Doctor Shocked At Insurance Company’s Audacity: “Do You Understand She Has Breast Cancer?”
Health insurance is a very sensitive subject in the United States. Recently, the topic has been in the public eye more than probably ever before. The core problem is that many Americans feel that they pay a lot of money for insurance, but in some cases, their insurers go to extreme lengths to try to deny them coverage when they need healthcare.
The internet is applauding a Texas-based doctor who publicly called out UnitedHealthcare. In a massively viral video on TikTok, Dr. Elisabeth Potter claimed that she had to stop mid-surgery to take a call, during which she was told to urgently contact the company. An insurance employee then asked for information about a patient’s diagnosis while she was on the operating table. The employee was trying to determine whether the person’s inpatient stay should be justified. Read on for the full story.
Bored Panda has reached out to Dr. Potter via email for further comment, and we’ll update the article as soon as we hear back from her.
More info: TikTok | Instagram | Facebook | Website
A doctor made a huge splash on the internet after calling out an insurance company which interrupted her in the middle of surgery
Image credits: Getty Images / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Dr. Potter, who works in Austin, Texas, was appalled by the entire situation and posted a video about it on TikTok
“It’s 2025, and insurance just keeps getting worse.”
Image credits: drelisabethpotter
“I just did two bilateral DIEPs and two bilateral tissue expanders for patients, and I’ve never had this happen before. During the second DIEP, I got a phone call into the operating room saying that United Healthcare wanted me to call them about one of the patients who was having surgery today, who was actually asleep having surgery. They said I had to call right now. So I scrubbed out of my case, and I called United Healthcare, and the gentleman said he needed some information about her.”
Image credits: drelisabethpotter
“He wants to know her diagnosis and whether her impatience day should be justified. And I was like, do you understand that she’s asleep right now and she has breast cancer? And the gentleman said, actually, I don’t. That’s a different department that would know that information.”
Image credits: drelisabethpotter
“And I was like, well, she does need to stay overnight tonight. You have all the information with you, because I got approval for this surgery, and I need to go back and be with my patient now.
It’s out of control. Insurance is out of control. I have no other words.”
You can watch the full viral video right here
@drelisabethpotterIt’s 2025, and navigating insurance has somehow gotten even more out of control… I just performed two bilateral DIEP flap surgeries and two bilateral tissue expander surgeries. During one of the DIEP cases, I was interrupted by a call from United Healthcare—while the patient was already asleep on the operating table. They demanded information about her diagnosis and inpatient stay justification. I had to scrub out mid-surgery to call United, only to find that the person on the line didn’t even have access to the patient’s full medical information, despite the procedure already being pre-approved. It’s beyond frustrating and, frankly, unacceptable. Patients and providers deserve better than this. We should be focused on care, not bureaucracy. I just have no other words at this point♬ original sound – Dr. Elisabeth Potter
Image credits: Chad Davis (not the actual photo)
The company that the doctor called out is one of the most powerful businesses in the entire world
Dr. Potter has gone viral on TikTok, social media, and in the media after calling out UnitedHealthcare for interrupting an important operation. Not only did the company allegedly dispute the patient’s care while she was in surgery, but the insurance representative also did not have access to the patient’s medical history.
UnitedHealth Group Incorporated is a US multinational for-profit company that specializes in health insurance and health care services. It sells insurance products under UnitedHealthcare. Meanwhile, it also sells healthcare services under the Optum brand. It is the world’s largest healthcare company in terms of revenue.
The group had a revenue of $371.6 billion in 2023, an operating income of $32.36 billion, a net income of $23.14 billion, and assets worth $273.7 billion.
At the time of writing, UnitedHealth Group ranked 8th on the 2024 Fortune Global 500 list, with a market capitalization of $460.3 billion as of December 20, 2024.
Dr. Potter is an Austin, Texas-based board-certified plastic surgeon and DIEP (deep inferior epigastric perforator) specialist. She has a large following of 28.9k people on TikTok and 31.3k on Instagram.
Her video on TikTok, where she explained what happened with the insurance company and her patient, currently has over 4.6 million views and counting. Meanwhile, the doctor also shared two follow-up videos on the topic, in which she gave a couple of updates.
UnitedHealthcare told the Daily Mail that Dr. Potter’s claims are supposedly unconfirmed. “There are no insurance related circumstances that would require a physician to step out of surgery and it would create potential safety risks if they were to do so,” a representative of the company told the outlet.
“We did not ask nor would ever expect a physician to interrupt patient care to answer a call, and we will be following up with the provider and hospital to understand why these unorthodox actions were taken.”
Meanwhile, UnitedHealthcare shared the same response with the team at Newsweek, more or less word for word.
“The trend is disturbing. There is no room in healthcare where the pressure of insurance isn’t felt by both patients and doctors. Not even the operating room. When will we say enough is enough and push back? I’d say now. This is already out of hand,” Dr. Potter told Newsweek via email.
Image credits: Andrea Piacquadio / Pexels (not the actual photo)
There appears to be a huge lack of trust between patients and health insurance companies. There’s a lot of tension
Finance expert Michael Ryan explained to Newsweek that insurance companies can sometimes employ so-called attrition strategies, which are “a calculated approach where administrative hurdles serve as profit protection mechanisms.”
Ryan states from his experience that “if even 30% of patients give up on pursuing care due to delays and denials, that translates to hundreds of millions in preserved capital for the insurer.”
Meanwhile, financial literacy instructor Alex Beene, from the Univesity of Tennessee, told Newsweek that whether or not that call was necessary, these situations are why public relations are so strained between the public and health insurance providers.
“Individuals pay a good portion of their earnings over their lives for coverage for their families and themselves, only to discover when they actually need to utilize that insurance, they are denied the ability to do so,” Beene said.
“No one expected businesses like UnitedHealthcare to completely change overnight, but there does need to be a better understanding of the policies and procedures that go into accepting or denying a claim. If all that’s known is that the claim is denied and transparency continues to be elusive, it’s going to bring more resentment to an industry that can’t afford much more.”
Meanwhile, founder and CEO of Ansel Health, Veer Gidwaney, told Newsweek that health insurance companies “often take actions such as this to manage costs.” However, Gidwaney stressed that expenses should never come at the expense of patient safety.
What do you think about the entire situation, dear Pandas? What would you have done if you were in Dr. Potter’s shoes? Have you ever had any issues with your health insurance or major problems with your health? What do you think US companies could do to fundamentally reform their approach to business and coverage? Let us know in the comments.
Here’s how some people reacted to the doctor’s story as it started spreading across the net
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
When the doctor was told that the insurance company said they had to talk to her "right now", she should have just replied "The hell they do" and kept caring for her patient. That's the only kind of language they understand.
Except that I'd she hadn't returned their call right away they might have just gone ahead and denied the claim and the patient would be billed for that inpatient stay.
Load More Replies...I’d like to see The Running man (book version) with CEO’s as the runners and the bereft families and patients that were denied care as the hunters. Or something like Saw. That would be good too.
Load More Replies...One day at work one of the lawyers comes in ranting and raving, turned out his wife was getting wheeled into the operating theater, surgeons scrubbed, patient under anaesthetic, when UnitedHealth called and said they're now denying the procedure they previously approved. Surgery canceled, poor woman must've been livid when she woke up. Unbelievable. The company changed to Presbyterian 3months later, we had over 450 employees, UH had to eat that loss.
United Healthcare sucks. They have the highest rate of insurance denials in the country. They are the worst of the rest!!!
BCBS is just as bad. Hell, they all are. Don't get me started. I work claims for a lab, and the amount that come back denied for cancer tests are sickening. Keep screaming people, we can't be silent about this!!
Load More Replies...This will only get worse in the coming months. Republicans want to do away with the Affordable Care Act, Obama Care, where the insurance companies can deny insurance due to a previous condition. It will be horrible!
I'm terrified of this. My pre-existing conditions got me denied by every major insurance company, wasn't until Obama care (ACA) that I actually got insurance.
Load More Replies...that's America for you..care more about money and guns than people's lives
Unless it’s “unborn lives”. Then we care more than actual lives, either of the mother or once it is a “born life”. Then it’s on its own. We are completely and utterly broken.
Load More Replies...America: Land of the Free?? No, it is damned near impossible to live here, housing insurance groceries all are outrageously expensive and will get worse before it ever gets better. Home of the Brave?? Nope, Too many racist gullible dingbats were too afraid TWICE to vote for over qualified women so they elected an unqualified, narcissistic criminal TWICE. America is becoming a third world country in real time. America weeps, while the wealthy steal the facial tissues.
Only in America thank god I live in the uk ! It’s disgusting that this happens and expensive insurance you HAVE to pay for to been seen is a joke when soon as u need them they do this ! Well done doc keep it up this needs doing blessed be x
Since insurance gets to make our healthcare decisions can we sue them for malpractice?
I really hope the patient sued them for prolonging her anesthesia time
Load More Replies...A nation which values patriotism, yet is happy to see its people die rather than pay a bit of extra tax?
A land of the brave indeed. Those founders would be horrified to see it all given over to the endless greed of just a few handfuls of people.
Load More Replies...Becoming?! More like already is and gonna get a hell of a lot worse.
Load More Replies...Free Luigi so he can finish his job, because apparently one CEO wasn't enough
Remember when that hillbilly bimbo palin was banging on about, “death panels”? That’s literally what American insurance companies are. Non-medical phone operators going down a checklist looking for reasons to deny you life saving healthcare.
United Healthcare... Yep says enough. The same company who's ceo got murdered for their inhuman policies and the same company who doubled down on their deny system after that ceo got murdered. So yeah why am I not surprised? Everyone from that company deserves to rott in hell or have the same stuff happen to them when one of their close ones is suffering and all treatments get denied.
Very recently, another United Healthcare CEO, Andrew Witty, had this to say about the other CEO who was recently killed: "He devoted his time to helping make the health system work better for all of the people we’re privileged to serve." By the way, United Healthcare announced $14.5 billion in net profits last year alone. So, useless BS statements and no accountability whatsoever.
My mother had to have urgent bypass surgery after falling ill on her trip... The Canadian travel insurance company tried to get her shipped back to Canada so OHIP could pay for the surgery and recovery. The surgeon leading the cardiac team refused, saying my mother could very well die on the flight. The complete bill for everything involved in her operation and aftercare came to around €30,000.- The travel insurance company was fine with potentially causing my mother's death for that amount of payout. Health insurance companies(like every other kind) will resort to almost any tactic to avoid paying out on a policy...
It seems more CEO's need to be plugged with lead pellets in order to understand why one of them is now pushing up daisies. The greed is awful and health should never have been a for profit business. Off topic; You need colorful language to bypass the censorship these days.... Also another sign of the times!!
I would like to see more people like Luigi doing silly Luigi things to all members of United Healthcare management and ownership without discretion :)
As a Canadian, I'm familiar with our system's limitations, but these are not (in my view) related to the fact that it's single payer for medically necessary services. The reason why the US system spends so much money for such limited results is because a portion goes to insurance profits. The efficiency gains from going to single payer would be huge (no more doctors having to fight insurance, or chase down a patient's insurer), but it would even have an economic impact -- greater employee mobility, since people wouldn't be chained to their jobs to get mediocre private insurance. But blame the system, not the poor shmuck of an agent making an individual call.
Why BP asks from us to vote for the decision of the doctor to publish the BS of the insurance company? I would expect to ask our vote for the disgusting attitude of the company. Very lame attempt to move the focus off the important point.
I agree. UHC spokesperson blaming the doctor and claiming they want the hospital to investigate. If the doctor hadn't immediately gotten on the phone, UHC could have denied the surgery and the patients stay. The insurance companies hold doctors and patients hostage. Gaslighting the public to make us think the doctor (who obviously cares deeply for her patients) is in the wrong because their public image is already in the toilet and they know it. Just like the media wants us to believe Luigi Mangione is a danger to the public. I'm not an insurance millionaire, I don't have anything to fear from him.
Load More Replies...I agree with her assessment of the healthcare system, it does indeed suck. However, if I was the surgeon, there's no way in hell I'm going to scrub out of a procedure to speak to an insurance rep. F**k that!
Problem was that the patient would have been denied her recovery stay. Just because some corporate drone wanted to dot his i’s and feels empowered by how the us system works.
Load More Replies...I would like to see more people like Luigi taking hostile action against any/all United Healthcare management and shareholders without discretion :)
So the idiots at UHC put a patient under anesthesia at risk. A lawsuit waiting to happen.
The entire Health Insurance system should be eliminated. Instead, all that money that is paid into the insurance sector should go into a general fund that automatically pays the salaries of health care providers. And then all medical care should be automatically received as soon as it is prescribed by a doctor.
For-profit health care has got to be one of the cruelest modern forms of torture. Every other bloody country that is considered "developed" has universal health care. For-profit health care is just inviting corruption. Same with for-profit correctional systems. Neither of these situations should be permitted to line ANYONE'S pocket. The U.S. is just so completely cruel and clueless.
For-profit care delivery can work: for-profit health ***insurance*** is the problem. Private cataract surgeries here in Canada can deliver great results -- but they're paid a regulated amount from the provincial health insurance plan.
Load More Replies...When insurance companies dictate what treatment doctors can give based on algorithims that ensure maximum profitability, maybe we need to rethink the system!
She solved it, but the insurance bstrds having the gall to demand she stop surgery to talk to her is completely insane.
Rest of the world, especially that part with universal healthcare, beware. The US is pushing for all of you to adopt the horrible US model. They’ve almost succeeded in western Canada and UK.
The rest of the world erm I’m in uk we get FREE healthcare no insurance needed ! Ok we do pay for it but out of national insurance contributions and NEVER EVER do we get told sorry no we won’t do it or call docs outta surgery for it so I’ve also no idea where u get that idea from it’s free in uk unless your rich n can afford private but the rest of us live in the real world and why USA doesn’t adopt our way saddens me it’s so wrong your all held hostage over scum insurance companies
Load More Replies...Even though it was someone from the insurance co calling, since they didn't have access to the medical files, could it be considered a HIPPA violation?
America should be grovelling in shame at their healthcare situation. There is no excuse for this behaviour and money should not be a factor.
We've got this kind of stuff going on in the UK. First the last Govt, and our current one, is going hard on pushing for yet more private (American) health companies to tear apart our NHS, and head into us paying private insurance, while most likely still paying the original NHS taxes to the Govt. It's worse as they are also severely defunding the NHS (read: diverting our taxes that pay for it), and deflecting the blame onto the medical staff.
Erm nothing anywhere close to! N I’m 60 lol and from the uk n live here our surgeons don’t get called out in middle of cancer surgeries for s**t like that winge all you like but we have got it bloody good ! Healthcare wise
Load More Replies...I feel like the doctor was an idiot for answering them during surgery. It sounds like they were checking on a prior authorization, which is common for in-hospital stays. At least it was when I worked for an insurance company. The doctor's office should have gotten the prior authorization before the procedure. Patients can't because they don't have the needed, very detailed information these require. Even if the procedure has to be done before getting the authorization approved there's a process to get it after the fact. There's also a process in case the claim is denied, often involving doing the authorization process after the fact. If it's still the same a claim denied for no prior authorization is the provider's responsibility. Meaning she wouldn't get paid without appealing and she wouldn't be able to go after the patient for the money instead. This wouldn't fall under not covered by insurance because it is. The provider just failed to follow the correct process to get paid and that's not on the patient.
There's a difference between hating Americans and hating a thing that's in the US - that would be like saying that anyone who thinks London was a bad experience is UK-bashing
Load More Replies...Bullshіt. Give me one scenario where a healthcare institution earns more by kіlling a patient than by keeping them alive.
Load More Replies...When the doctor was told that the insurance company said they had to talk to her "right now", she should have just replied "The hell they do" and kept caring for her patient. That's the only kind of language they understand.
Except that I'd she hadn't returned their call right away they might have just gone ahead and denied the claim and the patient would be billed for that inpatient stay.
Load More Replies...I’d like to see The Running man (book version) with CEO’s as the runners and the bereft families and patients that were denied care as the hunters. Or something like Saw. That would be good too.
Load More Replies...One day at work one of the lawyers comes in ranting and raving, turned out his wife was getting wheeled into the operating theater, surgeons scrubbed, patient under anaesthetic, when UnitedHealth called and said they're now denying the procedure they previously approved. Surgery canceled, poor woman must've been livid when she woke up. Unbelievable. The company changed to Presbyterian 3months later, we had over 450 employees, UH had to eat that loss.
United Healthcare sucks. They have the highest rate of insurance denials in the country. They are the worst of the rest!!!
BCBS is just as bad. Hell, they all are. Don't get me started. I work claims for a lab, and the amount that come back denied for cancer tests are sickening. Keep screaming people, we can't be silent about this!!
Load More Replies...This will only get worse in the coming months. Republicans want to do away with the Affordable Care Act, Obama Care, where the insurance companies can deny insurance due to a previous condition. It will be horrible!
I'm terrified of this. My pre-existing conditions got me denied by every major insurance company, wasn't until Obama care (ACA) that I actually got insurance.
Load More Replies...that's America for you..care more about money and guns than people's lives
Unless it’s “unborn lives”. Then we care more than actual lives, either of the mother or once it is a “born life”. Then it’s on its own. We are completely and utterly broken.
Load More Replies...America: Land of the Free?? No, it is damned near impossible to live here, housing insurance groceries all are outrageously expensive and will get worse before it ever gets better. Home of the Brave?? Nope, Too many racist gullible dingbats were too afraid TWICE to vote for over qualified women so they elected an unqualified, narcissistic criminal TWICE. America is becoming a third world country in real time. America weeps, while the wealthy steal the facial tissues.
Only in America thank god I live in the uk ! It’s disgusting that this happens and expensive insurance you HAVE to pay for to been seen is a joke when soon as u need them they do this ! Well done doc keep it up this needs doing blessed be x
Since insurance gets to make our healthcare decisions can we sue them for malpractice?
I really hope the patient sued them for prolonging her anesthesia time
Load More Replies...A nation which values patriotism, yet is happy to see its people die rather than pay a bit of extra tax?
A land of the brave indeed. Those founders would be horrified to see it all given over to the endless greed of just a few handfuls of people.
Load More Replies...Becoming?! More like already is and gonna get a hell of a lot worse.
Load More Replies...Free Luigi so he can finish his job, because apparently one CEO wasn't enough
Remember when that hillbilly bimbo palin was banging on about, “death panels”? That’s literally what American insurance companies are. Non-medical phone operators going down a checklist looking for reasons to deny you life saving healthcare.
United Healthcare... Yep says enough. The same company who's ceo got murdered for their inhuman policies and the same company who doubled down on their deny system after that ceo got murdered. So yeah why am I not surprised? Everyone from that company deserves to rott in hell or have the same stuff happen to them when one of their close ones is suffering and all treatments get denied.
Very recently, another United Healthcare CEO, Andrew Witty, had this to say about the other CEO who was recently killed: "He devoted his time to helping make the health system work better for all of the people we’re privileged to serve." By the way, United Healthcare announced $14.5 billion in net profits last year alone. So, useless BS statements and no accountability whatsoever.
My mother had to have urgent bypass surgery after falling ill on her trip... The Canadian travel insurance company tried to get her shipped back to Canada so OHIP could pay for the surgery and recovery. The surgeon leading the cardiac team refused, saying my mother could very well die on the flight. The complete bill for everything involved in her operation and aftercare came to around €30,000.- The travel insurance company was fine with potentially causing my mother's death for that amount of payout. Health insurance companies(like every other kind) will resort to almost any tactic to avoid paying out on a policy...
It seems more CEO's need to be plugged with lead pellets in order to understand why one of them is now pushing up daisies. The greed is awful and health should never have been a for profit business. Off topic; You need colorful language to bypass the censorship these days.... Also another sign of the times!!
I would like to see more people like Luigi doing silly Luigi things to all members of United Healthcare management and ownership without discretion :)
As a Canadian, I'm familiar with our system's limitations, but these are not (in my view) related to the fact that it's single payer for medically necessary services. The reason why the US system spends so much money for such limited results is because a portion goes to insurance profits. The efficiency gains from going to single payer would be huge (no more doctors having to fight insurance, or chase down a patient's insurer), but it would even have an economic impact -- greater employee mobility, since people wouldn't be chained to their jobs to get mediocre private insurance. But blame the system, not the poor shmuck of an agent making an individual call.
Why BP asks from us to vote for the decision of the doctor to publish the BS of the insurance company? I would expect to ask our vote for the disgusting attitude of the company. Very lame attempt to move the focus off the important point.
I agree. UHC spokesperson blaming the doctor and claiming they want the hospital to investigate. If the doctor hadn't immediately gotten on the phone, UHC could have denied the surgery and the patients stay. The insurance companies hold doctors and patients hostage. Gaslighting the public to make us think the doctor (who obviously cares deeply for her patients) is in the wrong because their public image is already in the toilet and they know it. Just like the media wants us to believe Luigi Mangione is a danger to the public. I'm not an insurance millionaire, I don't have anything to fear from him.
Load More Replies...I agree with her assessment of the healthcare system, it does indeed suck. However, if I was the surgeon, there's no way in hell I'm going to scrub out of a procedure to speak to an insurance rep. F**k that!
Problem was that the patient would have been denied her recovery stay. Just because some corporate drone wanted to dot his i’s and feels empowered by how the us system works.
Load More Replies...I would like to see more people like Luigi taking hostile action against any/all United Healthcare management and shareholders without discretion :)
So the idiots at UHC put a patient under anesthesia at risk. A lawsuit waiting to happen.
The entire Health Insurance system should be eliminated. Instead, all that money that is paid into the insurance sector should go into a general fund that automatically pays the salaries of health care providers. And then all medical care should be automatically received as soon as it is prescribed by a doctor.
For-profit health care has got to be one of the cruelest modern forms of torture. Every other bloody country that is considered "developed" has universal health care. For-profit health care is just inviting corruption. Same with for-profit correctional systems. Neither of these situations should be permitted to line ANYONE'S pocket. The U.S. is just so completely cruel and clueless.
For-profit care delivery can work: for-profit health ***insurance*** is the problem. Private cataract surgeries here in Canada can deliver great results -- but they're paid a regulated amount from the provincial health insurance plan.
Load More Replies...When insurance companies dictate what treatment doctors can give based on algorithims that ensure maximum profitability, maybe we need to rethink the system!
She solved it, but the insurance bstrds having the gall to demand she stop surgery to talk to her is completely insane.
Rest of the world, especially that part with universal healthcare, beware. The US is pushing for all of you to adopt the horrible US model. They’ve almost succeeded in western Canada and UK.
The rest of the world erm I’m in uk we get FREE healthcare no insurance needed ! Ok we do pay for it but out of national insurance contributions and NEVER EVER do we get told sorry no we won’t do it or call docs outta surgery for it so I’ve also no idea where u get that idea from it’s free in uk unless your rich n can afford private but the rest of us live in the real world and why USA doesn’t adopt our way saddens me it’s so wrong your all held hostage over scum insurance companies
Load More Replies...Even though it was someone from the insurance co calling, since they didn't have access to the medical files, could it be considered a HIPPA violation?
America should be grovelling in shame at their healthcare situation. There is no excuse for this behaviour and money should not be a factor.
We've got this kind of stuff going on in the UK. First the last Govt, and our current one, is going hard on pushing for yet more private (American) health companies to tear apart our NHS, and head into us paying private insurance, while most likely still paying the original NHS taxes to the Govt. It's worse as they are also severely defunding the NHS (read: diverting our taxes that pay for it), and deflecting the blame onto the medical staff.
Erm nothing anywhere close to! N I’m 60 lol and from the uk n live here our surgeons don’t get called out in middle of cancer surgeries for s**t like that winge all you like but we have got it bloody good ! Healthcare wise
Load More Replies...I feel like the doctor was an idiot for answering them during surgery. It sounds like they were checking on a prior authorization, which is common for in-hospital stays. At least it was when I worked for an insurance company. The doctor's office should have gotten the prior authorization before the procedure. Patients can't because they don't have the needed, very detailed information these require. Even if the procedure has to be done before getting the authorization approved there's a process to get it after the fact. There's also a process in case the claim is denied, often involving doing the authorization process after the fact. If it's still the same a claim denied for no prior authorization is the provider's responsibility. Meaning she wouldn't get paid without appealing and she wouldn't be able to go after the patient for the money instead. This wouldn't fall under not covered by insurance because it is. The provider just failed to follow the correct process to get paid and that's not on the patient.
There's a difference between hating Americans and hating a thing that's in the US - that would be like saying that anyone who thinks London was a bad experience is UK-bashing
Load More Replies...Bullshіt. Give me one scenario where a healthcare institution earns more by kіlling a patient than by keeping them alive.
Load More Replies...
69
108