Woman Learns The Cost Of A Prank After 2-Year Relationship Goes Up In Flames
Trust is the foundation of any relationship, but what happens when it’s put on the line in the name of a joke? In today’s post from the subreddit r/AITAH, a man recounts how his girlfriend’s elaborate “prank” with a mutual friend of theirs jeopardized everything they had built in two years. The woman said she was just playing around, but the guy’s definition of fun doesn’t include coming home to his partner straddling someone else in their bedroom.
Pranks often walk the line between harmless fun and hurt feelings
Image credits: cottonbro studio / pexels (not the actual photo)
Or in this case, causing a breakup
Image credits: freepik (not the actual photo)
After his story went viral, the man posted an update
Image credits: anonymous
Betrayal instantly destroys safety and trust in a relationship
Image credits: wayhomestudio / freepik (not the actual photo)
Sometimes you can’t know for sure if you’re partner is cheating or not, so we asked marriage and family therapist Dr. Talal H. Alsaleem, PsyD, LMFT, also known as the Father of Modern Infidelity Counseling, about the most common signs to look out for. Of course, every situation is different, but Dr. Talal told Bored Panda there are three that stick out:
#1 Over protection of privacy and access to digital interactions
“Secrecy is one the most common elements of infidelity,” he explained to us, adding that it manifests in a variety of ways, including:
- Closing out of chat windows when a partner walks in the room
- Deleting the computer history
- Erasing online interactions
- Deleting texts
- Pretending to be working on something else when engaging in internet infidelity behaviors
- Password changes
- Taking phone everywhere
- Using a burner phone
#2 Engaging in selfish behaviors
“When you don’t feel close to someone, you are less inclined to think and or care about their needs and desires, because you feel that they don’t care about yours,” Dr. Talal said.
#3 Superficial conversations
According to the therapist, a lack of intimacy breeds lack of trust and a decrease in vulnerability. As a result, “you are less likely to have a deep, soulful conversation with your partner about your hopes, dreams, and the things that bother you.”
#4 Living Separate lives
Dr. Talal, author of the books Unfaithful & Unrepentant: Affairs Beyond the Hope of Repair and Infidelity: The Best Worst Thing that Could Happen to Your Marriage: The Complete Guide on How to Heal from Affairs, said that when the bond is strong, we tend to spend a lot of time with our partners and wholeheartedly enjoy mutual activities. But when it’s weak, couples start drifting apart and look for things to do by themselves or with other people that they feel close to.
According to scientific research conducted on couples in Britain and published in the journal PLOS-ONE, the top reasons why couples break up are:
- Growing apart;
- Arguing;
- Unfaithfulness;
- Lack of respect;
- Different interests;
- Moving;
- Money problems;
- Not sharing housework;
- Difficulties with sex;
- Domestic violence;
- Not having children;
- Drinking/drugs/gambling.
So while it’s unclear whether or not the woman had actually cheated, judging from the post, it might be that the couple’s relationship had been already plagued by at least a couple of these issues.
Most of those who read what happened said the man did nothing wrong
However, a few saw the situation differently
Who the f**k dresses down to their underwear and straddles a person for a "prank." It's either a really, really stupid Idea or they decided to actually cheat and were setting up a gaslight in case they got caught in the future. Either way, move on and move forward. There's not much to salvage from a situation like that.
So, in the exGF's head, assuming that her intentions were purely prank-filled, what was she expecting to be the reaction? "Oh, you got me! Shucks, that was a good one, babe. Anyway, where do you want to go for dinner tonight?"
In the “best case scenario” and it was actually a joke, that’s my big question too. And _how_ is it funny? (for the record, breaking up was the right call. The whole thing is weird and suspicious) Edit: grammar
Load More Replies...If she wanted to be funny she could have painted her face as a clown. Oh wait, she already did that without the makeup
The prank itself is a major betrayal of trust. Recording it, with the intention of posting his reaction, is another betrayal - a violation of his privacy. Deliberately causing someone emotional distress isn't a prank, it's manipulative and abusive. Cheating pranks are up there with the "sorry, I accidently ran over your pet and killed it." pranks and the fake-blood-saturating-the-pants "I think I'm miscarrying in the 5th month of our wanted pregnancy" pranks, and the "your dad just called from the hospital, your mom's been in a car wreck, and she probrably won't make it." There are events that we all understand would be emotionally traumatic. We all understand that lying that a traumatic event has happened isn't funny, it's cruel. "It was a lie." doesn't take away the initial pain of the revelation, and it doesn't take away the fact that someone you previously trusted deliberately caused you emotional trauma, lied to you, and did so for likes online. NTA
This! You explained it perfectly. Lying about a traumatic event is always cruel and never funny.
Load More Replies...TikTok is rotting people's brains. Who else would think "Oh! *This* would be a hilarious prank!"
"It's not what it looks like!". "It's only sex!".
Load More Replies..."What? No officer I am not some insane bastards who burns orphanages for fun! You see that camera there? It is just a prank! As soon as the fire started I went in and escorted all the kids out! SO no harm done! I mean sure... 3 year old Timmy is in the ICU for third degree burns but who could know he was SUCH A SLOW RUNNER... That is not my fault that ppl don't know how to react to pranks!"
You didn't laugh it off, but you did choose to move on. Good call. 🙂
The entire point of the prank was to make you feel betrayed and then laugh at you for feeling that way. Don't spend any more time on a partner who's goal is humiliation for their own amusement.
That's the point of any "prank" isn't it? That's why nothing is truly a prank unless the person being pranked has ALREADY EXPRESSED that they think that sort of scenario is amusing TO THEM. Anything else is straight up bullying. Setting someone up for humiliation is NOT the way to make them feel loved. Some people are beyond repair.
Load More Replies...Jokes are supposed to be mutually amusing. Don't see ex GF and ex friend apologizing for upsetting OP. Therefore, it wasn't the least bit amusing all around. OP, go NC on any dissers. You deserve better.
As others have - she was straddling the other guy, and both were in their underwear, and they were moving as though they were having sex. That is sexual contact. If somebody did that to somebody else without consent, that would 100% be considered sexual assault (and rightfully so). How can anybody think that this is OK or that it is a joke?
You know what another great prank would be? Call her up and forgive her. Let her move back in, give her a good rogering and then kick her out with a 'psyche! That was a prank! Now f**k off forever.'
Who wants to bet the exgf and the "friend" are already shagging, this time for real
Where there is smoke there is fire and that prank was enough to blot out the sun.
The last esh " she should like a fun person".... I bet that is as friends of hers or herself or someone who thinks hurting people and recording that hurt is funny? He does not describe her atc all, how can you tell from this one example that she is fun to be around? Or maybe it's someone who likes that she takes her clothes off for a prank?
If OP feels that hurt (I would too, btw) and decides to end the relationship, that is OP's decision and his alone. He is doing what he feels is best for him. No one else has any say in what that is or what actions should be taken. Any real friend would understand that. I would tolerate neither gf's so-called prank nor the so-called friends who would not respect my decisions. There are eight billion other people in this world. They should get to know a few of them instead.
this is not a prank, they secretely want each other .Stop being a dummy & move on. They deserve each others foolishness lol good luck to you
I fail to see how anything about that "prank" was funny in any way. If the prankee isn't laughing it's not a joke.
ExGF wanted to be caught 'cheating' so two men would fight over her; even if only briefly. She likely enjoys having men vie for her attention. She talked the inmature idiot mutual friend into it under the guise of is being a 'prank' and because he's likely into her This is actually the best case scenario as the OP walked away instead of throwing hands; which, is a more reasonable reaction to expect than enyone finding this funny.
As a lawyer I know of a case where the two pranksters who were pulling a similar prank were shot dead by the husband when he found them. That's how stupid this alleged prank was. And why is it funny? Doesn't seem funny or harmless to me.
Insensitive people believing their insensitive, unrespectful, irresponsible behavior is a prank. They can FCK themselves way away from me.
It would take a warped mind to think up such a thing. How the heck did they expect you to react ..... laugh it off ? I don't think so.
Pranks are hurtful, period. This was not a prank!- it was abuse to the OP.
Seriously wtf wrong with some people. Do not understand the thought process and mental gymnastics needed. To think that would be a funny prank.
I despise practical jokes. Always humiliating. Definitely disrespectful. I don't blame the guy for ending that. I would have done the same thing. My suspicions would lead me to think they like each other. May want to open up the relationship. So what they did would definitely rattle my confidence in the future of the relationship. On the flip-side, they are in their 20s, so still young and dumb. IDK. Too much. And definitely not appropriate.
I'd bet cash money that the two "pranksters" were: 1. already fücking or 2. are now.
You my friend had a lucky escape imagine if you had married this woman then you would have had a lot more to lose.Be thankful not sad
You did the right thing. Ask those who think you are wrong how they would feel if their SO's genitals, only covered by underwear were within less than an inch of another person's genitals with the same (lack of) covering.
NTA. Please tell her to stop gaslighting u. And ask her how would she feel if u played the same prank on her. Pose the same question to all those who say u overreacted. Maybe its fine for them if their girlfriends played such a prank on them. Well if my bf or husband did that, I would tell him to get lost
OP is just doing a prank in return - pretending to want to have no association with them. He should wait a while before letting them know it's a prank - say, just before the Earth falls into the Sun.
I would have been livid had the shoe been on the other foot. There is not one thing funny or cute about it. Tasteless and trashy. I am glad you told her and the “friend” to kick rocks. If you had done that to her she would have gone ballistic! I don’t care how many guy friends I have I would NEVER even think to do something so cruel to someone I love. Good riddance!
NTA. Who in their right mind would actually think this was funny? Prank or not she crossed a line. Move on.
You mount a mutual friend to test your boyfriend too, Susan?
Load More Replies...Who the f**k dresses down to their underwear and straddles a person for a "prank." It's either a really, really stupid Idea or they decided to actually cheat and were setting up a gaslight in case they got caught in the future. Either way, move on and move forward. There's not much to salvage from a situation like that.
So, in the exGF's head, assuming that her intentions were purely prank-filled, what was she expecting to be the reaction? "Oh, you got me! Shucks, that was a good one, babe. Anyway, where do you want to go for dinner tonight?"
In the “best case scenario” and it was actually a joke, that’s my big question too. And _how_ is it funny? (for the record, breaking up was the right call. The whole thing is weird and suspicious) Edit: grammar
Load More Replies...If she wanted to be funny she could have painted her face as a clown. Oh wait, she already did that without the makeup
The prank itself is a major betrayal of trust. Recording it, with the intention of posting his reaction, is another betrayal - a violation of his privacy. Deliberately causing someone emotional distress isn't a prank, it's manipulative and abusive. Cheating pranks are up there with the "sorry, I accidently ran over your pet and killed it." pranks and the fake-blood-saturating-the-pants "I think I'm miscarrying in the 5th month of our wanted pregnancy" pranks, and the "your dad just called from the hospital, your mom's been in a car wreck, and she probrably won't make it." There are events that we all understand would be emotionally traumatic. We all understand that lying that a traumatic event has happened isn't funny, it's cruel. "It was a lie." doesn't take away the initial pain of the revelation, and it doesn't take away the fact that someone you previously trusted deliberately caused you emotional trauma, lied to you, and did so for likes online. NTA
This! You explained it perfectly. Lying about a traumatic event is always cruel and never funny.
Load More Replies...TikTok is rotting people's brains. Who else would think "Oh! *This* would be a hilarious prank!"
"It's not what it looks like!". "It's only sex!".
Load More Replies..."What? No officer I am not some insane bastards who burns orphanages for fun! You see that camera there? It is just a prank! As soon as the fire started I went in and escorted all the kids out! SO no harm done! I mean sure... 3 year old Timmy is in the ICU for third degree burns but who could know he was SUCH A SLOW RUNNER... That is not my fault that ppl don't know how to react to pranks!"
You didn't laugh it off, but you did choose to move on. Good call. 🙂
The entire point of the prank was to make you feel betrayed and then laugh at you for feeling that way. Don't spend any more time on a partner who's goal is humiliation for their own amusement.
That's the point of any "prank" isn't it? That's why nothing is truly a prank unless the person being pranked has ALREADY EXPRESSED that they think that sort of scenario is amusing TO THEM. Anything else is straight up bullying. Setting someone up for humiliation is NOT the way to make them feel loved. Some people are beyond repair.
Load More Replies...Jokes are supposed to be mutually amusing. Don't see ex GF and ex friend apologizing for upsetting OP. Therefore, it wasn't the least bit amusing all around. OP, go NC on any dissers. You deserve better.
As others have - she was straddling the other guy, and both were in their underwear, and they were moving as though they were having sex. That is sexual contact. If somebody did that to somebody else without consent, that would 100% be considered sexual assault (and rightfully so). How can anybody think that this is OK or that it is a joke?
You know what another great prank would be? Call her up and forgive her. Let her move back in, give her a good rogering and then kick her out with a 'psyche! That was a prank! Now f**k off forever.'
Who wants to bet the exgf and the "friend" are already shagging, this time for real
Where there is smoke there is fire and that prank was enough to blot out the sun.
The last esh " she should like a fun person".... I bet that is as friends of hers or herself or someone who thinks hurting people and recording that hurt is funny? He does not describe her atc all, how can you tell from this one example that she is fun to be around? Or maybe it's someone who likes that she takes her clothes off for a prank?
If OP feels that hurt (I would too, btw) and decides to end the relationship, that is OP's decision and his alone. He is doing what he feels is best for him. No one else has any say in what that is or what actions should be taken. Any real friend would understand that. I would tolerate neither gf's so-called prank nor the so-called friends who would not respect my decisions. There are eight billion other people in this world. They should get to know a few of them instead.
this is not a prank, they secretely want each other .Stop being a dummy & move on. They deserve each others foolishness lol good luck to you
I fail to see how anything about that "prank" was funny in any way. If the prankee isn't laughing it's not a joke.
ExGF wanted to be caught 'cheating' so two men would fight over her; even if only briefly. She likely enjoys having men vie for her attention. She talked the inmature idiot mutual friend into it under the guise of is being a 'prank' and because he's likely into her This is actually the best case scenario as the OP walked away instead of throwing hands; which, is a more reasonable reaction to expect than enyone finding this funny.
As a lawyer I know of a case where the two pranksters who were pulling a similar prank were shot dead by the husband when he found them. That's how stupid this alleged prank was. And why is it funny? Doesn't seem funny or harmless to me.
Insensitive people believing their insensitive, unrespectful, irresponsible behavior is a prank. They can FCK themselves way away from me.
It would take a warped mind to think up such a thing. How the heck did they expect you to react ..... laugh it off ? I don't think so.
Pranks are hurtful, period. This was not a prank!- it was abuse to the OP.
Seriously wtf wrong with some people. Do not understand the thought process and mental gymnastics needed. To think that would be a funny prank.
I despise practical jokes. Always humiliating. Definitely disrespectful. I don't blame the guy for ending that. I would have done the same thing. My suspicions would lead me to think they like each other. May want to open up the relationship. So what they did would definitely rattle my confidence in the future of the relationship. On the flip-side, they are in their 20s, so still young and dumb. IDK. Too much. And definitely not appropriate.
I'd bet cash money that the two "pranksters" were: 1. already fücking or 2. are now.
You my friend had a lucky escape imagine if you had married this woman then you would have had a lot more to lose.Be thankful not sad
You did the right thing. Ask those who think you are wrong how they would feel if their SO's genitals, only covered by underwear were within less than an inch of another person's genitals with the same (lack of) covering.
NTA. Please tell her to stop gaslighting u. And ask her how would she feel if u played the same prank on her. Pose the same question to all those who say u overreacted. Maybe its fine for them if their girlfriends played such a prank on them. Well if my bf or husband did that, I would tell him to get lost
OP is just doing a prank in return - pretending to want to have no association with them. He should wait a while before letting them know it's a prank - say, just before the Earth falls into the Sun.
I would have been livid had the shoe been on the other foot. There is not one thing funny or cute about it. Tasteless and trashy. I am glad you told her and the “friend” to kick rocks. If you had done that to her she would have gone ballistic! I don’t care how many guy friends I have I would NEVER even think to do something so cruel to someone I love. Good riddance!
NTA. Who in their right mind would actually think this was funny? Prank or not she crossed a line. Move on.
You mount a mutual friend to test your boyfriend too, Susan?
Load More Replies...
54
89