
Woman Attends Upscale Birthday Party, Ends Up Paying For Her Own Meal And Losing A Friendship
Interview With ExpertMoney has a way of sneaking into friendships, doesn’t it? Whether it’s splitting bills or keeping up with group trips to places that look like they’re straight out of a perfectly curated Pinterest board, navigating finances with friends is a delicate thing.
It’s not just about who has more or less, it’s about managing expectations, setting boundaries, and avoiding those awkward moments when the check arrives. Which is exactly what one Redditor experienced when her friend invited her to a birthday party but forgot to mention she had to bring a wad of cash with her.
More info: Reddit
Having good friends is priceless—until you’re handed a dinner bill that says otherwise
Image credits: frantic / Freepik (not the actual photo)
One woman and her husband were shocked when they had to pay over $200 for dinner at her friend’s birthday party, despite being her guests
Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Despite being on a tight budget, the woman and her husband agree to attend the party, where they are assured by the waiter that the meal would be paid for by the host
Image credits: Mikhail Nilov / Pexels (not the actual photo)
At the end of the dinner, the hosts say they are only covering the wine, leaving the woman and her husband to pay $211 for their food
Image credits: Curated Lifestyle / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
The shocked couple ends up paying for their meal, despite being told their friends would cover the entire dinner
Image credits: anonymous
The woman sends a text to her friend the next day, saying she would appreciate a heads-up the next time she has to pay that much for a meal, but ends up being ghosted by her
The OP (original poster) and her husband had been invited—by the OP’s wealthy friend—to an upscale birthday bash for the friend’s husband. Private room? Booked. Fancy menus? Check. Dancing afterward? Sure, why not? But see, the OP and her hubby decided to keep it low-budget, thanks to some wallet-draining home renovations. They planned to split the food and each sip on a single drink like refined penny-pinchers.
When they arrived, however, they were handed pre-planned menus that made their à la carte dreams disappear faster than a free sample at a supermarket. Still, no worries, the waiter assured them the hosts were footing the bill. The OP and her hubby let out a few sighs of relief while indulging in guilt-free bites of fancy steak.
But then, at the end of the night, the birthday guy announced they were only covering the wine, leaving the guests to pay for their meals. The OP’s total? A gut-punching $211. For a meal that was supposed to be a celebratory evening, it turned into a real financial horror show. I don’t know about you, but I’d be furious at that point.
Understandably rattled, the OP messaged her friend the next day to gently suggest a heads-up in the future. Nothing aggressive, just a polite, “Let us know next time.” Her friend replied with a breezy apology but has ghosted her ever since. Even after 3 months, every attempt at coffee dates or girls’ nights has been left on read. So, the OP was left wondering if she was wrong to have said something.
Image credits: Liza Summer / Pexels (not the actual photo)
To find out more about this topic, Bored Panda reached out to America’s trusted etiquette expert, Thomas P. Farley, also known as Mister Manners, for some comments. He told us that if you’re hosting a group for a special occasion, it’s generally understood that guests don’t pay for their meals, whether it’s a casual get-together or a wedding.
However, there are rare instances where asking for contributions is acceptable, such as if a group of friends decides to hire a private chef or friends gather at someone’s house to watch a game and decide to order food.
For a birthday celebration at an expensive restaurant, the organizer should make expectations clear by wording the invitation like this: “Luisa turns 40 next month. I’d love for any of us who are interested to treat her to dinner at her favorite restaurant. Here is a link to the menu. Please let me know if you’d like to join.”
We wanted to know which common mistakes hosts make when inviting guests to events involving shared costs. Farley shared that not communicating the need for contributions upfront is the biggest mistake.
Hosts shouldn’t expect guests to pay for something without making it clear beforehand. It’s uncomfortable for guests to find out after the fact, and definitely not ideal for a host to request money later, especially if it wasn’t previously discussed.
We asked Farley how a guest could tactfully ask about costs before attending a party or gathering. He explained that asking about costs should not be a concern for most gatherings. It’s generally the host’s responsibility to communicate any financial expectations.
However, if a guest suspects there will be substantial costs, they can approach it gracefully by asking something like, “What can I bring?” or “You’re doing such an amazing job organizing this event—can I contribute in any way to help with the expenses?”
Because let’s face it, money isn’t just paper, it’s a whole vibe, and sometimes, that vibe can make things awkward for friendships. The wealth gap between friends can feel like being the only person without a VIP pass at a concert. To avoid this, the key is transparency. If you’re the friend with a smaller budget, don’t hesitate to suggest wallet-friendly plans. Movie night at home? A potluck picnic? Yes, please.
On the flip side, if you’re the one who’s balling out, consider picking up the tab occasionally or offering options that won’t leave anyone feeling like they’re on an episode of Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous.
So, was the Redditor wrong for asking her friend to be more upfront? Or was her friend overreacting? Let us know your take in the comments below!
Netizens side with the woman, saying she is not the jerk in this story and that her friend has no reason to be upset with her
Poll Question
What should the host have done differently at the birthday party?
Clearly communicate costs upfront
Cover all guest expenses
Choose a more budget-friendly venue
Set clear expectations
Honestly I would have flagged down the waiter that told them it was covered. It's obviously not cool of the hosts to stick their guests with the bill for a pre-planned meal but the staff should also take some accountability as the couple obviously would have ordered something less expensive had they been told the truth. They were originally under the impression they would pay for themselves which is why they asked to order something less expensive. I would have just told the staff "I was told this would be covered, sorry but I can't afford this."
I would have said thank you for the meal happy birthday have a nice night and leave. Since the wait staff said it was covered by them. You have no responsibility towards the bill.
It sounds to me like the "hosts" saw how much the bill was and THEN claimed they were only covering the wine because it was so expensive. Not surprising because if one couple was $200+ and there were 15 people, well, you do the math. I'd call BS on that.
Oh I guarantee you the hostess knew what the price per head was...if you book a private room with a preset menu the restaurant tells you the price per person when you book your reservation... She was hoping her husband wouldn't object and embarrassed herself.
Honestly I would have flagged down the waiter that told them it was covered. It's obviously not cool of the hosts to stick their guests with the bill for a pre-planned meal but the staff should also take some accountability as the couple obviously would have ordered something less expensive had they been told the truth. They were originally under the impression they would pay for themselves which is why they asked to order something less expensive. I would have just told the staff "I was told this would be covered, sorry but I can't afford this."
I would have said thank you for the meal happy birthday have a nice night and leave. Since the wait staff said it was covered by them. You have no responsibility towards the bill.
It sounds to me like the "hosts" saw how much the bill was and THEN claimed they were only covering the wine because it was so expensive. Not surprising because if one couple was $200+ and there were 15 people, well, you do the math. I'd call BS on that.
Oh I guarantee you the hostess knew what the price per head was...if you book a private room with a preset menu the restaurant tells you the price per person when you book your reservation... She was hoping her husband wouldn't object and embarrassed herself.
14
36