Tired Of Property Developers Cutting Corners On Accessibility, Architect Illustrates How It Impacts People
Azari Mat Yasir has been teaching architecture at Universiti Teknologi Malaysia for 18 years now. Throughout this time, one particular problem kept bugging him and Azari just couldn't ignore it any longer. Property developers have been cutting corners on accessibility, making everyday life for people with special needs way harder than they could be. Moreover, the authorities in the country have been turning a blind eye to what's happening. So, the lecturer decided to take matters into his own hands, creating a series of illustrations depicting these struggles that shouldn't even exist in the first place.
More info: azarimy.com | Facebook
This post may include affiliate links.
This is the one that makes me angry. I have a friend whose husband is wheelchair bound. Her van has a side loading ramp to get him in and out. Many times we were sitting in parking lots with thawing and melting groceries trying to locate the owner of a car that thought the striped place at handicapped parking was an additional parking space. If I ever see you parked here...have no doubt I will call the police and have your car ticketed or towed. And if you have a motorcycle, be prepared to search for it because I will relocate it to the most inconvenient spot I can find.
Thank you on behalf of a wheelchair bound person! I hate when people park too close to a disabled spot or people without a disabled parking card (or whatever is used in other countries) park in a disabled parking spot. Just being rude/lazy. Or only parking there for a "second". You have working legs, you can walk, park in a normal spot!! Thank you! When I used to drive with my dad when I was younger, he would get so pissed if there was a car parked in a disabled spot without a disabled parking card. He would never fight in his lifetime, but always looked like he was ready to fight, lol. I myself, just get very annoyed and want to close them in. But then my husband would have to park in a spot that isn't a parking space. Don't want to get a ticket for that! Some people are just plain rude or lazy!!
Load More Replies...The city should just take these bikes and auction them out to the highest bidder, with the previous owner not getting anything.
I ride...but I never do this. In fact I have moved other bikes that have (when I can, some bikes lock so you can't move them either)....generally where they get blocked in.
Thank you. Even though there is a huge chance you are not able to do this for me. Thank you on behalf of disabled people! There should be more people like you!
Load More Replies...as a motorcycle guy - so much this. Its not a motorcycle parking, period.
Oh, so this is why that slots are bigger than standard slots. Nice to know, I always tought it was cause their cars where bigger (for carrying the wheelchair and other needed stuff)
Nope, it is for that reason. And people like me who have to transfer from wheelchair to the car. There has to be enough place to get your wheelchair next to the car so you can safely transfer. Or like the person above said, get in the car with your wheelchair from the side. Many people go into the car with their wheelchair from the back. But some get in via the side. There are several reasons why these spots are wider. And the reason they are mostly close to a store can for example be, for people who have lung diseases and decreased capacity of their lungs, so they can't walk far. Going through a store can be exhausting with a decreased lung capacity. So you want to be able to park as close to the store as possible. And some wheelchair users can’t drive themselves very far because of a lack of energy. Just some examples why the disabled parking spots are wider and mostly as close to a store as possible.
Load More Replies...This applies to anyone who needs extra space to unload needed equipment. In my case, it's a walker.
"As architects, we are trained to fulfill the needs of the end user," Azari told Bored Panda. "However, accessibility needs are almost never a priority in Malaysia, apart from special needs buildings like hospitals. Most architectural programs offered at local universities don't even emphasize on special needs, or more known as Universal Design, my university included."
Thats one reason. Another is, you can block the view of screen and keypad from bystanders more easily with your own body - so security.
I agree completely, and it addresses short people, like myself. I normally have to tip toe to cover the screen and the keypad.
Load More Replies...The only problem is they are impossible for those with other mobility issues to use as some of us don't have the flexibility to bend close enough to operate ... it's a balancing act that is still to be perfected
Very true, but unfortunately they are impossible or at the very least very, very painful for those with mobility problems that impact the ability to bend because they are set so low - it's a balancing act that hasn't been perfected yet
I wish they would come up with a screen that didn't fade away when the sun shines on it.
I appreciate this but now my little ones keep stealing my credit cards and taking out money for “getting turnt” and promiscuous women of the night
In an attempt to increase awareness amongst his students, Azari started sketching some of the issues. "It was after I shared my drawings on Facebook that they gained traction. Now I'm also advocating for universal design in architectural schools in Malaysia, mainly to get it implemented at least by a lecture or two if not become a full subject of its own."
Oh, dangerous spots. I remember those spots from way back when I just got my chronic diseases. Back then my diseases weren't as bad as they are now.. Now I am in a wheelchair. 2 years of crutches, followed by (to date, with no progress in sight) 11 years in a wheelchair. Oh, the memories and obstacles in my memory and still to this date. It isn't always easy!
I fell through a grate that broke when I was a kid. I have dodged them ever since, if I see one I walk around it. Never again will I walk over one.
I am 12 and for some reason I've always been really scared of them.......
Load More Replies...Local town put little troughs to drain water from gutters...right across the path every few feet. Nearby they use 3 grooves in the pavement instead, no horrible drop and scream for wheelchair users
"On this side of the world, our life expectancy used to be low, barely reaching 60 years," Azari explained. "So most people would pass before they reached an age where disability becomes much more possible. As a result, Malaysian buildings built in the 70s and 80s never really considered universal design. But nowadays, our life expectancy has increased to over 70 years, yet the mindset has not changed. Buildings still follow regulations which were set in the 70s."
I suspected for a long time now that many of those that I saw are too steep. Thanks for confirming. It really needs to be fixed. It's a risk both for the person in the wheelchair and for anyone passing by (walking) or standing at the end of the ramp.
Since wheelchairs must use the center of the ramp I can't tell you how many people I've almost run over because 1. They are in the only place I can be 2. My wheels are going fast
Load More Replies...I thought so by seeing some ramps, I was like "isn't this one a bit dangerous?" An interesting thing I saw, however, are some kind of motorised wheelchairs that, just like cars, have the features that take care of steepness as well. The problem is, not every disabled person has one of those.
Yes! It can be so hard or impossible to go up these ramps. Especially if you don't have a lot of strength. And going down ramps that are too steep can be dangerous too. You have to lean back as far as possible. If you even are able to do this.. If you encounter them, you just have to be lucky to have someone with you that can help you get up such a ramp and help you stay safe. I hate them with a passion!
My physical therapist office even has massive holes on the sides.its wheelchair x games
Every day, I walk past one that has a pipe directly across the path. 3 inches from the ground.
"Of course, to change something that is not easy. But many groups are now moving in tandem to create awareness by engaging the politicians, property developers and other invested parties. And I'm merely contributing in academia, creating awareness amongst young architects so they would be ready to tackle universal design issues in the future as well."
yeah, WTF is with housing laws that allow <5 stories high buildings to not have elevators? And its not just disabled...anyone that had kids (or more than one toddler at a time, chaos forbid...) will be hard pressed to move the baby carriage up and down, srsly.
Every new apt complex in my county is being built without elevators. I don't understand how the architects and builders comply with ADA laws. It's disgusting.
Load More Replies...That's me and it's too expensive or complicated to make it wheelchair accessible being handicapped is very very expensive my medication alone a month exceeds many people's yearly income. The rich gotta make their money, its all they can think about. Guess what we all think about money too. But most of us are just not willing to do the rotten things you do to get it. So lie, cheat,and steal. Live in your "University Sized houses and I'll just sit here staring out the window. Ah f#$k that I just close the shades. Just missing my freedom is all and I do have good people who help. Not all wealthy are lying cheating scoundrels just the ones like TRue pUMPed
This is rampant where I live, even new builds are being allowed with no disabled acces's - even to the ground level.
The other one that makes me angry is when there are not fire/carbon monoxide detectors required.
If only every blind / visually impaired person was able to have a guide dog.. but it can be very expensive!! And there is much/strict training required. And then you have those people (haven't seen it yet on the list, maybe it will be further down) who will pet the guide dog and thus distract the dog, while it is working! Even though their harness (I guess in all cases) clearly states: Don't pet me, I am working. Some people just can't resist to pet a working dog. If it happens too often this can get very dangerous!
Unfortunately guide dogs aren't always the answer either. My partner is completely blind and struggles all the time with dropped curbs. All around my city now the pavements are completely flat to the road, which I admit will help other people but his guide dog stuggles to know when there is a road and when to stop. This has got to be an issue with cane users too. Also he always gets stopped by people wanting to fuss her. Once someone was detracting her when he was waiting to cross a really busy road trying to get her cross to them.
Load More Replies...Accessibility issue aside, how is this even a practical thing for any person walking on that path? Everyone would need to duck under the sign. It's ridiculous that this was even considered, let alone implemented.
Lol it's not a path... it's the thing on the side of the highway that tells you when you're getting too close to the edge
Load More Replies...These excellent illustrations should be required reading for architects, developers, and city planners worldwide. In 1990, the Americans with Disabilities Act was enacted. One of the ADA-mandated accessibility features is the sidewalk curb cut (what is lacking in the illustration above). Curb cuts have been omnipresent in cities since the 1990s. I live in the Los Angeles area; there are curb cuts at virtually every intersection. But negligent officials have been unbelievably slow in installing curb cuts everywhere they are needed. One well-known affluent municipality in the area has had the mandated curb cuts for many years. However, there is a very small triangular sidewalk “island” at a point where three large streets intersect. Curb cuts were installed on this island ONLY ABOUT TWO YEARS AGO. This little island is located at the southern edge of the city, the less affluent side of town, where none of the city bigwigs live.
The textured sidewalk serve as tactile cues for the blind to know they are going in the right direction, when to stop prior to a curb or crosswalk, etc. so that big, annoying sign right in the middle of the path is an accident waiting to happen, particularly if you rely on other senses to help orient yourself to your surroundings. I'm speechless this actually happened.
What happened? He walked into the sign? he didn't vote because he didn't know what to vote for? I dont get what "actually happened"
He is on part of the pavement with a different texture, it should be able to guide him but some f*****g idiot has put a sign up so now the blind dude will walk into it and probably hurt himself.
Load More Replies...it gets better...my apartment building has an elevator with a nice, lovely buttons panel...that is a touch screen. No physical interface for anyone who has even remotelly bad eyes, because its dim like all f***s. Looks nice, but...just why?
Same here, do we live in the same building? I thought only mine was this insane...I guess Polish builders've gone little bonkers....
Load More Replies...In many Canadian provinces the building code requires handles on doors. Both as an accessibility issue but also for emergency fire escape.
That is great! Now the rest of the world will have to follow! Every single house/building/door!
Load More Replies...Omg public buildings with the automatic open buttons are my favorite. Trying to hold wheels steady while opening door and pushing myself through. Super fun to add a ramp and gravity to fight
My grandpa is an amputee and they advertised the town home as wheelchair accessible... the bathroom is wide enough he can get through-- without the wheels...
When we redesigned our kitchen and bathrooms, we installed what they call “arthritis friendly” taps, toilets, and shower and tub fixtures. It takes a very light touch to turn the taps off and on and you don’t need to grasp a k**b - they are all lever operated. ...///... When we build our new house, we’re going to do the same thing. I never could understand why people don’t do this in the first place.
How about those paper towel machines with sensors to spit out towels? Half the time I can barely see it and half the time it goes off without me being near it (so it seems).
I was once wheelchair bound, thank god not permanently. This did happen, but not only at bus stops. The advantage for me was after my arm healed (but not before) I was able to spin around and carefully climb or drop curbs on my own. Those who have no use of their arms or use electric wheelchairs cannot do this...
well isn't that just like the stupid people we put in charge to be dumber than a kindergardener
Here, they have to mark the bus stops that aren't suitable for wheelchair/ramp access, so that people know.
Just because you haven't experienced this does not mean it's not true. Why "exaggerated"? Of course there are a whole lot of difficulties for people with disabilities.
Load More Replies...Hmmm...I doubt any deaf person uses them as such. They are quite capable of walking down steps and talking...or waiting till the bottom!
My legs wobble inexplicably when I go down steps, they help me too.
That is very true. I know I can't talk (in sign) while walking up and down stairs, only ramps. I'm Deaf myself and agree with this one
They're also handy for the rest of us when carrying a heavy or awkward load.
I am deaf and I am disabled believe me walking and talking down the steps is not a problem. The lamp should be for wheelchairs and scooters and strollers, in that order.
O don't get that why the door in m American toilets open to the inside and not outside. They always open to the outside in Poland and I never got hit by a toilet door while passing outside. People do not open them with a karate kick. And with the door opening to the outside you have more room inside the toilet.
Most in Australia slide into the wall with a button press open
Load More Replies...Ain't that the truth. Also, bathroom stalls are good for manual wheelchairs but not for electric wheelchairs.
Even the standard loos require me to straddle the toilet so the door will shut
But the sensor is at the top, so the range is too short.
Load More Replies...I'm not a dainty female. I have been ignored by many sensors and trapped between automatic doors that ignore my leaping about, only for them to open after a sparrow flies past
It is the same as the door sensor at the back of the hospital where I go for the physio. Even if I am 5'4, I am too short to be noticed by the sensor, so I have to raise a hand and wave it so the sensor notice it and send the signal to open the door =_=
This happens all the time...with automatic light sensors too....being short is sometimes not enough to set the off.
I'm 165 cm tall, a relatively average height, and I often have this issue. The doors won't open until I'm practically walking into them or for some I've even had to wave. I have no idea how a disabled person (or even a child) would manage.
People think I'm weird when I wave at these doors. But I find it happens more often in states that are more expensive to live in. Not only are the parking spaces and aisles are smaller, the range on the motion sensors are shorter too!
He, the door to my chemist and doctor's is like this for "average" people. So people are walking backwards trying to get it open.
sorry. .. right onto the toes of the next person coming out of the chemist/ dr. It is a little foyer thing with three doors. one to outside ( the problem one ) then two more doors.
Load More Replies...I would definitely not be able enter my home (or leave after in it) if I ever end up in a wheelchair, at least not without some major help. It's a scary thought.
My next door neighbor has a wonderful ramp that her husband made for her. That's love.
Load More Replies...once im kindergarden my friend was in a wheechair, and the music room was in the basement. the chair life let him miss 6 minutes of music. no one likes music anyway, (Well no one in our school) but still
I'm lucky enough to have amazing parents who put in a wheelchair ramp for me at the appropriate incline so I can get in and out of my house. I have met many people who aren't as lucky.
Yeah I'm gonna shut up now in an altered state I might have said too much already. I really hate steps like really really hate them
I HATED going to places with this problem. You always get the angry look when the receptionist or attendant has to actually stand up and make and effort. Then the help you get is often half-assed, not even meeting the bare minimum. This isn't everywhere or everyone, but it is common enough that I dreaded it.
THIS> when I have taken my wheelchair-bound Mom to the doctor's and most of the time she cannot have a hope of seeing the people she needs to talk to. Not nice.
i dont think this comment section knows why he's covering his wheels but its because hes entering a mosque and when you enter the mosque you arent allowed to dirty the area with footwear or in his case his wheels
Thank you for that thoughtful comment and in recognizing that we don't all have the same knowledge base.
Load More Replies...Good idea Make covers for motorized chairs too Once I get out of the cramped 2story house it's good. I love my motorized chair
Thank you, I actually didn't recognize the significance of the door frame.
Load More Replies...I really do not think so. I believe it is the opposite, and because of this, we take more notice of the inconsiderate stuff that is still happening.
Load More Replies...My husband and I normally ask them if they want us to follow and lead when there is a large unmoving crowd. One of us pushes thru and the other follows behind to make sure they make it
... Or have mobility problems, and are pushed. Facial injury and a trip to the hospital.
You have no idea how many times I have to INSIST that wheelchairs be ALLOWED ON buses and low floor streetcars and subways FIRST!
I had a deaf friend, her phone & doorbell were set up to make the lights flash on & off.
yeeah, fixed furniture. Tell that to shorter than usual people that cant reach the table ;)
I'm 5'0". I know what you mean. You should see me trying to hop up on those stools at Micky D's. They do actually have designated tables marked for people with disabilities. I think that's great.
Load More Replies...On a cruise we went on , the dining room had allocated spots (using little signs on the tables) for disabled use only. How many times did we see some a@#$hole had flipped them over so they could take that spot. My husband uses a mobility scooter so made us extra mad and we would make it well known how selfish some people are as we went past those creeps.
This was really neat, reminded me of Harvey Pekar's comics. I think this really communicated something.
Things like this should be mentioned more often. People who have no special needs and no friends who do need to learn more about the life with disabilities. I do not have special needs and do not know anyone personally with such needs. Therefore I do not know many of the struggles those people face in every day life. I simply do not think about it. Not because I do not care. To be honest, I don't know why. It just does not enter my head. But if there were more articles like this, I think more people would start to think about this, be kinder and hopefully help in what ever way they can (stores might make their counters lower, architects may think more about ramps.... etc pp). Most people cannot emphasize with things they do not know.
It is okay that you did not think about this before. I did not think about it either, before I got sick. Now I come across obstacles like this many times when I go outside. But I love your attitude that you will probably think about this more often, thanks to this article. It is a great article which shows people to the struggles/obstacles that disabled people come across often. Hopefully this article will be spread across the internet, to reach a wider public. So that many contractors and architects come across this article and can implement this in whatever they work on. The world needs to get more accessible for all disabilities! I really like this article, since I recognize so many struggles/obstacles. I hope one day the world will be accessible to all people! But that is still a LONG way to go!
Load More Replies...Right! If using a screen reader, you can't read the captions on the pictures! This needs better alt tags or a image description.
Load More Replies...Panera Bread is terrible with their high counters. I'm not in a wheelchair, just short (5'1") and I have issues reaching my food.
I grew up in a town where we have a school for the deaf and blind and I totally get this. Our city has been pretty stellar in meeting thier needs but I dont see that often outside of where I'm from. I wish I did.
And also, wheelchair accessibility means stroller accessibility. Nice, serving the needs of disabled people and parents with the same means.
Thank for the shout out to MS ("yes, it's all in my head"). But I'm also very handicapped thanks to a brain aneurysm. Craving accessibility is my new normal.
I live in an old small town in England, and it's only when someone has crutches, or a wheelchair, or a disability scooter, that you realise just how inaccessible it is. but the buildings are all a few hundred years old, when no one even considered disability, steps up to doors everywhere. and things like ramps are not possible, they'd stretch out into the road if they were a reasonable incline.
Another one is software design. Plan for screen readers. Allow text to be resized. Download "Spectrum" to see how your website looks to the colour blind. (Don't make colour be the ONLY way to see important information). Similar for non-computer visual design - I have a card game I make in my spare time, and put a lot of thought into how to get important information across. And how small can I make this text before some people won't be able to play?
Things like this should be mentioned more often. People who have no special needs and no friends who do need to learn more about the life with disabilities. I do not have special needs and do not know anyone personally with such needs. Therefore I do not know many of the struggles those people face in every day life. I simply do not think about it. Not because I do not care. To be honest, I don't know why. It just does not enter my head. But if there were more articles like this, I think more people would start to think about this, be kinder and hopefully help in what ever way they can (stores might make their counters lower, architects may think more about ramps.... etc pp). Most people cannot emphasize with things they do not know.
It is okay that you did not think about this before. I did not think about it either, before I got sick. Now I come across obstacles like this many times when I go outside. But I love your attitude that you will probably think about this more often, thanks to this article. It is a great article which shows people to the struggles/obstacles that disabled people come across often. Hopefully this article will be spread across the internet, to reach a wider public. So that many contractors and architects come across this article and can implement this in whatever they work on. The world needs to get more accessible for all disabilities! I really like this article, since I recognize so many struggles/obstacles. I hope one day the world will be accessible to all people! But that is still a LONG way to go!
Load More Replies...Right! If using a screen reader, you can't read the captions on the pictures! This needs better alt tags or a image description.
Load More Replies...Panera Bread is terrible with their high counters. I'm not in a wheelchair, just short (5'1") and I have issues reaching my food.
I grew up in a town where we have a school for the deaf and blind and I totally get this. Our city has been pretty stellar in meeting thier needs but I dont see that often outside of where I'm from. I wish I did.
And also, wheelchair accessibility means stroller accessibility. Nice, serving the needs of disabled people and parents with the same means.
Thank for the shout out to MS ("yes, it's all in my head"). But I'm also very handicapped thanks to a brain aneurysm. Craving accessibility is my new normal.
I live in an old small town in England, and it's only when someone has crutches, or a wheelchair, or a disability scooter, that you realise just how inaccessible it is. but the buildings are all a few hundred years old, when no one even considered disability, steps up to doors everywhere. and things like ramps are not possible, they'd stretch out into the road if they were a reasonable incline.
Another one is software design. Plan for screen readers. Allow text to be resized. Download "Spectrum" to see how your website looks to the colour blind. (Don't make colour be the ONLY way to see important information). Similar for non-computer visual design - I have a card game I make in my spare time, and put a lot of thought into how to get important information across. And how small can I make this text before some people won't be able to play?
