
27YO Guy Gets A Reality Check From Older GF When He Tries To Stop Her Having A Glass Of Wine
Relationships are about give and take, but if one partner holds the reins too tightly, things seldom end well. After all, who wants to be constantly told what they can and can’t do, especially once they’ve reached adulthood?
One woman found herself in the unenviable position of having to tell her boyfriend where he could get off after he tried to deny her a glass of wine because he doesn’t “trust her family genes”. She turned to netizens to share her story.
More info: Reddit
A healthy relationship should never be about control, as this woman was forced to point out to her pushy boyfriend
Image credits: Gustavo Fring / Pexels (not the actual photo)
While they were out shopping for a seafood dinner, she asked her boyfriend to grab a bottle of wine she knew would pair perfectly with the dish
Image credits: senivpetro / Freepik (not the actual photo)
Much to her surprise, her boyfriend flat-out refused, telling her she shouldn’t be drinking during the week
Image credits: simonapilolla / Freepik (not the actual photo)
When she asked him why, he straight-up told her that her family are alcoholics, and he doesn’t trust her “family genes”
Image credits: bowlofglitter
When she told him she’s an adult and she’ll do what she wants, he stormed off to his dad’s place, leaving her to ask netizens if she’d been a jerk
Most people would agree that a glass of wine with dinner is perfectly normal—unless you’re OP’s boyfriend, Dave, that is. Her relaxing Thursday turned into a dramatic argument after Dave refused to let her enjoy a single glass of wine with her meal. His reason? Her family has a history of alcoholism, so he doesn’t “trust her genes.” Yikes.
It all started when the couple went shopping to pick up ingredients for a special seafood dinner. Thinking a small bottle of her favorite wine would pair perfectly with the dish, she asked Dave to grab one, but he flat-out refused. Confused, she asked him why, only to be hit with an unexpected and rather insulting insinuation.
Defending her right to make her own choices, she reminded Dave that she’s a grown woman and can make her own decisions. Instead of handling the conversation maturely, though, Dave exploded with anger, stormed off to his dad’s place for the night, and left OP high and dry with an untouched dinner. All over a measly glass of wine.
Now, she’s wondering if she was in the wrong, and turned to netizens for advice.
Let’s be real – controlling what your partner can and can’t drink (especially in moderation) on a random Thursday night? Major red flag. Dave is using his fear of OP becoming an alcoholic to try to control her, and that’s just not how healthy relationships work. But is there any sense in his argument that she might be at risk of developing into a full-blown alcoholic just because of her family history? We went looking for answers.
Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)
In her article for Healthline, Hope Gillette writes that, according to the 2021 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, alcohol use disorder (AUD) affects approximately 29.5 million people in the United States.
The 5th edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, a clinical diagnostic guidebook, states that AUD often runs in families at a rate of 3–4 times higher compared with the general population.
Basically, the more relatives you have living with AUD and the closer they are to you in relation, the higher your individual genetic risk becomes.
In her article for GoodRX, Emily Guarnotta writes that, while genetics play a role in the risk of alcoholism, there is no “alcoholic gene.” Someone’s risk of developing AUD is due to variations in many different genes – researchers believe that hundreds of different genes play a role.
But it doesn’t all come down to genetics, either. Other risk factors for developing AUD include starting to drink alcohol at a young age, a history of trauma, mental health conditions, cognitive impairments, and difficulty controlling impulses in childhood or adolescence.
From what she tells the community in her post, it doesn’t seem like OP is anywhere near an alcoholic – she even mentions not being able to remember the last time she had a drink with dinner. We think her boyfriend is going to have to ease up a bit, or risk ruining their whole relationship.
What would you have done if you’d found yourself in OP’s shoes? Do you think her boyfriend has a point, or should he let her make her own adult choices? Let us know your opinion in the comments!
In the comments, readers slammed the woman’s boyfriend for being too controlling and reminded her that he’s not her parent or boss
Poll Question
Do you think Dave's concerns about her family history of alcoholism are valid enough to restrict her from having a glass of wine?
Yes, family history can be a concern
No, she's an adult and can make her own decisions
He's just using it as a way to control her
It depends on how often this issue arises
I work in a liquor store. I'd have recommended a nice pinot gris to go with your meal
Oooo, I haven't had a good PG in years - I tend to do a nice New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc with fish, but...yum.
I've two divorces, both from men who attempted to control me. Ditch this guy, he is setting up to control you. This is a SERIOUS warning. Don't wait until he puts you in the hospital.
It ***may*** have come from a place of love- alcohoIism/addíction DOES have a genetic component- but he was definitely out of line.
A better approach would have been to bring up concerns, then observe and wait. I've met people from alcoholic families and they're all over the place: one didn't drink out of fear of add!ction; another was fine with two glasses on occasion; another has no issue with alcohol, but gave herself strict rules for gambling (potential add!*c+i0n).
Load More Replies...Mm no. He’s trying to control what she drinks. Big difference.
Load More Replies...OP, just remember this: If all he does is whine, whine, whine, whine, whine over wine, please don't let him waste your time, time, time, time, time (IYKYK). Enjoy your time that glass of wine now that the whine has taken his sorry behind home to daddy -_-"
It's not about the wine is about him thinking he gets any say in what you ingest. Run, it will only get worse.
This is your moment. Walk away NOW! He's a controlling p***k and it will only get worse.
"I don't trust your family genes" is such a romantic thing to say. If you don't trust my genes, stay away from me.
On one hand add*ction, especially alcoholism has a strong genetic component. On the other hand she's a grown a*s woman and it's one glass of wine. He has no right to say no to her as if she's a child wanting cake before dinner. She doesn't need to ask him for permission and he sure doesn't have the right to try to police her. If she was drinking often I could see his concern. But if what OP says is true then he's just a controlling pr*ck. (We also don't know why her dad was drinking. If it's due to an environmental factor it's unlikely to affect how OP handles drinking)
I would be very careful not to have any children with this guy because their father would be an a-hole and you can't trust those genes.
My (former) uncle was an alcoholic. It destroyed his marriage and his life before it killed him. His kids (my cousins) refuse to touch alcohol. It's a well-known inherited condition. There's more to this story. Dude's not just going to warn her out of the blue. And he's not stopping her from drinking, he's just not enabling her by buying it himself. It could be controlling, or it could be considerate and loving if we knew the complete story.
Enabling means that there is an issue or an unwanted behavior going on. If we go with what OP was saying there was no enabling possible as no such behavior excised. He was just refusing to do grocery shopping because he didn't want her to have one glass of wine to dinner. Even if she was drinking more than what was healthy just going "NO" as if she's a dog eating something she shouldn't is not the right way to handle it.
She says that she hasn't had a glass with her dinner for as long as she can remember, and clarifies that she has not previously had any alcohol dependencies. So it very much comes of as this being the first time. Judging by her reaction it very much seems like it's the first time he's said something like that to her too. Also that manual doesn't really seem right, especially for people in their 20's - 30's. Having more than 2 beers when you are out is not really being dependent on alcohol...
Load More Replies...It is actually meant to be used as a guide. It ONLY lists the MINIMUM criteria that MUST be met in order to receive a certain diagnosis. This person is ridiculous. lol the DSM uses statistical data from each diagnosis and says “these are the common denominators in everyone with this diagnosis” basically and a board then agrees that ok, then this is the minimum criteria that needs to be met before anyone can be given this diagnosis. That’s why it’s name is the Diagnostic & Statistics Manual. It’s NOT meant to be used as a checklist to say everyone who does THIS has THIS mental illness. SMH. The Original commenter here is confused
Source: worked in healthcare for 12 years, am a recovering a****t myself, and my fiance is as well, but he is also an addictions counselor
Also it is a DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA manual. Meaning the things that specifically HAVE to be met, AKA THE MINIMUM CRITERIA, in order to receive a SPECIFIC MENTAL HEALTH DIAGNOSIS. However, ALL mental health physicians KNOW that mental health is never one size fits all or even one size fits most. The DSM is meant to be used as a guide to help. It is not a checklist to go around diagnosing everyone. As with every diagnosis, all mental health diagnoses should take into account all things in an individuals case. NOT just what the dsm tells them to
Source: worked in healthcare for 12 years, am a recovering a****t myself, and my fiance is as well, but he is also an addictions counselor
I think you’re misreading if you indulge in alcohol more than three days a week (as in over half of the time) you MAY have an alcohol dependency issue. That’s very different than 3 or more times a week
I work in a liquor store. I'd have recommended a nice pinot gris to go with your meal
Oooo, I haven't had a good PG in years - I tend to do a nice New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc with fish, but...yum.
I've two divorces, both from men who attempted to control me. Ditch this guy, he is setting up to control you. This is a SERIOUS warning. Don't wait until he puts you in the hospital.
It ***may*** have come from a place of love- alcohoIism/addíction DOES have a genetic component- but he was definitely out of line.
A better approach would have been to bring up concerns, then observe and wait. I've met people from alcoholic families and they're all over the place: one didn't drink out of fear of add!ction; another was fine with two glasses on occasion; another has no issue with alcohol, but gave herself strict rules for gambling (potential add!*c+i0n).
Load More Replies...Mm no. He’s trying to control what she drinks. Big difference.
Load More Replies...OP, just remember this: If all he does is whine, whine, whine, whine, whine over wine, please don't let him waste your time, time, time, time, time (IYKYK). Enjoy your time that glass of wine now that the whine has taken his sorry behind home to daddy -_-"
It's not about the wine is about him thinking he gets any say in what you ingest. Run, it will only get worse.
This is your moment. Walk away NOW! He's a controlling p***k and it will only get worse.
"I don't trust your family genes" is such a romantic thing to say. If you don't trust my genes, stay away from me.
On one hand add*ction, especially alcoholism has a strong genetic component. On the other hand she's a grown a*s woman and it's one glass of wine. He has no right to say no to her as if she's a child wanting cake before dinner. She doesn't need to ask him for permission and he sure doesn't have the right to try to police her. If she was drinking often I could see his concern. But if what OP says is true then he's just a controlling pr*ck. (We also don't know why her dad was drinking. If it's due to an environmental factor it's unlikely to affect how OP handles drinking)
I would be very careful not to have any children with this guy because their father would be an a-hole and you can't trust those genes.
My (former) uncle was an alcoholic. It destroyed his marriage and his life before it killed him. His kids (my cousins) refuse to touch alcohol. It's a well-known inherited condition. There's more to this story. Dude's not just going to warn her out of the blue. And he's not stopping her from drinking, he's just not enabling her by buying it himself. It could be controlling, or it could be considerate and loving if we knew the complete story.
Enabling means that there is an issue or an unwanted behavior going on. If we go with what OP was saying there was no enabling possible as no such behavior excised. He was just refusing to do grocery shopping because he didn't want her to have one glass of wine to dinner. Even if she was drinking more than what was healthy just going "NO" as if she's a dog eating something she shouldn't is not the right way to handle it.
She says that she hasn't had a glass with her dinner for as long as she can remember, and clarifies that she has not previously had any alcohol dependencies. So it very much comes of as this being the first time. Judging by her reaction it very much seems like it's the first time he's said something like that to her too. Also that manual doesn't really seem right, especially for people in their 20's - 30's. Having more than 2 beers when you are out is not really being dependent on alcohol...
Load More Replies...It is actually meant to be used as a guide. It ONLY lists the MINIMUM criteria that MUST be met in order to receive a certain diagnosis. This person is ridiculous. lol the DSM uses statistical data from each diagnosis and says “these are the common denominators in everyone with this diagnosis” basically and a board then agrees that ok, then this is the minimum criteria that needs to be met before anyone can be given this diagnosis. That’s why it’s name is the Diagnostic & Statistics Manual. It’s NOT meant to be used as a checklist to say everyone who does THIS has THIS mental illness. SMH. The Original commenter here is confused
Source: worked in healthcare for 12 years, am a recovering a****t myself, and my fiance is as well, but he is also an addictions counselor
Also it is a DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA manual. Meaning the things that specifically HAVE to be met, AKA THE MINIMUM CRITERIA, in order to receive a SPECIFIC MENTAL HEALTH DIAGNOSIS. However, ALL mental health physicians KNOW that mental health is never one size fits all or even one size fits most. The DSM is meant to be used as a guide to help. It is not a checklist to go around diagnosing everyone. As with every diagnosis, all mental health diagnoses should take into account all things in an individuals case. NOT just what the dsm tells them to
Source: worked in healthcare for 12 years, am a recovering a****t myself, and my fiance is as well, but he is also an addictions counselor
I think you’re misreading if you indulge in alcohol more than three days a week (as in over half of the time) you MAY have an alcohol dependency issue. That’s very different than 3 or more times a week
34
29