Woman Reminds Everyone That Childfree People Also Have Families After Being Asked To Give Up Her Holiday For A Coworker That Has Kids
InterviewRecently, TikToker Callie who goes by the handle @_cal_cifer shared a video that sparked a heated debate on the internet.
In a short video, Callie said parents should not expect to be given priority when taking holidays just because they don’t have kids. “No, No!” the woman said in response to a comment from a follower who said that parents should get annual leave first, especially during the school holidays.
Scroll down to find out Callie’s point of view, and let us know your thoughts about it in the comment section below!
TikToker Callie sparked a heated discussion stating how it’s unfair that parents get priority in taking annual leave just because they have kids
Image credits: _cal_cifer
This video Callie shared on her TikTok channel took the internet by storm
@_cal_cifer Replying to @mymichaelryan Oh well so sad, bye rocco….. #childfreebychoice #childfreetiktok #childfreemillennial #entitledparents #workhorrorstory #badbosses #pto #vacation ♬ original sound – Callie
To find out an expert’s opinion on this controversial debate, Bored Panda reached out to Christine Mitterbauer, a licensed career and life coach, and serial entrepreneur who agreed that “this is a difficult one.”
“I am a parent myself, but in my opinion, whoever is the most organized and schedules the time off first, should get the holiday,” she said.
Mitterbauer argues that “an employee without children might have just as valid reasons for wanting the same week off as another employee with children.”
Moreover, “Parents get enough notice about when the school holidays are, so there’s no excuse not to plan ahead,” the career coach concluded.
Many people supported Callie’s point of view
Some people, on the other hand, disagreed with the author and shared what they think about the case
“An employee without children might have just as valid reasons..." Wanting time off is a valid enough reason and don't let anyone tell you otherwise.
Exactly. In a way we are saving the world by NOT reproducing. So aren't we entitled to stuff also? On a serious note i do agree. I mean hell last i checked you have a kid you SHOULD be able to afford them. Not ask for handouts and free off time. Your choice to have them. Why do us childless people have to be penalized?
Load More Replies...Hm, I dunno. You choosing to have children and then expecting me to be lenient whenever it suits you because 'memories with kids' really isn't a valid reason. I've got memories to make of my own, that are not less valuable just because they don't involve children. I understand how people may feel that way, but the possibility of not being able to spend a Christmas or whatever with your kids is just part of the deal. Be creative, think of an alternative. However, in practise, I'd rather eat my own toenails than go on holidays during summer season because everything sucks during summer season (peak seasons) :') So for me it usually works out, but my employer never really has issues with lots of people taking time off at the same time. Building is closed during Christmas anyway.
I really resent the poster who said 'oh you can work christmas but then you can get new years off to go drink an get drunk.' Do you think that if you don't have kids you're of course some drunken frat boy just looking to party? I'm 43 and I don't have kids and I want the holiday off because I like having the extra day off. I don't care if I'm sleeping all day- my reasons are mine and shouldn't have to be explained to anyone as being more or less worthy. I'm also not being selfish because I want to go 'party'. The problem is the company forcing people to work on those days. Don't take out your frustration toward the company on the people you work with because they got it off and you didn't. It's not their fault and they shouldn't be penalized for the company's greed. I get wanting to have holiday with your kids while they're young but if it THAT important to you then you should try to find a job that isn't open on holidays-which is the real problem.
I resent that same poster. I'm childfree as well. I LOVE Christmas, but can't be bothered with new year. Last time I properly went out for it was early 21, I think. I'm now 35. I will say, I'm lucky with the job I've had for most of my working life. Weekends and Bank Holidays guaranteed off. So I'm always off for a few days over Christmas. I now live with my parents and work from home in the same job, which is even better. I don't mind working during Christmas, because I still get to spend Christmas with my family around it. When I lived out of home and worked in the office, I at least would have a couple of days. But, I did work in a place for a couple of years, where the manager obce made a clear point of saying in a team meeting that if she had her way, those without children would never get Christmas off, ever. I was the only person on the team without either a child, or a child on the way. I was off that Christmas, and her favourite team members weren't, so she was annoyed.
Load More Replies...I love the ebtitled parent who jumped in the comments to say that it's different once you have kids. Schedule off like everyone else.
Seriously. Their work life is entirely separate from their personal life. If something happens at work, then it’s a problem they share with their coworkers. But their children are part of their personal life—-and therefore NOT their coworkers’ problem. So if people with kids can’t plan vacations ahead of time, like right when the school calendar comes out, then the rest of us should not be penalized for it. Additionally, how do essential workers handle not being home on Christmas or Thanksgiving, or birthdays, or other special events? The most levelheaded ones I’ve known plan ahead, or make alternative plans. For example, if they’re working Christmas Day but off Christmas Eve, then switch the big celebration to Christmas Eve. You get the idea. Unless you’re NEVER available on any of those days throughout your children’s lives, believe me, they’ll be OK if you miss one here and there and/or have to make alternative plans.
Load More Replies...This happened to me. I’m originally from the UK and was not as aware of spring break holidays when I moved to the US for my work. I was told by my psycho boss that I was being disrespectful of my peers with children when I took time off to see family back home during spring break since I didn’t have kids. I was embarrassed, disgusted, and hurt and quite soon after.
You should've gone to HR and complained. You could also sue because of the hostile work environment. Don't let anyone bully you at work.
Load More Replies...Your crotch goblins come at a price, and why should I have to pay it? You choose the kid life and have to deal with that decision. I chose childfree, and have just as much right to visit my distant family when they come to town.
I am so going to use the phrase "crotch goblins" next time a coworker asks me to take their shift so they can spend it "with the kids" 😂
Load More Replies...I work every other Christmas day and i will not work for someone because they chose to have kids. If you don't want to work Christmas find another job or work in a school to have the kids holidays off. Making memories with children are not any more important than me making memories with my family. Also for the first few years the kids don't even know what the day is anyway so it can easily be pushed to the day after without them even aware of it
My first long-term job uses to split the shifts at Christmas so everyone worked a few hours. That meant everyone got to spend time with family. My next place alternated years. You've got to make it fair. Yes people with kids want to spend time with them and make memories. But people without kids still have parents, grandparents, siblings, neices nephews. Lots of family members that they want to spend time with and make memories with. With school holidays one job used to prioritise people with kids but my mum worked in a school and my little brother was still a student. This meant they could only take leave on school holidays. It was so hard to get a family vacation because I could never get the time off when they were available.
Load More Replies...If you CHOOSE to take Christmas shifts to free-up time for your co-workers with kids, bully for you. Kudos, hand clapping, pat yourself on the back. But don't expect anyone else to think your self-sacrifice needs to be some rule, anymore than me donating to a particular charity means everyone else should, too.
This happened to me once. Walked out of that job and into another one. Bought a gold wedding band at Walmart, borrow pictures of the neighbor's kids put it in my wallet, told everyone I was married. Are refused to have my vacation time put on the back burner to somebody else's needs.
Nope. Your kids are not my problem. If you want off, you schedule it like everyone else on a first come/first served basis. If you don't get your first choice because someone beat you to it, tough luck.
This is how it works in my company. We don't work Christmas day or the 26th anyway, so thats good. If obe falls on a Saturday or Sunday, we get the next weekday off in lieu, as we don't work weekends. This year, Christmas day is a Sunday, so we h finish on Friday, then we are not open again until the Wednesday. The boon of a highly regulated industry. After that, it's booked though a system. First come first served. Extra hours get released closer to Christmas, that don't use the system. For those This year, I'm taking time at the start of December and leaving Christmas to the parents. I have no kids, I work from home, and have as much time off as I want.
Load More Replies...In some countries, it is not possible for parents to take their children out of school during term time for a holiday. If they do, they can face legal repercussions. This means a lots of people with children are trying to take holidays in the same few weeks. To be honest, it's brilliant when you aren't constrained by term times and can go places when it's cheaper and less expensive.
So true. I've just booked a holiday to disneyland paris for me and a friend. Both mid thirties, no kids. We are going for a week in May. I had the freedom to choose any dates, so picked a time of reasonable weather, less kids, cheaper prices.. brilliant!
Load More Replies...I'm a mother of two and a bartender, Thursday night is my regular shift. Guess who worked Thanksgiving? Me, because I'm not pawning that off on anyone else, we ALL have families, in one form or another, mine is no more or less important. This mentality is absurd
First up, best dressed. If you have booked time off work (for whatever your reasons) then you get priority, if YOU choose to alter your plans to accommodate someone else’s needs that is your prerogative, BUT if you choose to keep your original request then that’s fine. It is part of your package that your employer has agreed with you, it’s not conditional on another member of staff having a need to see their children. Sorry breeders, you need to plan your lives as well as everyone else.
I missed every Christmas during my dad’s sickness, including 2 he was on the transplant list just because my coworkers had kids and ‘needed it more.’ They still have their kids but my dad is gone. We could have done half days so mornings with their kids and lunch and dinner with my dad, but no. And I will never get those holidays back. Even without small kids holidays matter. Screw every employee that f****d me over with that excuse. Work with people and we won’t leave you stranded at the busiest time of year with only 2 weeks to find a replacement (the replacement never came)
Really sorry that this happened to you. People don't just f*cking think, do they?
Load More Replies...I think the bottom line here is everyone has lives outside of work and you never know how long you have with your loved ones regardless if they are kids or not. It does not mean those memories are less valid than those with children. As I said you don't know how long you have. Edit: Companies have added to the issue. I worked somewhere and when I found out about my brothers death there response was to work it will take your mind off of it. I did not get a time to grieve and as of now I don't think I have properly grieved. I just don't want anyone to go through the same thing.
I have another children-related topic to discuss. Bringing your children to work: should it be a norm and why not? I worked in a tiny entrepreneurial company with just two people (me included) not being the founders. Our director had a baby and since then she participated in everything with her daughter. I felt like it's a very cool thing for her but not a good one for me or for the other employee as we both weren't children people at all and trying to concentrate on an upcoming season's budget is a bit hard when a toddler is crying or cooing or whatever. What do you think?
All the time? Weird. Collegues have taken their kids to work to show them around. One did it twice in 20 years for half an hour or an hour and a few others did it once for an hour or so.
Load More Replies...At my store everyone had to work either Christmas eve or Christmas day. No one gets both days off. Ever. I put out a sign up sheet with the times & they have to pick day & time. I have employees with & without kids but we all have family we want to be with. I've done this for 15yrs & it's worked out great.
Why isn't your store closed on Christmas? I'm assuming your store is a gas station/convenience store or pharmacy but it's still too bad that you have to be open on Christmas day.
Load More Replies...The years I've missed out on time with family, especially those who are dead now because I was stuck with working shifts my "parent" coworkers called off on was sickening. My many visits to hr for writeups for me not coming in because I was to be off and my schedule got changed "last minute"...not even the days regulated to parents....you work and deal with it.
When I was child-free, I didn't mind not taking annual leave during summer-in the UK, schools are off for 6 weeks over summer and taking vacations then is usually more expensive and resorts are full of kids, so I was happy taking leave at other times. I was also happy being on call over Christmas, because I don't celebrate it. But I have to say, I found that colleagues who were parents were far more likely to abuse leave policies than those who weren't. Maybe I just had selfish colleagues, but we had one with 3 children who routinely arrived late and left early to collect her kids from school (whilst being paid for a full day's work, and with sanction from our line manager, who was a friend of hers, because 'it's difficult being a mother'). We had another who refused to use her annual leave to take her kids to the dentist/doctor/meetings at school etc and instead insisted this was an emergency, even for preplanned visits. I don't mind working with parents, but some take the p**s.
When I was single, my response to my coworkers with kids trying to manipulate me into letting them have MY days off/vacation time off, for no other reason than they have kids, was basically me saying that I would like to find someone, get married, and have kids too. Then asking them how TF can I do that if I’m working every weekend and holiday for YOU? NO, I will NOT swap with you. I have a life too. Even when I did finally meet my now husband and get married, just because I didn’t have kids right away, they STILL tried to pull that same b******t! I shut them down again, only this time it was How do you expect me to have a baby when my husband and I don’t get to spend time together because I’m working YOUR shift? NO, I will NOT switch with you!
I had a job once where we switched out working weekends and on Father's day weekend I overheard my supervisor telling someone they could put me on to work as I didn't have a father. (My dad had died some months before.) I still can't believe she said that.
People can be really insensitive and awful. Sorry that this happened and condolences for your loss.
Load More Replies...Growing up, my dad worked shift work a lot of the time. They had an unwritten rule that nobody asks off for Christmas because they all had families. When he worked the graveyard shift, we would open presents as soon as he got home and he would nap before work. If he worked the evening shift we, would open presents early and we would have a lunchtime dinner before he went to work. If he worked the day shift, we opened presents before he went to work and did Christmas dinner when he got home. Nobody at his job had to sacrifice a holiday for us to make memories. When he’s been at the job more than 25 years a fella asked of for Christmas. My dad told him that nobody asked off because that meant others would have to work k er time to cover his shift and that if he insisted on keeping the request, my dad threatened to use his seniority and request it off and that fella would be one of the ones working overtime. Needless to say, he withdrew his request. If a working parent tries hard enough
If you can't keep it in your pants, at least keep it out of my vacation calendar.
We are scheduled 9 hours, clocking out for 1 hour lunch. Had a coworker (salaried), arrange with her boss that she would come in at 830 after dropping her daughter at school, and work until 5. Except she still took an hour lunch. And didn't come in until 9 "because daughter made her late". Summer vacation - still showing up at 9. Daughter starts Jr high and goes in at 730 - mom still coming in at 9. I wouldn't mind the flexibility for parents if they didn't blatantly abuse it.
With or without kids shouldn’t matter, whoever asked for it off first. The worst though was when I went into labor over a holiday weekend and they told my husband too bad, other coworkers had already asked for the weekend off. He dropped me at the hospital, used his lunch break to come for the delivery. I had to find a ride home the next day. That is another scenario, but that, and emergencies (death, medical, etc) are the only situations that should take priority.
USPS employee here. Prime time vacation is chosen by seniority, rest of the year is first come first serve. I raised 3 by myself and never expected special consideration. Sometimes you win, sometimes you don't ( didn't say "lose" because this was a good lesson for them). Another person I knew would just use sick leave if she couldn't get those days. We could see that coming a mile away!
I had a job where the manager could not/would not have a set schedule for anyone but one guy. I didn't care what he did, but I wanted it then be a 'cookie cutter' M,T 6-2 Th 10-4 Sat 2-10pm and rinse/repeat each week. So I could then schedule my home life around work. BUT NO, each week was different, try to figure out when I could or would attend games for one daughter and be able to get the other one to her lessons. I didn't last,but 5 weeks. Too much chaos for home life.
And just because a fellow employee says they have children doesn't guarantee they actually have children.
"Think about that child's memories" .... how bout no? I didn't tell you to have kids. I didn't knock you up! Your kids rent my fucken problem! Lol. It's not my responsibility to plan my PTO for another person. Why in the f**k would I plan my own time off around another persons schedule just because I don't have kids? If you want those days off... request them off first. Otherwise f**k off! Why should you get preferential treatment when I put in my request weeks or months before you? So Im supposed to plan my vacation days.. hwhich I requested off accordingly...) & then change all of my plans at the drop of a hat just because Kathy didn't follow protocol & just assumed that she could f**k up my days off all because she has kids? Ya.. no. I don't think so! What about my memories? What about the valuable time I have left with my own parents? Don't you think my parents want to their kids on the holidays!? Why are your kids or family more important than anyone else's? Why
As a parent of 3, I can get behind that rationale as long as we apply that same approach to collecting social security
Ok, I'm intrigued by this comment, what exactly are you saying here?
Load More Replies...Good points. Companies should make it as fair as possible like alternating years and stuff like that (you have Christmas off, so you work New Year's). Allowing only parents to take off holidays is just discrimination based on family status and people who don't have kids or who have adult kids should have a fair chance of getting the day off. I do work somewhere where there needs to always be people because a chemical plant can't monitor itself.
I mean, what about the parents of the child free person? How can they spend their holiday with their adult child if the child is working? My mom still wants us to come visit during Christmas and summertime. I have no kids, my brother has two, and those are the times of year we get to visit with each other (and March break.) Fortunately we are all teachers, but my dad wasn't. His schedule rotated so one year he'd be off for Christmas, and the next year he'd be on call (he worked for the natural gas supplier in town, so only needed to work in case of emergencies on holidays, same thing with weekends and nights, two people always had to be on call in case someone smelled a leak.)
Companies have problems with this kind of thing when they lack policies and processes for scheduling vacations and instead leave it to individual managers to ‘work it out”. First come, first serve doesn’t work as someone can request all the desirable days. Basing it on family status is discriminatory. The only fair way to do it is to collect all the requests for prime vacation days and have a total. So if you work Christmas one year, you don’t work it the next year but you work Thanksgiving. Ties are broken by seniority or by lot. But this requires both the company and the manager to plan and discuss it.
No children by choice here. When I was a bartender and single I always volunteered to work holidays. I did Christmas or T-Day on the following Saturday. So I got an actual weekend free and coworkers could spend the holiday with kids and family and people are generous with tips and gifts when you're working a holiday. Then I got married and settled into an office job. Female coworker had a tradition of day after thanksgiving shopping with her adult daughter so I worked. I moved departments and the young lady I worked with was divorced with young child. I worked whatever holiday her son had off so she could spend time with him. I never scheduled vacations around spring break times anyway because everything was more expensive and booked. I'm an off season tourist. NYC in February is cheaper and less crowded. September and October at the beach or in Canada is also a good time because all the kids are back in school and it's hurricane season on the coast. Just get travel insurance 😉
I chose to work holidays, it was double time and a half. I was in a nationwide telecommunication repair service and it was essential service. On Christmas day, I think I got 2 calls in 6 hours. On a normal day I would get 20-30 calls an hour. We got PTO according to seniority, I was high on the seniority list with more years so I got to choose my days off accordingly.
As a person with three kids I absolutely agree that I should not get priority and that child free people should get the time they want off, too, BUT the one little spammer in the works is CHILD CARE. I had to squeeze out some extra time off last school holidays because our usual vacation care changed there hours and we were unable to get spots anywhere else. They also close for 4 weeks over Christmas, assuming that parents’ workplaces are shut down then (I’m a nurse - mine doesn’t). Arranging around childcare is an absolute nightmare, sometimes.
People without children still want to make memories and see their families. Also, if you work Christmas day...your kids don't HAVE to open up gifts while you're on shift. The gifts don't evaporate. Have your Christmas celebration on the 23rd, the 24th, or the 26th. I didn't know the difference as a kid and sometimes it was way after Christmas when we opened gifts because we wanted to wait for some family to fly in (and their flights got delayed).
If I know I want a holiday off, I book it off months in advance. I have heard other coworkers complain that they had to work a holiday. I tell them that they should book it off, months in advance. If you can't do that, then stop complaining, because it is your own fault you have to work.
I don't have kids, but my niece would be very upset if I wasn't there for Christmas! Also, we deserve holidays with our parents, siblings, etc, too, even if we don't have kids of our own. I am beyond grateful I celebrated my dad's last Christmas with him.
Why would you need time off and not request it in advance? They literally give you a whole calendar of school days off when school starts. If you want those days off take that thing straight in way back in August and start getting it worked out instead of trying to put people out like you didn't know they get a week off for spring break, Christmas, etc the day before it happens. I used to work at a place that gave holidays off based on seniority and the employees picked their top 3 and they made sure everyone got at least one. I thought that worked pretty well and was fair...however, most of us worked the holidays though bc we worked for tips and it was the busiest time of the year. As a parent and an employee, you literally go into a job knowing you won't get to spend as much time with your child as a SAHP would. That's just the facts, regardless of whether you are there bc you want to be or bc you have to be.🤷🏼
As a person who has no kids I have worked for parents many times at holidays if I had nothing going on I was happy to do it. Sometimes more for the kid than the parents. But it is all the other times we have to cover for them. They have a doctor appointment, have to go take kids lunch to school parent teacher meeting, kid sick and they have to be home. Running late coming in because something with kid, leave early to go see kids game or dance. There are many more.
Plus we do not get to do that. I have been told many times when I was younger that someday when you have kids you will get it back. I don't have kids. Where I work now the company encourages for family time for everyone and it can be scheduled.
Load More Replies...Ask for the time in a timely manner..it is not my problem if you can't do that..and YES..I have kids..2 of them
People with kids are generally contributing to the future, unlike all you selfish, neurotic millenials. The positive side of this is everyone expecting equality and not equity. Equity would give the family man more time off. Equality says, "nah, everyone gets the same amount of days regardless of how many kids you have." Time off is time off, you shouldn't even need a reason if it's allotted in your contract. I get it. I just don't get why everyone is so antihuman. We're living in the easiest time to be alive.
I requested PTO 6 months in advance for an out-of-state family wedding, with flight/hotel/car rental all booked, and my request was approved. 1 month before event date, boss told me that a coworker wanted PTO during that timeframe. I told him of all my pre-arrangements, so he told coworker "no-go" for them!!!!!
Have you not heard of people going away to see family. Many families get together for holidays and its a big thing. All businesses that are non essential should be closed for holidays have compassion for their workers. As for spring break is not a holiday. Whom ever puts in for that time first should get it. Parents know in august. But they also have all damn summer. Christmas is not just for parents. I took that time to spend with my family grandparents and parents. But yes if you work in a company that is open its usually based on seniority and switch out like if you take thanks giving you work Christmas. Blah blah blah.
We don't have kids. However I work in a school, so my husband likes to book his days off in school holidays. A few times, he has been asked to swap by someone with kids, more often than not he agrees provided he is asked nicely and before we have booked something. It's a pain only getting holidays when kids are off because a lot of stuff is more expensive. Luckily, he and his co-workers talk about holiday plans in a friendly manner. As his family is in a different country, he is very firm about his summer but in return he checks with others before things like Christmas and Easter.
Re: that last comment. I'm a childfree woman who has gone on holidays with siblings and niblings before. Said niblings attend school, therefore the holiday is going to be set in the school holidays. So bite me, Karen. Also, screw "making memories", it doesn't just apply to children. My dad has Parkinson's and has a limited number of Christmases left. I want to enjoy every single one, so sorry Karen but your healthy kids who will not care if you're there or not as long as they get presents do not trump my dad. And finally, my mum was a nurse who sometimes worked Christmas day. We kids managed to survive to adulthood without expiring of sadness cuz mum explained that sometimes she had to go and look after the sick people in hospital on Christmas and make it a better day for them. We understood.
When my children were younger, we drew holidays with the caveat that no person worked the same holiday two years in a row. For the most part we worked what we drew w/o complaint. After my children grew up if a co-worker with small children drew Christmas morning, I always offered to switch with them. But that was my choice, not a requirement
Dang what happened to avoiding families on holidays? I'm a first responder and the new/young childless employees would always cover for the ones without and for more senior coworkers. Once you get some seniority and start having kids, you get that luxury for a long longer than you give. But I guess other jobs work on Christmas too and act like they work from 6 am to midnight. Get a job/employer that fits your needs better. Those kids will be the next generation and let's not pass down the generational trauma. Kids are the worse they've been emotionally ever and it's really sad. It takes everyone to make the world a better place.
Maybe they needed time off due to child care, none of you are considering the fact that maybe because of the fact that they probably don't have anyone else to watch their kids while they are off from school could be a valid reason also. If that's the case they should take priority over those without children, because they don't need to worry about another living beings safety. They can leave the house whenever they want for however long they want, when you have kids everything is on a time restriction and if they are not of age for school or if school is out of session and they don't have any other option for child care, it would most certainly be an issue. So no I don't feel the parent in the situation is wrong, it's not about an employee or coworker feeling that they should have more priority over another because they have children, it's about the fact that the parent needs to work to provide, but if they don't have child care of some sort they can't provide, it's math people!!!
When I was younger, I was sacrificed on holidays and time off at my job(s) because of being overlooked on time off with my own family. I didn't have children. I am now 50 and most the family I had spent time with are no longer here. I wished I had fought for my time off now. Assuming that others don't have anything of importance to do outside of work is selfish. Thinking someone should be less than anyone else because they have no children is selfish. I have a lot of regrets and now only memories of long ago of my family sitting down to Thanksgiving. You should be turning your anger to company's that don't close for holidays not each other.
This is hard. As a young single person I personally would take a shift for a coworker on a holiday in a heartbeat so they could spend it with their kids/elderly parents/whoever, but I'm a weirdo who loves working holidays. I think workplaces should have more flexibility for all workers needs regardless of familial status. However I do understand that single parents especially sometimes need a specific school holiday off or something, but kids don't need both parents home every school holiday each year. Everyone should plan ahead as best they are able, however sick days are different. I think you should be able to use them for yourself or to care for a child/spouse/etc. I would never go on vacation during school holiday as a non-parent $$$ and too crowded.
At my old job, I looked at the calendar in February and realized that Christmas and New Year were on Thursday. So I put in my vacation request for both Fridays, giving myself two 4 day weekends to spend with my Mom. We just recently lost my Dad in January, so I knew the holidays would be difficult for her. Come October, two Moms I worked with finally took the time to look at their calendars and complained to management that I shouldn't be able to have both days off. Management tried to convince me to change my plans, but I refused, and I had the signed time-off requests, so there wasn't anything they could do. Got a lot of attitude, and in the end the owner decided to close the day after Christmas so they could have it off. My life and plans were not less important because I hadn't reproduced!
"But I have kids! I want to spend time with them during the holidays!" Yes, MY parents also want to spend time with their kids during the holidays. I have a child but I don't make that everyone else's responsibility. First come, first serve, alternate the schedule. Parents should not get every holiday off just cause they have kids.
As a mother of five I would like to say failure to plan on my part you should never constitute an emergency on someone else's. Yes it's very important that I have time off of my children are off school. I'm old enough and smart enough to know that that takes planning.
To Stephanie Jean- while most places are closed on holidays I think they mean the whole week before a major holiday,coworkers with kids feel entitled to it because their kids are off school, not thinking about a childless coworker whose family may live far with elderly parents who may not be in the best heath or whatever, just miss their mom and dad! As a mom, I would've LOVED such a rule but I KNOW its not fair to the person who asked before me or has more seniority. My office is unionized and its done by seniority for our yearly vacation bid then by first come first served after that. I have given up a week in June that I wanted to spend with my adult, childless girls who live an 8 hour drive from me but chose a different week so my coworker with a young daughter could have it.
At the beginning of every school year I would go through the calendar and request off for the days my kids were out of school. With that being said, I made so little as a single mom that if I were unable to take that time off I would be forced to call in. I didn't make enough to pay for daycare and that's a sad reality for a lot of parents. And no, I was not single and broke when I had kids. That came after and unexpectedly.
And also allow others to take those important days for themselves for the most part. Most people want Christmas, which I agree with. No one imo should be open on Christmas. Yet still, Muslim and Hindu shops stay open that day because they don't celebrate that day. Is what it is. Just let people choose and watch the differentiation flourish instead of forcing it or not.
Honestly, imo, if you want those holidays off then make that clear. If you're willing to work them, make that clear. I don't have anything against working or taking holidays tbh, but people forcing others to work or, not forcing but allowing others, to not work for suck specific reasons is stupid. Most places back in the day were closed for various holidays. And you might find that some random groups might want to to holidays off rather than other groups, so you still have workers enough to work those holidays and aren't 'losong money's which is all companies really care about. A Grinch will not mind working on Christmas, nor will a scrooge. A minority may want a significant day off for their heritage, such as Ramadan or Martin Luther king day, but you still have plenty of others who don't put the same significance into those days. National holidays are for show sure, but allowing people to choose what's important for them can allow your business to stay open those days.
I don't care about your crotch goblins. Pay me to switch & hope I don't have something really important planned. Other than that your loss.
I am a mom of 2 boys. I would never ask anyone to change their plans for me.. I would plan ahead... They give you the school schedule at the beginning of the year... I used to work a job that I often had to work on holidays (Christmas etc.) I always just made everyone wake up early before I went to work and we had Christmas early in the morning (where there is a will there is a way) Thankfully I no longer have to work there.
I don't have kids. I'm not a fan of kids. But I always went out of my way to work holidays and days kids had off. Spring break for a mom or dad was different than for me. And with a huge family we tried to do the holiday a weekend before or after. It's not that difficult to make accommodations for others.
Load More Replies...I think one of the issues here is that many commenters seem to be conflating corporate policy with individual compassion. As a company policy, time-off requests should be granted on a first-come, first-served basis, full stop. (In the US state where I live, an employer cannot legally ask the reason for your PTO request--they can decline a request based on business needs, but they cannot "prioritize" because they feel one person's request is more important than another's.) However, as a store manager, I always ask for volunteers to work before making the holiday schedules. Some of my employees--even those with families--are usually willing to work because they celebrate the holidays on a different day. Fortunately my current company is closed on Christmas, but my previous employer required a certain number of stores in each district to remain open, and in that case, there were always volunteers from closed stores willing to work at the open stores to get the extra holiday pay.
Yeah, so, like any work place whose policies cause problems like this should kind of re-evaluate what’s happening with the staffing situation and and just get it together. People shouldn’t have to have an issue if they need off on over-lapping days. We work to live, not the other way around. When things like that happen I would put it on the company…sorry if that hurts anyone’s feelings.
Having just had to complete the workplace harassment course at my job...this, in the US, would be an open and shut labor lawsuit for discrimination based on a protected status, as whether or not one is a parent is considered to fall under the umbrella of physical sex-based discrimination.
Needing time off doesn't make them entitled, but expecting to be given priority over child free people does.
Load More Replies...No, they won't. I'm over 50 and never changed my mind.
Load More Replies...“An employee without children might have just as valid reasons..." Wanting time off is a valid enough reason and don't let anyone tell you otherwise.
Exactly. In a way we are saving the world by NOT reproducing. So aren't we entitled to stuff also? On a serious note i do agree. I mean hell last i checked you have a kid you SHOULD be able to afford them. Not ask for handouts and free off time. Your choice to have them. Why do us childless people have to be penalized?
Load More Replies...Hm, I dunno. You choosing to have children and then expecting me to be lenient whenever it suits you because 'memories with kids' really isn't a valid reason. I've got memories to make of my own, that are not less valuable just because they don't involve children. I understand how people may feel that way, but the possibility of not being able to spend a Christmas or whatever with your kids is just part of the deal. Be creative, think of an alternative. However, in practise, I'd rather eat my own toenails than go on holidays during summer season because everything sucks during summer season (peak seasons) :') So for me it usually works out, but my employer never really has issues with lots of people taking time off at the same time. Building is closed during Christmas anyway.
I really resent the poster who said 'oh you can work christmas but then you can get new years off to go drink an get drunk.' Do you think that if you don't have kids you're of course some drunken frat boy just looking to party? I'm 43 and I don't have kids and I want the holiday off because I like having the extra day off. I don't care if I'm sleeping all day- my reasons are mine and shouldn't have to be explained to anyone as being more or less worthy. I'm also not being selfish because I want to go 'party'. The problem is the company forcing people to work on those days. Don't take out your frustration toward the company on the people you work with because they got it off and you didn't. It's not their fault and they shouldn't be penalized for the company's greed. I get wanting to have holiday with your kids while they're young but if it THAT important to you then you should try to find a job that isn't open on holidays-which is the real problem.
I resent that same poster. I'm childfree as well. I LOVE Christmas, but can't be bothered with new year. Last time I properly went out for it was early 21, I think. I'm now 35. I will say, I'm lucky with the job I've had for most of my working life. Weekends and Bank Holidays guaranteed off. So I'm always off for a few days over Christmas. I now live with my parents and work from home in the same job, which is even better. I don't mind working during Christmas, because I still get to spend Christmas with my family around it. When I lived out of home and worked in the office, I at least would have a couple of days. But, I did work in a place for a couple of years, where the manager obce made a clear point of saying in a team meeting that if she had her way, those without children would never get Christmas off, ever. I was the only person on the team without either a child, or a child on the way. I was off that Christmas, and her favourite team members weren't, so she was annoyed.
Load More Replies...I love the ebtitled parent who jumped in the comments to say that it's different once you have kids. Schedule off like everyone else.
Seriously. Their work life is entirely separate from their personal life. If something happens at work, then it’s a problem they share with their coworkers. But their children are part of their personal life—-and therefore NOT their coworkers’ problem. So if people with kids can’t plan vacations ahead of time, like right when the school calendar comes out, then the rest of us should not be penalized for it. Additionally, how do essential workers handle not being home on Christmas or Thanksgiving, or birthdays, or other special events? The most levelheaded ones I’ve known plan ahead, or make alternative plans. For example, if they’re working Christmas Day but off Christmas Eve, then switch the big celebration to Christmas Eve. You get the idea. Unless you’re NEVER available on any of those days throughout your children’s lives, believe me, they’ll be OK if you miss one here and there and/or have to make alternative plans.
Load More Replies...This happened to me. I’m originally from the UK and was not as aware of spring break holidays when I moved to the US for my work. I was told by my psycho boss that I was being disrespectful of my peers with children when I took time off to see family back home during spring break since I didn’t have kids. I was embarrassed, disgusted, and hurt and quite soon after.
You should've gone to HR and complained. You could also sue because of the hostile work environment. Don't let anyone bully you at work.
Load More Replies...Your crotch goblins come at a price, and why should I have to pay it? You choose the kid life and have to deal with that decision. I chose childfree, and have just as much right to visit my distant family when they come to town.
I am so going to use the phrase "crotch goblins" next time a coworker asks me to take their shift so they can spend it "with the kids" 😂
Load More Replies...I work every other Christmas day and i will not work for someone because they chose to have kids. If you don't want to work Christmas find another job or work in a school to have the kids holidays off. Making memories with children are not any more important than me making memories with my family. Also for the first few years the kids don't even know what the day is anyway so it can easily be pushed to the day after without them even aware of it
My first long-term job uses to split the shifts at Christmas so everyone worked a few hours. That meant everyone got to spend time with family. My next place alternated years. You've got to make it fair. Yes people with kids want to spend time with them and make memories. But people without kids still have parents, grandparents, siblings, neices nephews. Lots of family members that they want to spend time with and make memories with. With school holidays one job used to prioritise people with kids but my mum worked in a school and my little brother was still a student. This meant they could only take leave on school holidays. It was so hard to get a family vacation because I could never get the time off when they were available.
Load More Replies...If you CHOOSE to take Christmas shifts to free-up time for your co-workers with kids, bully for you. Kudos, hand clapping, pat yourself on the back. But don't expect anyone else to think your self-sacrifice needs to be some rule, anymore than me donating to a particular charity means everyone else should, too.
This happened to me once. Walked out of that job and into another one. Bought a gold wedding band at Walmart, borrow pictures of the neighbor's kids put it in my wallet, told everyone I was married. Are refused to have my vacation time put on the back burner to somebody else's needs.
Nope. Your kids are not my problem. If you want off, you schedule it like everyone else on a first come/first served basis. If you don't get your first choice because someone beat you to it, tough luck.
This is how it works in my company. We don't work Christmas day or the 26th anyway, so thats good. If obe falls on a Saturday or Sunday, we get the next weekday off in lieu, as we don't work weekends. This year, Christmas day is a Sunday, so we h finish on Friday, then we are not open again until the Wednesday. The boon of a highly regulated industry. After that, it's booked though a system. First come first served. Extra hours get released closer to Christmas, that don't use the system. For those This year, I'm taking time at the start of December and leaving Christmas to the parents. I have no kids, I work from home, and have as much time off as I want.
Load More Replies...In some countries, it is not possible for parents to take their children out of school during term time for a holiday. If they do, they can face legal repercussions. This means a lots of people with children are trying to take holidays in the same few weeks. To be honest, it's brilliant when you aren't constrained by term times and can go places when it's cheaper and less expensive.
So true. I've just booked a holiday to disneyland paris for me and a friend. Both mid thirties, no kids. We are going for a week in May. I had the freedom to choose any dates, so picked a time of reasonable weather, less kids, cheaper prices.. brilliant!
Load More Replies...I'm a mother of two and a bartender, Thursday night is my regular shift. Guess who worked Thanksgiving? Me, because I'm not pawning that off on anyone else, we ALL have families, in one form or another, mine is no more or less important. This mentality is absurd
First up, best dressed. If you have booked time off work (for whatever your reasons) then you get priority, if YOU choose to alter your plans to accommodate someone else’s needs that is your prerogative, BUT if you choose to keep your original request then that’s fine. It is part of your package that your employer has agreed with you, it’s not conditional on another member of staff having a need to see their children. Sorry breeders, you need to plan your lives as well as everyone else.
I missed every Christmas during my dad’s sickness, including 2 he was on the transplant list just because my coworkers had kids and ‘needed it more.’ They still have their kids but my dad is gone. We could have done half days so mornings with their kids and lunch and dinner with my dad, but no. And I will never get those holidays back. Even without small kids holidays matter. Screw every employee that f****d me over with that excuse. Work with people and we won’t leave you stranded at the busiest time of year with only 2 weeks to find a replacement (the replacement never came)
Really sorry that this happened to you. People don't just f*cking think, do they?
Load More Replies...I think the bottom line here is everyone has lives outside of work and you never know how long you have with your loved ones regardless if they are kids or not. It does not mean those memories are less valid than those with children. As I said you don't know how long you have. Edit: Companies have added to the issue. I worked somewhere and when I found out about my brothers death there response was to work it will take your mind off of it. I did not get a time to grieve and as of now I don't think I have properly grieved. I just don't want anyone to go through the same thing.
I have another children-related topic to discuss. Bringing your children to work: should it be a norm and why not? I worked in a tiny entrepreneurial company with just two people (me included) not being the founders. Our director had a baby and since then she participated in everything with her daughter. I felt like it's a very cool thing for her but not a good one for me or for the other employee as we both weren't children people at all and trying to concentrate on an upcoming season's budget is a bit hard when a toddler is crying or cooing or whatever. What do you think?
All the time? Weird. Collegues have taken their kids to work to show them around. One did it twice in 20 years for half an hour or an hour and a few others did it once for an hour or so.
Load More Replies...At my store everyone had to work either Christmas eve or Christmas day. No one gets both days off. Ever. I put out a sign up sheet with the times & they have to pick day & time. I have employees with & without kids but we all have family we want to be with. I've done this for 15yrs & it's worked out great.
Why isn't your store closed on Christmas? I'm assuming your store is a gas station/convenience store or pharmacy but it's still too bad that you have to be open on Christmas day.
Load More Replies...The years I've missed out on time with family, especially those who are dead now because I was stuck with working shifts my "parent" coworkers called off on was sickening. My many visits to hr for writeups for me not coming in because I was to be off and my schedule got changed "last minute"...not even the days regulated to parents....you work and deal with it.
When I was child-free, I didn't mind not taking annual leave during summer-in the UK, schools are off for 6 weeks over summer and taking vacations then is usually more expensive and resorts are full of kids, so I was happy taking leave at other times. I was also happy being on call over Christmas, because I don't celebrate it. But I have to say, I found that colleagues who were parents were far more likely to abuse leave policies than those who weren't. Maybe I just had selfish colleagues, but we had one with 3 children who routinely arrived late and left early to collect her kids from school (whilst being paid for a full day's work, and with sanction from our line manager, who was a friend of hers, because 'it's difficult being a mother'). We had another who refused to use her annual leave to take her kids to the dentist/doctor/meetings at school etc and instead insisted this was an emergency, even for preplanned visits. I don't mind working with parents, but some take the p**s.
When I was single, my response to my coworkers with kids trying to manipulate me into letting them have MY days off/vacation time off, for no other reason than they have kids, was basically me saying that I would like to find someone, get married, and have kids too. Then asking them how TF can I do that if I’m working every weekend and holiday for YOU? NO, I will NOT swap with you. I have a life too. Even when I did finally meet my now husband and get married, just because I didn’t have kids right away, they STILL tried to pull that same b******t! I shut them down again, only this time it was How do you expect me to have a baby when my husband and I don’t get to spend time together because I’m working YOUR shift? NO, I will NOT switch with you!
I had a job once where we switched out working weekends and on Father's day weekend I overheard my supervisor telling someone they could put me on to work as I didn't have a father. (My dad had died some months before.) I still can't believe she said that.
People can be really insensitive and awful. Sorry that this happened and condolences for your loss.
Load More Replies...Growing up, my dad worked shift work a lot of the time. They had an unwritten rule that nobody asks off for Christmas because they all had families. When he worked the graveyard shift, we would open presents as soon as he got home and he would nap before work. If he worked the evening shift we, would open presents early and we would have a lunchtime dinner before he went to work. If he worked the day shift, we opened presents before he went to work and did Christmas dinner when he got home. Nobody at his job had to sacrifice a holiday for us to make memories. When he’s been at the job more than 25 years a fella asked of for Christmas. My dad told him that nobody asked off because that meant others would have to work k er time to cover his shift and that if he insisted on keeping the request, my dad threatened to use his seniority and request it off and that fella would be one of the ones working overtime. Needless to say, he withdrew his request. If a working parent tries hard enough
If you can't keep it in your pants, at least keep it out of my vacation calendar.
We are scheduled 9 hours, clocking out for 1 hour lunch. Had a coworker (salaried), arrange with her boss that she would come in at 830 after dropping her daughter at school, and work until 5. Except she still took an hour lunch. And didn't come in until 9 "because daughter made her late". Summer vacation - still showing up at 9. Daughter starts Jr high and goes in at 730 - mom still coming in at 9. I wouldn't mind the flexibility for parents if they didn't blatantly abuse it.
With or without kids shouldn’t matter, whoever asked for it off first. The worst though was when I went into labor over a holiday weekend and they told my husband too bad, other coworkers had already asked for the weekend off. He dropped me at the hospital, used his lunch break to come for the delivery. I had to find a ride home the next day. That is another scenario, but that, and emergencies (death, medical, etc) are the only situations that should take priority.
USPS employee here. Prime time vacation is chosen by seniority, rest of the year is first come first serve. I raised 3 by myself and never expected special consideration. Sometimes you win, sometimes you don't ( didn't say "lose" because this was a good lesson for them). Another person I knew would just use sick leave if she couldn't get those days. We could see that coming a mile away!
I had a job where the manager could not/would not have a set schedule for anyone but one guy. I didn't care what he did, but I wanted it then be a 'cookie cutter' M,T 6-2 Th 10-4 Sat 2-10pm and rinse/repeat each week. So I could then schedule my home life around work. BUT NO, each week was different, try to figure out when I could or would attend games for one daughter and be able to get the other one to her lessons. I didn't last,but 5 weeks. Too much chaos for home life.
And just because a fellow employee says they have children doesn't guarantee they actually have children.
"Think about that child's memories" .... how bout no? I didn't tell you to have kids. I didn't knock you up! Your kids rent my fucken problem! Lol. It's not my responsibility to plan my PTO for another person. Why in the f**k would I plan my own time off around another persons schedule just because I don't have kids? If you want those days off... request them off first. Otherwise f**k off! Why should you get preferential treatment when I put in my request weeks or months before you? So Im supposed to plan my vacation days.. hwhich I requested off accordingly...) & then change all of my plans at the drop of a hat just because Kathy didn't follow protocol & just assumed that she could f**k up my days off all because she has kids? Ya.. no. I don't think so! What about my memories? What about the valuable time I have left with my own parents? Don't you think my parents want to their kids on the holidays!? Why are your kids or family more important than anyone else's? Why
As a parent of 3, I can get behind that rationale as long as we apply that same approach to collecting social security
Ok, I'm intrigued by this comment, what exactly are you saying here?
Load More Replies...Good points. Companies should make it as fair as possible like alternating years and stuff like that (you have Christmas off, so you work New Year's). Allowing only parents to take off holidays is just discrimination based on family status and people who don't have kids or who have adult kids should have a fair chance of getting the day off. I do work somewhere where there needs to always be people because a chemical plant can't monitor itself.
I mean, what about the parents of the child free person? How can they spend their holiday with their adult child if the child is working? My mom still wants us to come visit during Christmas and summertime. I have no kids, my brother has two, and those are the times of year we get to visit with each other (and March break.) Fortunately we are all teachers, but my dad wasn't. His schedule rotated so one year he'd be off for Christmas, and the next year he'd be on call (he worked for the natural gas supplier in town, so only needed to work in case of emergencies on holidays, same thing with weekends and nights, two people always had to be on call in case someone smelled a leak.)
Companies have problems with this kind of thing when they lack policies and processes for scheduling vacations and instead leave it to individual managers to ‘work it out”. First come, first serve doesn’t work as someone can request all the desirable days. Basing it on family status is discriminatory. The only fair way to do it is to collect all the requests for prime vacation days and have a total. So if you work Christmas one year, you don’t work it the next year but you work Thanksgiving. Ties are broken by seniority or by lot. But this requires both the company and the manager to plan and discuss it.
No children by choice here. When I was a bartender and single I always volunteered to work holidays. I did Christmas or T-Day on the following Saturday. So I got an actual weekend free and coworkers could spend the holiday with kids and family and people are generous with tips and gifts when you're working a holiday. Then I got married and settled into an office job. Female coworker had a tradition of day after thanksgiving shopping with her adult daughter so I worked. I moved departments and the young lady I worked with was divorced with young child. I worked whatever holiday her son had off so she could spend time with him. I never scheduled vacations around spring break times anyway because everything was more expensive and booked. I'm an off season tourist. NYC in February is cheaper and less crowded. September and October at the beach or in Canada is also a good time because all the kids are back in school and it's hurricane season on the coast. Just get travel insurance 😉
I chose to work holidays, it was double time and a half. I was in a nationwide telecommunication repair service and it was essential service. On Christmas day, I think I got 2 calls in 6 hours. On a normal day I would get 20-30 calls an hour. We got PTO according to seniority, I was high on the seniority list with more years so I got to choose my days off accordingly.
As a person with three kids I absolutely agree that I should not get priority and that child free people should get the time they want off, too, BUT the one little spammer in the works is CHILD CARE. I had to squeeze out some extra time off last school holidays because our usual vacation care changed there hours and we were unable to get spots anywhere else. They also close for 4 weeks over Christmas, assuming that parents’ workplaces are shut down then (I’m a nurse - mine doesn’t). Arranging around childcare is an absolute nightmare, sometimes.
People without children still want to make memories and see their families. Also, if you work Christmas day...your kids don't HAVE to open up gifts while you're on shift. The gifts don't evaporate. Have your Christmas celebration on the 23rd, the 24th, or the 26th. I didn't know the difference as a kid and sometimes it was way after Christmas when we opened gifts because we wanted to wait for some family to fly in (and their flights got delayed).
If I know I want a holiday off, I book it off months in advance. I have heard other coworkers complain that they had to work a holiday. I tell them that they should book it off, months in advance. If you can't do that, then stop complaining, because it is your own fault you have to work.
I don't have kids, but my niece would be very upset if I wasn't there for Christmas! Also, we deserve holidays with our parents, siblings, etc, too, even if we don't have kids of our own. I am beyond grateful I celebrated my dad's last Christmas with him.
Why would you need time off and not request it in advance? They literally give you a whole calendar of school days off when school starts. If you want those days off take that thing straight in way back in August and start getting it worked out instead of trying to put people out like you didn't know they get a week off for spring break, Christmas, etc the day before it happens. I used to work at a place that gave holidays off based on seniority and the employees picked their top 3 and they made sure everyone got at least one. I thought that worked pretty well and was fair...however, most of us worked the holidays though bc we worked for tips and it was the busiest time of the year. As a parent and an employee, you literally go into a job knowing you won't get to spend as much time with your child as a SAHP would. That's just the facts, regardless of whether you are there bc you want to be or bc you have to be.🤷🏼
As a person who has no kids I have worked for parents many times at holidays if I had nothing going on I was happy to do it. Sometimes more for the kid than the parents. But it is all the other times we have to cover for them. They have a doctor appointment, have to go take kids lunch to school parent teacher meeting, kid sick and they have to be home. Running late coming in because something with kid, leave early to go see kids game or dance. There are many more.
Plus we do not get to do that. I have been told many times when I was younger that someday when you have kids you will get it back. I don't have kids. Where I work now the company encourages for family time for everyone and it can be scheduled.
Load More Replies...Ask for the time in a timely manner..it is not my problem if you can't do that..and YES..I have kids..2 of them
People with kids are generally contributing to the future, unlike all you selfish, neurotic millenials. The positive side of this is everyone expecting equality and not equity. Equity would give the family man more time off. Equality says, "nah, everyone gets the same amount of days regardless of how many kids you have." Time off is time off, you shouldn't even need a reason if it's allotted in your contract. I get it. I just don't get why everyone is so antihuman. We're living in the easiest time to be alive.
I requested PTO 6 months in advance for an out-of-state family wedding, with flight/hotel/car rental all booked, and my request was approved. 1 month before event date, boss told me that a coworker wanted PTO during that timeframe. I told him of all my pre-arrangements, so he told coworker "no-go" for them!!!!!
Have you not heard of people going away to see family. Many families get together for holidays and its a big thing. All businesses that are non essential should be closed for holidays have compassion for their workers. As for spring break is not a holiday. Whom ever puts in for that time first should get it. Parents know in august. But they also have all damn summer. Christmas is not just for parents. I took that time to spend with my family grandparents and parents. But yes if you work in a company that is open its usually based on seniority and switch out like if you take thanks giving you work Christmas. Blah blah blah.
We don't have kids. However I work in a school, so my husband likes to book his days off in school holidays. A few times, he has been asked to swap by someone with kids, more often than not he agrees provided he is asked nicely and before we have booked something. It's a pain only getting holidays when kids are off because a lot of stuff is more expensive. Luckily, he and his co-workers talk about holiday plans in a friendly manner. As his family is in a different country, he is very firm about his summer but in return he checks with others before things like Christmas and Easter.
Re: that last comment. I'm a childfree woman who has gone on holidays with siblings and niblings before. Said niblings attend school, therefore the holiday is going to be set in the school holidays. So bite me, Karen. Also, screw "making memories", it doesn't just apply to children. My dad has Parkinson's and has a limited number of Christmases left. I want to enjoy every single one, so sorry Karen but your healthy kids who will not care if you're there or not as long as they get presents do not trump my dad. And finally, my mum was a nurse who sometimes worked Christmas day. We kids managed to survive to adulthood without expiring of sadness cuz mum explained that sometimes she had to go and look after the sick people in hospital on Christmas and make it a better day for them. We understood.
When my children were younger, we drew holidays with the caveat that no person worked the same holiday two years in a row. For the most part we worked what we drew w/o complaint. After my children grew up if a co-worker with small children drew Christmas morning, I always offered to switch with them. But that was my choice, not a requirement
Dang what happened to avoiding families on holidays? I'm a first responder and the new/young childless employees would always cover for the ones without and for more senior coworkers. Once you get some seniority and start having kids, you get that luxury for a long longer than you give. But I guess other jobs work on Christmas too and act like they work from 6 am to midnight. Get a job/employer that fits your needs better. Those kids will be the next generation and let's not pass down the generational trauma. Kids are the worse they've been emotionally ever and it's really sad. It takes everyone to make the world a better place.
Maybe they needed time off due to child care, none of you are considering the fact that maybe because of the fact that they probably don't have anyone else to watch their kids while they are off from school could be a valid reason also. If that's the case they should take priority over those without children, because they don't need to worry about another living beings safety. They can leave the house whenever they want for however long they want, when you have kids everything is on a time restriction and if they are not of age for school or if school is out of session and they don't have any other option for child care, it would most certainly be an issue. So no I don't feel the parent in the situation is wrong, it's not about an employee or coworker feeling that they should have more priority over another because they have children, it's about the fact that the parent needs to work to provide, but if they don't have child care of some sort they can't provide, it's math people!!!
When I was younger, I was sacrificed on holidays and time off at my job(s) because of being overlooked on time off with my own family. I didn't have children. I am now 50 and most the family I had spent time with are no longer here. I wished I had fought for my time off now. Assuming that others don't have anything of importance to do outside of work is selfish. Thinking someone should be less than anyone else because they have no children is selfish. I have a lot of regrets and now only memories of long ago of my family sitting down to Thanksgiving. You should be turning your anger to company's that don't close for holidays not each other.
This is hard. As a young single person I personally would take a shift for a coworker on a holiday in a heartbeat so they could spend it with their kids/elderly parents/whoever, but I'm a weirdo who loves working holidays. I think workplaces should have more flexibility for all workers needs regardless of familial status. However I do understand that single parents especially sometimes need a specific school holiday off or something, but kids don't need both parents home every school holiday each year. Everyone should plan ahead as best they are able, however sick days are different. I think you should be able to use them for yourself or to care for a child/spouse/etc. I would never go on vacation during school holiday as a non-parent $$$ and too crowded.
At my old job, I looked at the calendar in February and realized that Christmas and New Year were on Thursday. So I put in my vacation request for both Fridays, giving myself two 4 day weekends to spend with my Mom. We just recently lost my Dad in January, so I knew the holidays would be difficult for her. Come October, two Moms I worked with finally took the time to look at their calendars and complained to management that I shouldn't be able to have both days off. Management tried to convince me to change my plans, but I refused, and I had the signed time-off requests, so there wasn't anything they could do. Got a lot of attitude, and in the end the owner decided to close the day after Christmas so they could have it off. My life and plans were not less important because I hadn't reproduced!
"But I have kids! I want to spend time with them during the holidays!" Yes, MY parents also want to spend time with their kids during the holidays. I have a child but I don't make that everyone else's responsibility. First come, first serve, alternate the schedule. Parents should not get every holiday off just cause they have kids.
As a mother of five I would like to say failure to plan on my part you should never constitute an emergency on someone else's. Yes it's very important that I have time off of my children are off school. I'm old enough and smart enough to know that that takes planning.
To Stephanie Jean- while most places are closed on holidays I think they mean the whole week before a major holiday,coworkers with kids feel entitled to it because their kids are off school, not thinking about a childless coworker whose family may live far with elderly parents who may not be in the best heath or whatever, just miss their mom and dad! As a mom, I would've LOVED such a rule but I KNOW its not fair to the person who asked before me or has more seniority. My office is unionized and its done by seniority for our yearly vacation bid then by first come first served after that. I have given up a week in June that I wanted to spend with my adult, childless girls who live an 8 hour drive from me but chose a different week so my coworker with a young daughter could have it.
At the beginning of every school year I would go through the calendar and request off for the days my kids were out of school. With that being said, I made so little as a single mom that if I were unable to take that time off I would be forced to call in. I didn't make enough to pay for daycare and that's a sad reality for a lot of parents. And no, I was not single and broke when I had kids. That came after and unexpectedly.
And also allow others to take those important days for themselves for the most part. Most people want Christmas, which I agree with. No one imo should be open on Christmas. Yet still, Muslim and Hindu shops stay open that day because they don't celebrate that day. Is what it is. Just let people choose and watch the differentiation flourish instead of forcing it or not.
Honestly, imo, if you want those holidays off then make that clear. If you're willing to work them, make that clear. I don't have anything against working or taking holidays tbh, but people forcing others to work or, not forcing but allowing others, to not work for suck specific reasons is stupid. Most places back in the day were closed for various holidays. And you might find that some random groups might want to to holidays off rather than other groups, so you still have workers enough to work those holidays and aren't 'losong money's which is all companies really care about. A Grinch will not mind working on Christmas, nor will a scrooge. A minority may want a significant day off for their heritage, such as Ramadan or Martin Luther king day, but you still have plenty of others who don't put the same significance into those days. National holidays are for show sure, but allowing people to choose what's important for them can allow your business to stay open those days.
I don't care about your crotch goblins. Pay me to switch & hope I don't have something really important planned. Other than that your loss.
I am a mom of 2 boys. I would never ask anyone to change their plans for me.. I would plan ahead... They give you the school schedule at the beginning of the year... I used to work a job that I often had to work on holidays (Christmas etc.) I always just made everyone wake up early before I went to work and we had Christmas early in the morning (where there is a will there is a way) Thankfully I no longer have to work there.
I don't have kids. I'm not a fan of kids. But I always went out of my way to work holidays and days kids had off. Spring break for a mom or dad was different than for me. And with a huge family we tried to do the holiday a weekend before or after. It's not that difficult to make accommodations for others.
Load More Replies...I think one of the issues here is that many commenters seem to be conflating corporate policy with individual compassion. As a company policy, time-off requests should be granted on a first-come, first-served basis, full stop. (In the US state where I live, an employer cannot legally ask the reason for your PTO request--they can decline a request based on business needs, but they cannot "prioritize" because they feel one person's request is more important than another's.) However, as a store manager, I always ask for volunteers to work before making the holiday schedules. Some of my employees--even those with families--are usually willing to work because they celebrate the holidays on a different day. Fortunately my current company is closed on Christmas, but my previous employer required a certain number of stores in each district to remain open, and in that case, there were always volunteers from closed stores willing to work at the open stores to get the extra holiday pay.
Yeah, so, like any work place whose policies cause problems like this should kind of re-evaluate what’s happening with the staffing situation and and just get it together. People shouldn’t have to have an issue if they need off on over-lapping days. We work to live, not the other way around. When things like that happen I would put it on the company…sorry if that hurts anyone’s feelings.
Having just had to complete the workplace harassment course at my job...this, in the US, would be an open and shut labor lawsuit for discrimination based on a protected status, as whether or not one is a parent is considered to fall under the umbrella of physical sex-based discrimination.
Needing time off doesn't make them entitled, but expecting to be given priority over child free people does.
Load More Replies...No, they won't. I'm over 50 and never changed my mind.
Load More Replies...
103
137