33 Examples When Folks Were Reading Something And Caught The Author In 100% Ignorance
It used to be easier to write books in the old days. Even fiction books - at least because readers in those blessed times when there was no access to all human knowledge literally on the go often had to take the author's word for it.
On the other hand, preparing to write a lot of educational videos and texts used to be much more difficult without the internet. Today, a person can even write a good travel guide to a city they have never been to by just using Google Street View. And yet, human negligence knows no bounds. This viral thread in the AskReddit community is further proof of this.
More info: Reddit
This post may include affiliate links.
I read a book with the sentence, "His heart rate rose as his pulse began to slow."
You don't even have to be a healthcare person to raise an eyebrow at that.
Come on! Completely possible! If the body part where the pulse is being taken is small and just been amputated. Just expect the heart rate to fall very very quickly thereafter too if you don't do something to stem the blood loss.
Hmmm. I could be wrong. Maybe I should test it just to be sure ....
Load More Replies...
Whenever a character is whimpering that her corset hurts.
For 90% of history, corsets did not hurt! Tightlacing was not the norm! Corsets were just bras and bodice shapers! A princess who’s worn corsets her entire life should be used to it. She can hate the feeling, but the whole “I can’t breathe!” trope needs to stop.
Edit: And don’t even get me f*****g started on the idea of someone having scars bc of their corsets. Corsets were NOT worn on bare skin. They would wear a chemise ffs!
I don't know about this. I have yet to find a bra that actually fits me and mine are tight and a pain in the patootie to wear. There are tons of women who take off their bras first thing after getting home from work, but in 80 years I bet we read things like "Bras never hurt. They were never tight and no one ever minded wearing them."
It's like telling me my bra doesn't hurt. People go through priorities with their clothing. If you're not in the mood for all that, it's uncomfortable, especially if somebody else is dressing you.
French royalty wore their corsets so tight that they couldn't raise their arms properly, and most upper class women could not bend or twist or sit naturally due to corsets. Freedom to move like a human was only for the working classes. The higher the rank, the more you were restricted physically and socially. So sure you could breath, but this modern apologist bs about how they were super chill is pure romanticism
And corsets were part of the undergarment, not a decorative piece of clothing you would wear over everything else.
If I remember correctly most of the time they were harmless but there were some cases where they caused injury due to misuse
Sorry, my browser had a hiccup... Can't delete my first comment. Have you ever thought about bra fitting? If your bra is uncomfortable or hurts maybe it is the wrong shape or size. A bra shouldn't be more uncomfortable as any daily worn clothes.
Load More Replies...sure...i have heard this before...maybe the pre-victorian era corsets didn't hurt, but i am sure they were as annoying AF...i mean just think how annoying a modern day bra is...they MUST'VE been annoying ...and they must've been hot...
Actually, modern day clothing is much hotter because it's made of synthetic material. Linens and cotton are generally much cooler, hence layers.
Load More Replies...Even when people looked like their corset was tight laced, usually it was enhanced by a bustle etc
Any time they mention "poisonous" snakes. Poisonous snakes do exist, but they're much rarer than what people are actually worried about, which is *venomous* snakes. If it bites you and you die, it's venomous. If you bite it and you die, it's poisonous. If you're worried because a snake is poisonous, just don't eat it.
I'm not sure when this technical distinction between "poisonous" and "venomous" developed but it seems extremely recent (20th century, I think) and domain-specific, like the botanical definitions of nuts, berries etc. I've been trying to find historical support for it but found extensive use of, for example, "poisonous snake" including in technical literature up until the 1970s at least (examples including New England Journal of Medicine, the CDC, very many US Army publications such as Poisonous Snakes of the World, published by the Bureau of Medicine and Surgery etc.). Personally, I find this "gotcha" very irritating, like insisting a tomato is a fruit. It's true when you're using the technical terminology of a specific domain but outside of that context, it's just annoying and ignores centuries of usage.
Let's make an assumption right away - there are a lot of authors who have done poor research on the subject they are writing about. Even more than those who haven’t done any research at all. Both in fiction and non-fiction.
And so we get the roar of spaceship engines in the vacuum of space, knights performing gymnastics in full armor and tirelessly waving a two-handed sword for several hours, and other stories that then appear in threads like this one.
There is always the temptation to explain any inconsistencies in the plot and text with the universal "It's just magic!", but there’s a limit to everything! You can try to provide scientific justification for the possibility of dragons flying or how they manage to breathe fire and not burn themselves - but when you have a Viking drinking from a fjord (which is, in fact, a sea bay with salt water), that's something completely different!
I don’t know a ton about this, but all media from top to bottom seems to believe that bonking someone on the head with a blunt object merely results in an “unscheduled nap.”
The fact is that if you’re out for more than a second or two, you likely have permanent brain damage. Especially without modern medical care.
Yes, this one annoys me too, particularly because it's been used for decades and many people actually believe that a knock-out is a harmless and temporary injury.
Think of the TV series where major characters get knocked out many times over its run. They would be so seriously brain damaged in real life.
Load More Replies...And having knocked someone out you cannot instantly wake them up with a bucket of water to the face.
Yes, this makes me truly angry. I've hated it for decades, but I especially hated it after some 9th graders (14-15yo) badly beat a 10th grader (15-16yo) at my son's old high school. They kicked him repeatedly in the head. Of course, he went unconscious. And actually was in a coma for days (maybe weeks). Those kids maybe didn't even realize that the kid wouldn't just go home with a headache and bump on the head.
That it causes brain damage is usually not the case, but it takes at least some weeks in order to go back to normal and is often connected to very heavy headaches/migraines, balance issues, forgetting things and other temporary cognitive issues.
In one of the fantasy series I read, the town guards refer to knocking people out with a sap as giving them a 'nap tap'. One of the main characters eventually dies from one too many nap taps.
This reminds me of a comedy RPG named Zenith. You have to blackjack someone. For the rest of the game, the villain's minions can be heard having casual conversations of when the guy you knocked out is going to recover. It was super sad
I find that suspension of disbelief always has to happen with this. I've been rereading Animorphs, and this is constant to their moral clause of not killing humans - by cracking them on the side of the head with a huge bone blade =.=
Omg Animorphs! I haven’t thought about those books in years!
Load More Replies...I sometimes dislike watching movies with my wife. She has the habit of pointing out all the inconsistencies in the movie.
I recently read a book where a couple was in Paris during WWII and they strolled into a restaurant and ordered a whole duck to eat. During.... WWII....... they were not even rich.
The Nazis confiscated much of the food in Paris to feed their troops. A person would have to be in line very early in the morning to get just a loaf of bread. Meat of any kind was practically nonexistent. Many people today don’t know the sacrifices people, especially Europeans, had to make during WWII.
A friend's Dutch mom told us they ate a flour and water paste and tulip bulbs.
Load More Replies...If you had money, you could get about anything you wanted. The black market was flourishing, even in restaurants, but some discrétion was required. That whole duck would have been à bit too obvious.
Even today, in any part of France, you do not usually stroll into a restaurant and order a whole duck. Exceptions may be a Michelin * restaurant, in which case you would have made reservations, or a rotisserie type place or farmers' market. Even there, whole chickens are the norm, while any sort of duck is more legs or breasts. I sat this having lived in southwestern France for 4 decades, and being really into food and cooking.
Load More Replies...I read something set in the early 80s in Paris and the couple got the Eurostar home. I'm not that old (37) and I remember the thing opening
Wow! That IS lazy writing. I've got a set of stamps from when the tunnel was completed.
Load More Replies...If the scene took place prior to France's surrender in June of 1940, the scene might be plausible.
Maybe they were optimistic and everyone just pretended their grilled rat was duck.
I feel like this is gonna lead to a conspiracy that the characters were secretly Nazis and able to access duck
Computers and programming.
"I just need to upload the IP address to the cloud server and then we will have root access to the network"
No, you won't. You just won't. That's like saying
"I just need to glue the plastic frog to the radiator and then the car will be able to fly".
Back in Golden Hollywood, script writers could get away with fake tech speak because audiences had not been exposed to the huge amounts of information, scientific or medical, that we are today. Pseudoscience sounded technical enough for most everyone. We are no longer as gullible as our parents and grandparents.
Speak for yourself my friend. I can assure you, I am EXTREMELY gullible.....🤪
Load More Replies..."I just need to glue the plastic frog to the radiator and then the car will be able to fly". Now this is just ridiculous! The car won't be able to fly!! It will be able to hop! For a car to be able to fly, you'd need a plastic flamingo, not a frog!
Hacker: "We need to access their system but this program has multiple layers of encryption more complex than anything I've ever seen! (Tappety Tappety Tap) "Ok, we're in!"
"Okay," you may say - "but what to do then if the author cannot be an expert in absolutely all possible things?" The answer is quite simple - do not try to be an expert yourself when playing on a deliberately foreign field.
For example, the great John R.R. Tolkien, as is well known, when describing the campaign of the Fellowship of the Ring, specifically calculated the phases of the Moon - just to casually mention in some scene that there was a full moon in the sky.
On the other hand, the Professor was never an expert, for example, in economics - his goal was, first of all, a grand linguistic experiment. That is why you will not find in The Lord of the Rings any attempt to explain how the underground cities of the dwarves lived without grain and vegetables, or how much a pint of milk cost in Minas Tirith.
And still, the world created by the genius of Tolkien is considered one of the most developed in all of world fantasy.
I read a novel in which the character kneaded pie crust for a long time. You should knead bread dough to activate the gluten, but pie crust should never be kneaded—it should be handled as little as possible!
I never knew "activating gluten" was a thing. From the internet: "Kneading, stirring, or mixing the dough causes the gluten strands to develop and strengthen. The more the dough is mixed, the more gluten is developed, resulting in a more elastic and stretchy dough." From that, yes, makes perfect sense you would not want to knead pie crust! Learn something new every day.
Pastry dough should be handled as little as possible because you don't want the butter to be completely incorporated into the dough and you don't want it to get warm. Cold butter is what makes the layers in pastry and layers are what make pastry flaky and delicious.
Load More Replies...My mom read a book where the characters were eating a giant trifle and went on and on about the "exquisite crust". FFS do you even know what a trifle is???
The author could have easily Googled this. I make pie crust in 20 minutes (though it should chill for a few hours in the refrigerator). You never, ever knead pie crust.
Therapy! It's rare to see it portrayed correctly. Usually the therapist says things that are wildly inappropriate or just not right. Oversharing personal information, taking weird notes or being oddly distant and aloof.
Same with psych wards. Usually they're just a normal part of a hospital, no spooky dungeon / asylum. And often there are two different wards (open vs. closed), depending on the severity of your condition. If someone is a danger to himself or others or psychotic, he will be kept in a closed ward where you can't leave without permission or supervision. Open wards are pretty much like normal hospital routine and you can leave as long you don't have scheduled therapy at the time and sign out.
Ps: Nobody will lock you up for life in a psych ward if you haven't commited a crime (that's forensics psychiatry). Hospitals are swamped with patients that need help, they'll send you on your way as soon as they remotely think you'll be able to fend for yourself again.
Load More Replies...Does this mean that "What about Bob?" wasn't an accurate depiction?
Theory: writers are poorly paid, and have terrible insurance if they have any. So they get the therapists that take the poor people for a scam ride. And I can promise you, all that wacko, unprofessional behavior goes down every day in cheap offices. I was the transcription office for two psyche mills. They hired nutcases.
This makes me so angry. They are almost always private therapists, even if the patient is not rich. They jump right into their conclusion almost immediately after asking two questions. They actually take notes, which I personally have never seen. But sometimes they show them being unrealistically good, where they actually act as a detective (by questioning, not investigative work) to try to help the person. Almost all therapists I've seen just sat there like lumps and did and said almost nothing. Maybe that works for people with emotional issues, but it doesn't work if your problem is that you are an undiagnosed autistic person with pretty serious executive functioning disorder, and still suffering long-term effects of a bad concussion. But a good therapist would realized that there is more needed than just "listening" for someone like that. Although I have a caring therapist and is good at the listening stuff, it's only slightly helpful to me. The profession needs serious work.
I'm being treated for OCD and found a therapist that specializes in it. She takes notes, and we have a great back and forth. I feel like there is a light at the end of the tunnel. But she is my fifth therapist. None of the others were helpful at all. Left the fourth one because she kept mixing me up with other clients and saying things that weren't relevant to me at all.
Load More Replies...My therapist told me that if there was a victim of murder and the phone was locked that investigators wouldn't go through it. A little off topic in a way but I was bamboozled. Like alright boiis, phone is locked. Guess we need to head on home.
Hacking. The speed and ferocity is something commonly shown incorrectly, but another is hardware. You're not going to break into an encrypted database on a secure network with a Macbook. Brute forcing requires server farms worth of power.
Not a book, but I think the worst hacking scene is from NCIS, where two characters are both using the same keyboard to go faster.
The most infamous hacking scene indeed : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8qgehH3kEQ
Load More Replies...I always loved that the alien mothership in "Independence Day" was plug compatible with Jeff Goldblum's Macbook and allowed viruses to be uploaded seamlessly
When they say universal adaptor they mean universal adaptor
Load More Replies...Half the time all you really need to do is impersonate someone and trick some poor office bum into giving you their password.
if you want to look impressive tho, try https://hackertyper.net/
Maybe not, but I can definitely hack the Gibson with a collection of laptops on dialup modems.
The scene from "Sneakers" where Whistler "engineers" the bank employee (tricking him into turning off the security alarms) was far more believable. It shouldn't surprise you to hear that Lawrence Lasker and Walter Parkes created both "Sneakers" and "War Games", two of the more believable hacker movies.
Many authors, succumbing to the already typical cliches, try to add excessive realism to their books - and the texts only suffer from this. "For example, in a typical fantasy world, elves are so reverent about their forests and trees that they are ready to give their lives - both their own and someone else's - literally for a broken branch?" says Oleksiy Arkhireyev, a Ukrainian copywriter and novelist, with whom Bored Panda got in touch for a comment here.
"At the same time, elves are usually great archers. And any big battle is a huge number of arrows. For example, at the Battle of Agincourt in 1415, English archers fired about 7 thousand arrows. And where, I ask you, did the elves get such a quantity of wood for these arrows?" Oleksiy questions.
In any case, it’s best to be guided by common sense, check the opinion of experts, and do a detailed study of the material you will write about, Oleksiy believes. "And even better - write about what you personally know very well, what you understand at an expert level or so. Then the text will definitely be interesting - and if you add some writing skills, then it will be completely captivating."
Characters with wildly inaccurate names for their time period, location, gender during that time period, culture, etc.
Names are so easy to research and yet…
Also someone not knowing the appropriate ways to use Your Highness, Your Majesty, Your Grace, etc….
There is also the opposite problem. Many readers don't realise how old certain names are, so if they are in a historical fiction they think they are too modern and lose respect for the author, so publishers have had authors change them despite them being historically accurate. I can't remember the major example, but it might have been Phoebe or Penelope.
The Tiffany problem! Actually a real, medieval old name. People don't believe it so the brain nopes it and calls mistake.
Load More Replies...Also, characters breaking rules or norms of the time that would landed them in prison or dead. A soldier questioning an officer, a commoner interrupting a King, addressing a higher class person without asking? Yeah, not happening...
I worked at Barnes and Noble when most of the Harry Potter books were released, and we'd have huge events where a lot of employees would dress in costume and host game and craft stations throughout the store. After four years of being a generic British wizard, I got a little wacky for the sixth book and hosted my station as Biff Smiley, the California Surfer Dude wizard--I wore a Hawaiian shirt under my wizard robes and spoke in Valley dialect all night. "Whoa, that's some gnarly wand you've got there, little dude!" The kids loved it.
And then there is Tiffany, a name used for a very long time which can be used for a lot of time period stories, but won't be used cause it sounds to modern.
i recently learned that tiffany was a popular medieval name, but it is not used in most period pieces just b/c it feels anachronistic.
Reminds me of that thing I read about the name Tiffany and how it was actually a common nickname dating back to the 12th century but if someone tried to use it in historical fiction people would dogpile them for it.
Dune. Tens of thousands of years in the future, millions of kilometers from earth, and the dudes name is Paul.
As for medical field... Where do I even start?!
Idiotic CPR and defibrillator use, of course. People waking from long coma, getting up and leaving like nothing. Blunt force head trauma, knocking person unconscious for two mins, them getting up like nothing happened. Running with broken leg. Horror is super notorious with this - immediately passing out after getting shot with tranquilliser dart.
Closer to my field - cancer patients, their treatment portrayal.
There was an early Friends episode where Monice and Phoebe accidentally distracted a guy and he was hit by a car. They visit him in the hospital and call him 'coma guy' yet he's not hooked up to anything, his hair is perfectly styled....but he's in a coma? Then they go see him and he's coming out of the bathroom totally fine and coherent.
It always bugged me in Rocky II that Adrian is in a coma long enough for Rocky to have grown a beard, yet she's not connected to any iv machines, no ng tubing, she had no catheter in place or anything. How is she getting her nuitrion and hydration needs met? Where is her urine going while she's comatose?
Load More Replies...As a phlebotomist/medical assistant, seeing doctors in media doing the menial tasks that they never actually do. They don't draw blood, or take your vitals. Also, seeing people in movies/tv draw blood--it's always done in a very unrealistic way.
I recently tried to read a book where the main character was using Ativan for weight loss. FFS.
OMG People being fine after getting narcaned and walking off no one explaining it will wear off in 15 - 30 minutes and they will overdose all over again.
True story - a friend was in a roll over car accident. He was taken to the trauma center and was in a coma for two weeks. He did, in fact, wake up and walked out. He managed to get to his house, and asked a neighbor to let him in, as she had a key. She called the hospital and he was picked up by an ambulance and returned to the hospital. He did not remember anything. He was worried about his dogs, who were being cared for by his neighbor.
"People waking from long coma," - as awful as Steven Seagal movies are, he ~did~ get that right in "Hard to Kill", where his character was in a long term coma and his muscles had atrophied (barely escaping his pursuers).
Characters eating anything with tomatoes in medieval Europe. Makes me think the author did zero research as to what people ate in medieval Europe.
Hunchback of Notre dame to answer aces question of the top off my head 😂 festival of fools, confused me as a kid into history.
To add to yours: the whipping boy, the tale of desperaux (idk if that counts though it’s fantasy)
Load More Replies...my favorite lotr trivia is that tolkein wanted to keep everything medieval english, but just could not picture his pastoral hobbits without tea, potatoes, and tobacco, so he bent the rules
Not sure how many tomatoes were kickin' around 7th century China either but my guess is none.
I'm under the impression they didn't eat tomatoes because of the type of tableware used - the acid in the tomato would improperly mix with the plating material. I'm sure any lowly to peasant would have raised an eyebrow at tomato based fear.
Tomatoes are from South America, so they didn't arrive in Europe until the 16th century.....so....
Load More Replies...However, even the greatest masters of world prose and poetry could make mistakes - and sometimes even quite grossly. What can we say about simple craftsmen of texts then? So now just feel free to read these stories, and maybe share your own in the comments below. Perhaps your tale will be no less funny and captivating than those that we have collected in this selection? Who actually knows?
I remember hearing about a James Bond script that was to start with a Day of the Dead celebration in Mexico. The writer didn't do his research and assumed that the holiday was celebrated all throughout the country.
When they go to film, they discover the locals didn't actually celebrate Day of the Dead in that region. The studio decided to host the festival themselves so that the movie could film its scenes as scheduled. The festival was such a hit with the locals that ever since then, the town *now* has a Day of the Dead celebration.
So who knows, maybe not doing research can result in a fluke where your factual errors can force reality to make them become true.
Somebody once told me that Day of the Dead was for Mexicans what St Patricks Day was for the Irish: something fun Americans did
That somebody was dead-wrong about it. The Day of the Dead is a huge deal here in Mexico, since it's a celebration thet syncretizes indigenous and European customs and beliefs. People take it very seriously in most parts of Mexico. PS: I've lived in Mexico for almost thirteen years.
Load More Replies...I might be wrong but as far as I know that movie (Spectre) made the Day of the Dead parades out of whole cloth. They literally didn't exist at all before that. The "town" being Mexico City btw.
Correct! Only the parade didn't exist, the celebration has very much always been a huge thing here.
Load More Replies...Not entirely true: The Day of the Dead is celebrated almost everywhere in Mexico (including Mexico City where they filmed this particular scene for the JB movie and it is a HUGE deal here), there was just not a Day of the Dead parade and there never was one anywhere in Mexico, or at least not with those specific characteristics.
Plus, the 20ft tall skeleton puppet was from the same movie. The city voted the funds to buy one.
I was in Mexico City when that was being filmed (in Feb 2014) and more than one person told me that they didn't do that. I later learned that now they do I still chuckle when I think about it.
It became thing after the movie and now it's held every year. Although the celebration itself has always been popular and an integral part of Mexican festivities, contrary to what OP said.
Load More Replies...It was 2015. ETA: Well, the film was 2015. I guess they were shooting a year or two earlier. Definitely not pre-internet though!
Load More Replies...
In John Gwynne's Shadow of the Gods, a character DRINKS FROM A FJORD. Excuse me that is salt water, you should be dead!
They also take their boats up the "rivers" at the end of the fjords, as if that's a thing. The author apparently didn't even spend 5 minutes googling what a fjord is before including the word at least four times per chapter. If you wanted it to be a river just call it that!
Only book I've ever rage quit.
TBF not all fjords contain seawater, some of the Norwegian ones are freshwater too.
The Norwegian Blue parrot drinks from them. When separated, they pine for those fjords.
Load More Replies...Oh, may I just add one thing? I have actually helped transport a viking ship across a field and down to a lake. It was incredibly easy and even though we were perhaps 30 ppl pushing and pulling the ship, it was very clear that you could do it just 5-10 people. We were 30 because everybody wanted to try. Lol.
Being a Fjord doesn't mean there's no rivers connected to it, or that the cliffs dont break. Water flows to water, and there's lots of freshwater mixes and glaciers feeding into many fjords, especially tidal zones. I've flown a plane over Alaska's Misty Fjords, and several boats, so I understand the terrain of many fjords.
The fjords in Norway are filled with ice melt. You can absolutely drink the water.
The size of the ocean vs the volume of our little rivers... Also, the tides mixes the waters several times daily, so at best, a few weeks during the spring, the innermost part of the fjord may be a little brackish
Load More Replies...
Anything to do with horses.
Making taking care of a lot of animals seem like just a few minutes' work a day. Ditto farming acres of any crops. That work never ends.
Using real-world cities but never mapping distances. Miami and Tampa, for instance, are not at all close to each other.
I spend two hours a day looking after my horse. It's a real commitment, not something that can be done in a few minutes.
Yep, I grew up with horses, and it was my job to do morning feedings and muck stalls every other day. Probably about 10-16 hours worth of work a week, and a good workout. Stacking hay bales, cleaning hooves, carting hot water from the house to the barn in winter to melt the water buckets, making oat mash, giving medicine and dewormer, grooming and fly spray, cleaning tack and horse blankets, putting blankets on when it’s cold…..it’s a lot more work than average people think!
Load More Replies...And horses that can be ridden from dawn until dusk day after day without shelter at night or any sign of a farrier.
Right! All the movie cowboys have their one special horse, but on a real cattle drive each rider would have a string of up to 10 horses that they rotated through.
Load More Replies...It always bothered my grandfather that the old western movies always had the characters riding horses everywhere at a full gallop.
My grandfather made similar remarks. Also , in "The Searchers" ( the more I watch this movie, the more I dislike it, but it is on the reading/watching list for the class I taught in France ) Who the heck takes care of John Wayne's horse when he rides in out of the blue?
Load More Replies...To be fair, most people don't want to watch movies that well encompass everything involved in taking care of hundreds of acres of crops or a very long road trip. Movies usually don't usually show everything the character does, for example, everybody needs to poo, but only certain movies will show it.
My mum said I shouldn't watch those types of films!
Load More Replies...I read a book a few years ago written by a Brit in which one of the characters drives round-trip from NYC to L.A. once a month. That's almost 5400 miles roundtrip by the shortest driving route. It would take almost 80 continuous hours at 70MPH to drive that.
Best example: In the movie "The sound of music" the Von Trap climbed the mountain just west of Salzburg and ended up in Switzerland. In reality they took a train
I also get mad at the inaccurate terms. A colt is a MALE horse under the age of 4. A filly is a FEMALE horse under the age of 4. The non-gender-specific term is FOAL (up to age 1, anyway.) Tired of people calling every baby horse a "colt".
Animal companions that are immediately loyal to the protagonist, and go everywhere with them/do whatever they want without any training or general care. Bonus points if it’s an exotic animal.
I get that in many cases this is a “suspension of disbelief” thing more than a “author didn’t research” thing, but it still irks me. This trend repeated over and over again in media has left the general population with some really unrealistic/misinformed ideas about how animals think and work, which A- is unfortunate for their pets; and B- glorifies and bolsters the exotic pet trade, which is rife with animal abuse and mistreatment.
Everyone’s spent their whole lives consuming media that tells them that animals will automatically love/obey the “good guy”, and everyone is the good guy in their own mind. In reality it takes learning and work to train and bond with an animal no matter who you are.
I can’t count the amount of times I’ve told someone “my dog is a little scared of strangers but if you ignore him and pass him treats he’ll warm up fast”, and they’ve gone “dogs like me!” And reached right for his face anyways. Then they spend the next ten minutes trying to rationalize why the dog barked at them when he was obviously just scared.
Or the opposite. Many people think of wolves as dangerous, bloodthirsty monsters. Well I volunteer at a wolf sanctuary, and let me tell you - given the choice between getting in the pen with the wolves, and getting in a pen with chihuahas, I will choose the wolves every time. They are often very sweet, and loveable goofs. In the wild, wolves that are not used to humans will absolutely flee humans every time. Because wolves are smart, and one of the number one killers of wolves in the wild is human. So they Don't want to start any conflict, because it could kill them. Even if you p**s them off, they will warn you multiple times before even thinking about hurting you. One guy tried to ride one of our wolves like a pony, and Still didn't get bit for that.
What kind of dilhole tries to ride a wolf like a pony?? I try to be understanding and patient in all things, with everyone, especially when I don’t know all the details of the situation. However, this one has me scratching my head, like…just…what kind of dilhole tries to ride a wolf like a pony??
Load More Replies...The way to get animals to like you is to respect the animal’s wants, needs, boundaries, and space.
Not always the case. An ex of mine had a very grumpy old fox terrier who hated pretty much everyone, except he apparently fell in love with me the moment he saw me. I was sitting on her couch when he climbed up, walked over and flopped into my lap with a loud "hmph" noise. My ex, her parents and her brother were all in shock.
A client got a Siberian Husky pup because she lived in Alaska and wanted an expensive breed of dog (maybe a little Game of Thrones envy). The first year the dog kept vomiting, and three expensive vet visits later, she found out the dog was overheating because she was from India and kept her house at +75 Fahrenheit. The dog was soon stressed and hot, and she didn't understand that different breeds need different things.
Stephen King's "Fairy Tale" narrates an example of how to win a dog's trust.
Yes. In the movie War Horse, all the kid has to do is plead with the horse to do something and it does. "Please plow this field." "Please fix me a cuppa."
It bothers me when people don’t know the difference between jail and prison. Books, movies, and TV shows always talk about “going to jail for (x number) years” or “you’ll get arrested and they’ll take you to prison.” Jail is pre-trial and people sentenced to a year or less. Anything more than a year is prison.
It bothers me when people assume that this is a linguistic difference rather that just a convention is a certain country. Across the rest of the world the two words are interchangeable,
Bothers me more that BP would pick a photo of a concentration camp for the example.
Load More Replies...unbelieveable, that you use a photo of Auschwitz for this absolutely uninteresting question
It bothers me that some Americans think that the rest of the world uses exactly the same language they do. In the UK, prison and jail mean the same thing. If a prisoner is awaiting trial or sentence, then it's called being "on remand."
In the UK we have 'local jails/prisons' which will house remand prisoners for nearby courts and sentenced prisoners. Short sentenced prisoners will generally stay in their local area but long sentenced prisoners will be moved onto convicted only prisons/jails elsewhere in the country. The trouble is, due to overcrowding, the spaces aren't available to move on prisoners quickly enough.
Load More Replies...It's not completely accurate, even for the US. Where you're convicted to depends on what crime you've committed. People can be convicted to jail.
Load More Replies...this building is neither a jail nor a prison. how can you be so ignorant not seeing, that this is Auschwitz, a concentration camp, where more than 1.000.000 people were killed
The words jail and prison are synonymous and interchangeable in every part of the anglosphere outside of North America.
And probably it's the same for a bunch of other languages. In my own language all the synonyms of prison, jail etc are interchangeable
Load More Replies...Jail: a place of confinement for persons held in lawful custody. Prison: a place of confinement for persons held in lawful custody. In the US the two are different places, but in the rest of the world they are the same thing.
Weight of armor and weapons mainly swords. The heaviest plate armor weighed under 100lbs and was distributed over the body. Swords weighed 2 to 3 lbs. The 6 foot blades weighed up to 7lbs. More movie than book but if I see one more steel sword cast in an open mold I'm gonna lose it.
Its so rare to see a good blacksmithing scene. One of the things I liked about Blue Eyed Samurai is that they did get a lot of things right. Not everything, but a lot.
I’ve been thinking about watching that, is it good? And how bad is the sexual violence (main reason I’ve stayed away)?
Load More Replies...Also, a character needing an armor, "borrowing" one from a random place and then wearing it without any difficulty. And then remembering that those things were custom made to fit one owner.
Fair, to a point. What irks me is the lack of attention to how many layers go under the armor and pad it. So, yeah, you might be able to use that piece you borrowed, but they'd better show what goes under it. Same with steel breastplates for women, with molded boob shapes - there's so much padding under that, there's no need to make it look "womanly"
Load More Replies...The one movie that gets a pass for the open mold cast is LOTR, because those swords being just mass-produced pieces of c**p is kind of the whole point of that scene.
I've been binge-watching Forged in Fire, and it's really interesting to see how powerful so e of those ancient swords were, in spite of weighing only a few pounds.
Wielding a gladius. These are very heavy short swords used for punching through armour, between shields in close quarter battles. When an army is tightly packed behind shields, if you wield a sword, you'll more than likely hit one of your own side.
Someone watched the moulding of the Oathkeeper (or was it Oathbreaker?) in GoT with my exact thoughts
I think they were Oathkeeper and Widow Maker (or might have been Widow's Bane).
Load More Replies...
When their stories only include the famous landmarks of a city. For instance, if the story takesChicago and the only locations the characters visit are Wrigley Field or the Chicago River, or they just generically call downtown "The Loop," as in one character says to the other, "Fine, meet me in the Loop.." WHERE IN THE LOOP???
This holds true for every other major city as well that is the backdrop of a book.
The landmarks I can understand. Someone reading a book about, say England, would more likely recognize landmarks like Buckingham Palace, Big Ben, St. Paul's Cathedral, etc. Than places like Liberty or Greggs if they've not been there before. It helps the reader "visualize" a location using familiarity.
I remember a movie set in London when two characters walk by the Big Ben, Trafalgar Square and St. Paul's Cathedral in the space of a single conversation, and me saying "oh, wow, those places must be really close to each other." Turns out they are not...
Load More Replies...Robert B. Parker (RIP), who wrote the series of Spenser detective novels, describes Boston (MA) in such intricate and accurate details that I felt like I already knew my way around the city the first time I visited just by reading his novels. He also is accurate in the small details, such as having Spenser walk to most locations, since downtown Boston is a fairly walkable city. When he does have to drive, he will talk about it being a minor miracle finding a parking spot, or the difficulty in tailing someone when you have to u-turn on a one way street. Parker was well known for doing extensive research and even visiting any locations he planned to write about to ensure accuracy.
Every monster & villain that ever comes here to San Francisco seems to be bent on destroying the Golden Gate Bridge. (We don't mind, but it costs us a fortune to rebuild it every time.)
also "Can I get a beer?" and immediately getting a drink. uhhh, what kind? there are several types and brands. I don't want an IPA, it tastes like pine tree.
I love Ben Aaronovichs descriptions of London. He may not be the best in writing people, but I have the feeling, I would know a lot more a out London, if I'm going to visit, than having not read the books.
Once I read a book where one of the MCs could draw really well and wanted to study at the academy of fine arts. She took drawing classes before she applied and was praised for her talent there, but the teacher showed her that there are more kinds of pencil than a HB. So you mean to tell me you’ve been drawing your whole life and you just learned that? And she did get accepted to the academy if i remember correctly, which is a very hard thing to do.
In the same series there was an article about a woman with an eating disorder and they said something like “at 13, she weighed 50kg (110lbs), which is way too much for a 13 year old”. Excuse me? No it’s not? Funny thing is I read it at 13 with an eating disorder, weighing 50kg and at that time people would ask me if my parents gave me food at all lmao
Edit: i hate to say it guys but the author is a woman. It seemed like she actually did some impressive research on eating disorders but that line shouldn’t be there
Edit2: actually i remembered another crazy thing she wrote about eating disorders, one of the mcs had ed and she would always judge other women who were fatter than her. i won’t speak for everyone with an ed but yeah, we don’t do that.
I am an artist from a super poor family growing up and I was also around 12-13 when someone finally introduced the 2, 4 & 8B pencil to me 😂 it happens
I didn’t discover them until I was 16 and I’ve been into art basically forever 😂
Load More Replies...That is a stupid line, not just because of the link to eating disorders. No one child is a standard weight. It depends on your genetics, athleticism, medical conditions and other things. For me at 13, 50kgs would have been over weight, because I was very short and an active kid, and my family was naturally small built. I didn't weigh over 50kg until I was at least 17, which really annoyed me at the time, because it meant I couldn't donate blood when I turned 16. My sister had adhd on top of the things I was dealing with, so she was even more active and her meds surpressed her appetite, so she weighed even less, being in the lowest percentile for weight most of her childhood which meant she had to drink Sustagen to make sure she was at least getting all the needed vitamins. No wonder young people get insecure about their bodies when there are blanket statements in books about the 'correct' weight, height, skintone etc.
True. I'm having 3 kids on 15/16/18. Neither one of them is anywhere near 50 kilos. The oldest one is 40 kilos and not too thin.
Load More Replies...I read this book where this guy, the main character, was somehow really great at painting. The author kept describing his “finely muscled painter’s hand” or whatever, and I had to snort each time it happened. Because, I myself paint and my dominant hand looks just the same as my other, I don’t have any fine muscles or whatever, painting doesn’t do as much for your hand as this author thinks it does. Plus, she kept describing this sudden, fiery urge to paint where that guy would leap up the stairs and head to his studio and immediately begin dumping paint on his canvas. If you’re really crazy good at art, I guess you can create wonderful art from seemingly chaotic strokes. But, for 90% of us, that’s not how art works; it’s usually a big commitment that requires you to sit down and plan it out first, and then carefully begun painting. Anyway, I don’t think that author knew much about art.
I have a good set of drawing pencils, but usually prefer to use an HB as I find it very versatile. Not for everything of course, but it's the pencil I go back to.
Just because someone is great at art doesn't mean they're knowledge about all art supplies, and everything to do with art. That was a gripe I had with everyone in school. It was assumed that because I enjoyed drawing and was decently good at it, I must be good at all mediums.
It would depend on their height, metabolism and BMI. I, too, was 105-110 at 13-16. I wasn't average weight, slightly under but I was also 5'4 and had a slender, narrow, dancer's body. I never had an eating disorder. Actually, I loved food and snacked as much as I could. Ate hearty dinners. But someone else at 13 weighing 110lbs could be severely underweight and malnourished if they aren't eating enough. The opposite could be true, too, to someone else.
Weather, specifically severe storms and tornadoes, is so easy to get right with even surface level research that it makes me want to tear my hair out. Some more egregious examples include: Issuing tornado warnings before the storm has even formed (that's what a watch is for), giving tornado ratings before the tornado forms or while it is on the ground (we can now kinda ballpark it with radar, but all ratings are done post event), tornadoes having a calm center "eye" like a hurricane (It's a giant blender full of debris, and even if it did have an "eye" they move too fast), just to name a few.
On the other hand, those kinds of inaccuracies did drive me into writing because I figured out I could write better tornado stories than that, so I guess it worked out in the end.
I watched "Twisters", and the most realistic part was where the heroes had to go and TELL people to take shelter while they milled around like idiots. Friend in Texas confirmed that this is exactly what happens and that some people will respond to a tornado warning BY GOING OUTSIDE TO WATCH.
My relatives in South Dakota go outside when the sirens go off. Bizarre
Load More Replies...Tornado scales are based on the damage done. For instance you could have a very wide tornado go through an open grassy area and since it did very little damage to man made structures it will have a lower rating than a smaller one that tracks through a neighborhood. They will issue an alert like a day sometimes two before when they see conditions shaping up to be favorable for tornado formation. I live in Oklahoma and boy do they get people stirred up about conditions being favorable a few days before the storm occurs.
Lots of people mix up what kids can do at different stages
Barring any disability or circumstantial factors:
A 1yo should be able to walk and say a few words
A 2yo can run, kick things, climb around, go up and down the stairs, and speak in 2-3 word sentences
A 3yo can ride a tricycle
A 4yo should be able to hop on one foot and start knowing the alphabet
A 5yo can skip, somersault, read, count, ride a bike (with or without training wheels), and climb bigger things—and also speak in complete and grammatically correct sentences
(also by 10-11, a child's speech is pretty much the same as adults).
No, even if there is no delay or disability, a 5 year old shouldn't automatically be able to read. That's what school is for, to teach them (assuming children start formal school at about 5, not all countries are the same). This is a myth that makes parents and children feel bad a lot. Preschools should follow the child's interests, so if they want to learn the alphabet, form letters, read words, count above 10, they can be given those challenges, but if they don't show an interest they should not be forced to. 'School readiness' isn't being able to read, write and count, it's actually being able to hold a pencil, hold scissors, sit for 5-10 minutes and focus on a group activity/story.
OP did not say 'has to be able to' but 'can'. So a 5 year old is absolutely able to learn to read. That does not mean they MUST learn it.
Load More Replies...I still can't ride a bike...then again I've got goodness-knows-how-many different conditions. At least they didn't include 'doesn't regularly run into stuff' as a criterion.
Put me on a stationary exercise bike, perfectly fine. Moving bike not going anywhere at all!
Load More Replies...Child development, particularly language development, is MUCH more varied than this list suggests. Between 18-24 months many children have a vocabulary sport and can add 10-20 words per day to their vocabulary. Some two year olds are producing sentences that are much more complex than 2-3 words, and some aren't speaking much at all yet. That doesn't mean they don't know the words. An assessment by a speech pathologist would be a good idea, but chances are good that the child will end up with normal language skills.
My son only knew 1 word at 2 years. Duck. He was delayed. But we put him in speech therapy and he caught up in a couple of months. Ends up we were just getting everything for him without making him talk. Once we put stuff out of reach and he had to make the first sound to get it, he started talking. There's a great deal of variability in development. As long as everyone's moving forward things are hopeful.
Load More Replies...No, a kid will do it when they do it. Girls tend to speak earlier and better than boys, but not by much. Your scale is a vague guideline.
I couldn't walk until I was 17 months old, and according to my parents I genuinely ran before I could walk, the first instance being after an operation through the hospital corridors and almost out into the active ambulance bay. By the time I was 3 I could read and understand things at a level most secondary/high school kids were only just learning themselves, and by the time I started primary/elementary school I was a very nerdy little dude. Yes I'm bragging but my bullies made sure I didn't let it go to my head, so now I'm a very introverted nerdy little dude. Go me!
If you ever read Calvin and Hoppe, Calvin has a vocabulary and philosophical way beyond and his years.
Divisions > Brigades > Battalions > Companies > Platoons > Sections/Squads
You can immediately resolve this with a 10 second google search.
Also, an infantry section or squad has around 8 guys in it, not 3 or 4. We can thank the *Battlefield* games for that misunderstanding, I think.
This is entirely dependent on the country whose army the game is portraying. British Infantry battalions can have sqads of 4, consisting of two 2 man fire teams.
It's not even country dependent - it's specific military dependent. For example the standard US Marine infantry rifle squad and the standard US Army infantry rifle squad are different sizes and have different equipment loadouts. This, in turn, effects the relative sizes of their respective platoons - companies - battalions.
Load More Replies...Military organisational levels and sizes is actually country-dependent, and not uniform throughout the world. Depending on the country's military doctrine and even the branch of the military in question, a "squad" can consist of between 4 and 12 members, platoons can be between 14 and 50, and so on.
Exactly what I thought - different countries have different definitions for their military personnel.
Load More Replies...On a side note, it drives me crazy when they refer to an individual soldier as a "troop". I'm not even saying it's incorrect. Language evolves. Might just be a pet peeve of mine. But at least up until recently, a "troop" was a group of people. ("I followed the troop of survivalists through the woods.") But even from reputable media sources, they will refer to a single person as a troop, as in "7 US troops hurt in raid", meaning 7 people. But in my head, I'm wondering, "Okay, how many people were in each of those 7 troops?" Drives me batty.
the US Army cavalry units generally do refer to their soldiers as troop or trooper. It's a tradition. Especially when your sergeant is mad at you and utters those fateful words - "Get your @$$ over here trooper!"
Load More Replies...The notion of "squads" having four likely goes back to the 1990s when LANs and networked gaming was limited to four people (e.g. DOOM).
Part of _Station Eleven_ takes place in an abandoned airport with an airplane chilling on runway 37. Runways only go up to 36.
Because they're just named for the direction they face (divided by ten) and there are only 360 degrees in a circle.
I've had flight simulator training, and they never mentioned that. Thank you for the information.
Load More Replies...Honestly if I was writing an airport scene I might add in a runway 37 just as a little joke to see if anyone was paying attention 😂
Load More Replies...Why do you think the airport was abandoned? The world is not ready for runway 37. Yet. (j/k)
We are talking about "Station Eleven", so suspension of disbelief.
Load More Replies...What bothered me about this book was that the only characters who went back to their old professions after the flu were artists and actors. Like sure, no one who knew how to operate a power plant or run a hospital felt like going back to their profession, because only artists truly are called to their work? GTFO.
Tbf most people probably wouldn't even consider that there might be a number limit on runways that they SHOULD look up.
I am not comfortable with calling medicine "my field" yet but anything involving cpr or defibrillators. CPRs may break ribs, and last up to an hour until professional help comes.
Also as of lately, epigenetics become the "quantum" of human biology by that I mean how it is used in a manner in worldbuilding and fiction completely detached from how it actually works.
This person's heart has stopped due to drowning! Quick, put them in the bottom of the boat in a pool of salt water we are all standing in and then hit them with electricity! - a certain tv show about pretty but not very bright life guards in red
At least one of the lifeguards made 2 very good points
Load More Replies...The CPR thing drives me insane. They'll do CPR for like 30 seconds, and when the person's heart doesn't start up again, they're like "Well, they're dead," and stop CPR, even though the ambulance is still on its way! You do CPR to keep the brain oxygenated until help arrives, not to restart a stopped heart. I heard a podcast recently about a woman who had just had major surgery and did CPR on her husband ON A BED for around 10 minutes, which is nearly impossible. And help did arrive and he survived and is doing well! No apparent brain damage!
I was going to say CPR on a bed or soft furniture is pointless.
Load More Replies...My favorite was that one movie, Mission to Mars I think? Where they go inside the face on Mars. One scene, they have analyzed DNA, and the screen shows the characters like a 5 nucleotide sequence of 3D DNA...they immediately declare "that's human DNA!". Dude, even if you memorize the entire genome in your head, you still can't tell what kind of being today it is from five nucleotides.
That second sentence was absolute gibberish to me and, I'm sure, most others.
They mean that the term "epigenetics," which is a real and complicated thing in genetics, is being used in science fiction to mean, essentially, "magic/stuff we just made up," similarly to how "quantum," which is a real and complicated thing in physics, is used in sci-fi.
Load More Replies...Also CPR doesn't usually restart the heart , it just keeps it alive long enough to get a defibrillator to them by simulating the breathing process. There are obviously situations like in drowning where it does work but in the majority of cases it doesn't
Tazers rendering people unconscious. I worked on a project where people were being trained on the use of tasers. I'm no expert, but I learned enough to be annoyed with the trope of them knocking people out.
Depictions of kink. I write erotica specifically around a few specific, less run-of-the-mill kinks, and a LOT of authors get the kink lifestyle very wrong.
You can knock people out with tasers, but those strong enough to do that can't be commercially bought and demand a license. The police usually have them.
You can knock somebody out with any taser if you hit them on the head hard enough with it.
Load More Replies...Also, if you hug a person and taser her/him, you taser yourself too. Seen many times in movies, so not related to books. Annoys me every time i see it
Only if you're making skin-to-skin contact, otherwise your clothes will insulate you from the electric current.
Load More Replies...So, the kink lifestyle comes with a rule book and everyone behaves the same regardless of their own personality? Ummm
Used in this context, lifestyle means a shared community of people who have somewhat similar interests/needs. There *are* some fundamental rules, yes, and people who don’t comply with those rules are shut/shoved out of the community at large. Consent, respect (outside of the scene if humiliation is the kink), no life threatening harm, and a safe word are the basic minimum. Not everyone wants to wield a whip or be dominated but you’re confusing kink preferences with an uncontrolled free for all, which kinda demonstrates OPs point. Authors get it regularly wrong because they’re clueless.
Load More Replies...Tasers have a better chance of setting someone on fire than rendering them unconscious. Most cases of people going unconscious is due to heart attacks because the cop using the taser is torturing the victim.
Largely. But most fiction gets it really wrong. Have a read on how 50 shades of grey gets it so wrong
Load More Replies...
99% of poker scenes in books, movies, TV. too many wrong depictions to count, some very technical, but one-in-a-million hands, mischaracterizing what makes a great player and betting more than is allowed are the most common ones.
out of context philosophical statements to pretty up an authors manuscript who woefully misunderstood the concept.
every decorative german basically being from bavaria (in serious media, comedy is whatever).
A German you use to decorate your house with, obviously
Load More Replies...I know of someone who had to wear lederhosen on his Berlin stag do. It didnt go down very well with the locals. It's not a national dress in Germany.
I hate it when people in movies or shows are playing Texas Hold 'Em and go all in by shoving their chips in a messy heap to comingle with the main pot. Like, no, hold on, that needs to be able to be counted. And what if your opponent doesn't call? It's called "splashing the pot" and is a big no no.
When I read that someone is going "free climbing," 9 times out of 10 the author means to say that the person is going free *soloing.*
I go free climbing all the time. So many people do. Free climbing includes pretty much all of what we think of as recreational rock climbing, using ropes, carabiners, harnesses, etc. Free *soloing* means walking up to the wall and climbing with no safety gear of any kind. Soloing is inherently risky.
Also for some reason when I point this out, I invariably get harassed for it, as though my niche sport/interest doesn't rise to the level where we would expect an author to get it right. Drives me CRAZY.
**Author**: My [cool] character goes FREE CLIMBING and look how [cool] she is
**Me**: Oh nice, free climbing is great. A quiet afternoon at the crags with friends enjoying nature. Sounds lovely. Let's bring the kids.
Meh. " as though my niche sport/interest doesn't rise to the level where we would expect an author to get it right. " Yupp, that pretty much defines it. they don't care, and even if you point it out you'll just be labelled as pointlessly pedantic
Pedantry is my favorite sport but authors never get it quite right.
Load More Replies...Literally didn't know the difference until now! I've always assumed "free climbing" was climbing without gear, as in "free of all gear". I've never heard the term "soloing" before. I would have assumed it just meant you were going climbing alone, with or without gear.
Exactly, yeah. I think people who make these kinds of nitpicks don't think about the fact that authors want their story to make sense to readers who aren't involved in whatever niche hobby the characters are doing, and they don't want to stop the story in its tracks for a vocabulary lesson. (And, of course, they don't think of this because they are not involved in the relatively niche activity of fiction writing, so here we are back around where we started.)
Load More Replies...I had someone beta read my book where I had someone make a primitive parachute using old diagrams and jump off a cliff with it. She pointed out what was wrong in my drop and how I was "controlling" it. So, I fixed it.
LOL, If you think Climbing gets it wrong. Sailing takes the cake. OMG they get everything wrong, every single time... No boats do not go directly into the wind No matter the camera angle.... The Womper would not do what they said it did... No Kevin Costner could not have run that boat by himself... It is really sad that the Maelstrom scene in Pirates is one of the best, well sorta kinda, no...
Any time a character on a horse “flicks” the reins to make it go.
I think this stereotype has been caused by this being portrayed in western. The actual way to make a trained horse walk is to gently nudge it in the sides with both of your feet once or twice. Horses are smart, they understand this signal.
Light squeeze and lean a bit forward. You control the horse best just by shifting your weight. Like, literally, one of my exercises was to put my hands on my head and still ride like normal. Walk, trot, canter, and small jumps. Look ma, no hands!
Load More Replies...Also the horribly exaggerated use of reins to guide horses. I hate to see actors literally sawing at the reins with both hands for dramatic effect, which is painful and abusive to the horse. I get that "acting" horses are trained differently, but I don't understand why it's allowed.
So that audiences can see what's happening. Controlling a horse in real life is way to subtle for film. That's also why they have to train the horses to tolerate it.
Load More Replies...I did trail riding years ago. Wagons, pulled by horses or mules, are common in trail rides. I heard a story of someone new to trail riding, and driving a wagon, who had recently bought a wagon and team of horses. He complained that they always ran away with him. He was asked to demonstrate. He climbed up in the wagon while his team patiently stood there. He grabbed the lines (reins), raised them up as high as he could, and slammed them down on the team while yelling, because that's what he'd seen in the movies. It's no wonder they ran away. The proper thing to do is just lightly flick the reins while speaking softly.
I hate the "hiya" I have never once heard anyone say "hiya" a tongue click or two... Maybe I'm wrong though
My mom did with her late horse if she wanted him to go faster than a walk. lol that horse hated to go any faster than a walk.
Load More Replies...
Guns. Wow, are guns so poorly understood by the media. Like seriously. I've seen guns being mislabbeled as completely different guns, semi-automatics being portrayed as fully automatic, constant serious gun safety violations (looking at you Baldwin), never seen a gun jam in a movie or show, and seen people taking rounds they shouldn't survive and being completely fine, etc etc. Not to mention supressors.
BP deciding to think of the children by showing us a picture of water pistols.
Don't you mean the 'gateway guns'????? Like the 'gateway d***s'.. :-)
Load More Replies...Shooting in confined spaces with zero hearing protection with no repercussions
In season 4 or 5 of CSI: Miami, Tim Speedle dies in a shootout because he didn't clean his gun properly (even after Horatio tells him to) and it jams during the firefight. I thought that was pretty accurate (if you ignore the whole thing about forensic technicians actually carrying guns and interrogating suspects).
"never seen a gun jam in a movie or show," - CSI Miami using it as a plot device to kill off a cast member. [ ........... ] "people taking rounds they shouldn't survive and being completely fine," - Compare that with "Ronin", where DeNiro's character Sam takes a bullet in the fleshy part of his abdomen (surface wound) and is barely able to function.
Anytime someone touches a handgun in a movie it sounds like rattling metal parts. They don't sound like that just being picked up or handed to someone. It's silent. You don't want loose parts in a gun.
On the other hand, look at "Romeo and Juliette" with Leonardo di Caprio. The text is the original Shakespeare, but with modern settings. They clearly show the handgun carrying the engraving "Sword 9mm" and the rifle "Longsword 0.303"
Also the lack of trigger discipline in trained soldiers. Now I've only done target and clay shooting, but even with me trigger discipline is something I do without thinking. So would a soldier, or anyone properly trained with firearms.
"Fingers off the trigger" didn't become commonplace until the 1970s what does look odd is a movie set in say WW2 where soldiers DO have fingers off triggers. Oh, and firing a Sten gun while holding the magazine - shame on you David Niven (Guns of Naverone) and Richard Todd (The Longest Day) you BOTH used them for real in WW2 you should have known better!
Load More Replies...the movie "Open Range" had people getting shot, getting patched by the doctor, and almost normal in a week or less. In the 1880s. Gut shots with no antibiotics or even surgeries to fix it.
Let's add random people being able to hit somebody with a handgun at 20 feet, people flying backwards when hit by a rifle bullet, people not using the sights correctly, never-ending magazines, silencers that somehow hide the sound of the mechanism of an pistol, etc, etc, etc.
There's countless examples of video games being portrayed really weirdly in media, particularly television. I immediately think of some kid wildly waving like a Super Nintendo controller around while playing some modern generic royalty-free Call of Duty clone.
It was worse in the 90s. They had actors using NES controllers and the sounds were clearly Atari 2600 games. TV seems to consistently be as wrong as possible about video games.
One time I was watching this show and either the dad or the kid ask the other one if they wanted to be his wingman. The game they were playing was Starfox. That is a one player game.
the 2 kids playing playing FF8 as if it was multiplayer in charlies angels
As a scientist, units are often a dead giveaway. Often, they pick a unit that sounds impressive, but is really small, and describe something that's enormous with a unit more appropriate for a crumpled up piece of paper or a lighter.
Colours in labs more specifically. Hate to disappoint, but 98% of lab liquids are transparent. Except for maaybe an analytics lab, where the reagents can be coloured
Load More Replies..."Scientists" who practise "science" by attempting to prove an existing assumption and ignoring any evidence that doesn't fit that assumption. That's pseudoscience and no actual scientist would behave like that, but I've seen it in at least one novel.
"You've never heard of the Millennium Falcon?…It's the ship that made the Kessel Run in less than twelve parsecs." ―Han Solo
Thank you, I came here to say just that. I've heard so many Star Wars fans over the years try to rationalize why Han Solo would use a measure of distance instead of time--but, no, sorry--Lucas just didn't know what the H*ll he was talking about.
Load More Replies..."one point twenty-one jiggawatts". He even got the concept of numbering wrong.
Not a book but a video game.
I love Detroit Become Human but living in Detroit myself I noticed some things.
-They call the People Mover the tram. No one in Detroit will call it that.
-The hyperfixation on poverty porn in the game. Even in the downtown and nice areas of the city you’re really not going to see rundown houses in Downtown anymore as it looks like nice and gentrified around the collages.
-The severe lack of npcs trying to get you to buy their mixtape as they tell you they’re going to be the next Eminem.
The volume of male writers getting female anatomy wrong is staggering. And hilarious. I highly recommend looking it up. Everything from thinking women have a tamper evident seal and have no vaginal opening as a virgin, to breasts having personality, to one describing keeping a tiny purse in a vagina. It is friggin hilarious. You can't help but think 'oh bud, no real relationships yet huh'. Except one of the offenders is Stephen King, which is just baffling.
When complaining about this issue (totally rightly btw) you're contractually obligated to quote "She breasted boobily to the stairs and titted downwards." Sorry I don't make the rules.
Load More Replies...In apocalypse type books, when they write that societies will "revert" back to women being treated as subservient and inferior, as if that's the norm, when in fact, it's a fairly recent development for humans (as far as we know), and is getting worse on average every century for a while now. Look at the perverted Taliban treating every woman in the country as a sex object they own. That's not normal. And if societies broke up into hunter-gatherer societies, small nomadic bands, or sustenance farming, they would very, very, very likely revert to the types of societies that form with those economies, which is largely egalitarian.
Hmmm. Interesting. Very good point. Some of the older civilizations were matrilineal societies. And there are still cultures around today...
Load More Replies...Something so obvious and so stupid. "By the light of the new moon". I don't know if I should laugh or scream.
they also shouldn't bleed, since their hearts aren't beating....
Load More Replies...In astrophysics: showing the moon at vastly more than its normal size (which is about the width of the thumb at arm's length); showing moons and planets so close to other planets that they would collide; showing closely packed asteroid fields (in our asteroid belt, the gaps between objects are at least 500 miles); showing sandstorms on planets with hardly any atmosphere (eg Mars).
Mars has huge dust storms covering areas the size of continents and lasting for weeks at a time.
Load More Replies...A baby that never cries or needs a nappy change and doesn't need to be fed every few hours and is instead basically just a cute little doll. And also it only took about ten minutes to be born and the mother doesn't need to spend any time recovering.
Bonus points if she drifts ethereally around wearing a white dress in the postpartum period.
Load More Replies...Mine is the heart monitor "pull the plug". All that does is... you guessed it, monitor the heart. It is not what is keeping them alive...
Also that the family make the decision about when to turn off life support. In the UK at least the final decision is made by the medical staff, but the gentle discussion with family is to make sure that the family is in agreement. If not, then the situation needs to be explored further.
Load More Replies...In a very popular book from decades ago, A Woman Of Substance, the author says the main characters twins, a boy and a girl, are identical, you know, because they're twins.
In the book "Pride and Prejudice and Zombies" they walked past a pond with "coy" fish. I'm still mad about it.
But the fish would have to be coy in those days, or demure at the very least 😂
Load More Replies...CHESS: If you're going to use it as a plot device, please know how chess works. More often than not, the board is turned the wrong way. Also: Person A: "Check" Person B, grinning: "Checkmate". While this isn't impossible, it is EXTREMELY unlikely. Like winning the Mega Millions while getting struck by lightning rare.
Queen's Gambit did a better job than usual, the Russian conceding after a certain position, not a check. That's far more likely.
Load More Replies...The volume of male writers getting female anatomy wrong is staggering. And hilarious. I highly recommend looking it up. Everything from thinking women have a tamper evident seal and have no vaginal opening as a virgin, to breasts having personality, to one describing keeping a tiny purse in a vagina. It is friggin hilarious. You can't help but think 'oh bud, no real relationships yet huh'. Except one of the offenders is Stephen King, which is just baffling.
When complaining about this issue (totally rightly btw) you're contractually obligated to quote "She breasted boobily to the stairs and titted downwards." Sorry I don't make the rules.
Load More Replies...In apocalypse type books, when they write that societies will "revert" back to women being treated as subservient and inferior, as if that's the norm, when in fact, it's a fairly recent development for humans (as far as we know), and is getting worse on average every century for a while now. Look at the perverted Taliban treating every woman in the country as a sex object they own. That's not normal. And if societies broke up into hunter-gatherer societies, small nomadic bands, or sustenance farming, they would very, very, very likely revert to the types of societies that form with those economies, which is largely egalitarian.
Hmmm. Interesting. Very good point. Some of the older civilizations were matrilineal societies. And there are still cultures around today...
Load More Replies...Something so obvious and so stupid. "By the light of the new moon". I don't know if I should laugh or scream.
they also shouldn't bleed, since their hearts aren't beating....
Load More Replies...In astrophysics: showing the moon at vastly more than its normal size (which is about the width of the thumb at arm's length); showing moons and planets so close to other planets that they would collide; showing closely packed asteroid fields (in our asteroid belt, the gaps between objects are at least 500 miles); showing sandstorms on planets with hardly any atmosphere (eg Mars).
Mars has huge dust storms covering areas the size of continents and lasting for weeks at a time.
Load More Replies...A baby that never cries or needs a nappy change and doesn't need to be fed every few hours and is instead basically just a cute little doll. And also it only took about ten minutes to be born and the mother doesn't need to spend any time recovering.
Bonus points if she drifts ethereally around wearing a white dress in the postpartum period.
Load More Replies...Mine is the heart monitor "pull the plug". All that does is... you guessed it, monitor the heart. It is not what is keeping them alive...
Also that the family make the decision about when to turn off life support. In the UK at least the final decision is made by the medical staff, but the gentle discussion with family is to make sure that the family is in agreement. If not, then the situation needs to be explored further.
Load More Replies...In a very popular book from decades ago, A Woman Of Substance, the author says the main characters twins, a boy and a girl, are identical, you know, because they're twins.
In the book "Pride and Prejudice and Zombies" they walked past a pond with "coy" fish. I'm still mad about it.
But the fish would have to be coy in those days, or demure at the very least 😂
Load More Replies...CHESS: If you're going to use it as a plot device, please know how chess works. More often than not, the board is turned the wrong way. Also: Person A: "Check" Person B, grinning: "Checkmate". While this isn't impossible, it is EXTREMELY unlikely. Like winning the Mega Millions while getting struck by lightning rare.
Queen's Gambit did a better job than usual, the Russian conceding after a certain position, not a check. That's far more likely.
Load More Replies...
