Widowed Dad Is Offended And Hurt By Sister’s Comment, Refuses To Babysit For Her
Interview With AuthorParents are everyday heroes for all the effort they put in, and being a single mom or dad certainly isn’t easy. However, raising children shouldn’t be seen as a competition. It’s unhealthy to start comparing who has more kids, more chores, and a busier lifestyle. Meanwhile, it’s unfair to saddle a relative with babysitting duties when they’re otherwise busy.
A single dad, u/Plenty-Blood1526, went viral on the popular AITAH online group after asking the community for some friendly advice after an argument with his sister, a mother of three. He shared how he decided to enforce some boundaries with her after she disrespected his role as a parent of one. Read on for the full story and for the advice many helpful internet users gave the dad.
We reached out to the author of the viral story, u/Plenty-Blood1526, who was kind enough to answer our questions about the delicate situation. You’ll find Bored Panda’s interview with him below.
Being a good parent is a full-time job and requires you to regularly spend quality time with your children
Image credits: peus80 / envato (not the actual photo)
A dad shared how his sister tried to pressure him into babysitting her kids, when he had already made plans with his own daughter
Image credits: msvyatkovska / envato (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Plenty-Blood1526
“Don’t let others take advantage of the fact that you have a big heart”
Image credits: cottonbro studio / pexels (not the actual photo)
Bored Panda asked the author about how he hopes that his relationship with his sister will change in the future. “I truly care about my sister, and I hope we can continue to be there for each other. But moving forward, I realize that I need to set healthier boundaries,” u/Plenty-Blood1526 opened up to us.
“Our relationship is important to me, but so is my own peace of mind and my time with my daughter. I’ve learned that I can’t just go along with every request, especially when it conflicts with my responsibilities as a single parent. So, while I’ll always be there as her sibling, I’m going to be clearer about my limits and prioritize what’s best for me and my daughter.”
Meanwhile, the dad also shared his thoughts on some of the biggest challenges that single parents face. One of the toughest parts is having to play multiple roles.
“We’re not just ‘mom’ or ‘dad,’ we’re everything to our child. We have to be their friend, their role model, and their support system. For me, it means giving my daughter as much time, stability, and love as I can, because she really depends on me—I’m the one person she’s closest to. It’s rewarding but also a huge responsibility, and sometimes it feels overwhelming.”
The author also had some encouraging advice to share with other single parents. “Don’t let others take advantage of the fact that you have a big heart. It’s okay to say ‘no,’ even when it’s hard or when you’re afraid of the fallout. Sometimes, people will push our boundaries without really understanding what we’re dealing with, and standing up for ourselves is necessary to protect our energy for the people who matter most.”
Healthy boundaries and mutual respect are good for everyone, no matter if they’re your family or complete strangers
The simple fact is that nobody likes to feel used. Nor does anyone enjoy being pressured into doing something that goes against their values and beliefs. Boundaries are there for a reason: they allow us to develop healthier, happier relationships with other people. That holds true for interacting with your relatives, too.
Love is centered around respect and trust, not just sacrifice. There needs to be a give-and-take dynamic at work here. If you’re always giving but never receive anything in return, it’s not love, it’s someone taking advantage of you because it’s convenient.
So, family members can’t just demand you to ignore all of your plans and responsibilities at the drop of a hat, to help them out with whatever. If you constantly run errands for others without finding time for yourself or your own loved ones, not only are you going to end up being exhausted, you’ll likely end up having a superficial relationship with your kids. And that’s not great for anyone.
Prioritizing yourself and your children isn’t a sin. You can love your siblings very much and have meaningful relationships with them without being at their every beck and call. Saying ‘no’ when you mean it, being authentic, and protecting your boundaries are all mature things to do. Telling someone they don’t have it as hard because they have fewer kids, on the other hand, is very immature.
It’s definitely possible to reestablish a good connection between the two siblings, but it’ll require the sister to change her attitude, cut back on the requests, and show that she respects her brother. Rebuilding that trust probably won’t come easy and will take a long time, though. Starting things off with a sincere apology, taking responsibility for the hurtful comment, and a promise to change is probably a good start.
You don’t always have to rely on your relatives to look after your kids. It’s not difficult to hire a good babysitter
Image credits: Andrea Piacquadio / pexels (not the actual photo)
And it’s not like there’s a Catch-22, unsolvable dilemma here. There are so many possible solutions and compromises here. Asking your relatives to babysit once in a while is fine, so long as you don’t turn it into a full-time unpaid job. However, if they’re busy with other things, there are plenty of quality babysitters you can hire, whether from super fancy organizations or your friendly neighbors.
If it’s a matter of trust, you can always ask around for some recommendations. It’s incredibly likely that your family, friends, and neighbors know some trustworthy, experienced, and capable sitters whom they’d be happy to recommend to you.
Hiring a babysitter once in a while won’t break the bank. To put it slightly more bluntly, if your financial situation allows you to go on a retreat, it’s certainly not out of your price range to hire someone to look after your children, instead of always relying on a family member to pitch in.
Meanwhile, any of the author’s relatives who are judgmental of him enforcing some basic boundaries are also fully capable of lending a hand and babysitting his sister’s 3 children.
Having boundaries and enforcing them is nothing to feel guilty about. On the contrary, this leads to healthier relationships
Broadly speaking, the clearer you are and the better you communicate about your babysitting needs, the easier things will be between you and your family members.
Everyone needs to be on the same page. There need to be some basic ground rules so that everyone knows what to expect. If there are any issues, they need to be raised and actively listened to. Free babysitting is a privilege, not a right. And publicly showing some gratitude every once in a while is certainly appreciated, even if it’s become commonplace.
From a psychological point of view, it’s usually best to stay calm and keep away from judging others or accusing them, even if they’ve done something wrong.
If your goal is to find common ground and to reinforce your boundaries, then should use a lot of “I” statements and talk about how their behavior makes you feel. The less defensive the other party gets, the more likely they are to hear you out.
What would you do if you were in the single dad’s shoes, dear readers? Have you ever become your family’s free go-to babysitter? What do you do to enforce healthy boundaries with your siblings? How often do you ask your relatives to babysit your kids? Share your advice and opinions in the comments.
Many readers were shocked by the sister’s behavior. They stood in support of how the brother handled things
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
Damn i came here looking for the usual unhinged YTA comments... and there aren't any. What is the world coming to? :D
We'll have to make up our own, I guess. Ummmmm...OP is TA because his niblings LOVE him and their little HEARTS are BROKEN that he doesn't want to see them and doesn't he know how HARD it is to be a mom these days? She just wants a BREAK is that so terrible???? It's not HER fault that he doesn't have a wife to provide him with more kids so that he can be a REAL parent. /end facetious unhinged-ness
Load More Replies...She insulted you, doubled down, then quadrupled down. Wild guess, her job doesn't involve negotiation, does it? So she's lost her free babysitter, then. Tell her to take her real parent money and pay for a real babysitter.
LoL you are too nice, I would have told her to shuff that money were the sun don't shine. Hmmm, I wonder if she ever even thought of babysitting OP:s child? I mean sence she is a "real parent" and obviously soooo good at handling several kids?
Load More Replies...Yes, she has 3 kids... and a husband to support her and them. He is a single Dad, running his house, I assume working, raising a daughter, dealing with his grief and dealing with his daughter's grief. WTAF. He is also too nice, should not babysit again but if he does, he should stop rearranging his plans - if he has plans, no babysitting.
I wanna smash OP's sister in the head, her comments made me so angry! Not a real parent?!?! OP went through the soul-crushing experience of losing his partner soon after birth. So, not only has he had to be a single parent, but he had zero other help to rely on. And his sister has the balls to diminish his struggle and his hard work just because he didn't keep getting women pregnant. The sister has a whole other adult to help run her house AND she had the added assistance of a brother who sounds like he would drop everything to help her children. I hope finding regular, quality child care is near impossible for her and she recognizes what a stupid, selfish àsshole she is.
I like the part about “a full household” like-if the sister talked to a mom who has 6kids… I hope the sister be insulted that her own house would be ‘not a full household’
Load More Replies...What's wrong with these people. Tell her to f**k away off. Either kiss someone's a*s when then do you favours or get f****d.
Yikes. Special "what a jerk the sister is" points goes to her for telling him she needed him to babysit for her couples weekend, while telling him he's not a real parent, and apparently not even considering that his partner died. There's just a lot of insensitive buttheadness to unpack on that one. Also, why are the moms in these scenarios always just peace makers? "Let it go she has a lot on her plate". So does he, and she should apologize like a responsible adult. Jeepers.
I would rather be in a couple raising eight kids than be a single parent to one. Anyone who can't respect how difficult it is to do it solo is delusional.
I'm reading your story wondering in my head why THEY aren't the ones helping you out more. You are ONE parent fulling the role of two whole adults, at least! She's way out of line & needs to get a clue. Maintain your boundaries respectfully but honestly if anything they need to be stepping it up more for you & your daughter because that's what a healthy family does. Not punish & take advantage of you! Good luck & enjoy your weekend.
Not ah. She wants to go for a weekend w her husband. You want to go do a thing with your kid. They could go an leave the kids w gm. Since she had to chime in. And maybe talk to sis husband about this too as it's becoming so common a you have to move plans for no reason.
Last I looked, being a real parent meant prioritising your own kid(s) over someone who wants a spa weekend away. Suck it.
Very similar story yesterday, but that one he didn't have a six year old
One of the most significant decisions my Mom and I made was to cut off our toxic family. It's just her, my sister (she's a handful herself) and me. Most of them are dead, but the few that are left aren't worth dealing with. And since we are magnets for needy folks, we don't socialize either. I do have a women I've been friends with for 40 years, but she lives in another state and we just keep in touch by FB messenger and it's great.
She was so far out of line she should crawl on her knees begging for forgiveness just to be able to look in the mirror. Calling a widowed father or mother not a real parent when they are clearly managing it very well because of a minor annoyance? Does she have any idea how that can effect widows/widowers? Suddenly they are alone managing a little person. Just the grief is hard enough for anyone, but I'm sure men are especially prone to self doubt in this situation. These were extremely cruel words, whatever her intentions, and she must give an honest and heartfelt apology.
She obviously doesn't realize this man is parenting and doing it all by himself. Good grief, the man needs a break! It seems to be those closest to us that hurt us the most. I had to cut off my entire family due to their toxicity.
You're not a real parent cause you had one kid and I chose to have multiple children because of the tax credit....lol
Your sister is off her rocker. She waned 3 children so they are her responsibility. It doesn't take a village and family is not obliged to help out: your kid, your responsibility. If your mother has problems with how you feel, tell your mother to go and help her daughter. To call you 'not a real parent'
If anything, according to his account of the story he was incredibly generous and under reacting to that. The moment that twat started with her insults the conversation should have been over. If it was text, then soon as she started getting family involved Id post the whole thing. This is UNACCEPTABLE. Scortched earth until it apologized to me and made real effort to appreciate the time and effort he put in. Just because you share DNA doesnt mean you owe filth like that ANYTHING
Anyone wants your help babysitting and then has the gumption to say you aren't a "real" parent: Simple! Dean Ambrose- NOPE and done! If OP's mother wants to take his sister's side, then SHE should do the babysitting like a "real" grandparent instead. Sh*tmouth sister is finding out how "real" the situation got and now she's in REAL trouble having no babysitters. People, jeez!!!
"Only a small comment..." An ice pick only makes a small hole but can be just as de@dly as a .44 Magnum
I wouldn't babysit for her ever again or have anything to do with her.
I've noticed everything is always wonderful until one time when the free baby sitter has other plans. That family member becomes the most selfish, mean, horrible person on the face of the earth! Usually even their mother thinks so! How dare they ever say no. Aunts, Cousins, Uncles etc, please do yourselves a Huge Favor, say No the 3rd time you're asked. Then say you're unavailable every 4thor 3rd or 5th time! DO NOT make yourself so reliable! It becomes expected. You then OWE IT TO THEM TO ALWAYS BE AVAILABLE. Don't allow it to happen.
That poll is completely unhinged. Does the single father have the right to refuse to babysit? Yeah, regardless of circumstances, not his kids, not his problem, duh.
To add, her reasoning for the request was a "want" that did not warrant any obligation from his needs and responsibilites to his daughter ... whether 1, 3, 7 or 10, his child comes first to him ... she must have forgotten that rule when making plans for herself and her husband ...
Genuine and Amazing service on how to get back your ex. To whom it may concern, After spending hours searching the internet about how to get my lover back i was glad that i contacted Dr Iyayi who help me get back my ex within 48 hours, So Without wasting much time i would like to write out the details of Dr Iyayi whose details has done a lot of people a huge favor. website: http://Driyayilovespell.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Driyayi48hourslovespell Email: Driyayi48hourslovespell@gmail.com
I do hope it is. Reading reminds the rest of us to be grateful for what we have and mind our own manners. My SIL would drop her kids off when we visited my in-laws on vacation for me to watch for a week, "so the kids could all play together" since we "lived so far away" That left me watching 4 kids, while on my vacation, two to three times a year. My in-laws always had projects that required my husband's help (reroofing, fixing plumbing, put in new floors, etc.). After a really bad visit, we never went back and my SIL was mad because she had to cancel her vacations away from her kids ... 🤬
Load More Replies...The only part where the OP might step into soft YTA territory is when he talks about his sister and BIL scheduling more things last notice with him lately and "I've *had* to cancel plans, juggle my own schedule, and rearrange things to accommodate them." No, you didn't have to, and no, you shouldn't have. This is the gateway to being taken advantage of. There's nothing wrong with doing things for people when it fits into your schedule, but as soon as you start rearranging your life to accommodate other people's wants (not needs, but wants), everyone ends up on Reddit (surprised Pikachu face) asking if AITA because someone accused them of being selfish after they got tired of being treated like a doormat and said no.
Damn i came here looking for the usual unhinged YTA comments... and there aren't any. What is the world coming to? :D
We'll have to make up our own, I guess. Ummmmm...OP is TA because his niblings LOVE him and their little HEARTS are BROKEN that he doesn't want to see them and doesn't he know how HARD it is to be a mom these days? She just wants a BREAK is that so terrible???? It's not HER fault that he doesn't have a wife to provide him with more kids so that he can be a REAL parent. /end facetious unhinged-ness
Load More Replies...She insulted you, doubled down, then quadrupled down. Wild guess, her job doesn't involve negotiation, does it? So she's lost her free babysitter, then. Tell her to take her real parent money and pay for a real babysitter.
LoL you are too nice, I would have told her to shuff that money were the sun don't shine. Hmmm, I wonder if she ever even thought of babysitting OP:s child? I mean sence she is a "real parent" and obviously soooo good at handling several kids?
Load More Replies...Yes, she has 3 kids... and a husband to support her and them. He is a single Dad, running his house, I assume working, raising a daughter, dealing with his grief and dealing with his daughter's grief. WTAF. He is also too nice, should not babysit again but if he does, he should stop rearranging his plans - if he has plans, no babysitting.
I wanna smash OP's sister in the head, her comments made me so angry! Not a real parent?!?! OP went through the soul-crushing experience of losing his partner soon after birth. So, not only has he had to be a single parent, but he had zero other help to rely on. And his sister has the balls to diminish his struggle and his hard work just because he didn't keep getting women pregnant. The sister has a whole other adult to help run her house AND she had the added assistance of a brother who sounds like he would drop everything to help her children. I hope finding regular, quality child care is near impossible for her and she recognizes what a stupid, selfish àsshole she is.
I like the part about “a full household” like-if the sister talked to a mom who has 6kids… I hope the sister be insulted that her own house would be ‘not a full household’
Load More Replies...What's wrong with these people. Tell her to f**k away off. Either kiss someone's a*s when then do you favours or get f****d.
Yikes. Special "what a jerk the sister is" points goes to her for telling him she needed him to babysit for her couples weekend, while telling him he's not a real parent, and apparently not even considering that his partner died. There's just a lot of insensitive buttheadness to unpack on that one. Also, why are the moms in these scenarios always just peace makers? "Let it go she has a lot on her plate". So does he, and she should apologize like a responsible adult. Jeepers.
I would rather be in a couple raising eight kids than be a single parent to one. Anyone who can't respect how difficult it is to do it solo is delusional.
I'm reading your story wondering in my head why THEY aren't the ones helping you out more. You are ONE parent fulling the role of two whole adults, at least! She's way out of line & needs to get a clue. Maintain your boundaries respectfully but honestly if anything they need to be stepping it up more for you & your daughter because that's what a healthy family does. Not punish & take advantage of you! Good luck & enjoy your weekend.
Not ah. She wants to go for a weekend w her husband. You want to go do a thing with your kid. They could go an leave the kids w gm. Since she had to chime in. And maybe talk to sis husband about this too as it's becoming so common a you have to move plans for no reason.
Last I looked, being a real parent meant prioritising your own kid(s) over someone who wants a spa weekend away. Suck it.
Very similar story yesterday, but that one he didn't have a six year old
One of the most significant decisions my Mom and I made was to cut off our toxic family. It's just her, my sister (she's a handful herself) and me. Most of them are dead, but the few that are left aren't worth dealing with. And since we are magnets for needy folks, we don't socialize either. I do have a women I've been friends with for 40 years, but she lives in another state and we just keep in touch by FB messenger and it's great.
She was so far out of line she should crawl on her knees begging for forgiveness just to be able to look in the mirror. Calling a widowed father or mother not a real parent when they are clearly managing it very well because of a minor annoyance? Does she have any idea how that can effect widows/widowers? Suddenly they are alone managing a little person. Just the grief is hard enough for anyone, but I'm sure men are especially prone to self doubt in this situation. These were extremely cruel words, whatever her intentions, and she must give an honest and heartfelt apology.
She obviously doesn't realize this man is parenting and doing it all by himself. Good grief, the man needs a break! It seems to be those closest to us that hurt us the most. I had to cut off my entire family due to their toxicity.
You're not a real parent cause you had one kid and I chose to have multiple children because of the tax credit....lol
Your sister is off her rocker. She waned 3 children so they are her responsibility. It doesn't take a village and family is not obliged to help out: your kid, your responsibility. If your mother has problems with how you feel, tell your mother to go and help her daughter. To call you 'not a real parent'
If anything, according to his account of the story he was incredibly generous and under reacting to that. The moment that twat started with her insults the conversation should have been over. If it was text, then soon as she started getting family involved Id post the whole thing. This is UNACCEPTABLE. Scortched earth until it apologized to me and made real effort to appreciate the time and effort he put in. Just because you share DNA doesnt mean you owe filth like that ANYTHING
Anyone wants your help babysitting and then has the gumption to say you aren't a "real" parent: Simple! Dean Ambrose- NOPE and done! If OP's mother wants to take his sister's side, then SHE should do the babysitting like a "real" grandparent instead. Sh*tmouth sister is finding out how "real" the situation got and now she's in REAL trouble having no babysitters. People, jeez!!!
"Only a small comment..." An ice pick only makes a small hole but can be just as de@dly as a .44 Magnum
I wouldn't babysit for her ever again or have anything to do with her.
I've noticed everything is always wonderful until one time when the free baby sitter has other plans. That family member becomes the most selfish, mean, horrible person on the face of the earth! Usually even their mother thinks so! How dare they ever say no. Aunts, Cousins, Uncles etc, please do yourselves a Huge Favor, say No the 3rd time you're asked. Then say you're unavailable every 4thor 3rd or 5th time! DO NOT make yourself so reliable! It becomes expected. You then OWE IT TO THEM TO ALWAYS BE AVAILABLE. Don't allow it to happen.
That poll is completely unhinged. Does the single father have the right to refuse to babysit? Yeah, regardless of circumstances, not his kids, not his problem, duh.
To add, her reasoning for the request was a "want" that did not warrant any obligation from his needs and responsibilites to his daughter ... whether 1, 3, 7 or 10, his child comes first to him ... she must have forgotten that rule when making plans for herself and her husband ...
Genuine and Amazing service on how to get back your ex. To whom it may concern, After spending hours searching the internet about how to get my lover back i was glad that i contacted Dr Iyayi who help me get back my ex within 48 hours, So Without wasting much time i would like to write out the details of Dr Iyayi whose details has done a lot of people a huge favor. website: http://Driyayilovespell.com Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Driyayi48hourslovespell Email: Driyayi48hourslovespell@gmail.com
I do hope it is. Reading reminds the rest of us to be grateful for what we have and mind our own manners. My SIL would drop her kids off when we visited my in-laws on vacation for me to watch for a week, "so the kids could all play together" since we "lived so far away" That left me watching 4 kids, while on my vacation, two to three times a year. My in-laws always had projects that required my husband's help (reroofing, fixing plumbing, put in new floors, etc.). After a really bad visit, we never went back and my SIL was mad because she had to cancel her vacations away from her kids ... 🤬
Load More Replies...The only part where the OP might step into soft YTA territory is when he talks about his sister and BIL scheduling more things last notice with him lately and "I've *had* to cancel plans, juggle my own schedule, and rearrange things to accommodate them." No, you didn't have to, and no, you shouldn't have. This is the gateway to being taken advantage of. There's nothing wrong with doing things for people when it fits into your schedule, but as soon as you start rearranging your life to accommodate other people's wants (not needs, but wants), everyone ends up on Reddit (surprised Pikachu face) asking if AITA because someone accused them of being selfish after they got tired of being treated like a doormat and said no.
52
47