't put that message up in a public place. It is rather insulting and I'm going to guess obese people know it isn't healthy (despite some people thinking fat stomachs are beautiful).
Not best pleased about this campaign from cancer research. I wrote: Wow start with blame eh great campaign well done Cancer Research - What are the causes of obesity? Perhaps you should be speaking to manufacturers and marketeers and the government as well as fat people. I don't know and have not met a single fat person with cancer not as yet. I am plus sized myself and struggle with my weight I became a plus sized personal trainer to get fitter and healthier and encourage plus size/obese people to move more and focus on their fitness and not listen to the bull***t noise out there. There are photos of skinny and muscular women and men in campaigns for fitness and hanging on the gym wall - I will never be a skinny white woman! At my largest I could not even get through the turnstile at the gym, I had to use the service entrance with 100 apologies from the staff.
I have lost weight (6stones/ 84 lbs so far) I have done that through tender love and self care and healing from the abuse and pain I have suffered as a fatty. I do not come from a place of self BLAME it does not help. Blaming obesity and using it as a blanket statement will not help your campaign nor will it help obese/ fat/ overweight/ large people and get them on board - your stupid advert is giving licence to let people continue to abuse overweight and obese people. Look at the vile comments can they say that about cancer of course not but you have given people licence to abuse obese people. I hear stories about emotional eating, fat being used to 'hide' behind and become 'invisible', unseen health conditions, co-morbidities, mental health, childhood abuse it goes on.
Load More Replies...This is the response I wrote to the facebook advert: Wow start with blame eh great campaign well done Cancer Research - What are the causes of obesity? Perhaps you should be speaking to manufacturers and marketeers and the government as well as fat people. I don't know and have not met a single fat person with cancer not as yet. I am plus sized myself and struggle with my weight I became a plus sized personal trainer to get fitter and healthier and encourage plus size/obese people to move more and focus on their fitness and not listen to the bull***t noise out there. There are photos of skinny and muscular women and men in campaigns for fitness and hanging on the gym wall - I will never be a skinny white woman! At my largest I could not even get through the turnstile at the gym, I had to use the service entrance with 100 apologies from the staff. I doubt if I will ever be skinny but I can focus on my fitness, health, f
Okay, both sides are right here. (really??). Yes, obesity is a big risk factor for cancer. But negative comments of any kind are a big risk factor for obesity. If you want to help people take control of their body weight, it really cannot come from making them more afraid, more uncomfortable with themselves, and more negative about their body image. So, people who are obese are OK as they are. They are beautiful strong amazing people. Helping people of any weight to discover that feeling fit is an amazing feeling (whatever their weight) I think would be much more beneficial here.
But that's not a reason to be offended by the results of scientific research, is it? After all, the ad does not say "You are obese, you will get cancer."
Load More Replies...I think one of the problems with body acceptance movement is the habit of using the word "Health" interchangeably with the word "attractive". Attractiveness is subjective, this whole campaign deals with health and it reached it conclusions through scientific studies, Also you're being a hypocrite as I'm pretty sure I saw you insulting thin women on the Celeste Barber thread.
Load More Replies...Fat stomach doesn't look beautiful and it's not healthy. Stop being delusional because ignoring facts won't spare you from getting a heart attack .
Leading cause of death in the USA and pretty much everywhere else in the developed world. So can't wait until that "comedian" starts a campaign for smoking, drug use, arming schoolkids and driving while you are drunk.
[12 year old does drive-by shooting while smoking and high on coke] - leave him alone, he's expressing himself...
Load More Replies...Nothing wrong with the ad. It is a proven risk factor for cancer; along with smoking, alcohol consumption, physical inactivity and poor diet. You don't see smokers, alcohol drinkers or fast food eaters complaining that they are being shamed for their lifestyle choices. They just accept that their lifestyle habits are unhealthy and may be increasing the risk of cancer. She should do the same. Be obese and proud if you want, just don't be a special snowflake and turn yourself into a victim.
You want to love you body, do it up, but don't pitch a hissy fit because being over weight has, once again, been linked to an earlier death. We all know being overweight is unhealthy; why deny it?
Being obese is unhealthy. Being slightly overweight is linked to a longer life.
Load More Replies...I've been fat and I've been thin. Thinner looks better, feels better and is healthier. Sorry fat people, but I get offended if people call me thin and keep commenting on my weight. And basically, being really fat just looks bad, on everyone. What does not offend me, is an organisation stating facts about health risks. Get over yourself.
As a fat person who had been thin and got shamed both times - I wholeheartedly agree with you!!!
Load More Replies...Did she seriously say that fat shaming is more damaging than cancer? I can't wait to see the statistics on that one. You know, something along the lines of "N thousand of people died from fat shaming this year which is M thousand more than from cancer"...because otherwise it really doesn't sound very convincing to me.
"JFK: Literally NOBODY knows what causes any cancer" That's shocking, if only there was an organisation that was set up to "Research" "Cancer" it would be even more awesome if they were based in the "UK" were I'm from, then following their research they could advise us regular Joe's that know literally nothing about what causes cancer how best to avoid getting it.
Cancer is the most researched disease that humans get. We DO know what causes most cancers.
Load More Replies...So the medical world is supposed to lie to you or omit facts between cancer and obesity because it may offended someone?
As an obese adult man who recently had a heart attack I want to know the best scientific evidence. Facts are not offensive. We as a society can only (and I mean only) advance when we make rational decisions based on the best scientific evidence.
Good to see you're taking it rationally. More carrots, more water, more moving, it's all good. Best of luck to you.
Load More Replies...As a fat girl I am totally NOT offended by this ad. It is simply stating a fact-Obesity could contribute to cancer. As someone who would like to avoid cancer at all cost by now knowing this perhaps it will be more of a motivator to get healthy. (already working on it and having some success).
Well, what can you say? A fat woman who is offended when scientists point out that obesity is dangerous for health? It's no different from a rotten-teeth-owner (who always craves for candy and never brush her teeth properly after that) that complains about the fact offered by the dentist which said "over consumption of candy and no brushing after it is dangerous for your tooth".
Where are all the cigarette smokers throwing their hands up in the air whining about the insulting ads about lung cancer? Oh they don't do that? This "comedian" clearly hates herself. Those fat acceptance photos these people post are a mere "security signal" and are there to BEG people to look at you and comment on how secure and brave you are. Nothing could be more insecure. Sorry you're obese, now go get a hug from someone and get on the f*****g treadmill.
Being overweight is okay upto an extent... That's when you say you are confident with who you are... Being Morbidly obese is not something to be proud of, and should concern you if you think that it's who you are, cause it's not. You need to change if you're obese... Coming from an overweight person !
Being big is not healthy, I get that it hurts some people's feelings to hear that but we cannot withhold important life or death scientific information to protect peoples feelings over their health. If Sofie does not want to hear this fine, but don't stop others from hearing this too.
Fat shaming is real and serious thing, but that doesn’t make being overweight healthy. No one should be made fun of or punished for their weight, whether they are underweight or over. But these are actual doctors, and your weight IS relevant to them, and they understand how obesity works. It’s silly to ignore facts just because you don’t like the way it is.
Why do I get the feeling that these are same type of people that say "Global Warming is fake," "Vaccines make you sick," and the "Earth is Flat"....?
Genetics make me sit on my couch and binge watch netflix all day while eating fast food. It isn't my fault I'm fat, it is genetics!
Everyone has different beauty standards. But I think we all would agree, that when a person is eating healthy and exercising enough, you wouldn't be obese. Maybe curvy, but not obese. And so obesity is not healthy.
Very true. Since I got Netflix I have a few pairs of pants that don't fit anymore... Granted, I'm getting a bit older, but sitting on my a**e every day is not going to help me fit in those pants...
Load More Replies...So she googled herself a scientist degree? Its not about some cellulite or love handles, its about being pathological overweight.
reminds me of a former friend who doesnt talk to me anymore, because i said i´d like to loose a few pounds. according to her i was putting women down who a thicker than me by that..wtf.
Load More Replies...Dieting is the worst thing you can do to your body? Um, okay. >_>
Well, many diets actually are unhealthy because they favor some sort of food type over the other, or favor unhealthy habits, or dangerously low calorie intake. It's not the worst thing you can do to your body, but if you do it constantly, it can actually be just as damaging as smoking. A healthy balanced lifestyle (and thus loosing weight) is what every doctor would probably recommend, unless you have health related dietary restrictions.
Load More Replies...People like Sophie are why some go from being 20-something liberals to mid-30-something conservatives, and maybe go too far that way. You have to listen to science, even when that goes against your political beliefs.
I agree, but I also see plenty of conservatives ignoring science in favor of their own political or religious beliefs
Load More Replies...As an obese woman who has had uterine cancer and has Type 2 diabetes, I can tell you this: fat cells produce estrogen. Too much estrogen sends your uterus into overdrive, which causes replication errors on the cellular level, which *is* cancer. And there is a strong correlational link between being obese and having insulin resistance, the essence of what Type 2 diabetes is. And so many people have reversed their insulin resistance by losing weight, which points strongly to causation. Yes, it could be that the obesity itself is yet another symptom of an underlying metabolic syndrome, harmless in and of itself but associated with deeper problems. But if losing weight will get rid of the other deeper problems, then why not try. In the meantime, though, we have to be careful to not stereotype obese people as lazy or having poor self-control. But merely calling us obese is not an insult. It's a fact. I will never have children because of my cancer. If I can save one person from that I will.
And I'm grateful for my inherited metabolism; it saved my parents' and grandparents' lives when they were starving during war. But now, in this time of plenty, it's working, uh, too well. :p
Load More Replies...Fat-shaming against cancer? Bring it. Obesity IS an illness. It's a MEDICAL CONDITION. I am not referring to BIG-BONED here, (tall and squarely-set people, there is a huge difference.) I am referring to an adult who was 55Kg during their teens and 90kg during the mid-life, who are NOT at 7% Body-fat, preparing for a bodybuilding contest.
so, don't encourage it, don't disparage it, don't ignore it, highlight it (but don't single it out). you can see why there is confusion. 'freedom of speech for some'. surely just 'living as healthily as possible' is the best advice? but how do you give advice in a 'don't tell me what to do' world? with difficulty it would appear.
NO. Your photo of your fat belly is NOT beautiful. It is very sad and dispiriting for those in the health and medical professions. As a teacher I would never embark on shaming anyone, but education of the REAL risks and lifestyle choices that contribute to such health problems is ESSENTIAL.
Deciding you are offended by something that is trying to save your life is ridiculous. If you are overweight and completely happy with it, that is brilliant, but most people aren't happy with it (and I can say that from solid experience) and it's time to start realising that being overweight DOES lead to heart attacks, diabetes and now possibly cancer, so it's not SHAMING and HATING on you for being overweight, it's literally trying to help you. Some people think big is beautiful, some don't, whatever you're into, but only the blindly stupid people can fail to see that being fat DOES bring medical issues (again, speaking from experience) so you can't blame on Cancer Research UK (bless them for the amazing work they do) for trying to HELP!
ok first of all she's only doing this for publicity and honestly in that respect, shes won. So kudos. But you CANNOT seriously argue that being obese isn't harmful to your health. How about you stop getting so "hurt" by these statements and start eating right and exercising? Would that kill you? Let me answer that for you: no. In the contrary, would NOT doing any of these things kill you: yes. yes it would.
She's got too much body fat and it's not healthy. She looks very unhealthy for such a young woman (29 years old). I for one didn't realise being obese could lead to cancer so the advert IS successfully raising awareness and I will keep the information in mind and try to eat well and exercise more!
There are far more serious things to get offended about - medical facts are not among them. I have struggled with my weight my entire life and know damn well the adverse affects it has on my health. Being offended doesn't make you right. Pointing out that carrying excessive weigh is directly responsible - FACT - for many health issues - is not discriminating against overweight people. It is trying to educate and warn. And yes - I know how hard it is to lose weight. But I'm also not stupid and I know that it is down to me to do something about it. Doctors and scientists warning me about the various implications are not offending me. Get off your high and ill--informed horse, Sofie. Nobody is attacking you, or any other overweight person. Educating isn't attacking, you silly girl. Grow up.
Obesity is a health risk. The ads are a public service. Whining about it being "fat-shaming" is just wrong.
It's one thing to accept your weight, it's a whole other thing to get offended by the fact that having a lot of fat isn't healthy. That's like a smoker getting mad about health warnings (like the last person on Twitter mentioned). It's not a means to offend someone, it's trying to educate the public about what is true.
Some anorexics think they are Fat. Some Obese people think they are fine. Their opinions on health issues shouldn't be considered.
I agree with the latter about how people need to if the advert makes them feel bad do something and try work on it.
Her and everyone like her should be directly held accountable for everyone who dies via obesity related issues. Her misinformation is MALICIOUS.
On one hand, according to statistics, obesity is the second biggest cause for cancer. Then again, we all know that statistician are people who drown in lakes with the average depth of 4,72 inches. On the other hand, as an obese person myself, I find this lady's "happy stomach" photo incredibly disgusting. There are people who can't lose weight because of thyroid problems, whatnot. That's sad but fact and they don't deserve being fat-shamed. That being said, obesity, as a health risk - cancer or not -, should NOT be handled as if it was perfectly normal and the new sexy.
I'm pale AF and if I see a report from the cdc thats like "pale skin and blonde hair hint at a lack of melanin which can increase risk of skin cancer." I'd be like "oh wow! Thanks for looking out for my well being! I'll remember to put sunscreen on today!" Not "They're shaming me for my pale skin!"
So you can't say anything negative about obesity because as soon as you do it's considered fat shaming? Geesh. Obesity does lead to a lot of health issues, that's not shaming, it's a FACT. I mean, imagine if a smoker said the same thing ? "How DARE you say to me that smoking increases the risk of lung cancer and destroys my overall health? I am OFFENDED!" That would be kinda stupid wouldn't it? Yeah, and so is this.
Remind me at all the times people told me to quit smoking. However, saying someone they are too fat, this is unhealthy and they should quit eating so much (and/or bad) food, is unaceptable because of "public shaming". Us as smoker and drinker got use to these remarks and kind of campaigns, apparently some obese people still not ... :-)
LOL. Yeah, f**k science, I have feels! Yet another lady that should have been checked in to the psych ward.
the problem is that the general consensus is that fat people need to get off the couch and stop eating take aways. this for the majority is not the case. those people that say " i just started eating healthy and i lost 2 stone ... etc etc" are the reason the rest get fat shamed.
Load More Replies...Holy Hell, when are we going to actually get past this idea that fat is beautiful and fat is healthy?? Yes, there is a certain percentage of fat that is healthy to have on your body to support organ function, etc., but OBESITY is not health and it is not beautiful. I have never looked at an obese person and thought "hey there are beautiful", maybe as an individual but not in physical appearance. Call me shallow, but humans are meant to be fit and in great shape, that is why we were able to suceed in our evolution. Sorry, but this "comedian" is fat and gross.
I'm all about being comfortable with your body... but come on. Don't lie to yourself about the health complications that come with being obese. Next thing they will say is that it's offensive to say obesity causes heart attacks and diabetes.
"Obese" is a technical term for someone who is more than just 'a little overweight', it's a term used to signify your weight is now a detriment to your health. I'm gonna stick with the science board, not someone who is upset at seeing something around her she doesn't want to hear.
Ischemia and ischemic heart disease are overwhelmingly caused by obesity. Ischemic heart disease is the number one cause of death by over 2 million per year (in 2015) above strokes. Now there is evidence that 13 cancers are may also be caused by obesity? To me this is a wake-up call, not some ignorant comedian's already shamed self's time to try to gain popularity. I am obese and I despise it, Its not a question of shaming, its a question of the more knowledge the better. If this campaign should make people not accept being obese, then where is the shame in this? People need to stop thinking their feelings are the responsibility of anyone else.
Why are we giving this lady a platform? She is ignorant and writing this article just gets her more exposure than she deserves
You can tell someone that smoking is unhealthy and causes cancer: socially acceptable, you are seen as a hero to everyone. Telling someone obesity is unhealthy and causes cancer: Oh, my god! YOU'RE FAT SHAMING! Fat shaming has killed more people than cancer!
It's killed mostly stupid people, who, instead of the right, chose the easy path: and that is committing a suicide instead of simply looking at their problem directly into the eye and try to beat it!
Load More Replies...Okay... Time to get personal. My Aunt, a lovely woman who I am named after, is overweight (not sure if clinically obese) and had breast cancer. So yeah, I believe there is a link. Luckily she survived, but had to surgically remove her breasts. "Fat is beautiful" sure, you can think that, that’s your aesthetic opinion. But "Being obese isn’t a negative thing that effects your health” is just stupid, and it’s hurting more people than it’s helping.
Oh wow... Seriously? Well give yourself a major pat on the back if you feel it's so healthy to be obese. This "fat acceptance" thing went a little bit too far.
You'd have to give her a pat. You certainly can't wrap your arms around her in a hug. (Yeah, that's fat shaming but I don't care because she brought it up in the first place and tried to attack the people trying to save her life so f**k her).
Load More Replies...I really have no patience for these ""body positive" people who are ignoring actual medical science that says that being overweight is unhealthy. They want to be overweight? That's on them. Telling others that being overweight is super Ok is just stupid, dangerous, and anti-science. Sure, it can be hard to lose the weight. I know, cause I try, and I'm not perfect.
Uhhh.. seriously ? These doctors are trying to look out for you, not trying to shame you. I get that there has been a lot of fat-shaming in the media, and I'm not in ANY way saying that's okay. But the bottom line is that obesity IS extremely dangerous and unhealthy and it is in your best interest to work hard to lose that extra weight. It doesn't have anything to do with your level of attractiveness; it is simply about staying alive. Jesus Christ.
Anyone think the DIET our idiot governments are pushing on us MIGHT have more to do with both problems? We've had "Low Fat/High Carb" pushed on both of our countries for FIFTY YEARS, on the hypothesis that it will make us all healthier. Guess what IT DOES NOT WORK! For 50 years we've gotten fatter and sicker than ever before, to the point that we now have children with "ADULT ONSET DIABETES"! We should be eating like humans naturally ate for hundreds of years when obesity, diabetes, AND CANCER WAS UNCOMMON!
Except that overall caloric intake has MARKEDLY increased. THAT is why people are getting fatter. Eating bread won’t make you fat. Consuming more calories than you expend will whether you’re eating bread, pure sugar cane or nothing but vegetables. Also cancer rates are NOT increasing.
Load More Replies...so she's ignoring the science, and concentrating on being offended? Makes sense. And BMI hasn't been debunked. In the world of Google there is no excuse to be this dull.
I don't see fat-shaming. The ad is blunt, but it is based on current medical research, not some newly enlightened groupie's interpretation of outdated data. Now if the ad had something like "if you look like this, then you're fat", yeah that's fat-shaming. Now if I can only recall what movie that line came from...
I've been smoking for nearly twenty years and a recent lung checkup turned out so good that the doctor didn't believe me I was a smoker. Am I bitching around about the fact that wherever I go I'm told smoking is bad and causes a trillion forms of cancer? No of course not. Because I'm aware of that. It's my choice. And I'm happy that I'm healthy despite this habit. But if I were to get sick I knew whom to blame. But just because I'm lucky and in good shape it doesn't mean I have to go on a rant about scientific evidence and be offended by every poster I see... She knows exactly that she's wrong and doing something very unhealthy to her body but simply can't admit it. Grow up, girl. You're fat and it's bad for you.
Right, something tells me she already Knows all of it!
Load More Replies...Great ad! Raising awareness is important and apart from maybe avoiding cancer, trying to loose wait is beneficial for your body in so many ways.
So.....you don't like the truth. Fine, but shut your gob. This could save people's lives. You are not the only one. Selfish 'Look at me'.
So she googled herself a scientist or doctors degree?! Its not about some cellulite or love handles, its about being obese..
Obesity should not be normalized. It is a preventable illness. It should be treated as such.
The ad is stating a fact based on research. Why does she need to make it about her insecurities?
I agree that it is 100% okay to be heavy, but obesity SERIOUSLY causes cancer. It's because of our unhealthy intake that builds up fat, blocks cells from cleaning, and clogs our areas that need the most movement in order to stay healthy. This is a serious issue and all they are trying to do is to bring awareness to this fateful disease.
confident as my fat a*s and I are .....I dont see a problem with the add
She and the like should be held personally responsible for everyone who's ever died because of weight based complications. Her self righteous miseducation is beyond dangerous. Teach the loudest that their barking is irrelevant.
Why is it that human beings have such trouble with nuance? Yes Obesity is a health risk. No, no one should be shamed for their physical appearance. There IS a way to communicate this important information without shaming and alienating people. Think of the times in your life when you had the courage to change and grow. Someone supported you, showed you compassion. There is a big problem in our society. Obesity is just a symptom. We have to get better at helping one another. You don't have to sacrifice facts to do that. Just embrace the best parts of being human. We can be intelligent AND kind.
You can not like the truth all you want. Still doesn't mean the organization that's repsonsible for informing people about cancer awareness is wrong. If you're diabetic, your chances of hear tattack are significantly higher. That's not an offensive belief, it's a fact.
Obesity is unhealthy. That's a medical fact. Just because you don't choose to believe in science doesn't mean you're right. You can't complain that doctors are telling people not to be obese and claim it's fat-shaming. There's nothing to be ashamed of! It's a disease like anything else. You wouldn't be ashamed of having cancer, right?
I don't think this is shaming. I need to lose some weight and this just gives me more incentive to do so. This is a factual advert. Being overweight is linked to many health issues. It's just the way it is.
Here we have yet another example of the reality distortion ride so many folks seem to be on these days.
I've seen this sign a few times. More attention needs to be given to food we put in our bodies and what it can do to our health. Why are cigarettes covered in warnings and hard to attain when anyone can just buy junk food and soda without warnings on the packaging? Being obese is probably more dangerous than being a smoker in many cases, especially in the young. Double standards much?
Pandas I dont post many comments. you can check my history. I felt the anger and vitriol in the comments were truly disgraceful. Firstly - why this level of reaction to someone complaining that they felt offended by an advert. this is a comment we see again and again on the internet and only a few areas receive this abusive reaction, and being overweight is one. think to yourself why you feel you need to react so aggressively. Secondly. did anyone read into CancerResearch UKs information on this? I can break it down to 3 statments. 1. obese people die. 2 obese people get cancer. 3 we dont know how but obesity probably causes cancer and here is how i think it might happen. If they entered into research into this topic, they have not provided the data or a link to the data. It is the equivalent of 30% of all people hit by cars smoked - therefore smoking increases your chance to be hit by a car by 30%. read the research before you sign up to it. Thanks for reading. Be Nice to each other
The anger is because you can say "Hey man, smoking is bad for you and I wish you'd cut it out for your own sake and those who love you". You can say that all day long, but try substituting smoking for obesity and people lose it. People are just sick of being told they're awful people just because they point out biological facts that are in fat people's best interest to adhere to.
Load More Replies...I don't think that it is fatshaming. People are just being overly sensitive. It's a fact. Not an attack.
Sorry, fat stomachs are NOT beautiful. And being overweight is not healthy, it's a fact. Nothing wrong with the ads
Ahhhh!!!! comedians teaching us science. Where do they get so much confidence ?
How is it okay that there are kids starving and you keep eating enough for 4 people? Dumbass.
Hi you delusional fat idiot ... if you want to stay fat, it's your bussiness .... but if someone gets cancer because you succeeded in removing the anti-cancer add to inform people about cancer risk factors, then I consider you a murderer.
loose some weight you fat idiot ... and get over yourself .... if you don't want to loose weight, at let others be informed to make their own lifestyle choices !!!!
For people with lipedema I'm sorry, I hope you can get better soon, but for others, it's called junk food for a reason
People with lipedema could hardly do anything to prevent the disease from appearing, so they do have an excuse. However, people who are not genetically predisposed to any similar conditions really are just being stupid and eating unhealthy.
Load More Replies...While obesity may/may not be directly related to causing cancer, obesity does increase the chances for a person to contract health diseases and that has been a fact for a loooooong time.
No one wants to be obese. So many people are this way due to severe health problems though. It is something beyond just "stop eating" school of thought. I feel this story can go two ways, Stating the obvious or agreeing with her that the ad is shaming fat people. For myself, I think just about everything we touch, breath or taste is loaded with harmful chemicals that can and do cause us cancer. We are living in an age when everything is loaded with dangerous chemicals esp. our food and the way we prepare it. So I wish she would be quiet about this silly little issue and concentrate more on the WHY and WHAT is in our food that is really causing cancer. These are things we really need to be protesting about but no one seems to really care.
Cancer Research UK 's third-largest donor is the diet company Slimming World, and I think in good conscience they should put this on the ads.
She's f*****g stupid and in denial about her own health. She is obese and doesn't like the fact that it could be lethal.
I happen to own a beer gut myself. I damn sure ain't going to paint it up and parade around in a speedo and expect love and applause. (You're welcome) The lady needs to quit wallowing in her pity party and take a reality check.
I believe the comedian needs to dig deeper into herself to get at the root of why this upsets her so much. She probably knows she needs to make a life change to better her health, but has chosen the easier route by denying body fat is a health concern and promoting others to form a community around that idea
Good grief, a bunch of sensitive snow flakes aren't they? Being over weight is bad for your health. Period. It's not fat shaming, it's reality.
People always fear facts. Many thing in the extreme cause cancer. THAT we know is a fact. People on this planet need to re-learn moderation. even for criticism.
typo - yikes - "many things* in the extreme"
Load More Replies...B*tch, please!! Fatness IS a negative thing, and seeing it as otherwise is dangerous. Being healthy is a goal and obesity is not healthy and no political correctness will change that.
I know that we shouldn't body shame others but she needs to wake up and see that being obese is linked to cancer, and if people can't deal with that then there's a real problem THERE not in the ad
I imagine the entire medical and scientific community currently have their eyes stuck pointing towards the back of their heads after reading her idiotic twitter posts.
To play devil's advocate, are you referring to the same medical community who treats obesity with pills and surgery, and tells you that grains are the most important foods to eat? Just askin.
Load More Replies...Being fat isn't healthy. It has many negative side effects for your health, and chances are that if you are overweight you have an unhealthy lifestyle. The fact that people who are fat are told to love their bodies is positive and all, but let's be real. Fat isn't healthy. It can be life threatening. You shouldn't be offended every time someone say something about fat being bad for you. Suck it up buttercup.
Fat acceptance is damaging to health in multiple ways. No one should be shamed, but don't pretend keeping an unhealthy weight or damaging lifestlye {diet} is okay. It's not.
Oh for f*cks sake, stop this sh!t. Fat is neither beautiful nor healthy. I was really fat. Now I say that fat people should move more and eat less/healthier. It's way much better.
Does the "link" between obesity show correlation or causality? As was pointed out in one of the tweets: in many , many types of cancer all we know is correlation, not causality. And If you cannot prove that obesity causes cancer, then whatever your good intentions, you need to dial your campaign down a notch, because the way it is now is not only harmful emotionally to many, many people, it's misleading.
I get what you're saying, but if you want to get all pedantic, you don't even know that you are you. Maybe you are a butteryfly dreaming you are you. All we can do is go by the latest information we have, and I'll be damned it ALL of it doesn't lead to: "being obese is less healthy than being not obese".
Load More Replies...It's a sad that now people can't even accept simple statements of fact. Being fat is not healthy. If you want to not get Cancer, exercise and eat healthily until you're not fat, keep it up. Simple as that. I need to lose weight, only a little, but still. We can't be offended at the results of research and facts, or we'll stop advancement.
Just because you don't like the outcome of a scientific study doesn't mean you should take it personally. I really dislike this lady. Should we stop telling people cigarrettes cause cancer? Addiction is a really legitimately hard thing to beat and should we not inform people of the connection because we might make people who have had trouble quitting feel bad about themselves?
Facts are facts. Obesity isn't healthy and no amount positive body imagine can change the facts.
Shh... I'm waiting for Sofie's doctor to inform her she has cancer. XD Is she an anti vaxxer? Why does she hate science?
Why to people keep equating fatties to anti vaxxers? They are not related in any way whatsoever. One says "I don't believe the things I put into my own body are bad for me" and the other says "Please don't make me put s**t in my body against my will". Big difference. Obese difference ;-P
Load More Replies...While this advertisement certainly could've been worded differently, it's insanely thick to go through life thinking that being obese is completely free of health risks. Insinuating that people can be as enormous as they like without any repercussions, is far more damaging.
You can also be thin obese by having to much fat in your stomach area, it should be about 20%, so just because someone looks thin doesn´t mean they aren´t having an unhealthy amount of fat on their bodies, obese isn´t just being big.
First comment: Literally nobody knows what causes cancer (who is he, Trumps brother?) I can give you some reasons. let's start with: there is sugar in EVERYTHING....
There it is: the Trump reference. Thankfully they aren't as frequent as they once were. What obesity and cancer research have to do with the president is beyond me.
Load More Replies...I don't find the ad offensive to fat people - if you're obese, you should definitely know it's unhealthy. It might not change your eating-habits, but you should be aware. What I really really REALLY find offensive is that tabacco-industry is doing this ad. The people who for YEARS forged records and medical data to make people believe smoking isn't dangerous, or even make them think it's healthy! Why is TABACCO doing this? If it came from some hospital or science-forum or whatever - great! But why tabacco? What possible GAIN would they have, because you can be sure their gain is not for people to live healthier. That won't make them more money. No, what it's meant to do is make people look somewhere else for bad health. They are trying to shift blame, to make some other industry the Bad Guy they have been for so long. They are saying "Look - obesity is so bad, it has so many negative side-effects... come, have a smoke, at least you'll only die of ONE cancer". It's evil!
Um the ad was created for a cancer research organisation not a tobacco company. You are offended because of your own inability to read.
Load More Replies...Cancer doesn't care about your feelings, Sofie. Neither does science. Move along now...you could use the exercise.
F**k off, you stupid bitch! What you and fat nobs like you are doing is so much worse!!!!!!! Being fat and UNHEALTHY is not a goal that anyone needs to reach and promoting it like its some stupid trophy is beyond ludicrous!!!!!!!! Being fat is never something I wanted to be! My 80yrs old mum can walk rings around my lard ass!!!!!!!!!!
Honestly some people struggle so hard to loose weight no matter what they try also like if you feel healthy and ok with your self who cares if you're chubby like if you're struggling to loose weight but your weight isny cause health issues then who cares you're beautiful how you are body positivity needs to be shared like ya some people have health problems from weighing more but honestly it up to them on how they not to look or feel and no one else why are people going to sit here in the the moments like completely calling chubby people ugly it's more about personality anyways not looks plus like some other people said some people like big tummys
I really don't give a d*m about ads p*ssing people off, if the facts are supported by solid, scientific research, then you just gotta face the music
It is so childish to call this fat shaming. I'm a fatty and all I take from this is a reminder that my weight is a health risk and that by taking steps to change that, I'm doing the right thing. I make myself feel bad about the rest of it, not ads like this.
The guy who said that 'more studies show that it is a genetic cause than a circumstantial' one is the reason why lay people should not be making statements about biological issues. That is PATENTLY false. The environment is what ALTERS the genetic code directly or indirectly (epigenetics) and results in overproduction of cells (cancer). Things like hormone replacement therapy, smoking and obseitiy have been linked to cancer. Also, his statement saying that no one knows the cause of cancer is also wrong. Cancer isn't just 1 disease. It is almost a conglomerate of diseases. Unlike say...the common cold, there are different variations of cancer (I'm talking about divisions beyond just breast cancer and lung cancer). Even within the same cancer, there can be different genetic or epigenetic anamolies.causes. The truth is that cancer is a complicated disease. Her anger over an informational add is unjustified and she also provides 0 facts to support her claims.
I'm glad I live in Japan where fewer of my taxes go to supporting those who knowingly make poor choices about their health.
Omg not this again. Obesitz isn't healthy and never will be and deal with it. Exactly as being too skinny isn't healthy as well. And that whole Sofie should really do something about herself.... :x
Dear god, that is the line between rightful anger and attention seeking.
Dieting is damaging to the body? Seriously? That happens when you use sudden starvation and immediately switch from an unhealthy diet to another unhealthy diet just to slice some kilos off for beach season. Maybe take a look at what can be achieved with gradual changes in eating habits, reducing processed carbs and sugar, and combine that with strength training and conditioning. Then take a measure of your health indicators and say that losing fat the right way is damaging.
Wow she is alarmingly stupid, and all the ones in the article that agreed with her, what is with this over sensitivity? Where does it come from? There isn't even any merit to it and it drives me insane because I can't begin to understand it. The food that generally causes one to become obese is usually laced with tons of chemicals, additives, hormones, artificial ingredients etc etc, these are the elements that many times cause cancer and obviously an obese person is consuming more of these things so why is this so hard to understand?
I'm normally enthralled by all things Denmark, but she's an idiot. Maybe she didn't leave, they just kicked her out. Eat cake, get fat, do what you want. They didn't make the add to hurt you, they did it to hopefully save you, you ungrateful cow. Please reconsider your awful lifestyle for your own sake and those who love you.
This woman is a goddamn idiot. As a 31 year old obese man who has been obese all his life, I can say with 100% certainty that the only reason obese people would find literally anything offensive when it comes to weight is simply because they are too lazy to deal with the issue and have simply found another way around it. Being curvy and "plump" is beautiful and sexy, not cross-legged and smelling like a pig because you break into sweat if you run for more than five seconds. I've avoided dealing with it my entire life and even though I think it's kind of too late, I'm changing that this year!
If science is allowed and encouraged to point out that alcohol, smoking and other lifestyle factors increase your risk of cancer then it is essential people know that obesity increases this risk too. Anyone who finds this a personal attack has failed to see the bigger pricture of educating people. Once again it’s political correctness gone too far. If obesity causes cancer people SHOULD know. Don’t take it personally!
How can anyone be offended about this advert and say it's 'body shaming'. What should they write? 'Hey you're beautiful as you are, whatever your size! You're perfect. Except factually you're more at risk of this disease. Objectively you're at risk. But subjectively you're beautiful. But yeah you could die.' The advert isn't saying 'you're fat and it's bad' it's saying 'obesity is a cause of cancer'. Beauty has nothing to do with this s**t. Would smokers be offended if it said 'hey there cool kid, smoking may look cool but you might get cancer.' It's just as factual, it's still a personal choice.
I'm thinking the body never chose to be that way. It's an excess of standard in-take of food expected. This excess brought on by innovations and availability of foods not immediately provided by nature and filled with fats. While I wouldn't shame it, I would not accept it as normal as well. Hence all the health issues associated with it. I don't look at that stomach and immediately think, "Ahh the wonders of nature, ordewring it to appear so." I think, "Holy hell somethings wrong here. That the way that's supposed to be?" Sorry to all obese pple in depresson and self pity and sorrow, but sometimes having terminal cancer is as simle as having terminal cancer, and being obese is as simple as being obese. You wish it weren't so, then congrats, you're functioning normally as someone crying at cancer diagnosis. ignoring it and taking everything as shaming just doesn't hange a thing. Much love to y'all
corrections: "simple" not "simle" ; "ordering" not "ordewring"
Load More Replies...I need to see more data, though. The data as presented suggests not that obesity is a cause of cancer but that there are more cases of cancer in obese people- the age-old adage of correlation, not causation. This isn't to say that there isn't a connection between the health issues associated with obesity and ailments like cancer, but it's more complex than more weight = more sick. Sophie did exaggerate the situation and misconstrue the organization's message, but, IMO, both sides are guilty of shaping the narrative here.
When they publish research showing that processed meat increases cancer risk, it's not to demonize people who eat processed meat. The research isn't meant to convince me that putting pepperoni on a pizza makes me less valuable as a human being. It's not even telling me not to eat pepperoni, really. It's just sort of... letting you know the score. If you want to eat that go ahead, but know the risks. If you're happy being overweight and you have decided not to try and change that, then good for you, but you should make that decision knowing the consequences.
i think its good because it is "problematic", so people will start talk about the topic , sharing their opinions and perspective about an apparent connection
Actually people like her are very dangerous making obesity be the norm. No, it is not healthy to be overweight! No, it is not okay to talk out of your a*s dismissing scientific evidence! #idiot
IF obesity causes cancer is it truly obesity that causes it or is it the fact that most obese people have horrible diets? Not diet in the meaning of someone trying to lose weight but diet in what we eat on a regular basis. The vegetarian obese person is absolutely healthier than a "thin" person who eats nothing but junk food. Quality of food, not personal weight should be examined here
She is disgusting. I certainly don't want to see her flabby rolls caused by excessive eating and laying around. Where do these people get their nerve?
So, an overweight comedian got butt hurt because she felt she was called out because of her weight. If being overweight contributes to some cancers, why not make it known. If someone is obese and feels that they are happy that way and doesn't want to try to be healthier, that is their right. However, if that pregnant woman sees the bill board linking cancer and obesity, and in turn, ensues that her child learns healthy eating and exercise habits, the advertisements have done their job.
Being a survivor, I know the feeling of worry and I tell you what, scare tactics, no matter how small, are scary. I don't agree with the rant, but I agree it may have been a bit blunt. Then again, Cancer is blunt too.
I can't help but think of all the medicine commercials they have out now. Medicine for bladders or asthma or even allergies that can cause any number of side effects "even death" and it's those same scientist that claim being fat causes cancer.
I think Cancer Research would be better off sharing stories of overweight/obese people who have successfully changed made a difference in their lives and health. I also think they should have dialogue with people who are overweight as opposed to this advert. I am not offended but I think it could be a lot better.
She’s obviously done this for attention. She’s just received free advertising for her upcoming shows. Not stupid.
The doctors are providing you and us with facts. If the facts say that you, the obese comedienne, are more likely to get cancer than are slim people, that's not a personal attack, that's just presentation of the facts.
Are we really living in a world that has gone so insane with political correctness that simply pointing out medical research shows being obese is unhealthy gets people this upset?
I'm fat and I don't find this ad offensive. It's not the comments about my bodyweight or shape that hurt me, but the opinions people have about me 'Oh you must be lazy' etc. There is a reason why most obese people look the way they do and most of the times it's not about being lazy or not caring. But attitudes like Sophie aren't helping. Obesity does kill. Encourage yourself to heal what's underneath it.
Whether the ad is true and whether the ad is effective are entirely different questions. I see a lot of people arguing about the former, but isn't the latter entirely more important? Stating true facts isn't always the fastest way to get a desired result. Any legitimate beef with the ad would be over its effectiveness, IMO. Whether there are grounds for that beef is a subtler question. Who has studied the effectiveness of such campaigns? Possibly, no one has.
Fat Shaming has become popular in the UK now and in the United States, if you are not thin then you are a reject. Meaning thin by what the stars in Hollywood look like. Most are sickly looking. I am not fat and not thin, just right and I see shaming all the time for both sides. Wish everyone would just like people for who they are not what they look like.
It would be so much more rewarding if all the money was put into searching for solutions. For exampe, put it into: 1) research why so many people grow obese and do something about that (viruses, diabetes, et, 2) use all the taxes on smoking into research and medication so that people really can quit smoking. Nowadays all the tax money is put into shaming victims. It should be used for research and medical help instead of criminilizing people.
First of all it is not an advertisement, they are not going to earn money from anyone reading it. They are doing a public service for the public good. These people opposing it are just showing their own ignorance. If they wish to live in denial it’s their own problem. I preferred to watch my weight and stay healthy. They can keep complaining all the way to their Kemo therapy appointments.
Now, you looking at the wrong side of this. First - obesity often is mistaken with chubiness. Some people are born to be bigger than others. For such individuals having 'weight' won't cause any trobule. Another point is that most extreme obesity cases are caused by dis-eases and side effects of medication. Third point : Yes, there are people who don't manage their diet, who eat junk food filled with thousands of calories and therefore becoming obese. However cancer research looks at only one side of it -result of overweight. What about the reason why people stuff themselves in the midnight with chiken nuggets and fries? You should acknowledge the cause of this type of obesity rather than effect of it. That is just my opinion.
I used to be a smoker and I don't know about anywhere else but Australia has some extremely aggressive anti smoking adds. I didn't find these offensive I found them accurate, I was a smoker because I chose to be. Quiting was horrendous and difficult and required constant trying and failing but it happened and now I have a reduced likelihood of getting cancer. If you are fat you will get sick and die. You have the ability to do something about that, stop pretending you don't.
I know much people with obesity I find beautiful. But that doesn't change, it's unhealthy. You mix two different things. pictures of a stomach doesn't change the risk of getting ill. And: don't you have AdBlock? If you don't want to see the ad, block it. Ignoring facts just because some people find them offending doesn't change them.
GOOD GRIEF! HOW IS A LINK TO CANCER "A BEAUTY STANDARD"? What is her take on breast cancer? Is it a plot to target women ?? Because, obbviously, it is an attack on women to make them feel fearful and thus cower knowing they have a ticking time bomb. GROW UP. It means fat=cancer. A fact. Not "you should be ashamed of being fat". How about " If you weigh more than recommended, you should be aware of a possible increase of the likely hood you'll be diagnosed with cancer." Oh, thats what the campaign said. And what I read said to make small changes, not do whatever it takes to look like a model.
As someone who has been and is still classed in the "obesity" category (f**k off BMI), to me its her allowing people to think that being obese (which is extremely unhealthy to the body) is okay. There is scientific research claiming that this is an issue. It'll be just the same if Mind posted that those with anorexia have one of the leading death rates for those with a mental illness. Yes, I personally understand that there are medical conditions & mental health issues that may make people overweight, but for me that's what I used to use as an excuse to not try and lose weight. Unfortunately she's upset that her lifestyle doesn't fit the criteria of healthy. It's not fat shaming, it's science.
Such people should not get health insurance. Fat shaming is different. This infoAD is spreading awareness that how can you save yourself from health issues. There is difference in being a body type and being lazy.
Even if this was "incredibly damaging" - is it really worse than getting cancer? If it isn't, then maybe we can handle the ad.
it'd be exactly like me getting offended at the part saying that smoking is the number one cause, because how dare they attack me like that for choosing to smoke, but for real c***s like her just close the door for solving ACTUAL issues
I hate that we have to live in a society that doesn't know what's bad for them.
I agree with most others on here- the woman doth protest too much! Go vegan, exercise at least 30 min 5 x week & get back to us.
No I've changed my mind: Just saw a TEDTALK on YT & doctor reminded me that America & much of Europe's food industries have scientifically engineered such such a huge amount of our food is loaded with sugar, fats & artificial ingredients that deliberately addicts us to the very bad foods available. It's ridiculous that the FDA & other European institutions designed to regulate these things have totally failed. Obesity across the planet that is making us sick & left with medical bills here in the states since we cannot get single payer! Dirty rats. It took me nearly all my 50 years to make a conscious effort to get away from all the lousy food but still addicted to sugary treats. Gawd help us but don't punch down - don't blame people for sh!t we aren't even aware we are being manipulated by science!
Load More Replies...We will look back in a few years with absolute horror that the idea "Big is Beautiful" was so widespread... just like we look back now with horror at the time when smoking was deemed healthy and positively reinforced by doctors
There is a difference between fat shaming and health promotion. Obesity (which can be unrelated to BMI) is a significant risk factor for anything terrible. It's called a "comorbidity" in healthcare for a reason...it usually goes with death at an early age. So yeeeaahh if you have a large amount of fat that places additional stress on your body...not good things happen. Also obesity is usually correlated to "an unhealthy lifestyle" (high fat, low exercise, poor nutrition, poverty, homelessness, etc.) which increases the risk of cancer, strokes, and yeah everything. So I'll go with science on this one.
So she’s hysterical because proven medical advice supported by numerous scientific studies is offensive to her? There’s no way to make this truth of overeating and under exercising work for her because she’s talked herself into an alternate reality like the anti-vaxxers have. Look, she can declare that she loves her fat sagging belly all she wants, but the reality is, like all abusive one-sided relationships it doesn't love her back and in fact its very likely going to slowly kill her.
Just because someone is offended by something doesn't mean it's always wrong. The ad didn't say obese people were ugly or had less worth, all they were doing was letting people know. Just because a comedian decided it was offensive, she isn't a scientist nor did she study cancer at all so I support this ad.
She needs to grow up. I'm fat and I'm not offended by science. I know my weight comes with a LOT of health risks, not just a higher chance of developing cancer. Now, if someone decides to treat me like c**p simply because of my weight then we're gonna have a problem. But stating health facts isn't offensive.
Guys, you only live once, so why not do what you want, eat what you want, and have fun while you can
Because doing what you want in the moment isn't always the safest choice in the long wrong. Hard work tends to be more fulfilling (just make sure to balance out the work with bursts of fun sometimes ;)
Load More Replies...Its bull. i have known many obese people who never had cancer, also why do skinny people get cancer then uh, it is wrong to make a claim that is not right, scientists my a*s they dont k now fk all they make up c**p all the time
I also know people who smoke and don't have lung cancer, I guess they're wrong about that as well.
Load More Replies...Nothing feels sexier than when you sit, your stomach too sits...on your lap. Haha
I have only known non-obese people with cancer, so I'm not so sure about the statistics. I do think obese people do have shorter life spans though. But I wouldn't put that message up in a public place. It is rather insulting and I'm going to guess obese people know it isn't healthy (despite some people thinking fat stomachs are beautiful).
Not best pleased about this campaign from cancer research. I wrote: Wow start with blame eh great campaign well done Cancer Research - What are the causes of obesity? Perhaps you should be speaking to manufacturers and marketeers and the government as well as fat people. I don't know and have not met a single fat person with cancer not as yet. I am plus sized myself and struggle with my weight I became a plus sized personal trainer to get fitter and healthier and encourage plus size/obese people to move more and focus on their fitness and not listen to the bull***t noise out there. There are photos of skinny and muscular women and men in campaigns for fitness and hanging on the gym wall - I will never be a skinny white woman! At my largest I could not even get through the turnstile at the gym, I had to use the service entrance with 100 apologies from the staff.
I have lost weight (6stones/ 84 lbs so far) I have done that through tender love and self care and healing from the abuse and pain I have suffered as a fatty. I do not come from a place of self BLAME it does not help. Blaming obesity and using it as a blanket statement will not help your campaign nor will it help obese/ fat/ overweight/ large people and get them on board - your stupid advert is giving licence to let people continue to abuse overweight and obese people. Look at the vile comments can they say that about cancer of course not but you have given people licence to abuse obese people. I hear stories about emotional eating, fat being used to 'hide' behind and become 'invisible', unseen health conditions, co-morbidities, mental health, childhood abuse it goes on.
Load More Replies...This is the response I wrote to the facebook advert: Wow start with blame eh great campaign well done Cancer Research - What are the causes of obesity? Perhaps you should be speaking to manufacturers and marketeers and the government as well as fat people. I don't know and have not met a single fat person with cancer not as yet. I am plus sized myself and struggle with my weight I became a plus sized personal trainer to get fitter and healthier and encourage plus size/obese people to move more and focus on their fitness and not listen to the bull***t noise out there. There are photos of skinny and muscular women and men in campaigns for fitness and hanging on the gym wall - I will never be a skinny white woman! At my largest I could not even get through the turnstile at the gym, I had to use the service entrance with 100 apologies from the staff. I doubt if I will ever be skinny but I can focus on my fitness, health, f
Okay, both sides are right here. (really??). Yes, obesity is a big risk factor for cancer. But negative comments of any kind are a big risk factor for obesity. If you want to help people take control of their body weight, it really cannot come from making them more afraid, more uncomfortable with themselves, and more negative about their body image. So, people who are obese are OK as they are. They are beautiful strong amazing people. Helping people of any weight to discover that feeling fit is an amazing feeling (whatever their weight) I think would be much more beneficial here.
But that's not a reason to be offended by the results of scientific research, is it? After all, the ad does not say "You are obese, you will get cancer."
Load More Replies...I think one of the problems with body acceptance movement is the habit of using the word "Health" interchangeably with the word "attractive". Attractiveness is subjective, this whole campaign deals with health and it reached it conclusions through scientific studies, Also you're being a hypocrite as I'm pretty sure I saw you insulting thin women on the Celeste Barber thread.
Load More Replies...
106
312