Everybody has a right to make rules in their home and nobody can do anything against it. My house – my rules, that’s a very frequently heard phrase. Well, probably that phrase is most often said by parents when they don’t want to argue with their kids, so they just play the card that “As long as you are under my roof – the rules are mine.” And the worst thing is that it’s probably right and you can’t really do anything, just be mad at them if you want to.
More info: Reddit
There is no reason to be mad when an adult doesn’t let an underage person drink alcohol in their home
Image credits: Dương Nhân (not the actual photo)
Woman shares that her 25 Y.O. son’s 18 Y.O. girlfriend spent Christmas together with them at their house
Image credits: Edward Eyer (not the actual photo)
Her mom contacted the woman, thanking her for welcoming her daughter, and expressed her concerns about her daughter drinking at college
She kindly asked her to not let her 18 Y.O. daughter drink alcohol at dinner
Image credits: u/Fit_Departure800
Everything went fine, but the following day, her son called and scolded her for being rude and treating his GF like a child
One Reddit user shared her story to one of the most popular and judgmental communities asking its members if she in fact was being a jerk for not allowing her son’s girlfriend to drink alcohol after her mom requested that she not do so. The post received quite a lot of attention and now it has over 6K upvotes and 1.3K comments.
The author starts her story by saying that her 25-year-old son has a girlfriend who is 18 years old. She said that she is nice, but childish. However, she couldn’t spend Christmas with her family, so OP’s son asked if he could invite her to be with them. Later on, the author received a message from the son’s girlfriend’s mom thanking her for welcoming her daughter, and they started talking.
The girlfriend’s mom expressed her concerns about her drinking in college and asked the OP not to let her drink alcohol at dinner as well. Later on, OP informed her son and his girlfriend about this, to which the young woman was surprised, but everything went well. Well, until the next day, when OP’s son called and said that she was being rude and shouldn’t have treated his girlfriend like a child.
Community members decided that the woman in fact was not being a jerk in this situation. Folks discussed that the legal drinking age is 21 in the USA, thus OP didn’t do anything wrong. However, the bigger question was why a 25 Y.O. man is dating such a young woman.
“Well, if OP’s son doesn’t like his mother treating his gf like a child, then he shouldn’t date children,” one user wrote. “You are totally in the right. Son needs to date closer to his age if he wants his dates to drink,” another added.
Image credits: Chuotanhls (not the actual photo)
Moreover, Bored Panda got in touch with Dr. Jane Greer, who is a marriage and family therapist. She kindly agreed to share her insights regarding effective communication techniques for resolving conflicts within a family, tips for managing emotions during heated family discussions and how parents can help create a welcoming and inclusive environment for their child’s partner within the family.
To begin with, Dr. Jane shares that effective conflict resolution techniques involve a shift in focus. “Instead of striving to make the other person see things your way and proving their perspective wrong, it’s essential to prioritize empathy and understanding their point of view,” she says. It’s about knowing when to persist and when to let up, rather than obstinately trying to prove a point, and it draws from a skill I discuss in my book, “Am I Lying to Myself.”
Instead of trying to prove one person right and the other incorrect, the ultimate goal should be to come to a mutual understanding, agreeing to disagree, and accepting each other’s diverse viewpoints. This is an organized method to resolve conflicts.
Image credits: cottonbro studio (not the actual photo)
Now, when tensions escalate, it’s important to shift away from fixating on the literal content of the conversation and avoid directly clashing personal beliefs and perceptions, as this only fuels anger. Dr. Jane shares that instead, opt for a more observant approach. “Express recognition of the escalating emotions by stating something like, ‘It seems we’re all getting quite upset, let’s set this topic aside for now and revisit it at a more appropriate time, perhaps not during dinner.’”
And finally, as for how parents can create a welcoming environment for their child’s partner, the therapist says that it starts with being open-minded and receptive when meeting them. This entails making the person feel accepted by engaging in conversation and avoiding judgment.
“For instance, expressing encouragement like, ‘It’s great that you’re applying to school,’ or ‘It’s wonderful that you have that job,’ rather than making negative comments such as, ‘Is that all you’re doing?’ or ‘Aren’t you thinking about going to school?’ The goal is to acknowledge, support, and accept their decisions and behaviors while avoiding judgment or imposing your own standards!”
And, of course, don’t forget to check out Dr. Jane Greer’s website, or follow her on Instagram and Facebook!
So, guys, what do you think about this story? Was this woman treating her son’s girlfriend like a child, or was she doing the right thing? Write your thoughts in the comments below!
Redditors backed up the woman but paid more attention to the age differences between her son and his girlfriend
She's 18 and legally an adult, so making it about her mom was weird, but saying, "I am not comfortable with someone under the legal age drinking at my house," would have been perfectly reasonable. The delivery might not have been great, but the reasoning is sound. NTA
My Alberta a*s was reading this like “but wait she’s of legal drinking age though?” 😅 I always forget most posts here are about the US!
Load More Replies...My 15 yr old daughter has half a Bud fairly regularly. Though I've educated her to better beer now. I don't want her hitting 18 and acting like so many others, binge drinking, getting drunk. and thinking it's a huge new thing. A more continental view of alcohol is healthier than the usual British view..
Yeah, reading this article when you're not from the USA is awkward. In Canada, just over the border, 18 is considered legal in 2 provinces and 19 in all the others. In Manitoba, where it's 18, it's not illegal to serve alcohol to minors under supervision and in you're own house. They're allowed to sit in lounges drinking virgin cocktails or pop as long as food is being served. I had my first sip of wine when I was about 10 and a flute of champagne when I was 15 for New Years. I hated champagne.
Load More Replies...In the UK you are legally allowed to drink alcohol in your own home from the age of 5 just a useless bit of information I know.
A lot of states have a caveat to the drinking law that allows patent to give their kids alcohol at home, too. Then there is the other side, there are states that don't even have medical exemptions to alcohol
Load More Replies...My husband is 7 years older than me. We started dating when I was 18 and he was 25. There are mature 18 year olds and immature 25 year olds. 18 is a legal adult so there should be no problem. We are still together 34 years later.
If you let her have alcohol under your roof, you can get charged if she gets a dui or drunk and disorderly for supplying alcohol
@Shane what a weird thing to say, it’s happened many many many times, there’s plenty of proof online.
Load More Replies...If this is in the US, NTA because giving alcohol to someone under 21 is illegal anyway. If this is not in the US, YTA as an 18 year old is an adult and able to make their own decisions regarding her life/alcohol disregarding what her mother says. I mean, it doesn't sound like the girl's an alcoholic that actually needs to be monitored around drinking.
Bizarre how an imaginary line drawn on the ground redefines right and wrong,
Load More Replies...I have a bit of a different perspective on this. The girlfriend's mom mentioned she was just worried about her daughter drinking. No mention of why she's worried. Was the gf drinking back at home? Is she just worried about bad influences? Does she have trust issues with her daughter? Or is she only being a typical worried mother? I have this thought because I recall being falsely or presumptively accused of doing things before it would cross my mind and it would leave me feeling unfairly judged and ridiculed just because of my age, or just because my over-thinking mom didn't trust in me making good choices for myself. The OP just flat out asked her not to drink wine like it was expected she would. Sometime like "Oh, just an fyi, I know you're only 18 and because of that we would prefer you sticking to non-alcoholic beverages. What kind of drinks do you like?" I'm not even going to comment on the age difference. I hate it when people make age as this relevant thing when it's not always.
Absolutely, that part seemed... odd. It could very well just be general motherly concern, but it comes off like such a strangely specific request
Load More Replies...She’s 18. Dating a 25 year old. Her mum is naive to think she isn’t drinking alcohol, or having sex… You seem to not have an issue with your son dating younger? Personally, I would have let her have a glass or two. Moderation with parent-type supervision. As for those slating the age gap. It isn’t a huge gap in actual years, but in life experience and maturity. Men do tend to mature a little later than women. I wouldn’t say the son is weird or creepy.
So many insecure people asking AITA when they're clearly not. If it's the law, no one should question it, ever.
If it helps, it's pretty well established that the majority of AITA postings are made up rage bait. More likely than not this story is either completely fictional, or grossly exaggerated.
Load More Replies...She's 18 and legally an adult, so making it about her mom was weird, but saying, "I am not comfortable with someone under the legal age drinking at my house," would have been perfectly reasonable. The delivery might not have been great, but the reasoning is sound. NTA
My Alberta a*s was reading this like “but wait she’s of legal drinking age though?” 😅 I always forget most posts here are about the US!
Load More Replies...My 15 yr old daughter has half a Bud fairly regularly. Though I've educated her to better beer now. I don't want her hitting 18 and acting like so many others, binge drinking, getting drunk. and thinking it's a huge new thing. A more continental view of alcohol is healthier than the usual British view..
Yeah, reading this article when you're not from the USA is awkward. In Canada, just over the border, 18 is considered legal in 2 provinces and 19 in all the others. In Manitoba, where it's 18, it's not illegal to serve alcohol to minors under supervision and in you're own house. They're allowed to sit in lounges drinking virgin cocktails or pop as long as food is being served. I had my first sip of wine when I was about 10 and a flute of champagne when I was 15 for New Years. I hated champagne.
Load More Replies...In the UK you are legally allowed to drink alcohol in your own home from the age of 5 just a useless bit of information I know.
A lot of states have a caveat to the drinking law that allows patent to give their kids alcohol at home, too. Then there is the other side, there are states that don't even have medical exemptions to alcohol
Load More Replies...My husband is 7 years older than me. We started dating when I was 18 and he was 25. There are mature 18 year olds and immature 25 year olds. 18 is a legal adult so there should be no problem. We are still together 34 years later.
If you let her have alcohol under your roof, you can get charged if she gets a dui or drunk and disorderly for supplying alcohol
@Shane what a weird thing to say, it’s happened many many many times, there’s plenty of proof online.
Load More Replies...If this is in the US, NTA because giving alcohol to someone under 21 is illegal anyway. If this is not in the US, YTA as an 18 year old is an adult and able to make their own decisions regarding her life/alcohol disregarding what her mother says. I mean, it doesn't sound like the girl's an alcoholic that actually needs to be monitored around drinking.
Bizarre how an imaginary line drawn on the ground redefines right and wrong,
Load More Replies...I have a bit of a different perspective on this. The girlfriend's mom mentioned she was just worried about her daughter drinking. No mention of why she's worried. Was the gf drinking back at home? Is she just worried about bad influences? Does she have trust issues with her daughter? Or is she only being a typical worried mother? I have this thought because I recall being falsely or presumptively accused of doing things before it would cross my mind and it would leave me feeling unfairly judged and ridiculed just because of my age, or just because my over-thinking mom didn't trust in me making good choices for myself. The OP just flat out asked her not to drink wine like it was expected she would. Sometime like "Oh, just an fyi, I know you're only 18 and because of that we would prefer you sticking to non-alcoholic beverages. What kind of drinks do you like?" I'm not even going to comment on the age difference. I hate it when people make age as this relevant thing when it's not always.
Absolutely, that part seemed... odd. It could very well just be general motherly concern, but it comes off like such a strangely specific request
Load More Replies...She’s 18. Dating a 25 year old. Her mum is naive to think she isn’t drinking alcohol, or having sex… You seem to not have an issue with your son dating younger? Personally, I would have let her have a glass or two. Moderation with parent-type supervision. As for those slating the age gap. It isn’t a huge gap in actual years, but in life experience and maturity. Men do tend to mature a little later than women. I wouldn’t say the son is weird or creepy.
So many insecure people asking AITA when they're clearly not. If it's the law, no one should question it, ever.
If it helps, it's pretty well established that the majority of AITA postings are made up rage bait. More likely than not this story is either completely fictional, or grossly exaggerated.
Load More Replies...






















55
71