“They Always Play Themselves”: 35 Actors & Actresses Accused Of Having No Versatility On The Screen, See If You Agree
Some actors are super versatile and can play anyone or anything. Others, on the other hand, are often described as “just playing themselves.” Today we have a list of 35 actors and actresses who, at least once, have been accused of such performances. Some of these you might agree with, while some might be controversial. It’s time to put this question to bed once and for all - are they really good, or are they just really good at playing themselves? Cast your votes and see if others agree.
This post may include affiliate links.
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson
If you smeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeell what The Rock is cooking... then you're probably a guest in his house, so mind your manners.
His electrifying charisma is so powerful that the only reason someone would shell out the massive money it takes to hire him is to try to capture his magnificence on film. It would be a waste to make him play someone else.
He had some versatility early in his film career when he played a few villains, but his acting skills weren't great so he just started playing himself.
A reviewer for some NY magazine said that the Jungle Cruise was simply a platform for Johnson to play Johnson, and I can't watch his movies at this point.
Rebel Wilson
The Aussie Melissa McCarthy. Appears in so many crappy "comedies" because idiots find them both funny.
Seth Rogen
It seems he always plays similar characters, but I don't think he can be said to be "playing himself." His characters tend to be hapless schlemiels, but he is actually pretty thoughtful and erudite in real life. (TBH - I have only seen a few of his movies.)
What's the difference in between a schlemiel and a schlemozzle (sic) ? A schlemiel will trip, fall and break his nose. A schlemozzle will trip, fall and break his back.
Load More Replies...Amy Schumer
Jason Statham
Lol his character in Spy always cracks me up because it's like a spoof version of his regular roles.
Load More Replies...I would watch this man read a dictionary... As long as he shoots it when he done
Snatch and Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, both movies he plays the comedic straight man. He has range and can act, but makes more money being himself.
Thing is, even if he is just playing himself, you're not watching and thinking Jason Statham, you see him getting into a role.
i think he is tight casted into a role, which suits himself perfectly. As i do not know how he is off set, i cannot comment.
Maybe, but I've enjoyed a good amount of his films. Be right back, gonna go rewatch "The Bee Keeper."
Arnold Schwarzenegger
There are three different Scharzeneggers and they are all great; Serious Action Arnold (the Terminator, Total Recall, Predator) Goofy Action Arnold (Last Action Hero, Commando) and comedy Arnold (Twins, Jingle all the Way)
Yes, I agree. I also liked him in the Netflix series he did a year or two ago. Can't remember the name but in it, he and his daughter are both CIA agents that didn't know about the other until they had to work together.
Load More Replies...I always knocked him as action-hero role only, then watched him in Maggie and Escape Plan. In Maggie his acting was almost tender, and in Escape Plan I was impressed when he's in the cell yelling in German "mein gott!", that whole monologue was some of the most convincing acting i've ever seen him do, and far more than the superficial action roles.
He still has that something that makes him cool to watch though. Same with Stallone.
Chris Pratt
Dude has no versatility, I really like Andy in Parks and Rec and Starlord (pretty much the same character) his other roles are bland action heroes with no personality
Mark Wahlberg
He's a decent actor who mostly plays meat heats but the characters he's played in the Departed, the Lovely Bones, Ted, and Pain & Gain are all distinct and different roles.
Jonah Hill
Seth is not the same as Jonah Hill or Schmidt, so Jonah is not himself even when he's himself.
Owen Wilson
Adam Sandler
He has shown he has versatility. He just doesn't want to use it. Fair play.
That character he plays is not himself. He plays the same character often, but it's an alter ego.
Load More Replies...I watched Spanglish, which is a much more serious roll, and he was quite good.
Load More Replies...I take it none of you have seen his movies like Punch Drunk Love or Uncut Gems...his dramatic acting is incredible.
A-listers are one dimensional actors, the real talent are the "character actors". Steven Root, Allison Janny, JK Simmons, etc.
He’s remarkable when he doesn’t do comedy, like “Reign Over Me,” “Spanglish,” the diamond merchant movie especially (I’m blanking on the title), and many more. In the comedy movies, he tends to always play the same character.
Kristen Stewart
It's really funny. I used to think like most of the commenters, but then I learned she has won a César (French Oscar equivalent) and then I've seen a couple movies where her acting is truly great! She can actually act, and well, but it is the shadow of the Twilight movies (best watched as the bad lip reading dub) that makes American viewers hate her so.
She was great in Underwater too. And man I despised her from the shiny vamp movies.
Load More Replies...maybe a little, but i adored her in both "underwater" and "love lies bleeding", she was incredible in both.
Tom Cruise
Comedian Rich Hall mentioned that not only is he the same character, but the plots of his movies are all the same. "He's a fighter pilot, maybe the best damn fighter pilot. Then he has a crisis of confidence, meets a girl, and gets his mojo back. He's a cocktail waiter, maybe the best damn cocktail waiter, until he has a crisis of confidence, but then he meets a girl and gets his mojo back. He's a race car driver, maybe the best damn race car driver..."
Maybe for his blockbusters, but he has a long filmography that shows off his range; Tropic Thunder, Magnolia, Valkyrie, Eyes Wide Shut, a Few Good Men, and a bunch more.
Load More Replies...Except for Magnolia, Collateral, Vampire, Rain Man, Eyes Wide Shut, The Outsiders, Tropic Thunder, Jerry Maguire... His catalogue is easy bigger than you realize. The MI series is just the behemoth in the middle of it.
Yes, I bet some people don't even realize he's in Tropic Thunder; totally unrecognizable.
Load More Replies...He's the same dude with a different job in every movie, except for Interview with the Vampire. He was fabulous in that.
And also, Interview with the Vampire!
Load More Replies...He is versatile if he wants to, he just doesn't always want to be. And, obviously, the real version is the problematic one.
Exactly, when he wants to. Still don't like him but I love his back catalog.
Load More Replies...He used to put his back into his acting, delivery of his lines was sometimes captivating. After a certain point it's like he stopped trying in that aspect and focused everything on doing crazy stunts. Now it feels like he shows up, goes "i'm Tom Cruise", flashes his center-tooth smile, throws himself out a helicopter and collects his paycheck. Playing the same role over and over and over..... can we get another Legend, or Jerry Maguire, or Born on the 4th of July?
Whatever. His movies rarely disappoint and he has more range when people think.
Oblivion? Great job. Collateral Damage? Great job. On and on. He could be a sh1t in private life but the dude really can act.
Mindy Kaling
Vince Vaughn
His comedy roles are all identical but when he branches out to dramas he shows his range.
Quick talk, darting eyes, punch line jokes, responds by awkward look like he just heard French and has never heard a foreign language before....basically all his roles.
He's brilliant in the film "A Cool Dry Place". A recommend if you can find it to watch 👍🙂
It's an unpopular opinion but he really did. Also, again not a hit, but he was great in the 2nd True Detective which was also much better than people thought.
Load More Replies...Samuel L. Jackson
The man is an amazing actor, yes we all know he likes one particular curse word, but all of his roles are different unique characters.
The films - 'Glass', 'A Time To Kill', 'Do The Right Thing', 'The Displaced Person' just for example do show his range. He's a fantastic actor
Compare his roles in The Hateful Eight and Black Snake Moan and you can see his range.
I think the only movies I didn't see him play the same role is Master Windu in Star Wars
Will Smith
This comment. Pursuit of Happiness and Seven Pounds. He made my eyes pis* tears with both those movies.
Load More Replies...He has range as actor, from comedy over drama to action horror. He is good at his job at least
Loved "Bright". So bummed he had to ruin it by getting the sequel canceled with that idiot move at the Oscars.
Melissa McCarthy
I think fat actresses get screwed over with the roles they're given. They're either the funny fat chick, or the wise bestfriend/momma character.
Watch Can You Ever Forgive Me? She's brilliant in that drama
Load More Replies...Robert Downey Jr.
He play eccentric characters well Like Tony Stark and Sherlock Holmes.
Bill Murray
Why isn’t there a “just plays himself” option? Are we giving Bill Murray an out?
Haha the options are different for different people I guess! The Amy Schumer one had “Always herself, mainly not funny” just for an extra kick. Whoever put this one together is def playing favorites with the options.
Load More Replies...He almost always plays a dick in movies, but from what I've heard he's got a quirky sense of humor in real life & is generally a good guy. A friend of mine was an extra on a short-lived TV series in the early 80s, and Bill was a guest star on it once. During breaks in filming he'd hang out & play Uno with everyone, and jokingly told my friend he'd "never work on this show again" because he (friend) kept playing "draw 4" & "skip turn" on him. (Ironically, my friend never did work on the show again, because he got a full-time job & was no longer available.)
Load More Replies...Jennifer Aniston
Aniston, like DiCaprio, is one of those people who does have some range, but I can nevertheless never see her as anything other than Jennifer Aniston. The normal suspension of disbelief never happens because...she's Jennifer Aniston. It's actually really distracting for me.
Most of the film roles she plays (romantic comedies) are a variation of her Rachel character. She tried to beat this pattern with acting jobs in a few serious films, with very moderate interest from the public. I am not a fan of hers, but I think she has great comedic timing.
Generally plays quirky women. Her character in Horrible Bosses was what most men wanted to see!
"Cake" broke all perceptions of her capabilities. She wasn't just 'Rachel Green' anymore.
Ryan Reynolds
He plays himself a lot, but that's what the people go watch his movies for I think
Yeah, his character in Amityville Horror and The Proposal is exactly the same personality. (Sarcasm, for those who can't tell)
He's a good actor, but, all I see in most of his movies is the wackiness. I just see Ryan Reynolds playing Ryan Reynolds playing himself. I don't see him as Deadpool, I see Ryan. Makes it hard to dive into his movies
Julia Roberts
Steel Magnolias, Erin Brockovich, Sleeping With The Enemy... She's definitely got range.
There's an 'i don't know' option. Where's the 'i don't care' option?
Zach Galifianakis
One of my favorite Onion articles was titled something like, "Director of new Zach Galifianakis movie disappointed to find out he's just a potato with a crayon beard." But I think he's pretty great.
ZOMG! I’m dying! Now I kinda want the Onion to describe me! 🤣
Load More Replies...Jennifer Lawrence
Am one of the few people who disagree, I find her acting as flat as Kristen Stewart, she just knows how to smile more.
Angelina Jolie
What?! I don't think I've seen her play same character in any of her movies. She's all range. I get people don't like the person I suppose, but she's a very good actor.
I wonder if it's just because she is very recognizable?
Load More Replies...The Changeling was heartbreaking, a million mile turnaround from the superficiality of Tomb Raider. She's not everyone's favorite person, but she does have excellent range.
Agreed, also Gia, girl interrupted and so many other movies she's an excellent actor.
Load More Replies...Steve Carell
If you only know him from The Office, just watch Foxcatcher and you'll see why he doesn't deserve a place on this list at all.
Cameron Diaz
I don't care even if she is playing herself. She is just such a charming woman!
Jack Nicholson
His characters are always so intense and a little off-balance that it makes me wonder about his actual personality. (I had a friend who is an actor, and he was so caught up in the character he was playing that it took a long time to see who he really was.)
I can only think of ONE movie where he's not Jack Nicholson: About Schmidt
I have some movies for you to watch then to change your mind: One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, A Few Good Men, Terms of Endearment, and the Departed.
Load More Replies...Nicolas Cage
Really? I don’t even like him, but there’s no denying his talent. The problem is he’s been calling it in for years. He’s just lazy
He's the exact opposite of lazy. He's working his a*s off and takes really bad roles just to make money and get out of debt.
Load More Replies...I wouldn't say so...eccentric and over the top yes but he's got some range.
He’s played a vampire. Surely that’s not just playing himself, or is there something you’re not telling us??? 🤔🩸
He's become less versatile as he agedm but in the 90s, it was like different people put on a Nicolas Cage suit for the various roles.
Leaving Las Vegas... That film is very dark but he apparently filmed himself drunk and I think he visited rehab centres too in preparation for the role.
Reese Witherspoon
I heard once that, supposedly, her agent told her at the start of her career she was too ugly to be an actress. That twit must be kicking himself at her becoming the first global ambassador of Avon.
Scarlett Johansson
I feel like we haven't seen her full capability yet. Like if we gave her a really good dramatic role, lots of pain and anguish, and the right director to bring out the best in her, I think we could see an incredibly deep and powerful performance. Think she's not getting utilized well or she's not taking enough challenging roles.
Scarlett, Kristen Stewart, and Christina Ricci all give me that same blah vibe, to be honest.
Load More Replies...Keanu Reeves
I think it's funny how Kristen Stewart is hated by so many people for showing no emotions while acting, and Keanu is universally adored despite showing even less emotions while acting.
He is adored for the person he is rather than his acting roles.
Load More Replies...I mean, how do we go from Bill and Ted, to Parenthood to Point Break to the Matrix to John Wick and claim that he only plays himself. I mean, come on.
same voice,same gestures...johnny depp does the same.they can not get into character.and keanu is very robotic..love him to death but he cant act normal..not to mention the sexy scenes...hes like fighting a bull
Load More Replies...A friend summed up his acting in the Matrix saying "It's OK that he seems totally clueless and out of his element, b/c that's what his character is experiencing." I might agree - but that doesn't excuse him for channeling Ted Logan (Bill & Ted) when he tried to pull off playing a cardiologist in "As Good As It Gets."
John Wick, Neo, Ted, Johnny Utah, and Johnny Silverhand are all different and distinct characters even if they mostly share the same name.
His derision and revulsion for everyone else in Much Ado About Nothing completely contradicts this.
Load More Replies...He's great in action movies, dramas. In comedies and romantic movies, he just looked out of place.
Lara Verne - I first saw him in "Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure." He seemed so perfect in the role that it took me a while to accept him playing any other sort of role.
Load More Replies...Morgan Freeman
Weird that out of all these, Adam Sandler has actually displayed the most versatility.
Seven, The Bucket List, Amistad, Clean and Sober etc etc etc!
I think Jeff Goldblum always plays himself and that he’s brilliant at it
He does. Also, I'm surprised that Jim Carrey isn't on this list.
Load More Replies...What the f**k is this? What kind of answer options are those? Some are *way* too specific why not just have the same options for everyone, and make them general, instead of trying to put words into people's mouths? Also, yes, I DO sometimes take things too seriously. WHY DO YOU ASK?
Lol yeah the options changing seemed to be based on how the OP felt about the celeb
Load More Replies...There really should have been a 'No they are just s**t' option for a lot of these.
This is undeniable evidence that Any r****d with an internet connection can write an article on Bored Panda.
I think Jeff Goldblum always plays himself and that he’s brilliant at it
He does. Also, I'm surprised that Jim Carrey isn't on this list.
Load More Replies...What the f**k is this? What kind of answer options are those? Some are *way* too specific why not just have the same options for everyone, and make them general, instead of trying to put words into people's mouths? Also, yes, I DO sometimes take things too seriously. WHY DO YOU ASK?
Lol yeah the options changing seemed to be based on how the OP felt about the celeb
Load More Replies...There really should have been a 'No they are just s**t' option for a lot of these.
This is undeniable evidence that Any r****d with an internet connection can write an article on Bored Panda.
