MIL Shocked Family Ate Without Her After Telling Them To Do Exactly That, Scolds The Perpetrator
Interview With ExpertEvery family has its own set of rules and expectations, especially regarding elders in the house. In some Asian households, you’re expected to wait for the eldest to begin eating before you do. In others, there may be unspoken guidelines about how to behave at the dinner table. While it’s understandable to follow these customs out of respect, sometimes it’s necessary to prioritize your own needs.
A woman recently shared her decision to eat before her mother-in-law finished her prayer, igniting outrage and judgment from her family. Although her hunger prompted this bold choice, it sparked a heated debate about respect and family dynamics. Keep reading to discover how this seemingly simple decision escalated into a full-blown family drama.
In some cultures, praying daily is an integral part of their traditions and way of life
Image credits: Nina Zeynep Güler (not the actual photo)
A woman recounted how her mother-in-law labeled her as manner less for deciding to start eating before she finished her prayer
Image credits: Anna Jakutajc-Wojtalik (not the actual photo)
Image credits: throwawayaita70
The author provided additional insights into the meal dynamics and how things are handled in their household
Image credits: Nina Zeynep Güler / Unsplash (not the actual photo)
Prayers play an essential role in daily life, promoting discipline and a sense of belonging within the Islamic community
To gain a deeper understanding of the prayer system in Islam, we spoke with an Imam from India. He explained, “A Muslim is obligated to perform five daily prayers, known as Salah, at specific times throughout the day.”
He further mentioned, “While these prayers are important, they are not directly tied to meal times. Instead, they serve as essential moments of spiritual reflection and connection to God, helping to structure the day around faith.” The Imam emphasized that, regardless of mealtimes, these prayers are a vital part of their daily routine, fostering discipline and a sense of community.
In this particular situation, the family chose to wait for the author’s mother-in-law to finish her prayer before they began their meal, honoring the tradition of respect for elders. However, this practice varies greatly around the world, with unique dining etiquettes shaping how families share their meals.
Image credits: Nguyễn Khanh / Pexels (not the actual photo)
Dinner etiquette varies widely across cultures, with each country having its own unique customs and traditions
For example, in Japan, it’s customary to place your hands together in a prayer-like gesture, bow your head slightly, and say “itadakimasu” before eating. This phrase, which translates to “I humbly receive,” is not just a formality; it embodies a deep sense of gratitude and respect for the food, the effort that went into preparing it, and the natural world that provides it.
In France, dining is more than just a meal; it’s an experience that emphasizes connection and appreciation. French food expert Laura Calder explains, “When you’re dining with people, you’re expected to engage in conversation, appreciate your food and the ambiance, and be present where you are.” She adds, “So keep that mobile phone tucked away.”
While chopsticks are a staple in Chinese dining, there are important etiquette rules to follow. You shouldn’t use chopsticks that have touched your mouth to take any food from a shared plate. It is considered unhygienic. Instead, you should use the utensils specifically provided for this purpose. If these aren’t available, it’s best to look for a clean pair of chopsticks to transfer food from the shared plate to your own.
In many Indian households, it is customary to eat using only your right hand. Using the left hand is typically frowned upon and considered unclean. This practice reflects cultural beliefs about hygiene and respect during meals. Additionally, sharing food from your plate is a cherished tradition, symbolizing friendship and hospitality.
While some of these etiquettes are deeply rooted in cultural traditions, there are certain unwritten meal rules that sometimes don’t seem fair or reasonable. In this case, do you think the daughter-in-law acted appropriately? Was the author’s mother-in-law’s behavior justified?
People online felt that the author’s mother-in-law was acting unfairly and displaying rude behavior
[YTA] A few others believed that the author was partly to blame in this situation
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
This is such an obvious power play on the MIL's part. She's hiding behind religion but that's what it is since she's purposely making her prayers coincide with just before the meal. If she has that much control and she wasn't making this about power she'd do the prayer while the cooking is being done. I'm with the commenter who said the best course of action would be for OP to just stop cooking. Let someone else deal with this nonsense and see how quickly those chickens come home roost.
That's the entire point of religion, power. How a person chooses to use religion to do their manipulating may be different, but that's what religion is all about. "Believe in these ridiculous stories and the traditions/rules behind them or else!"
Load More Replies...This is too silly. First, the MIL has said previously to go ahead and eat without her. Second, my Muslim friends say their prayers at certain set times throughout the day, so why does the MIL make the meal to coincide with prayer times ? It's nonsense.
She’s just being controlling and knows exactly what she’s doing.
Load More Replies...I’m an atheist, honestly your prayers mean absolutely nothing to me, I won’t be held hostage to anything your religion puts upon you. Here’s the kicker, you mean something to me, you should be present when food is served, you are part of the group who are eating together, my manners demand that we wait for everyone to be seated before anyone eats. If you have a prayer to say that’s fine but I expect that you extend the same consideration to me as I do to you. Be on tine, to be anything otherwise is selfish and inconsiderate. You’ll only do it once and after that I’ll be as rude to you as you are to the family being seated for a meal.
My (also adult) brother and I started eating when someone is saying grace at a family dinner. It’s not in an obnoxious way, but after years of just sitting there looking at everyone with their heads bowed, I’m going to eat. I’m an atheist and he’s either an atheist or agnostic (btw I don’t like how those two things are always grouped together because they are incredibly different). Extended family is Catholic.
Load More Replies...This is such an obvious power play on the MIL's part. She's hiding behind religion but that's what it is since she's purposely making her prayers coincide with just before the meal. If she has that much control and she wasn't making this about power she'd do the prayer while the cooking is being done. I'm with the commenter who said the best course of action would be for OP to just stop cooking. Let someone else deal with this nonsense and see how quickly those chickens come home roost.
That's the entire point of religion, power. How a person chooses to use religion to do their manipulating may be different, but that's what religion is all about. "Believe in these ridiculous stories and the traditions/rules behind them or else!"
Load More Replies...This is too silly. First, the MIL has said previously to go ahead and eat without her. Second, my Muslim friends say their prayers at certain set times throughout the day, so why does the MIL make the meal to coincide with prayer times ? It's nonsense.
She’s just being controlling and knows exactly what she’s doing.
Load More Replies...I’m an atheist, honestly your prayers mean absolutely nothing to me, I won’t be held hostage to anything your religion puts upon you. Here’s the kicker, you mean something to me, you should be present when food is served, you are part of the group who are eating together, my manners demand that we wait for everyone to be seated before anyone eats. If you have a prayer to say that’s fine but I expect that you extend the same consideration to me as I do to you. Be on tine, to be anything otherwise is selfish and inconsiderate. You’ll only do it once and after that I’ll be as rude to you as you are to the family being seated for a meal.
My (also adult) brother and I started eating when someone is saying grace at a family dinner. It’s not in an obnoxious way, but after years of just sitting there looking at everyone with their heads bowed, I’m going to eat. I’m an atheist and he’s either an atheist or agnostic (btw I don’t like how those two things are always grouped together because they are incredibly different). Extended family is Catholic.
Load More Replies...
21
38