What was once a dream home for Taralyn Romero quickly became a living nightmare the moment her community claimed her property as theirs. “I got threatened, and I got told that it wasn’t my land and that I had stolen it,” the property owner said.

The picturesque area in Kittredge, Colorado, right next to Bear Creek, was perfect for the nature-lover — pine trees surrounded the house, with untouched snow, adding a magical feel to the atmosphere. And through it all, the north bank of a river flowed through the endless white.

For Taralyn, it was “pure bliss” until people started to label her as the “wicked witch” — and it seems that her insistence on keeping the land has backfired, with more people showing up to the park than ever before.

Taralyn Romero bought a beautiful home in a rural area but her community hasn’t taken kindly to the boundaries she set for privacy

Image credits: wickedwitch_ofthe_west

The 43-year-old bought the property when the COVID-19 pandemic hit, back when she was still living in Denver. Her partner and her daughter rented and moved into the area in 2021, when she decided she wanted more space.

“I bought it in the middle of the housing crisis and during the pandemic so prices were sky-high for everything,” Taralyn told Bored Panda. “I was extremely worried I’d over-pay for something so the creek in the backyard was what sold me.”

When locals started disrespecting the area, she went on TikTok to blow off some steam. Now, the popularity of the creek has started to skyrocket, and Taralyn is convinced it was the result of her own doing.

Image credits: wickedwitch_ofthe_west

On November 11, the ERPD stated that “data shows visits to Kittredge Park jumped 23 percent from 2022 to 2023, from 9,100 to 15,500 visits, with most visitors spending just over an hour there.”

In a TikTok posted earlier this week, Taralyn said she was “99.99% sure that this increase is a direct result” of her land dispute.

“Could it be that people just love the park?” she asked. “Possibly. But I don’t think so.”

Taralyn’s move to Kittredge Park was a means to escape from the constant bustle of the city

Image credits: wickedwitch_ofthe_west

Initially, the Colorado native had seen the space as a temporary getaway from her Denver home. She made the decision to stay when her lease expired. 

The village had a little over 1,300 people, according to the 2020 Census, and was mostly occupied by wildlife. 

But as the snow melted and the days grew longer, more tourists started to flock to the creek, similarly needing a place for peace and quiet.

Families played by the water, bringing their floaties and coolers to the park, but left a mark as they departed. Socks and dirty kids’ clothing were scattered along the property, as well as empty baby wipe containers and children’s water bottles.

Image credits: wickedwitch_ofthe_west

Taralyn was somewhat confused at first, assuming visitors weren’t aware they were on private land. But some told her they knew of the boundaries, although previous owners had long opened up the space to the public.

Beside the trash being thrown around, the 43-year-old grew worried about the potential liability.

“Having a playground where kids are running back and forth and the parents are sometimes distracted on their phones, made me incredibly concerned that I was going to be dealing with a drowning at worst, or someone getting hurt and slipping on the rocks at best,” she told Fox News Digital.

Taralyn’s friendly reminders to tourists to respect her land were ignored and even met with hostility

Image credits: wickedwitch_ofthe_west

@wickedwitch_ofthe_west Replying to @user2327081555294 On my way to seek justice for my dream home #truestory #homebuyingprocess #horrorstory #buyerbeware #reallifenightmare #storytime #whatwouldyoudo #propertyvalue #realtorsoftiktok #housingmarket2023 #creeklife #elk #colorado ♬ Beautiful Paradise – Aga Alamsyah

Taralyn put up a sign that read, “Private Property: Residents and Invited Guests Only,” additionally encouraging “no digging” after seeing kids and pets digging holes everywhere.

“We wanted to make friends. We wanted to fit in,” she said, hoping the reminders weren’t seen as aggressive in any way.

But the requests were both largely ignored.

The 43-year-old claimed interactions with the locals were fairly antagonistic, especially after she decided to build a fence. 

@wickedwitch_ofthe_west BIG NEWS regarding the prior home owners #realestatetiktok #lawsuit #fraud #newhomeowners #truestory #justice #accountability #badfaith #property #colorado #caselaw #liarliar #deception #shortstory #legaltiktok #lawyersoftiktok ♬ original sound – Real Wicked Witch of the West

“I got maps thrown in my face,” Taralyn informed. “I got cussed out. I got screamed at. I got threatened, and I got told that it wasn’t my land and that I had stolen it.”

As things started to escalate, many visitors arrived at the property for the sole purpose of cussing her out, claiming she had destroyed a beloved community.

Taralyn felt as if she was portrayed “as a villain… someone who didn’t want to watch children have fun.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Don’t want to see ads?

@wickedwitch_ofthe_west Part 1: Real Life Salem Witch Trial #truestory #romanempire #witchhunt #witchtok #kittredgeparkdrama #salemwitchtrials #entitlement #smalltownproblems #smalltownusa #colorado #creeklife #forshame #fyp #badneighbors #propertydispute #property #creeklady #romanempire #trending ♬ original sound – Real Wicked Witch of the West

Image credits: wickedwitch_ofthe_west

“We all wonder what we’re made of,” she told Bored Panda. “Everyone likes to imagine what lengths they’d go to if they had to fight against all odds. I got to find out. Because of what my family and I endured through this whole situation, I got to find out exactly what I’m capable of and what type of person I am.

“When great adversity came knocking, and threatened to take away everything I had worked my entire life for: my reputation, my dream home, my peace… I answered the door, stepped through, and came out a battle hardened warrior.”

But to Taralyn, the main question remained: “What kind of neighbor tries to steal their neighbor’s land while villainizing them for trying to keep it? What type of government seeks to take land from one of their constituents simply because the locals are demanding they do so?”

It wasn’t long before authorities got involved in the growing tension

Image credits: wickedwitch_ofthe_west

But Taralyn knew she needed to stand her ground.

She said the county did a poor job of offering clarification or assistance, saying the whole situation was a complete “frenzy,” especially after the dispute boiled over into the following summer.

Officials also revealed they were taking a closer look at where the boundary lines stood.

“We don’t know if the creek has meandered onto their property,” said Matt Robbins, a spokesperson for Jeffco Open Space to local media.

An attorney has even expressed interest in seeking a temporary restraining order so families would still able to publicly use the area, at least until the county can determine whose land the park stands on.

Image credits: wickedwitch_ofthe_west

Since then, Taralyn has sued the people who sold her the home for fraud and breach of contract.

ADVERTISEMENT

Don’t want to see ads?

“I got them to bend the knee in record time and we settled out of court,” she said. “I then turned my attention on helping others and was recently recognized for my plight and advocacy by the Pacific Legal Foundation.”

Jacky Liu, a lawyer based in Vancouver, told Bored Panda his “gut reaction” was that the seller had “no obligation to disclose that they had previously allowed the public to use the space.”

However, “if someone does understand that the property is private but chooses to trespass regardless, then that person surely would be in the wrong,” he added.

Netizens rallied in support of Taralyn but pointed out that broadcasting the dispute on social media wasn’t the wisest idea

@wickedwitch_ofthe_west When the impact of social media is quantified lmfao #kittredgepark #update #wedidthis #bangthedrum ♬ original sound – Real Wicked Witch of the West

Commenters said Taralyn’s concerns for liability were valid.

“Sorry, but she’s absolutely correct!” one user wrote. “If someone drowned or injured themselves in the river on her property, then any attorney is going to try to hold her legally liable. If it were me, then I would hire a survey crew to figure out the exact property line, then install fencing.”

Another questioned social media’s role in the whole dispute, saying, “I would not want random people traipsing through my property and taking a dip in the creek for the simple fact of civil liability if for nothing else.

“But her mistake was venting on social media. I would have quietly sold the place and moved on.”

@wickedwitch_ofthe_west Finally, a happy ending and some accountability served after years of suffering. #creeklady #kittredgeparkupdate #apologyvideo #accountability #evergreen #colorado #bearcreek #priorhomeowners #update #truestory #storytime #inspirational #miracleshappen #happyending #seriesfinale ♬ Mr. Blue Sky – Electric Light Orchestra

A third user expressed, “IF the property is hers… private property is PRIVATE property. I side with her. Think of the liability if a kid drowns. Put up an electric fence.

“Disagree? How about we all come to your house and have a picnic on your lawn everyday. Knowing Americans I bet many leave their trash everywhere. Too many disrespectful.”

Additionally, Taralyn said there have been a few locals in her area who have supported her, as well as hundreds of other people who donated money to help her cover a small fraction of her legal fees. Politicians, lawyers, and realtors were also involved in the process.

Commenters were divided on what they’d do if they were in Taralyn’s shoes

ADVERTISEMENT

Don’t want to see ads?

Poll Question

Thanks! Check out the results:

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Games

View all games

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!