Hey Pandas, AITA For Ignoring My Swim Coach’s Advice On Tampons And Choosing What Works For Me?
Moderator’s note:
If you find yourself disagreeing with this person’s actions, we encourage you not to downvote the post. Instead, kindly express your opinions in the comments. We recommend maintaining politeness and articulating your thoughts with well-constructed arguments.
I (17 F) don’t wear tampons. I find them uncomfortable and unsafe, as my personal opinion
Image credits: Reproductive Health Supplies Coalition (not the actual photo)
I’m also on a high school swim team. I had a swim meet the other day, not a very important one, but still mandated to go to.
I have a swimsuit that was designed to be able to swim when you’re on your period, which I was
Image credits: margot pandone (not the actual photo)
Unfortunately my coach (42 M) requires matching swimsuits for the girls on the team, and my special suit isn’t the right color
Image credits: cottonbro studio (not the actual photo)
My coach proceeded to make me explain why I won’t change, and then told me that as I’m old enough I should be wearing tampons!?
He then didn’t let me participate in the meet and is considering removing me from the team for a month!? AITA?
Moderator’s note:
Please note that the images included in this article are for illustrative purposes only and do not represent the actual individuals or items discussed in the story.
If you have a comparable experience or story you’d like to tell, we welcome your submissions. Click here to share your story with Bored Panda.
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
23Kviews
Share on FacebookThis is a team sport and you're refusing to wear the uniform. I don't understand why you didn't make arrengements to have a team uniform that's made to be safe with pad wearers? The couch should have spoken to you with more care but you are in a team sport and are required to wear a uniform. You can't just show up in something different because you didn't plan ahead and hoped to get preferential treatment instead of planning ahead.
Well said. If this was gym class (aka something that's forced,) I'd agree with the student 1,000,000%. But the student joined and continued to stay on the swim team knowing the requirements. Due to several medical issues, I only wear tampons for the last few days of my period, and only briefly when I have to leave the house. Knowing this, I would never purposely sign myself up for something that pretty much forced me to wear one for long stretches or for the first few days, even if that meant missing out on something I enjoy. Kid needs to understand that actions have consequences. Don't wear the uniform, don't get to be part of the team. 🤷♀️
Load More Replies...With all consideration of a woman's right to handle her cycle aside, I'm thinking that the most basic issue here is that the coach doesn't want the pool water contaminated with menstrual fluid. A garment that allows for a pad to be worn is fine, out of the water, but once it is submerged anything the pad has absorbed is released into the water. The issue here isn't matching uniforms; it is keeping the water clean and safe. If you're a woman on a swim team and you're serious about it, then you'll do what is necessary to participate even if that means wearing a tampon. It's a minor inconvenience and won't hurt you.
The health hazard alone says, YTA. Show me there's no way your blood leaks into the pool... guaranteed, ok. Female swimmer here.
I'd be worried more about the urinary and fecal contaminants that end up in a pool due to poor hygiene.
Load More Replies...This is a team sport and you're refusing to wear the uniform. I don't understand why you didn't make arrengements to have a team uniform that's made to be safe with pad wearers? The couch should have spoken to you with more care but you are in a team sport and are required to wear a uniform. You can't just show up in something different because you didn't plan ahead and hoped to get preferential treatment instead of planning ahead.
Well said. If this was gym class (aka something that's forced,) I'd agree with the student 1,000,000%. But the student joined and continued to stay on the swim team knowing the requirements. Due to several medical issues, I only wear tampons for the last few days of my period, and only briefly when I have to leave the house. Knowing this, I would never purposely sign myself up for something that pretty much forced me to wear one for long stretches or for the first few days, even if that meant missing out on something I enjoy. Kid needs to understand that actions have consequences. Don't wear the uniform, don't get to be part of the team. 🤷♀️
Load More Replies...With all consideration of a woman's right to handle her cycle aside, I'm thinking that the most basic issue here is that the coach doesn't want the pool water contaminated with menstrual fluid. A garment that allows for a pad to be worn is fine, out of the water, but once it is submerged anything the pad has absorbed is released into the water. The issue here isn't matching uniforms; it is keeping the water clean and safe. If you're a woman on a swim team and you're serious about it, then you'll do what is necessary to participate even if that means wearing a tampon. It's a minor inconvenience and won't hurt you.
The health hazard alone says, YTA. Show me there's no way your blood leaks into the pool... guaranteed, ok. Female swimmer here.
I'd be worried more about the urinary and fecal contaminants that end up in a pool due to poor hygiene.
Load More Replies...
-10
109