
People Are Sharing What Happened To The Smartest Kids In Their Class
Interview With ExpertBeing deemed a “gifted” child can be a blessing and a curse. It can be a great confidence booster to hear you’re excelling in school and that your teachers see a bright future ahead of you. But it can also come with immense pressure to exceed expectations and have all the right answers. And what happens when these kids grow up?
Redditors have recently been discussing where their most promising classmates ended up, so we’ve gathered the juiciest replies below. From changing the world with scientific discoveries to dropping out of college and abandoning academics altogether, enjoy reading through these surprising stories. And keep reading to find a conversation with Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist, Vicki Botnick!
This post may include affiliate links.
She opened her own cafe in a neighboring town and employs people with disabilities. She graduated as valedictorian in high school and later, top 10% at Yale.
I'll break the mold here from the burnt out gifted kid sterotype.
He got a PhD from a very prestigious university, worked for Google on one of their flagship products, married a Medical Doctor, quit Google and semi-retired. He's mostly a stay at home dad now and does some occasional consulting work part time.
What, I'm not jealous... you're jealous. Seriously though the guy deserved every bit of what he has.
To learn more about this topic, we got in touch with Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist, Vicki Botnick. She was kind enough to have a chat with Bored Panda and discuss how being deemed "gifted" can impact a person.
"Being identified as gifted can give a child the advantages of pride, extra resources, and a chance to be accurately challenged academically. However, the label can also be a burden," the expert shared.
"Kids who are singled out as exceptional often put a lot of pressure on themselves to maintain the sense of being special. In addition, parents can add to the pressure, either by overtly having high expectations, or by more subtly indicating that they value the label highly," Vicki explained. "Suddenly there’s something to live up to."
He became the surgeon general of the US.
Those wondering, this guy was in the position from 2015-17 and throughout the biden admin. Wikipedia. Got replaced during Trump's second wind.
The smartest kid in my class was also very disciplined and emotionally stable. I lost track of him in the last 20 years, but a quick Google search says he graduated from Stanford and started a biotech company.
Full scholarship to Harvard, track and field star, opera singer, fashion model, actually funny improv comedian, and now she’s an environmental lawyer or something. Also has a husband and kids now. I don’t know how a real person can achieve all this and I can’t help but feel like my life is inadequate.
Vicki also says parents sometimes inadvertently project their own insecurities and dreams onto their kids. "Many communities put a lot of emphasis on childhood accomplishments, and parents might get drawn into comparisons and one-upmanship for their own self-image. This adds to the weight of expectations on kids who are on the highest achievement track."
"Giftedness can also come with some inner challenges. A very bright and sensitive child, the type often referred to as 'an old soul,' might be trying to manage increased awareness and intellect, while still being developmentally a little kid, often one with social challenges," the therapist shared. "They might be thinking about big topics (religion, death, morality) before they are really capable of making sense of these issues, which can lead to anxiety and rumination."
The same thing happened to the two smartest kids in my class, a guy and a girl. They both got accepted into Ivy League schools and then had to dropout after they developed serious mental health issues. I imagine the high stress environment must have flipped a switch in their brains to make them go off the deep end.
They were such cool people, I was really rooting for them. :(.
He went to a top university and struggled like f**k because everyone was clever and he realised he wasn’t the special unique snowflake that his mum told him he was.
The guy was one of the most arrogant twats I’ve met so I feel karma worked its magic here.
Exactly what happened to me - I was an arrogant know-it-all in high school, ended up going to one of the top universities in the U.S. and got the sh1t kicked out of me, academically speaking. A very humbling experience, but honestly, I don't think U.S. schools adequately prepare you for anything.
I was the smartest kid in my class. I did ok academically in the end, I have a bachelor’s and two postgraduate degrees.
Professionally, I did absolutely terrible for many years until I started my business recently. Things are looking up professionally.
I also have a wonderful husband and children, so I consider myself in an amazing position, best I’ve ever been in in my life.
My childhood was s**t (a*****e parents, very poor, and socially inept weird kid with no friends) and so was most of my adulthood (still socially inept, lonely, no family support, partners in my life could easily take advantage and abuse me), so I feel like I deserve the happiness I have now.
"To be thought of as exceptional and stand out fairly easily can set a child up for disappointment as they age," Vicki warns. "Many children at the top of their class move on to more competitive environments where, eventually, every person there is a former gifted child. Sometimes, it’s a tough transition from being a top performer to being one of the crowd, and can bring on feelings of imposter syndrome, lower self-esteem, or increased pressure to excel."
There were 2 geniuses in my class. One became a neurosurgeon, the other opened a candle store.
She was constantly stressed out by her family pressuring her to get a 4.0 GPA and get a full ride to a good school and then immediately did nothing with it because then she was pushed to marry some guy who was a total washout but got a job through his dad.
That family was s**t and I kind of stopped checking in when I moved away from the area. No idea what came of her in the end. She was very smart, but I don't think I ever saw her happy.
EDIT: Sad to say there were also a lot of cruel jokes about her among the class cause she was so busy with church stuff and studying she never had time for friends and never seemed to know what to do with other people. Poor girl was basically a spectator sport in high school. Not very proud of that now.
He got bored of school, joined the navy, and never grew out of his love for trains.
I'm sorry when I first glanced the pic I thought the guys standing by the torpedoes (..??) were showing thighs with tall shiny boots....
The therapist noted that one common effect of giftedness comes from the message from the world that you’re valued if things come easy to you. "Kids learn at an young age (in California, second graders are tested for giftedness) that they are considered special for things that come naturally to them," she explained. "Later, when the work gets harder and they need to put more effort in, they sometimes interpret this as meaning they are 'dumber.'"
"Some avoid the subjects that they struggle with, because having to work hard at something doesn’t fit into their positive self-definition," Vicki shared. "They worry that failing at something, which everyone does at first with a difficult task, might expose them as not as bright."
There were two of us.
J had rich parents and went to an Ivy League school, got a law degree, spent some time working for the AG of Guam and while I have no idea what he's up to now, he's very successful.
I was poor. They took my Ritalin away, my grades dropped. I became depressed, got profiled because of my depression as a potential school shooter in the wake of Columbine, and eventually dropped out of school. I only finally went back to college because of the pandemic, where I'm working toward the goal of a doctorate in psychology.
I really feel for them. My sister had to stop her ADHD meds once for about 8 months because the government changed the prescribing rules and she had to see a psychiatrist (rather than just the GP) to get them re-prescribed. Everyone (especially adults) with ADHD was in the same boat and very few psychiatrist were taking adult patients at the time, oh and covid was around. When she finally got to see one, he wouldn't prescribe the one she had been taking successfully for years because 'these other ones work best for the majority of people' and he kept upping the dose and her symptoms just got worse. Thankfully she managed to find another psychiatrist who started her back on the original meds straight away. Anyway, it was a terrible time for her, her symptoms were so bad she almost drove her friends away. I could see how someone else could take that turn to depression (my sister has that too but is medicated well for it). I really hope this person does achieve that degree because there
The smartest I never heard from again but the last time I saw him he learned fluent Chinese as his third language. The second became a hard left activist. The third smartest became a dentist.
He went to university studying math. After a while he decided that the teachers didn't know math like he did. They did not respect and love it. He got furious and quit. He got some good jobs in investment banking, quit them because they did not respect the math.
Last I heard he was some sort of janitor at a research facility. Apparently very well liked since he can solve any ones math problems. Guess they respect it enough.
I think he is on the spectrum...
So how can parents and teachers support these children without putting too much pressure on them?
"Instead of focusing on measures of achievement, parents and teachers can encourage bright kids by letting them follow their curiosity at their own pace," Vicki told Bored Panda. "By using praise that focuses on effort rather than accomplishment ('You worked so hard on this' rather than 'Wow you did that so quickly'), they promote values that will serve the child throughout their development, rather than reinforcing a false sense of virtuosity."
The smartest lad got addicted to d***s and overdosed (his parents we're apparently really over bearing) and the smartest girl became an onlyfans model and also an escort.
Wild ride I guess.
🤔 ..smart enough to realize only fools and suckers work on their feet for a living 🫡
I work at a pet store, highest GPA voted most likely to succeed, almost skipped grades but I was extremely socially inept and parents thought that would only make it worse. IQ tested at 164, was tested for eidetic memory (don’t have one just insanely good recall). Went to college for Physics and Mathematics. Junior year I had a series of psychotic episodes and was later diagnosed with schizophrenia. Dropped out of college, found that animals help with my anxiety and depression, keep me a bit more leveled overall so I stuck with it. It would be pretty cool to have my own store but economy is s**t so ya know just kinda cruising.
From OOP in the comments: "I don’t regret not finishing college, I was very much on a track that was set for me. I was expected to have a PhD from a young age. My parents are very upset with where I am in life, I’m a failure in their eyes and sort of my own. I absolutely love animals, I love teaching people about biotope and setting up natural habitats for fish and reptiles, it’s great. My biggest problem with unhappiness is mostly just it’s not financially redeeming at the moment. I enjoy helping people, educating, seeing things people do and what they enjoy with advice I give but my bank account is well, I’m in a similar boat a lot of Americans are in. Trying to do what you love isn’t always a money maker but I refuse to do anything else. Why be a 9-5 zombie for slightly extra money than share a passion with people?"
It was often me, so I'll tell ya
I got depressed, turned into a smoker/alcoholic, and dropped out of high school.
Then i worked s****y restaurant jobs, continued being a smoker/alcoholic, and did a bunch of d***s. I also got my GED.
Then i went to rehab
I moved out to the country and the only things that have changed are that i dont do d***s, weed started giving me panic attacks, and i dont have a job.
I never properly learned how to drive. I have zero social skills.
But i can cook fairly well and I'm planning on going to community college in the fall. I'll be 24 when that starts.
Essentially, life got to be too much even without responsibilities and i turned into a deadbeat do-nothing
The person who wasnt inherently smart but worked her a*s off to get good grades and learn things? Extremely successful comparatively and is now a newscaster on one of the big stations around here. I envy her. But she also grew up with a stable family and decent support and social skills, so.
"Schools that offer gifted kids extra resources and a chance to work in a less restrictive way can hone not only achievement-oriented results like good grades, but the more impactful characteristics like open mindedness and creativity," Vicki added. "In general we’d like to have high expectations of our children to work hard, gain confidence and leadership abilities, and be excited about learning, rather than focusing on outer trappings of success like high GPAs, trophies, college acceptances and resume building."
They studied Maths and Psycology, wrote the master thesis about Maths in English (not our mother tongue) and now works at a uni renowned for their Maths department.
My brother had a friend in elementary school who turned out to be a super genius and skipped a few grades. That kid graduated in my highschool class at 13 years old.
4 years later and he's already got a Masters, co-wrote some papers, and is leading a nano-tech project at a VERY reputable university.
He became an attorney, a well known member of the local LGBTQ community, and was my very best friend for 28 years. He died in a horrible car accident two years ago. His legacy lives on in part by an LGBTQ scholarship for the law school he attended.
He went on to become an eye surgeon. He married the most beautiful woman in San Francisco and they had three amazing boys.
The smartest kid in my class denied a full ride to Harvard to become a priest only to die 1 day after becoming a priest (got hit by a car).
All of the top 10 smart kids stayed in our hometown and are making less than 50k a year or are d***gies.
The bottom 10 of my class are all successful, making over 100k yearly.
I was sure he would become a scientist however he got into music and toured with The Who as a musician and sound guy for the past 20 years.
He got into med school, hated it and then dropped out. Then he became a Drag Queen for a short time. Then he joined some kind of non-profit organization for troubled youth. Then he moved to Paris with his husband and got into modeling. Now he works for OECD in France.
He's done pretty well by all accounts.
He moved to the states to play soccer and ended up going to Penn State. He is a software developer and is doing quite well.
He dropped out of a prestigious, very expensive college junior year because he didn’t understand why he was going into debt for a piece of paper. He joined the navy. Had the government pay him to go get his undergrad and masters. There were lots of sucky years on a submarine, too, but now he’s pretty high up in rank working in the pentagon. Smartest guy I’ve ever met and is beyond hard working.
Hopefully he got his lights punched out at some point. He was always was pulling, "Oh, you got 82 on your test? I only got 98. I suck." humble brag horses**t.
Texas public school. He went to Yale and got a degree in economics. Works in DC now for a state rep. Getting into an MIT asynchronous then in person graduate program.
He is/was my best friend.
Note: this post originally had 71 images. It’s been shortened to the top 30 images based on user votes.
Poll Question
How do you perceive the label 'gifted' in schools?
Necessary for recognizing talent
Creates unnecessary pressure
Only beneficial for some
It's mostly subjective
I was the smartest kid in my class. I did a Master's degree followed by a teaching qualification, then worked as a teacher for 18 years which completely broke me. I know work as a Teaching Assistant ("unskilled", no qualifications required kind of job) and am happier than ever.
As a former gifted kid, I think the gifted kid label is beneficial for some because it got me the proper level of teaching I needed instead of having me repeat what I already knew
I was the smartest kid in my class. I did a Master's degree followed by a teaching qualification, then worked as a teacher for 18 years which completely broke me. I know work as a Teaching Assistant ("unskilled", no qualifications required kind of job) and am happier than ever.
As a former gifted kid, I think the gifted kid label is beneficial for some because it got me the proper level of teaching I needed instead of having me repeat what I already knew