Woman Upset Stepson Won’t Accept His Growing Up Gift, Gives Her A Taste Of Reality
Stepparents will always have a different relationship with their spouse’s children. There are boundaries they should never cross, especially when it involves the mother or father they replaced.
A young man was in this complicated situation with his father’s wife, who showed blatant disdain for his late mom’s memories. Things reached a tipping point one day when he threw out a gift from her for his 18th birthday. Unfortunately, his dad sided against him and accused him of being “spiteful.”
The author had already distanced himself from his father and stepmom, but he asks the AITAH subreddit if he went too far with his actions. Scroll down to read the story below.
Stepfamily relationships are complicated, with boundaries that shouldn’t be crossed
Image credits: DragonImages/Envato (not the actual photo)
A young man threw out a gift from his father’s wife after she disrespected his late mother’s memories
Image credits: ASphotostudio/Envato (not the actual photo)
His dad sided with his stepmom, causing more division in their already strained family dynamic
Image credits: Dry_Butterscotch522
Stepparents must avoid specific actions to keep a harmonious relationship
Image credits: Julia M Cameron/Pexels (not the actual photo)
The stepmom may have overstepped her boundaries, causing the author to distance himself. In an interview with Parents.com, a few experts shared these no-nos. The first on the list is trying to take the other parent’s place.
As parenting expert and stepfamily coach Derek Randel said, “These children are not yours.”
Maligning the ex-spouse is another item on the list. In this case, the woman disrespected the author’s late mother by throwing out all her photos.
According to clinical psychologist Dr. JoAnn Pedro-Carroll, such actions can only damage the child’s psyche, especially if they are repeated messages or actions.
Assuming a position of authority is another mistake mentioned by experts, which the woman made with her controlling behavior. Research has shown that authoritarian parenting isn’t as effective on teenagers because they will likely reject such attempts, which the author did.
Keeping distance from family members is sometimes necessary
Image credits: Alex Urezkov/Pexels (not the actual photo)
While estrangement among family members is unfortunate, it is sometimes necessary. According to psychology professor Dr. Leslie Halpern, it’s usually when the child no longer benefits from the relationship and the parent is incapable of curtailing negative interactions.
“There is no point to continue to maintain a hurtful relationship,” Dr. Halpern said in an interview.
If the situation calls for distancing oneself or cutting ties, family counselor Andrew Roffman advises evaluating the type of relationship you want to establish. Doing so may make things less toxic, especially since blood relations are indelible.
“Family relationships continue on an emotional level whether we are actively in contact or not,” he said.
Roffman adds that putting yourself in the family member’s shoes could also provide possible explanations for their unacceptable behavior, which could ultimately ease the lasting effects of hurtful actions.
In the author’s case, he chose to distance himself since both his father and stepmother have gone against him and continue to harass him even after moving out. It would help him cope and improve his mental health.
What’s your take, readers? Was the young man spiteful, as his parents accused him? Or were his actions warranted?
Most people in the comments sided with the author
But some people had rather controversial takes
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
Are you ESH and AH agree-ers delulu or high on some ganja with moronic side-effects? OP had all the reason in the world to not just cut but destroy all contacts with his "family"! They tried to erase his mother, his pillar of strength! If anything OP should've dumped that album in his sperm donor's face and tell him to keep it because that's "his" family, not OP's. OP being spiteful? I like to call that deserved spitefulness to his sperm donor and the pathetic imposter parading around as a "mother figure". Sheesh!!!
The ganj slows ya down but not that dang far. Blunt force trauma is more likely
Load More Replies...The last comment that the wife wasn't a bad person is bonkers, OP had just lost his mother and she not only forced herself in as a replacement but also tried to erase all memory of her out of jealousy. Throwing these photos away in the deliberate manner he did echoes the way his mum's stuff was disposed of and was the least dad and his wife deserve.
"It was very upsetting and disrespectful when you forced the photo album on me, but now that I reflect on it, it was very cathartic to dump it the way you dumped my mother's things. A big thank you!"
I have to say, I admire the kid, he's a lot stronger than I was at 18, if I'd known then what I know now, I'd have gone NC with my parents a lot sooner. The piece de resistance, tossing the photo album, the symbolism of this feature is a mirror of what his father did with his mother's belongings, it was perfect. I think those telling him to seek therapy mean well, but I think he's well adjusted, and likely because he did have contact with his mother's family, which did some damage control, and helped him keep his memories alive. Maybe some for PTSD because of the trauma inflicted by dad and stepmonster.
Am I the only one to think the mother's death was very convenient and by a means easily and surreptitiously achievable?
No no, very sus honestly. Couple of the comments posted here mentioned it, too, so very likely many comments on the post also mentioned it. It's just....super unnervingly convenient. And the throwing everything away, especially just the two of them? ....yeah.... 👀 😳
Load More Replies...all the esh are basically "hey, a heavily traumatized 18 year old isn't serenely taking absue from adults, how dare he!" They really expect sainthood or gtfo
Yeah, the mom dying of a known allergy and dad just erasing her and marrying again in such a short time frame is way suspicious. Normally you'd at least save the photo albums and some jewelery or a favorite dress.
They were destroying evidence. However the spitfulness of people never fails to amaze me.
Load More Replies...For only being 18, this guy has some real healthy boundaries and responses to pretty toxic behaviors that he had to live though during such a formative period of his life.
NTA, move on and consider things closed. Keep contact with mom's family if possible. Congrats on moving out, sounds like things are finally getting better. Long may it continue.
I’ve read a lot of messed up stuff on Reddit for years, especially the “insane parents” subreddit, and never once has murder come to my mind. Dad definitely killed mom.
That last comment - "It sounds like your dad's wife isn't a bad person". What did that commenter read, because it can't have been this post. I mean, I can see how SHE thinks she's a good person, because most people think that about themselves, but she is deluded if that's the case.
Yeah, all the ESH are forgetting that OP.was/is A CHILD. who traumatically lost his mom. And then lost her again as hus dad and new wife erased all physical memories of her. And he had no say, no choice in any of it. Stop expecting a child to step up and be the bigger person than the parents who can't even be half decent. WTAF
People don't throw away the belongings of the one they lost, and they don't allow pictures to be destroyed. Is the kid sure it was an accidental "poisoning"?
Speaking as someone who has a couple of deadly allergies: It could easily have been intentional. I'm always on the fence about telling people my allergies. On one hand, people who care about me can help me avoid the allergens. On the other hand, someone could easily murder me with that info. On the third hand (lol), some people don't care either way. My ex allergied me three times in one month. The last time, the ER doctor asked to speak to me alone, and asked me if I sure it was "accidental" at that point. I told him I was pretty sure it wasn't intentional, but I would be filing for separation nonetheless. I didn't have an Epi-pen the last time, and my ex walked away and left me alone after he thought I had passed out. I was conscious, but unresponsive, so I heard him walk away and I heard him watching YouTube videos in the other room. I don't know if he tried to kill me, but I know he didn't care if I died.
Load More Replies...My aunt died at age 31. The night of her funeral, her husband met another woman and had her moved in very quickly. She took all the photographs of my aunt, threw them away then threw away my eldest cousin when she objected to it! About 8 years later - I was only a child at the time - I contacted everybody I could think of and got copies of pictures of her and made my cousin a photo album of her mum. Apparently she still looks at it regularly and we're all in our 50s now. Grief never ever stops. Not for one moment. The stepmother and father are sick for thinking a 12yo should just move on after a matter of weeks!
I'm so glad you did that for your cousin. That was so sweet! Thank you for being such an awesome person.
Load More Replies...No negative reaction is too much if someone takes your deceased mother's belongings to the dump, especially PHOTOS. He was fully justified to throw that album in the trash right in front of her. I'd have told her to F herself for good measure and dad too. What they did was equally or more traumatic than even getting hit. I'd have take punches in place of losing photos of someone I loved that is gone.
There's no way that it's ok to throw away pictures of OPs mom. She died and he has the right to have her pictures. Step mom isn't going to win the mother of the year award!
Just a side note, but are any Redditors here who have an idea as to why he did not move to live with the maternal grandparents in the years before he turned 18?
Maybe I watch too much true crime but ITA with those that are side eyeing the manner of the mother's death, the timing of the new relationship & the erasing of all things Mom once the new lady showed up. Was SM a waitress at the restuarant, did Dad already know SM, did Dad make sure Mom didn't have her epiPen that night, was the erasing of all things Mom an effort to make sure the kid didn't start asking these questions? I don't know, I think Mom's family should have opened an investigation. Either way, kid is NTA for tossing the SM's gift. You don't clear all photos & memories of a kids Mom & expect a harmonious relationship to blossom. He had every right to remember his Mom & had SM & Dad respected that maybe their home life could have been better.
Are you ESH and AH agree-ers delulu or high on some ganja with moronic side-effects? OP had all the reason in the world to not just cut but destroy all contacts with his "family"! They tried to erase his mother, his pillar of strength! If anything OP should've dumped that album in his sperm donor's face and tell him to keep it because that's "his" family, not OP's. OP being spiteful? I like to call that deserved spitefulness to his sperm donor and the pathetic imposter parading around as a "mother figure". Sheesh!!!
The ganj slows ya down but not that dang far. Blunt force trauma is more likely
Load More Replies...The last comment that the wife wasn't a bad person is bonkers, OP had just lost his mother and she not only forced herself in as a replacement but also tried to erase all memory of her out of jealousy. Throwing these photos away in the deliberate manner he did echoes the way his mum's stuff was disposed of and was the least dad and his wife deserve.
"It was very upsetting and disrespectful when you forced the photo album on me, but now that I reflect on it, it was very cathartic to dump it the way you dumped my mother's things. A big thank you!"
I have to say, I admire the kid, he's a lot stronger than I was at 18, if I'd known then what I know now, I'd have gone NC with my parents a lot sooner. The piece de resistance, tossing the photo album, the symbolism of this feature is a mirror of what his father did with his mother's belongings, it was perfect. I think those telling him to seek therapy mean well, but I think he's well adjusted, and likely because he did have contact with his mother's family, which did some damage control, and helped him keep his memories alive. Maybe some for PTSD because of the trauma inflicted by dad and stepmonster.
Am I the only one to think the mother's death was very convenient and by a means easily and surreptitiously achievable?
No no, very sus honestly. Couple of the comments posted here mentioned it, too, so very likely many comments on the post also mentioned it. It's just....super unnervingly convenient. And the throwing everything away, especially just the two of them? ....yeah.... 👀 😳
Load More Replies...all the esh are basically "hey, a heavily traumatized 18 year old isn't serenely taking absue from adults, how dare he!" They really expect sainthood or gtfo
Yeah, the mom dying of a known allergy and dad just erasing her and marrying again in such a short time frame is way suspicious. Normally you'd at least save the photo albums and some jewelery or a favorite dress.
They were destroying evidence. However the spitfulness of people never fails to amaze me.
Load More Replies...For only being 18, this guy has some real healthy boundaries and responses to pretty toxic behaviors that he had to live though during such a formative period of his life.
NTA, move on and consider things closed. Keep contact with mom's family if possible. Congrats on moving out, sounds like things are finally getting better. Long may it continue.
I’ve read a lot of messed up stuff on Reddit for years, especially the “insane parents” subreddit, and never once has murder come to my mind. Dad definitely killed mom.
That last comment - "It sounds like your dad's wife isn't a bad person". What did that commenter read, because it can't have been this post. I mean, I can see how SHE thinks she's a good person, because most people think that about themselves, but she is deluded if that's the case.
Yeah, all the ESH are forgetting that OP.was/is A CHILD. who traumatically lost his mom. And then lost her again as hus dad and new wife erased all physical memories of her. And he had no say, no choice in any of it. Stop expecting a child to step up and be the bigger person than the parents who can't even be half decent. WTAF
People don't throw away the belongings of the one they lost, and they don't allow pictures to be destroyed. Is the kid sure it was an accidental "poisoning"?
Speaking as someone who has a couple of deadly allergies: It could easily have been intentional. I'm always on the fence about telling people my allergies. On one hand, people who care about me can help me avoid the allergens. On the other hand, someone could easily murder me with that info. On the third hand (lol), some people don't care either way. My ex allergied me three times in one month. The last time, the ER doctor asked to speak to me alone, and asked me if I sure it was "accidental" at that point. I told him I was pretty sure it wasn't intentional, but I would be filing for separation nonetheless. I didn't have an Epi-pen the last time, and my ex walked away and left me alone after he thought I had passed out. I was conscious, but unresponsive, so I heard him walk away and I heard him watching YouTube videos in the other room. I don't know if he tried to kill me, but I know he didn't care if I died.
Load More Replies...My aunt died at age 31. The night of her funeral, her husband met another woman and had her moved in very quickly. She took all the photographs of my aunt, threw them away then threw away my eldest cousin when she objected to it! About 8 years later - I was only a child at the time - I contacted everybody I could think of and got copies of pictures of her and made my cousin a photo album of her mum. Apparently she still looks at it regularly and we're all in our 50s now. Grief never ever stops. Not for one moment. The stepmother and father are sick for thinking a 12yo should just move on after a matter of weeks!
I'm so glad you did that for your cousin. That was so sweet! Thank you for being such an awesome person.
Load More Replies...No negative reaction is too much if someone takes your deceased mother's belongings to the dump, especially PHOTOS. He was fully justified to throw that album in the trash right in front of her. I'd have told her to F herself for good measure and dad too. What they did was equally or more traumatic than even getting hit. I'd have take punches in place of losing photos of someone I loved that is gone.
There's no way that it's ok to throw away pictures of OPs mom. She died and he has the right to have her pictures. Step mom isn't going to win the mother of the year award!
Just a side note, but are any Redditors here who have an idea as to why he did not move to live with the maternal grandparents in the years before he turned 18?
Maybe I watch too much true crime but ITA with those that are side eyeing the manner of the mother's death, the timing of the new relationship & the erasing of all things Mom once the new lady showed up. Was SM a waitress at the restuarant, did Dad already know SM, did Dad make sure Mom didn't have her epiPen that night, was the erasing of all things Mom an effort to make sure the kid didn't start asking these questions? I don't know, I think Mom's family should have opened an investigation. Either way, kid is NTA for tossing the SM's gift. You don't clear all photos & memories of a kids Mom & expect a harmonious relationship to blossom. He had every right to remember his Mom & had SM & Dad respected that maybe their home life could have been better.
62
44