Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
“None Of Her Pains Are My Concern”: Woman Sparks 5-Hour Mid-Flight Drama By Refusing To Help A Pregnant Woman
Interview With Expert
Let’s face it: airplane coach seats aren’t designed for comfort. So, if you’re heavy-set, pregnant, or both, they can be problematic.
In this story, a passenger with two plane seats under her name refused to give one of them up to a pregnant and overweight woman. Her reason: she’d paid for both and would gladly sell it to the lady instead.
The author’s reaction caused a slight commotion, but she did not fold. However, she wonders if she was in the wrong and seeks answers from the AITAH subreddit.
Bored Panda also spoke with veteran Philippine Airlines flight attendant Kaz Icalina to get her input on passenger rights.
RELATED:
People are expected to follow airplane etiquette
Image credits: winnievinzence (not the actual image)
A woman with an extra seat refused to give it to a pregnant passenger
Image credits: OlgaSmolina (not the actual image)
The author didn’t fold and received dirty looks in return
Image credits: QueenPekPek
The author had the right to do whatever she wanted with her extra seat
It’s understandable to empathize with the woman in the story because pregnancy takes a toll on the body. However, regardless of her situation, it does not entitle her to anything.
According to Kaz, flight attendants can only do so much, especially during full flights. They could ask a passenger if they would accept a seat switch. If they decline, they won’t try to convince otherwise.
Unfortunately, the pregnant woman had no choice but to accept the rejection.
“Passengers have rights, and flight attendants can’t choose one over the other for humanitarian reasons,” she said, adding that you can’t force anyone to give up seats unless a legal reason is involved.
Image credits: Markus Winkler (not the actual image)
The woman could have made pre-flight arrangements to accommodate her situation
The pregnant woman knew fully well that a coach seat would be uncomfortable. According to Kaz, the least she could have done was to make pre-flight seat arrangements.
As she explained, many airlines offer a “neighbor-free” option. This allows passengers to book an extra seat even if they are traveling alone.
“She can’t rely on the kindness of people to give up their space.”
In this story, the woman could have done either one of two things: agreed to buy the author’s extra seat or accepted the situation. Her hostility put her in a bad light and possibly caused unnecessary stress that may have impacted the child somehow. It’s a lose-lose situation she could have avoided.
What’s your take, dear reader? What could they have done to prevent the situation from escalating?
Image credits: Amina Filkins (not the actual image)
The author provided more information in the comments
But most people sided with her
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
What do you think ?
Ace 4 months ago (edited)
Yeah, no. The ticket being scanned part of the story was not thought through - as one commentor pointed out that's not how it works - all else apart, eve if the agent had scanned it it without a passenger physically at the desk, the flight's boarding list would be showing one passenger missing. ETA: OK, so this could theoretically happen if both the check-in agent _and_ the gate staff scanned the extra ticket/boarding pass, or if she had herself done a self check-in for the child who by that point she'd have known was not travelling, printed off the boarding pass, taken it with her and got the gate agent to scan it. Naah, it's still a no from me.
P Peitsch 4 months ago
Generally speaking, you have right. But everywhere are working people, and people are making sometimes mistakes. So, I give a chance, that this story may have happened, especially right after Covid-time, when things just started opening up again.
Load More Replies...
Bouche and Audi and Shyla, Oh My! 4 months ago
I'm morbidly obese. If I needed to fly, I would have to buy two seats. If this woman is heavy enough to need an extra seat, she can pay for it.
justagirl 4 months ago
Props for not being a stick in the mud! (Tell bouche and audi i send pets)
Load More Replies...
Marianne 4 months ago
I don't understand the issue. Why would the other lady want to have the middle seat instead of her aisle seat? If the middle seat is free and OP's stuff is lying there, the other lady already wins, because she is not crammed in by another person and I'm sure it would have been ok if she just removed the arm rest. She has more space, but is still in her seat. Voilà, everyone is happy.
LakotaWolf (she/her) 4 months ago (edited)
I’m guessing the pregnant lady wanted the entire seat, perhaps to lay down/lean/put her legs up on? Or perhaps she was overweight enough to want/need to (I’m sorry, I don’t know how to put it in a more polite way) “spread out” onto both seats? I have family members who are morbidly obese, and they need more than just “armrest room” when they fly - they require two seats because their lower body parts absolutely do not fit into one seat.
Load More Replies...
Ace 4 months ago (edited)
Yeah, no. The ticket being scanned part of the story was not thought through - as one commentor pointed out that's not how it works - all else apart, eve if the agent had scanned it it without a passenger physically at the desk, the flight's boarding list would be showing one passenger missing. ETA: OK, so this could theoretically happen if both the check-in agent _and_ the gate staff scanned the extra ticket/boarding pass, or if she had herself done a self check-in for the child who by that point she'd have known was not travelling, printed off the boarding pass, taken it with her and got the gate agent to scan it. Naah, it's still a no from me.
P Peitsch 4 months ago
Generally speaking, you have right. But everywhere are working people, and people are making sometimes mistakes. So, I give a chance, that this story may have happened, especially right after Covid-time, when things just started opening up again.
Load More Replies... Bouche and Audi and Shyla, Oh My! 4 months ago
I'm morbidly obese. If I needed to fly, I would have to buy two seats. If this woman is heavy enough to need an extra seat, she can pay for it.
justagirl 4 months ago
Props for not being a stick in the mud! (Tell bouche and audi i send pets)
Load More Replies... Marianne 4 months ago
I don't understand the issue. Why would the other lady want to have the middle seat instead of her aisle seat? If the middle seat is free and OP's stuff is lying there, the other lady already wins, because she is not crammed in by another person and I'm sure it would have been ok if she just removed the arm rest. She has more space, but is still in her seat. Voilà, everyone is happy.
LakotaWolf (she/her) 4 months ago (edited)
I’m guessing the pregnant lady wanted the entire seat, perhaps to lay down/lean/put her legs up on? Or perhaps she was overweight enough to want/need to (I’m sorry, I don’t know how to put it in a more polite way) “spread out” onto both seats? I have family members who are morbidly obese, and they need more than just “armrest room” when they fly - they require two seats because their lower body parts absolutely do not fit into one seat.
Load More Replies... You May Like 50 People Who Weren’t Afraid To Call Out The Jerks They Saw In Public (New Pics) Mom Ends Up In Tears After Her Dramatic Scene To Take Over A Plane Seat Fails Tall Woman Nearly Has Her Spacious Seat Nabbed By Passenger With Dog, Puts Her Foot Down
Simona Kinderytė
Dominyka
Monika Pašukonytė
Related on Bored Panda
16
31