“I Was Honestly Dumbfounded”: Person Takes Back Crocheted Blanket After SIL’s Remarks

At first glance, a handmade gift seems perfect, particularly if you have a “crafty” hobby. There is something special about getting an item that is for the most part entirely unique. Of course, this does not mean that some of the more entitled folks out there won’t still insist on making demands about every little detail.

A netizen asked the internet if they were out of line when they refused to “fix” a minor error in a handmade crocheted blanket that was intended as a gift. As anyone who has crocheted can attest to, fixing mistakes a few rows down often means just redoing the entire thing.

Making a gift instead of buying it can be an exciting idea

Person crocheting a colorful handmade gift with a crochet hook, focusing on intricate details.

Image credits: Image by Freepik (not the actual photo)

But one netizen ended up causing some drama when they refused to do some excessive “fixes” to a blanket

Text about handmade gift demands and perfection for a crocheted blanket request.

Text describing a handmade gift and a woman's reaction, highlighting perfection demands.

Text excerpt discussing handmade gift critique and pattern issues.

Text exchange about a handmade gift needing perfection before being considered finished.

Text expressing frustration towards perfectionists' demands for handmade gifts.

Text about handmade gift demands: "I made this blanket for her for free out of love, but she won't use it due to mistakes.

Text discussing handmade gift returned after demand for perfection.

Text conversation about handmade gift demands and perfection.

Two women on a couch; one looking upset, highlighting demands about a handmade gift.

Image credits: stefamerpik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

Text exchange discussing demands for a handmade crochet gift and frustration over fixing an error on a large blanket.

Image credits: One_Entrepreneur5686

It’s best to not be too critical about free things or labor

While it’s possible to argue about if the netizen should have made some fixes, it’s worth pointing out that people have long argued for being more “forgiving” when it comes to receiving gifts. “Never look a gift horse in the mouth,” the old saying goes, although the original, in Latin, (Noli equi dentes inspicere donati) is almost as elegant, “never inspect the teeth of a given horse.” it originated in St. Jerome’s commentary on Paul’s letter to the Ephesians.

For those unfamiliar with equine biology, horse teeth keep developing as they grow older, pushing the first teeth forward. This is, incidentally, where the term “long in the tooth” comes from. In other words, you can tell a horse is old and less valuable just from its teeth. However, social wisdom would also tell you that criticizing a gift is just not something that is done. In general, every gift should be treated as a nice bonus, not something that you are entitled to like a client who has paid for a service.

Even if you are a perfectionist, it’s best to not project that idea onto other people, particularly if they aren’t your direct employees. Similarly, one of the “advantages” of a handmade item is that you can often give suggestions and express your preferences, which can’t always be done if it’s from a factory. Part of this bargain is the acknowledgment that handmade items won’t be factory perfect, unless you are really working with an expert. To add to this idea, if you actually are working with an expert and they are making something for you as a gift, perhaps relax a little bit.

“Perfectionism” isn’t an excuse to be rude

Image credits: SkelDry / Freepik (not the actual photo)

While it’s possible that the SIL didn’t initially understand the scope of her demands, it’s still quite telling that she was so dismissive of the work already put into the blanket. Indeed, she even insulted the netizen’s work, as if it was just a trial run to her. The fact that she refused to accept the reality of fixing crocheting work is quite telling.

It’s not exactly rocket science to know that being rude about a well-meaning gift is just horrible, socially. The SIL is well within her rights to be unhappy with the situation, but it’s still the sort of thing you keep to yourself. After all, in this day and age, one can just buy a blanket, taking the time to make one by hand is hours and hours of work. There are sometimes gifts that end up being so terrible that the giver needs to be called out, but this doesn’t seem to be the case here.

A more generous explanation would be that she thought you could go back and just make some “adjustments” to crocheting work, but given her tone and the words she used, it seems she has grown accustomed to making demands. This is rude and entitled behavior. She can hide behind her “perfectionisms” but acting like this hardly shows a person to be “perfect,” given that her words were so blatantly insensitive. In other words, she seems willing to sabotage familial relationships over a few mistakes in a blanket.

Most folks thought the SIL was being too demanding

Reddit comment expressing frustration over demanding perfection for a handmade gift.

Text highlighting knitting advice and demands for a perfect handmade gift.

Text discussing demands about handmade gift, with comments on gratitude and value.

Text discussing handmade gift philosophy, emphasizing uniqueness and love, addressing demands for perfection in crafts.

Text about handmade gift demands, highlighting issues with picky, entitled behavior.

Text response to handmade gift criticism in an online forum.

Text image highlighting demands for perfect handmade gifts and value of fiber art.

Comment expressing disbelief about a handmade gift needing to be flawless.

Text comment discussing handmade gift demands and sister-in-law's ungrateful behavior.

Comment about handmade gift demands and gratitude advice.

Comment discussing demands for perfection in handmade gifts.

Comment discussing demands for a perfect handmade gift and labor appreciation.

Text response discussing handmade gift expectations and appreciation for individual effort.

Reddit comment about unreasonable demands on a handmade gift, emphasizing appreciation.

Text exchange discussing handmade gift expectations and crafting imperfections.

Text comment discussing correcting errors in a handmade gift, referencing demands for perfection.

Text exchange discussing demands on a handmade gift's perfection.

Text discussing ungrateful behavior towards a handmade gift.

Comment about handmade gift demands and appreciation.

Comment discussing handmade gift demands and appreciation for handmade imperfections.

Reddit comment discussing demands for perfection on a handmade gift.

But a few thought the situation could have been handled better

Online comment discussing handmade gift demands and right to refuse adjustments.

Negative comment discussing blemishes on a handmade gift, mentioning perfectionism and a reaction labeled as YTA.

Text criticizing the quality of a handmade gift with demands for perfect standards.

Comment criticizing mistakes in handmade gift.

Text comment about crochet mistakes and handmade gift perfectionism.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!