User submission

Hey Pandas, AITA For Thinking My Mom Reported My SIL To CPS Behind Our Backs?

Moderator’s note:

If you find yourself disagreeing with this person’s actions, we encourage you not to downvote the post. Instead, kindly express your opinions in the comments. We recommend maintaining politeness and articulating your thoughts with well-constructed arguments.

A bit of background: A few months ago, my brother was experiencing serious mental health issues and problems with substance abuse. During one of his stays in the hospital, my sister-in-law (SIL) was struggling to manage their three children on her own. One night, while dealing with the usual routine of making dinner and getting the kids ready for bed, the eldest child had an outburst. In frustration, my SIL accidentally pushed the child, who then fell to the ground and injured their wrist. The next day, my SIL took the child for an X-ray, which revealed a minor fracture.

At that time, my brother wasn’t thinking clearly and relayed the story to our mother, who immediately assumed it was a case of abuse

Hey Pandas, AITA For Thinking My Mom Reported My SIL To CPS Behind Our Backs?

Image credits: Manny Becerra (not the actual photo)

It’s worth mentioning that my mother doesn’t particularly like my SIL and takes every opportunity to badmouth her. She also believes it’s entirely my SIL’s fault that my brother was experiencing mental health issues in the first place.

Fast forward to now: My brother has gotten sober and sought the professional help he needed. I’m so proud of how far he’s come

Hey Pandas, AITA For Thinking My Mom Reported My SIL To CPS Behind Our Backs?

Image credits: The Unmistakables (not the actual photo)

Today, my SIL told me that she recently received a call regarding a report of concern for the welfare of her child, specifically about the wrist injury

Hey Pandas, AITA For Thinking My Mom Reported My SIL To CPS Behind Our Backs?

Image credits: Paul Hanaoka (not the actual photo)

A “concerned” family member made this report. My husband and I are absolutely horrified that someone, especially a family member, would make such an accusation during such a rough and low period in their lives. My SIL suspects that either my sister or mother made the call. I personally believe it was my mother.

My question is, AITAH for wanting to know who made this call to CPS, or should I leave it to my brother to confront the person who did this and ask why?

Moderator’s note:

Please note that the images included in this article are for illustrative purposes only and do not represent the actual individuals or items discussed in the story.

If you have a comparable experience or story you’d like to tell, we welcome your submissions. Click here to share your story with Bored Panda.

Poll Question

Thanks! Check out the results:

30Kviews

This lazy panda forgot to write something about itself.

Read less »

This lazy panda forgot to write something about itself.

Read less »

Hi there! I'm Gabrielė, but you can also catch me responding to Gab, Gabi, Gabert, or Gabe – take your pick. Professionally, I'm the senior community manager over at Bored Panda, helping people share their awesome work and connecting artists with a worldwide audience. Beyond work, you'll catch me traveling, listening to vinyl and diving into movies, art exhibitions, and concerts. I'm a culture buff at heart, always eager to explore and embrace the richness of the human experience.

Read less »

What do you think ?

POST

Min 2 months ago

She got frustrated and broke her child's wrist. That is abuse. Very few child abusers actually set out to do so. As Libstak wrote, abuse is often caused by frustration.

51points

LakotaWolf (she/her) 2 months ago

As a child who was frequently shoved, pushed, and thrown across the room by my mother when she was "frustrated" or "angry": yes! This is ABUSE. This is not an ACCIDENT.

42points

Load More Replies...

Bouche and Audi and Shyla, Oh My! 2 months ago

But the child's wrist was only broken a little bit. (Yes, this is sarcasm!)

3points

Monica Thompson 2 months ago

This comment is hidden. Click here to view.

Libstak 2 months ago (edited)

She did act in frustration. OK yes, we all are capable of that but please do realise abuse is commonly about frustration too. I am sure she will cooperate well with CPS and they can also help her with the stress of dealing with your brother. These things go bad when CPS is treated as the enemy rather than the facilitator of a better outcome. Whoever reported her will be best disappointed if she embraces the opportunity of assistance that can be provided, her mental health deserves some care too and I am sure she is smart and loving enough to embrace the chance to get the best out of a bad situation. I hope she gets all the love support and courage she needs in trying to look after the mental health of her husband and the well being of her children as well as looking after herself, she so very much deserves it.

34points

Ms.GB 2 months ago (edited)

I agree with your suggestion that she use CPS as a resource to get help. However it's important to clarify that she didn't ACCIDENTALLY push her child in frustration, she became frustrated and pushed her child. She had a moment of frustration in which she couldn't control her anger or actions and that's a problem. An accident is walking around a corner, not looking where you're going, bumping into your child and they fall down and break their wrist...that's an example of an accident. Just because you lost control of yourself in the moment and immediately regretted your actions does not make physically hurting someone an accident. She may have not meant to hurt her child but they aren't any less hurt. Good intentions cannot undo a broken wrist or the emotional damage of being physically hurt by a parent, especially with another parent in the hospital. Whoever called CPS did the right thing because mom needs to be able to handle even extreme emotions and traumatic situations without getting physical with her children. Life gets rough and sometimes when you think it can't possibly get any rougher it does and then it gets rougher still...There are a lot of ppl dealing with horribly stressful almost impossible situations but there is no excuse to get physical, especially with someone whose care and well being is in your hands.

20points

Load More Replies...

Weasel Wise 2 months ago (edited)

Wow. Just wow! A grown àss woman broke a child's arm and you're going off on some insane soap box about how the woman needs love, love, love, and all the kindness. Just WOW! I can't believe people are upvoting you too! "Guys, she was having a tough day. So she broke her kid's arm? Let's give her a break cuz she was stressed." WOW!!!

5points

Helena 2 months ago

It entirely depends on who gets assigned the case. Some over react and now the next few years of your life are consumed with proving you aren't a trash human. Someone called cps on my mom when we were little. There was absolutely no call for it. It just made our lives been more difficult for years.

4points

Michael MacKinnon 2 months ago

You should leave it to the system to deal with this. Your SIL has a reasonable position (indeed, surprised the hospital wasn't required to report).

21points

Joey Jo Jo Shabadoo 2 months ago

Hospitals are required to report suspected abuse. If the injury and story didnt seem like abuse to them, they wouldnt have reported it

14points

Load More Replies...

Load More Comments

POST

Min 2 months ago

She got frustrated and broke her child's wrist. That is abuse. Very few child abusers actually set out to do so. As Libstak wrote, abuse is often caused by frustration.

51points

LakotaWolf (she/her) 2 months ago

As a child who was frequently shoved, pushed, and thrown across the room by my mother when she was "frustrated" or "angry": yes! This is ABUSE. This is not an ACCIDENT.

42points

Load More Replies...