Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
137
“AITA For What I Said? My Family Won’t Let Me Share Any Good News Because Of My Sister’s Disability”
In a perfect world, family is a place from which a person can draw strength and inspiration in difficult life situations. A group of people who are always ready to help and support, in word and deed. But the perfect world is definitely not the one we live in; in reality, everything is much more complicated.
For example, the user u/CherryOk1649, the heroine of our story today, did her best a few years ago to help and support her older sister after a serious injury. So did all her family. But over the years, the behavior of the parents began to cause more and more concern for the woman. However, let’s talk about everything in order.
More info: Reddit
RELATED:
The author of the post has an elder sister who got heavily injured in an accident 3 years ago
Image credits: Marcus Aurelius (not the actual photo)
The woman was left paralyzed from the waist down since then – and the family rallied to help and support her
Image credits: CherryOk1649
Image credits: Marcus Aurelius (not the actual photo)
However, the author says that her mom tries to shut her down every time she wants to share some good news from her own life
Image credits: CherryOk1649
Image credits: Karolina Kaboompics (not the actual photo)
Over the years, it has started to annoy the woman as she feels like an awful person for being happy around her sister
Image credits: CherryOk1649
So one day when the situation repeated itself, the author just claimed that she thought they’d all be happy for her, and simply left
So, the Original Poster (OP) is 26 years old, and her older sister was in a tragic accident three years ago, which left her paralyzed from the waist down. According to the author, the whole family rallied to help her sister, and our heroine was no exception. Rather, on the contrary, she really did her best… but over time she began to notice that her parents, in particular her mom, were using this situation in a not entirely appropriate way.
All the family members live separately, but the OP feels that when they get together, they regularly try to shut her down if she wants to share any good news or successes from her life. As the author’s mother stated, “so as not to upset her sister.”
The Original Poster got a promotion at work? Hush, it’s not the proper time to tell about it! Her boyfriend proposed to her? Not now, just look at your sister! She might get upset! And so from month to month, from year to year…
No, of course, our heroine realizes that her sister’s life changed drastically literally in one tragic moment. She loves her sister very much and sympathizes with her as well. But time passed, and the woman understood that her parents were blocking almost any manifestation of joyful feelings on her part.
Probably so that the sister would not be hurt – however, her sister herself would never shut her down. Only their mom. And, what’s most offensive, both the parents and the author’s BIL have never been shy about talking about their own successes…
And so, during the next family gathering, our heroine decided to share some more good news with her fam – she had been saving money for her first new car for a long time, and now she was ready to make this purchase. And again, as always, her mother abruptly intervened in her story. But this time the OP objected to her.
The woman loudly declared: “Can’t I share anything good in my life? I thought you’d all be happy for me!” Nobody found anything to say, and the author stormed out of her parents’ house. However, now she is overcome by mixed feelings. On the one hand, she feels awkward in front of her sis. On the other hand, she understands that this really cannot continue. So the OP decided to seek advice online.
Image credits: Liza Summer (not the actual photo)
“I can’t say that the parents of the sisters acted reasonably and wisely in this situation. Quite the contrary,” says Irina Matveeva, a psychologist and certified NLP specialist, with whom Bored Panda got in touch for a comment here.
“No, I do believe that they sincerely wanted to support the eldest daughter, but in doing so they are probably only making things worse for her. They are actually creating an atmosphere of sadness and despondency around her. Not the best atmosphere for any recovery process.”
“As for the younger sister, in my opinion, she did the right thing – after all, in any case, she cannot “preserve” her feelings and emotions for many years. And she’s not to blame for what happened to her sister. So that, it seems to me, it makes sense to talk to the parents again, to explain the reasons for her reaction, and if they don’t understand her – well, then it’s worth sharing the good news with those who are really happy about it,” Irina ponders.
Well, in fact, there are many studies that confirm that it’s crucial for people that the good news they share with important people is fully perceived. It is at this level that that same emotional closeness is created, so important between related people.
“Yet, not being able to authentically share good news with family, friends, and work colleagues can be devastating because it defies our expectations and changes how we think about the people around us,” says Zachary White Ph.D., in his dedicated article on Psychology Today. “Others’ lack of responses can make us feel confused and disconnected from our own experiences in ways that distort our reality.”
In the study on how people perceive good news from others, J. MacLaren Kelly, MAPP, PhD, constructs a matrix of responses to, for example, news about getting promoted at work: Passive Destructive (“Did you end up getting the mail yet or should I ?”), Passive Constructive (“Mmmm, Okay.”), Active Destructive (“That will mean you will have less time for me.”) and Active Constructive (“Wow – that’s terrific news! You deserve it. I’m so happy for you!”). And only an “Active Constructive” answer really supports your well-being.
And well, according to people in the comments, the author’s relatives seem to have formed unhealthy mental patterns around this situation, which is really troubling. “I’d spend less time with your family at your sister’s house. Spend time with your sister, spend time with your family, but stop combining the two so much,” another commenter added quite reasonably.
“Why do you think you owe your sister an apology? You don’t. It’s sad that she is disabled but YOU are entitled to your life” – it’s also hard to disagree with this opinion from one of the responders. And what do you, our dear readers, think about this story? Please feel free to share your comments below the post.
People in the comments almost unanimously sided with the author, advising her to limit the communications with parents then
What do you think ?
KatSaidWhat 5 months ago
Parents going to end up having low or no contact if they keep stifling her happiness.
Pumpkinpi 5 months ago
Not sure why you got downvoted because you’re absolutely right! This poor woman is going to cut her parents out of her life if they keep hindering her happiness. Here’s an upvote to counter the downvote.
Load More Replies...
Alexandra 5 months ago
This is insane. Contrary to all the efforts of so many people to show that being disabled doesn't mean you can't achieve or are not worth listening to, OP's mother has made her daughter's disability the centre of the universe for her other daughter, thus keeping both daughters hostage. Yes, the sister is disabled and yes, it's very sad and must be hard for her but no, it doesn't mean you can't be glad for someone else or have empathy for someone else. If hearing your sister's good news is enough for you to break down, you should see someone on the double. My guess is that the mother hasn't dealt with her daughter's disability and is projecting. Oh and yes, my husband is disabled and has been for more than 30 years.
AKA AKA 5 months ago (edited)
i feel like the sister would more likely to be happy for op than pi$$ed, and yes she will feel sad but i dont think its right to hide everything from the sister. she isnt a child, she's a fully grown adult who probebly wants to know, imagine how she will feel getting a wedding invite and not even knowing they were engaged. only AH here are the parents
KatSaidWhat 5 months ago
Parents going to end up having low or no contact if they keep stifling her happiness.
Pumpkinpi 5 months ago
Not sure why you got downvoted because you’re absolutely right! This poor woman is going to cut her parents out of her life if they keep hindering her happiness. Here’s an upvote to counter the downvote.
Load More Replies... Alexandra 5 months ago
This is insane. Contrary to all the efforts of so many people to show that being disabled doesn't mean you can't achieve or are not worth listening to, OP's mother has made her daughter's disability the centre of the universe for her other daughter, thus keeping both daughters hostage. Yes, the sister is disabled and yes, it's very sad and must be hard for her but no, it doesn't mean you can't be glad for someone else or have empathy for someone else. If hearing your sister's good news is enough for you to break down, you should see someone on the double. My guess is that the mother hasn't dealt with her daughter's disability and is projecting. Oh and yes, my husband is disabled and has been for more than 30 years.
AKA AKA 5 months ago (edited)
i feel like the sister would more likely to be happy for op than pi$$ed, and yes she will feel sad but i dont think its right to hide everything from the sister. she isnt a child, she's a fully grown adult who probebly wants to know, imagine how she will feel getting a wedding invite and not even knowing they were engaged. only AH here are the parents
You May Like “Am I A Jerk For Not Letting My Mother-In-Law See My Baby Until I Put Cameras Up In My Home?” “[Am I The Jerk] For Refusing To Pay For My MIL’s Broken Phone Screen After My Toddler Threw It?” Guy Seeks Advice Online: “My Family Invited My Ex To Thanksgiving And Christmas”
Rugilė Žemaitytė
Monika Pašukonytė
Rugilė Žemaitytė
Related on Bored Panda
58
35